This food is very good. First the house dressing is like a tomato vinaigrette it's delicious. Second the Alfredo sauce is top notch. The chicken Alfredo is very good. Chicken is grilled which adds another element of flavor, Alfredo sauce is creamy not gritty. I tried the chicken Maximo. Something different for me. It was also good. Not near the flavor the other items had but was still good. Servers were present and ensured a pleasant experience. The dining area is slightly dim but not dark which I appreciate. Kinda typical non chain Italian restaurant vibes but dang the food is good. I would definitely recommend this place. read more

See all

Very disappointing service. At noon we made a reservation for 9 for 6pm. We were shown to a table that could barely seat 8 people. We questioned the seating selection and were met with very rude and somewhat hostile response by both the hostess and (maybe) the owner. "Everyone makes reservations. This is what we can do." (In a rude tone might I add) Honestly, a bit of kindness and courtesy could have saved them from getting this negative review. Won't be visiting this location again. read more

Inwrote a long review on doordash but was so disappointed that I felt i needed to let people on yelp know. Will be brief. Sure doesnt seem like they use realnor fresh ingedients. Theblibster ravioli was some kind of paste, no chunks of lobster meet. Sauce was all onions and green peppers. Yuck. Canolli was a hard thick shell that seemed deep fried like a wanton. Inside cream was very bland. Not sweet, not cheesy, like thick, flavorless meringue. Sure wish I'd saved my $40 and made scrambled eggs like I had thought about doing. read more

Italian Garden we have missed you, been busy with life & have not stopped by in a while. Welcome In, rang out as we walked into this small family owned Bistro style restaurant. You feel like you're in Rome when the door closes and the hustle and bustle of the world shuts out. Hot garlic bread, iced tea & water with lemon for everyone. Soup of the day Cheese Tortellini, yes please, also Two slices of some of the best pizza we have tasted in the metroplex. The waitress was very attentive & took great care in making sure we had what we needed to enjoy our meal. In my opinion one of the best things for me, was watching the Family sitting at the head table speaking Italian and laughing enjoying their Family and each other's company while running their business. Lock this one in your gps. Load the kids and the wife up. Second thought this would be a great start to a date night event. You chose. Just stop in and enjoy this place. You will not be disappointed. Stay safe read more

See all

So this time we went and got a slice of pizza, which is just amazing pizza. It doesn't matter what you put on it. It comes out perfectly cooked, hot, cheesy, their dough is fantastic, it's just really good pizza! I will say our server kind of dropped the ball but it's hard to be mad when 99% of the time it's always perfect. I'm telling you you cannot find better Italian food in McKinney or prosper. And there is always a little bit of Frank Sinatra playing on the speaker to add to that homie feel of this restaurant! read more

See all

This may honestly be the best food I have ever eaten in my life. I believe I ordered the chicken and shrimp Marsala, or something very close to that, and it absolutely blew me away. Every bite was rich, perfectly cooked, and full of flavor. I already know I will be back, and there is a very good chance I will order the exact same dish again. My wife ordered the chicken dish, not sure the name, and she loved it. We both thought it was the best food we've ever had, and we are both in our 70's. On top of the incredible food, our waitress was exceptionally kind, attentive, and genuinely friendly, which made the experience even better. From start to finish, everything was outstanding. I truly cannot find a single negative thing to say about this place. It deserves 10 stars. We can't wait to go back. read more

Italian Garden - Italian Near Me - McKinney, Texas

Went here for anniversary dinner and the food was amazing. Got two different pasta dishes and meatballs. Also had bruschetta as an appetizer. Everything was well made and delicious. Only knock on this place is lack of liquor license and no wine available. Service was great and ambiance was pleasant with music playing in the background. Recommended for sure, but I'd probably get take out next time. read more

Italian Garden - Tiramisu - Italian Near Me - McKinney, Texas

See all

We have eaten here several times and the food is very good. I thought I had the eggplant parm before. Today I ordered it today and it was not what I was expecting. Baked layers of eggplant , not tasty at all! My husband didn't like the meatballs. I think we just didn't choose wisely. Service was great! read more

This food was really good! Enjoyed everything, the Italian wedding soup, house salad, chicken Florentine, the chicken & asparagus pasta was also good. I loved the music, the service was also very good. So glad I found this place via tik tok read more

See all

Tonight I ordered the chicken piccata togo, opened it up to find that the sauce was watered down to a thin soup consistency. Anyone who's eaten chicken piccata knows the sauce is what makes the meal. Next to the down side of the meal, the employees at the check out are extremely bossy and somewhat rude. read more

I made a takeout order on a Friday night and drove 15 minutes to pick it up. I ordered a GF dish for my wife and when I picked it up, I asked the cashier to verify they made it GF. She said it was and I drove home. Turns out it wasn't made as a GF dish. I immediately called and was annoyed because it's 30 minute round trip to get a correction made. However, the owner took my call and told me to text him my address and what we needed corrected. I did as he requested, and then he personally drove to our house within 20 minutes with the correct dish. What!?! Where has customer service like this been? It was such a welcome surprise. I was so impressed with his quick reaction to right the wrong and his personal touch to make sure his customers all have a great experience. That act alone has made our family customers for life. Well done Italian Garden and BIG thank you to Benny, the proud owner and someone I learned from today. PS: the food was great as always. read more

food tastes so good and authentic and the restaurant was such a vibe def recommend ! service was fast and waitress was nice

While most restaurants have the usual Italian food on their menu this one had an excellent options for food and wine. Had an excellent surprise and the service was great. read more

The little restaurant packs a big punch! The service was wonderful but please know it is BYOB meaning while they don't serve alcohol, you can bring your own wine with you. We were seated right away and enjoyed a good meal. read more

See all

Hidden gem. Tons of great food for the surprisingly low price. Tasted great. Pizzas are awesome too (takeout). Staff was super friendly. Restaurant was busy at 6:30 on a Friday but still only waited a few minutes. read more

Best Italian we've had (The restaurant I went to in San Diego doesn't count). I asked for the veal piccata but ended up getting served chicken piccata. The dish was so good I didn't even mind the mishap. This was the creamiest piccata I've ever had and I still think about it today. The restaurant itself had a family feel to it. Lots of families/close friends were at neighboring tables having a great time. read more

Italian Garden - Shrimp alfredo - Italian Near Me - McKinney, Texas

See all

Simple; authentic, affordable- delicious, and friendly. Staff always welcoming Food consistently good Excellent value always Bring your own bottle of wine ! Have an excellent time ! read more

My wife and I have been frequenting this restaurant since we moved to the area about 16 years ago. We are even more impressed today than we were way back then. Remember well when moma served you everything when things were slow. Still see this precious lady once in a great while. It has been a while though. The selection of Italian delicacies is impressive. Chicken. Veal. All absolutely delicious. The pizza is to die for as well. But let's talk about the soups. Just put your bib on and get ready to pick up the bowl to slurp up every last drop. Each day has a different soup specifically. Don't remember which day is which since each day is just "yummy ". Definitely try the wedding soup. Make sure you try the house salad dressing. It is completely unique and I really can't describe it. While the food has been consistently great that is to be expected since the same cooks in the kitchen the whole time. What is amazing is the staff. They consistently find servers that know Italian food and more importantly know how to treat customers correctly while still having a very open and friendly relationship with them. Maybe it's because we are there so much but either way. You will feel like your favorite daughter is serving you Give them a try. We did all those years ago and continue to do so on a routine basis. Now. Has anyone seen my bigger pants belt read more

Italian Garden is one of those rare hidden gems that totally surprises you, in the best way. From the outside, it's got that unassuming hole-in-the-wall look, but once you step inside, it's warm, cozy, and full of charm. You can tell it's a local favorite the second you walk in. I ordered the chicken parmesan and... wow. The chicken was crispy on the outside, juicy on the inside, smothered in rich marinara, and topped with just the right amount of melty cheese. Served with perfectly cooked pasta and warm garlic bread, chef's kiss. You can taste the love in their food. This isn't mass-produced chain stuff; it's homemade-style goodness. The service was just as impressive. Super friendly staff who genuinely seemed to care that we had a good experience. They checked in just the right amount, offered recommendations, and made us feel completely welcome without hovering. Whether you're craving comfort food or just want a laid-back, delicious dinner spot that won't break the bank, Italian Garden is it. I'm already planning my next visit, and I'm bringing friends! This place has been here forever & I can tell why! read more

First time trying Italian garden was GREAT!! Where do I start? The food was delicious, and they give you a great portion size for a decent price. I had the spaghetti with meatballs which I enjoyed. The service was also very good! Our waiter checked on us every five to ten minutes, while giving us lots of refills on drinks and garlic bread. There was one thing that I didn't enjoy as much about the restaurant, which is the ambience. It had great music, but lighting just felt slightly off and place seemed slightly outdated. However, food and service makes up for that big time. I highly recommend trying this place out. read more

Food is always incredible. Ambiance is a true Italian restaurant with paintings and murals. The service staff can assist you with glasses and bottle opener for wine you bring in. The original family runs this restaurant since the day it opened. Large portions so be ready to take some home. Lunch specials are phenomenal. read more

Great service and delicious food. We always get chicken Alfredo, lasagna or pizza. All are great. We go several times a month.

So I called in a to-go order for five lunch specials to go. When I came to pick them up, I told the older lady upfront that I would need the five sweet teas that come with the lunch special. She said we don't give the drinks when it's a to go order, only when you dine in. What would that even matter? It's the same price whether you eat in or take out. Smh read more

Our favorite Italian BYOB spot! The food is always delicious. Nice, local, family-owned business. Nice and cozy little spot right off of Custer Rd in McKinney! read more

Really great food. Take the recommendations of the weight staff they are top-notch. Italian sausage is one of my favorites as well. Flavorful not dry. read more

Italian Garden - Eggplant Rolotini! yum!! - Italian Near Me - McKinney, Texas

The service is family and awesome. The food exceptional - all the flavors and options. Some of the best calamari we've had, the veal piccata and cheese pizza top the charts. Definitely a must visit Italian favorite. read more

See all

My name is Sharon and I am new to the McKinney area. I have been looking for some good authentic Italian food. I saw it and decided to try it out; and I am so glad that I did. The experience was an awesome one as soon as I walked in the door. I was met with a kind greeting from Alicia. The restaurant atmosphere is very welcoming and warm; with a family owned vibe. I ordered a salad and the three trio pasta. My food came out very quick and it was fresh and very delicious!!! I believe I have found my spot for my Italian food! I will definitely be back and will for sure tell family and friends about this place. read more

Love the food but every time I order to go, I get home and it's the wrong order. Either the pizza or the calzone is wrong. This is 3rd time this has happened in the last 6 months. I suggest checking your items before leaving the restaurant. read more

First of all, I wish I got the name of the kind lady who helped us today she was amazing! We had a slight issue with the new ordering system and it wasn't getting made til we actually got there. We were fine waiting because it would be fresh and hot. We were able to sit in a booth and wait and it was really nice and had a good atmosphere. We waited maybe 10 minutes and we were all good to go when we got asked if we ate leftovers. Then they gave us a whole extra order someone had accidentally double ordered! We love this place regardless but we are so happy that they went the extra mile. Thank you guys so much for everything! read more

Italian Garden - Our meal and the food they gave us!!! - Italian Near Me - McKinney, Texas

This is my favorite pizza in the area! Outstanding service. Good food , reasonable pricing , family owned. The interior is nothing fancy nor does it need to be. The quality of the food is just fantastic. The family clearly cares for their customers especially their regulars. Love love love. If ya want a good pie check them out! read more

Food is not good at all! You can notice that they used 3 or 4 sources for all dishes like the rest of this Italian restaurant, this restaurant is not even from Italian owners!!! read more

The food was unfortunately underwhelming--nothing really stood out aside from the bread, which was decent. The atmosphere was extremely loud, making it hard to enjoy the experience. Staff seemed overwhelmed and rushed, which added to the overall chaotic vibe. I've had better, I've had worse. read more

Service was great! The food was excellent!! Very reasonable priced. Portions size was great! I do wish, I could have had a cocktail, though. I'll definitely be back! read more

Be sure and try the meatball appetizer... I dream about the pink sauce it comes in ...

My family and I just came from here and we loved the food! The staff is great and our server was nice and helpful! We are very shocked on how good the food and atmosphere was in the store, due to us being in McKinney TX lol. We lived on Long Island NY and this food tasted like a real home cooked Italian restaurant. Definitely will go back and we enjoyed everything about this location! read more

Excellent food excellent service. The pizza is absolutely amazing. We love Italian garden and we love the family.

Good food. Nicely decorated. Obviously Italians run it overall a nice place to eat. mangiare!

Wow!! What an amazing experience we had the ambiance was amazing the food was delicious taste of Italy in our small town! Our server Besi was as attentive and such a sweet heart she did amazing made the experience well worth it! We had the seafood combo and the chicken piccata delicious!! Will be back!!! read more

The food here is delicious, and the prices are very reasonable. I would recommend this place to anyone.

The whole family really enjoyed this place. We did take out and our food was still hot after the 15 minute car ride home. We got the lasagna, chicken Alfredo and the chicken parmigiana. read more