I went to the Flemington Jersey Mike's and probably will not visit there again. I ordered two sandwiches to go, an Italian Sub and a Chipotle Chicken Cheese Steak. The Italian sub was fine but the Cheese Steak was a disaster. As I watched the kid cooking it, I asked if that was mine. They were beating it, and chopping it, and cutting it up in such tiny pieces that it hardly resembled chicken. You wouldn't have even needed teeth to eat it. It should be called Chipotle Mutilated Chicken Cheese Steak. Then they shoved it in a bag and tried to send me on my way. There was no "what would you like on it" as there was with the Italian Sub. I would have preferred ketchup and hot peppers but when I questioned them (an older woman who could have been the franchise owner) I was given ketchup packets. I would have expected better, especially for the price they charge. Never again. read more

I have heard of Jersey Mike's but never ate at one. I went the week they opened and was happy to see they have a vegetarian option and they also offer to provide cheese that is precut so it is not sliced on the meat slicer. We have been back a couple times since then and thankfully the lines are not as long. The staff is very friendly. read more

Great sandwich everytime. I live about 30 min away and anytime I go to flemington my wife always requests a sandwich from Jersey Mikes!

Tasty and well worth the mess. Great authentic flavor on my buffalo chicken cheese steak.

Overall a solid option for a good sub or cheesesteak. I am currently in the keto diet so I have been mostly doing their tubs lately. I highly recommend grabbing a sub here and then fries next door at five guys. read more

Great subs and friendly servive. I've only tried a few (2-3) different subs in the mulitple times i've gone but they've always been fresh tasting and consistent. Will continue to go back. read more

This was my first visit to the sub shop which many have spoken highly about trying. We were running our annual rummage sale at our local Flemington Moose Lodge and all profits that are made from these functions are given back to our community such as our local police dept., rescue squad, hospital cancer center, etc. So when we called to have lunch ordered to be picked up for the ladies working the event that day, they offered to donate the subs to us which in turn allowed us to have that expense added to the profits at the end of the day. It's all about paying it forward and not only were the subs delicious, the service and kindness they showed was excellent! Kudos to Jersey Mike's and so glad we have them in our wonderful little town. :-) read more

I like their subs a lot. In fact, I'll go out of my way to go to Jersey Mike's. They give you a lot of meat and the spices they add are very good. I used to be a Just Subs guy but Mike's is much better. The employees are very friendly. I took away a star because despite being empty, the booths and the floor were dirty. Also, I wish they sold Coke products. read more

Love this!!! Use to live at the shore where jersey mikes are everywhere but moved here amd have miss it alot. Taste great!!! Fresh food!! Taste like it dod back at the shore!! read more

Amazing subs! Come here often! Lots of meat and toppings!! I recommend here over any other place with subs!!!! There's a cute sweet guy who makes the subs working here! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - This is the number 6 roast beef took it the mikes way! - Sandwiches Near Me - Flemington, New Jersey

Make sure when you call in an order that you are speaking to a competent person otherwise your order will be all messed up.

Made the mistake thinking a chicken parm sub couldn't be so bad from Jersey Mikes. Boy was I wrong!!!! It was the worst I have ever had. Sauce was burnt and there was so much of it, it destroyed the bread. I took two bites and tossed it. Barely any chicken or cheese. Never again. Gave two stars because I saw two employees and they were nice! read more

I went to Jersey Mikes for the first time in months. I got the number 2, which I believe is called the Jersey Shores Favorite. I got a regular size for $6 and some change. It was pretty small but it did satisfy me. If I had gotten a soda I probably would've filled up a lot quicker. It was not busy at all. It was me and another customer in there at about 8:30 at night. 16 Handles next door was PACKED though, probably because that is more of a desert time then dinner time. Something I don't like about Jersey Mikes is that they're told to conversate with you, and I mentioned this in my other review. I wrote that I had liked it in my other review, which I did, but honestly after a long day and trying to get dinner real quick it was annoying. I wanted her to just make my sub so I can get out but she was asking me what I do, where I'm from, etc. If I was running there for lunch during work I probably would've gotten annoyed. That kind of keeps me from wanting to return here because sometimes you just wanna get your food and get out. It's none of your business what I do. Small talk is fine though. But I haven't returned here in months prior to this because I always felt it was a little too pricy for subs. Will I return? Maybe. read more

Have gone to this sandwich shop twice since they opened. It is typically very crowded, but the employees are very helpful and obviously try to move the line as quickly as possible. The sandwiches are just as advertised, good quality heroes and salads. They will do well in this town as they really don't have any competition for the type of product they sell. read more

Staff is super friendly and the food is great, just like the sub places 'down the shore'.

Killer subs. The Chipotle Cheesesteak is awesome. Service is really good, fast and friendly. John the rewards program.. Got a free regular sized sub today. My fiancée always orders the Italian and she is a jersey girl and knows her Italian hoagies.. She loves Jersey Mike's. Good new spot in Flemington. read more

Awesome subs! Tuna always fresh and the cheese steak chipolte is out of this world. Staff couldn't be friendlier. Walked in at 856pm (closes at 9p) is welcomed with COME IN NO PROBLEM. read more

went there for the first time when I had a coupon for a free sub. well don't think it was even worth free. hardly any meat on the sandwich. maybe 2 slices? saw the prices too not worth it to me. I could make a better sandwich at home and put more meat on it more then two slices. I could have actually eaten three of those sandwiches. better off buying your own cold cuts and make your own. sorry Jersey Mikes. just didn't cut it for me. read more