I've been here a million times and always leave happy! There are so many flavors and they keep adding more. I had a double fudge brownie jelati which was a combination of chocolate ice cream and brownie batter ice, it was delicious! read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Double fudge brownie jelati (medium and tadpole mini size) - Desserts Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

Love the gelato with cherry and vanilla ice cream. Price just right and like the outside seating with umbrellas. Service was great and granddaughter liked the cookies and cream with vanilla ice cream. read more

See all

It's definitely not Rita's Italian Ice. The sour green apple gelati had a medicine taste and off pudding. Not my favorite. It was super sweet, too. The fam liked their choices. :( read more

Amazing! Loved it! Lots of options and shaved ice is an understatement. This is a great place!

I was visiting from California and now I'm so sad that i don't have one back home. Such an affordable and amazingly delicious sweet treat. Everyone working there was so kind and helpful, had no problem letting us try flavors and giving their recommendations. It was so delicious and refreshing can't wait to visit Florida again just to come back for this Italian ice! read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Desserts Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

For the longest time we drove by this place and always wondered how Italian Ice and ice cream could go together. A friend brought me here for a treat, and boy how I wish we had come before! Yummy, yummy, yummy. I had the salted caramel with the swirl ice cream. It is so good. They will give you a sample of any flavor you would like, which is nice to be able to figure out what might be your favorite. My daughter got the peppermint special and you could smell the fresh peppermint and she loved it. The service is great. They are very friendly, patient with questions, and are quick with the service. There is also an app so you can track your visits and get a freebie after several visits. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Sitting in the car enjoying our food - Desserts Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

Great spot for a sweet treat. Tried both the Italian ice and gelati and they did not disappoint. Staff was awesome and made some great suggestions for us first timers. Can't wait to go back. read more

See all

Our favorite ICE cream place. Wow! We've been here at least six times tasty ICE cream and sorbets. Friendly staff. Again the offerings causes you to pause and select . The pumpkin, latte and strawberry shortcake ICE creams is outstanding. Enjoy read more

Fun and cute little drive thru/walk up Italian ice/soft serve place. The Italian ice has a ton of flavor options and they are delicious. The service was quick and friendly! Kids lives it and the process were decent. read more

Soft serve ice cream cone is huge. I love it!!! The girls working there made my family's experience enjoyable and gave us some good recommendations. read more

This is a great little Italian ice spot. You can drive through and they give samples. You can get straight Italian ice or mix it with ice cream. Great for a hot day and not too expensive. The line moves at a moderate pace. read more

Great place to go when you are needing or wanting a fresh dessert! It's conveniently located, reasonably priced, has attentive staff, and a wide variety of Italian ices, gelatis, and ice creams. read more

Portions sizes are smaller than advertised, but still delicious, the service was mediocre but still good, the place looked nice too, it was just pretty ok read more

My wife and I love going to Jeremiah's to treat ourselves! Everything is delicious from the plain vanilla soft serve ice cream to the gelati and Italian ice. My dessert-island (#SeeWhatIDidThere?), all-time, go-to favorite is the cookie butter gelati with vanilla soft serve. I do like to venture out and yesterday I tried the special "4th of Gelati" - Strawberry Italian ice, Blueberry Italian ice, and Vanilla Soft Ice Cream. It was delicious and refreshing! The service is always great, friendly and informative. I recommend downloading their APP and racking up points! read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - The Patriotic 4th of Gelati! - Desserts Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

Italian ice is so refreshing and here there are lots if flavor options. There are only two locations in this area, one in Mandarin and the other on the South end if Orange Park. We have visited both on multiple occasions and always happy with the service and yum yum treats!! Never thought of ice cream and flavored ice? Try it- totally a fantastic texture adventure. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Outdoor seating - Desserts Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

I visited Jeremiah's Italian Ice a couple of weeks ago because my sister had a coupon. She had told me that they were very good so we went out to give it a try. I was very skeptical as I didn't see how ice cream and Italian ice would go together but it went together very well. You cant try a sample of any flavor you would like which is great. I am a coffee lover so I got the Caffe Latte Gelati. It was very good. This is definitely a place that I will go back and visit many, many times in the future. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Desserts Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

Need something refreshing on a beautiful sunny day?! This is thee best place for Italian ice. Flavors are so flavorful, the ice is nice and smooth, it's not overly sweet. I love coming here and trying a different flavor every time. Today I had the peach and it was so good. I've tried lemon basil which is amazing! Mango is really good. Bahama breeze is good too. But my all time favorite so far is the green apple! Looking forward to my next visit to try strawberry lemon! They have a drive thru and an outdoor seating area. The workers are really nice. Check out the menu I posted, they have a few other things too. They will have special flavors on certain days too that is not on the menu listed like the lemon basil. They also have an app you can download. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - the menu for today's ice flavors - Desserts Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

See all

I left a review about a month ago of a bad experience that I had. I appreciate the owner responding to me. I did decide to give them a try again today when I was in town from Gainesville. The employees were pleasant today and didn't give me any hassle about trying two samples. I told them that I don't need very much in the soufflé cup, but they filled it to the top anyway. (They were generous). I was glad to try the sample at the window this time instead of in the line. The gelato was delicious. Today I didn't mind leaving a tip for good service. The treatment I received today was how I remembered Jeremiah's being when I would come here with my family for years. read more

SO good! Such fun flavors to choose from! They're always adding new ones as well. My kids and I love adding custard or Oreos

I scream for ice cream (soft serve and shaved ice)!!! Cravings satisfied. Staff super nice. Lots of parking available. Drive thru also an option. read more

See all

I got a soft serve cone with rainbow sprinkles and my son got Italian ice and both were really great. Prices were fair, the service was excellent and there was not much of a wait. I prefer soft serve over hand scooped ice cream and it's not always easy to find good soft serve so I am happy that we just moved nearby this location. It's the simple things in life :) the girl at the window was great explaining everything since she asked if I had been there ever. Will be back, probably a little too often. read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - Desserts Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

This is the closest thing to "water ice" I have found down here. Anyone from up north knows what that is or means. I give Jeremiah's a hand for their valiant attempt, but it's just not totally authentic to the water ice im used to. The gelatis are good and they have a decent variety of flavors. read more

Today was our first time visiting Jeremiah's! Perfect treat for a hot Florida Summer day. The girls working were just darling and told us about the Jeremiah's app where you can earn free ice cream! We had the sugar free apple gelato and blueberry, cherry, gelati and they were both super good. I foresee many more visits for many more treats! read more

Jeremiah's Italian Ice - My sweeties enjoying sugar free green apple and vanilla gelati - Desserts Near Me - Orange Park, Florida

See all

The most refreshing cold snack to get in the area. Never disappoints and has so many options for flavors. The kids love this place and honestly want it all the time. Mix and match of icee and ice cream is a combination I would have never thought went together. read more

Great staff and great flavors! Make sure you're not in a rush because it does take some time to get your order but it's totally worth it!

My favorite desert!!! I treat myself on my day off every week!! A great refresher on a hot day read more

I don't know how they make their "ice-cream" but it's always really good. Awesome place if you are craving some cold sweets!

The food is great the staff is great i do have one complaint though. Ever since roughly after christmas break happened they had to put up signs saying that we couldn't go in there unless we were buying something. Just recently they put up a sign saying that we (high schoolers) couldn't go in and sit UNLESS we have a parent and or guardian. Most hs won't have an adult because a lot of us went right after school. Ever since they put the signs out they have lost so much business and will lose me very shortly. You also aren't allowed to use the restroom unless an adult is with you. I highly doubt that hs are going have parents go with them especially right after school. read more

Service and desserts are always great at any of their locations. They are also great about delicious suggestions on what to order.

If you are looking for a cold ice treat then this is the place. Their customer service was excellent. They have 2 drive thrus & a walk up with outside tables. There's a wide variety of flavors. I got the mix of coconut gelato & vanilla ice cream it was delicious. I highly recommend this place. read more

OMG the gelati is amazing. The staff is always super sweet and fast. They have so many great flavors. I haven't tried one I don't like yet!

Tried the the Key west Italian ice and wow after the brain freeze I'm there lol. Incredible and so many flavors and zero disappointments. Def try them out read more

We love this place! We've been a couple times now. The staff is always very nice!! The flavors are amazing. So many to choose from. The ice cream is on point. Everything is top notch! read more

A must for gelati. Favorites are Bahama freeze, peanut butter & chocolate gelati, and depending on how strong the basil is in the batch- lemon basil. Lesson learned on lemon basil - always sample it before ordering, usually it is good, but one time the basil was extra strong and it was gross. read more

By far my favorite location because of the drive through. I also go to the one on San Josè but I prefer this particular location because at the San Josè location you have to get out your car (if you couldn't tell already, I'm pretty lazy). Me and my Dad always get Jeremiahs on Saturday's after a day out and it's always so good. I've never had a bad experience at this location or any other location. If you have not tried Jeremiahs yet you are 100% missing out on the best ice cream in Duval. The best thing to get is their Italian ice and ice cream. Yes, I know how weird it might sound but trust me on this, it's bomb. I always get the cookies and cream plus the vanilla ice cream and it never fails me :) read more

Uniquely, different. Variety of flavors, friendly staff. To go orders are packaged nicely. Love, love. read more

I'm absolutely addicted to the scoop froggy-frog swirl gelati! My family of 4 stops by here at least once or twice a week & it never disappoints. Free samples if you want to try something new & their app & rewards system is great. Always friendly service. read more

I have no clue who Jeremiah is, but man his version of Mango Italian Ice mixed with soft serve vanilla ice cream is dyn-o-mite! I have passed this place a million times on my way to go visit my grandmother and failed to stop. Don't make that mistake. They have drive-thru. I love mango and If they have this flavor, get it. We got ours to-go in a small size cup. This was plenty for me, but if you go with a few people it's fun to get a ton of flavors and share. I also tried the watermelon flavor and it was good, but the mango combined with the vanilla was so tasty. They have a few locations in Jacksonville so Yelp it and check it out. So far, I've only been to this location and I love what I've tried so far. Next time I want to try the Horchata. Definitely going back! read more

First time I went there, my friend actually took me 3 years ago. And I was in heaven. Those gelatos and Italian ice! Coconut and peanut butter those two are some of my favorites! read more

They have my family hooked!! We come every night and they have the consistency of heaven, I swear you won't be dissatisfied...you'll be addicted in a good way! I recommend the cookie butter and vanilla gelati, the mango Italian ice, lemon basil and vanilla gelati, and the mint chocolate chip Italian ice!! You're welcome read more