Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Italian Pie

    3.1 (43 reviews)
    ModerateItalian, Pizza
    Closed 5:00 pm - 8:00 PM

    Order Italian Pie Takeout or Delivery

    Italian Pie Photos

    Business Info

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Italian Pie

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Garlic bread - RUBBERY AND BURNT

    It's used to be soooo good. Best pizza around. Now they just don't care at all. My last 2 orders have been horrid.

    Italian Salad
    Nick H.

    I'm not too thrilled with this place. The first time I ate here was a couple of years ago when I went with my sister and brother-in-law. They got pizza and I got a calzone. My calzone came quite a while after their pizza and when it did it was cold in the middle and not cooked. I had to send it back. By the time it got back to me my sister and brother-in-law were done eating. Fast forward two years. I go for lunch yesterday. They offer several appealing lunch specials. I go for the Italian salad and calzone. The salad was pretty good. It was a pretty hefty size. I opted for ranch dressing rather than the Italian that came with it and if there is a next time I'll ask them to hold the 200 olives. Yuck! Up next is the calzone and guess what? It's cold in the middle! The cheese is not even melted. How many cold calzones does this place serve? I may try Italian Pie again sometime but I won't be going back to this location. The one good thing about the experience was the waitress. Her name I believe was Alyssa and she was really nice.

    See all

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 1

    12 years ago

    Love the fresh not frozen ingredients! Calzone was great! Service is friendly and attentive! Price for lunch is nice.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Italian Pie

    You might also consider

    Impastato Cellars

    Impastato Cellars

    3.1(130 reviews)
    2.6 mi
    $$

    I had another amazing dinner here, this time with some old friends and their wives…read more Firstly, our server was fantastic. Ashleigh not only had the low down on the best foods to order, but she kept up with our table of 5 like we were beloved family. Everything was sooooo good tonight. From the delicious appetizers, to the incredible salad (seriously, you have got to try this Creamy Italian), all the way to this badass softshell crab dish and the most chocolatey-chocolate cake I've had in recent memory. I lost most of notes for this meal, sadly, because it was super delicious and perfect. We did the 5 course meal menu item and I cannot wait to go back and do it again. Highly recommend an evening at Impastato's. And hey, ask for Ashleigh, get her opinions and smiles, and bask in the warmth of how well she'll care for you and your peeps.

    We decided to try out Impastato's in Mandeville, and overall, it was just okay. The ambience was…read morenice and the restaurant has a pleasant atmosphere, so we definitely appreciated that part of the experience. Our waitress was friendly, but the service felt a little awkward at times. As for the food, what we ordered didn't really stand out. My husband had the chicken parmesan and I ordered the veal topped with seafood. Both dishes were pretty greasy and just not something we would come back for. The best thing we tried was actually the calamari it was tasty and definitely the highlight of our meal. Not a terrible experience, just not great. For the price and the options in the area, we'd probably choose somewhere else next time.

    Photos
    Impastato Cellars - Redfish Marcelo

    Redfish Marcelo

    Impastato Cellars - Cappellini

    Cappellini

    Impastato Cellars - Stuffed Artichoke Bottom

    See all

    Stuffed Artichoke Bottom

    Del Porto Ristorante - Such a great light dish! So refreshing!

    Del Porto Ristorante

    4.2(172 reviews)
    5.4 mi
    $$$

    Del Porto is in the top 3 when it comes to my Wife and I's favorite, but also best and most…read moreconsistent restaurants in Louisiana. I typically go here every year for my birthday and then we typically make it back another time or two throughout the year. I always get the pork chop, as you can tell from the photos I uploaded which are all from different visits. The menu here is always changing which can sometimes be a bad thing however, all the new items and different preparations of the main stays are always delicious. The only bad thing about a menu that changes is your favorite dish may not always be available. Luckily, at this place trying something new typically pays off. I have only gotten something other than pork chop once and it was a braised beef dish, which was great. My Wife typically gets a pasta dish which is always fantastic. We typically try a new app or two along with a salad. Their salads are always changing but the flavor combinations they come up with are awesome. We had a salad one time with Gorgonzola, apple, shallot, candied pecans and a vinaigrette that was one of the best salads we ever had. Their desserts also change and some of them are seasonal. One visit they had a pistachio cheesecake available, which was 10/10. Last year their seasonal sorbet was muscadine, also 10/10. Their wine selection is great and the service is always the best! Food critics typically say a restaurant that gets a 9 out of 10 or higher is worth more than an hour long wait or drive that is a few hours. This place hits that mark for my Wife and I.

    My wife and I went there for lunch today. I had meatballs and spaghetti we shared a salad. She had…read moreshrimp with pasta. She had a glass of Prosecco and I had one crown and seven and unbelievably. The bill was $95 before the tip. That's absolutely ridiculous. We won't ever be going back.

    Photos
    Del Porto Ristorante - Del Porto dining room and bar area.

    Del Porto dining room and bar area.

    Del Porto Ristorante - Pork loin panini

    Pork loin panini

    Del Porto Ristorante - Del Porto in Covington

    See all

    Del Porto in Covington

    Marcello's Restaurant & Wine Bar

    Marcello's Restaurant & Wine Bar

    4.5(78 reviews)
    5.4 mi

    On the recommendation of some friends whose restaurant suggestions have never let us down, my wife…read moreand I made reservations for a Friday evening dinner. Located in a beautifully repurposed home in downtown Covington, this charming spot exceeded our expectations from the moment we arrived. We were greeted by a friendly hostess and promptly shown to our table in one of the restaurant's small but thoughtfully decorated dining rooms. We started with the house-made whipped ricotta at our server's suggestion. Lightly topped with rosemary honey and served with grilled ciabatta, it was absolutely delicious. For our entrées, my wife ordered the Chicken Molli while I chose the Pork Cheek Marsala. Both dishes were phenomenal. Unfortunately, we didn't save room for dessert, so I guess we'll just have to return, which I'm sure won't disappoint my wife in the slightest. When we received the bill we were both surprised because we had expected it to be significantly higher than it was based on the service and quality of the food. The attentive staff, inviting atmosphere, and excellent food all help make this place stand out. We're already looking forward to our next visit.

    My wife and I had an Anniversary dinner at Marcello's Restaurant and Wine Bar in Covington and…read moreenjoyed it very much. Marcello's has an upscale, yet very comfortable, persona and excellent service that combined for an elegant dining experience. Before dinner cocktails were refreshing and we then enjoyed Caesar salad and tomato basil soup before our main courses of chicken parmigiana and chicken molli, both of which were tasty in a traditional way. A tasty cannoli followed up. My wife enjoyed a Pinot Grigio with dinner, and I a very full bodied Cabernet Sauvignon, which was the chef's evening's special recommendation. Marcello's has our recommendation for a special night out.

    Photos
    Marcello's Restaurant & Wine Bar - Interior at Marcello's Restaurant and Wine Bar in Covington,

    Interior at Marcello's Restaurant and Wine Bar in Covington,

    Marcello's Restaurant & Wine Bar - Caesar salad at Marcello's

    Caesar salad at Marcello's

    Marcello's Restaurant & Wine Bar

    See all

    DiCristina's Italian and Seafood Restaurant - Caesar side salad at DiCristina's

    DiCristina's Italian and Seafood Restaurant

    4.0(145 reviews)
    5.6 mi
    $$

    Outstanding food, atmosphere and service! I was a little worried when I visited with a group of…read moregirlfriends. I'm gluten-intolerant and thought the menu would be pasta, pasta and more pasta. Not the case! Our server, Shelby, helped me find a few really good choices and I went with the fish and grits (called something else on the menu). It was outstanding. Rich but not too rich. Large enough portion that I took half home. One friend had the fried chicken and raved about it. (Order early because it takes time.) Another had fried cheese ravioli Several had the Mac and cheese and everybody raved about their dishes. Took home some seafood-stuffed cornbread for my husband. The atmosphere adds to the experience. It's right in the heart of Historic Downtown Covington at the trailhead with huge windows and natural light. Really lovely! They were crowded (on a Tuesday night) but the service was great and the owner popped by several times to check that everything was okay. Already planning a return trip with my husband!

    Truthfully the only positive of this experience was our server, Brennan…read more The crab claws were a nice size on the appetizer but the butter sauce or whatever it was entirely overpowering. The veal was overcooked and the risotto it came with was salty, dry and mushy. Inedible honestly. I was very excited about my triple tail, but it was soaked in heavy cheddar; cheddar grits etc where it was hard to find the fish. So if you like XL portions but terrible food, dicristinas, so So bummed

    Photos
    DiCristina's Italian and Seafood Restaurant - The dining room at DiCristina's in Covington

    The dining room at DiCristina's in Covington

    DiCristina's Italian and Seafood Restaurant - Chef salad at DiCristina's

    Chef salad at DiCristina's

    DiCristina's Italian and Seafood Restaurant - DiCristina's, at the trailhead, in Covington

    See all

    DiCristina's, at the trailhead, in Covington

    Italian Pie - italian - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...