My fave little hidden location of Jersey Mike's to visit neighbored by Starbucks and Sweetberry Bowls. They're never suuuper busy. I know I can get my order promptly and be in and out. The location is cleanly, the staff is friendly and organized. They have a large variety of accompaniments from chips and fountain sodas to choose from, and their breads and meats are always fresh. read more

The last time my husband and I bought regular subs, the sub has gotten flatter as they really lessened the meat.And paying $13 for each, it is ridiculous. read more

The best, can't beat it. Tried the new chicken salad and it is amazing. Love all their sandwiches!

Always very friendly service. Good quality for fast food subs. Ample parking lot (it is not street parallel parking). A few tables available to sit down as well. read more

First time at this location. I walked in and wasn't sure what I wanted so stepped back to look over menu. Meanwhile, a man & his daughter walked in to order sandwiches. I happen to look down at the station the meat cutter was so dirty! I believe the daughter whispered to her dad about it being dirty so the worker asked him if he wanted her to clean it! I ordered from the grill and only noticed AFTER he put meat in it, how dark it was and I could see all the dark bits so the grill was dirty too. The chicken steak came out so dark that it could pass for regular steak. So disappointed. It was not busy at all so they could have taken the time to clean it. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Chicken cheese steak - Fast Food Near Me - Matawan, New Jersey

The gal who made my sandwich put her hands into the garbage can to move it then proceeded to use the same gloved hands to make my sandwich. Very disgusting. Do better. read more

This is a place that's consistent in its sandwiches. The ingredients are fresh and the bread choices are good. I always get the Turkey wrap. Never need extra meat since once you add what you want on it. It's already thick to roll up. This locations staff is very friendly. Nothing like hearing what the staff recommends. And still I get my Turkey sandwich. Today they had a group that was fun and fast in service. Team work and fresh food will always get 5 stars read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Turkey wrap - Fast Food Near Me - Matawan, New Jersey

just came from this jersey mikes in Aberdeen and although the service was good, they hardly put any meat on my sandwich. Definitely not the same at each location, but this one is off my list. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Where's the ham???? - Fast Food Near Me - Matawan, New Jersey

I'm reviewing Jersey Mikes because I've been getting consistently good sandwiches from this location on Main St in Matawan. I got the number 5 today, I used to get a number 11 but the 5 seems meatier somehow. Their cheesesteaks are very good too. Always a friendly greeting when entering and they're observing all covid protocols. I think I like the subs here so much because they remind me of when I was a deli manager when I was a kid. Our subs were very similar, always fresh cold cuts, bread is excellent, and toppings are done right. So stop by, get a number 5 mikes way. Also, I find it very convenient to order and pay from the app, and then pick up in the store. read more

My husband and I have been here many times for lunch or dinner and they continue to have excellent service. I can't believe I haven't written a review for them sooner! This last visit we used the online ordering for the first time and it went perfect. We were able to put in our orders through the app and also write in any special requests in the notes. In the past the only small issue Ive had is if you take the sandwich home with you it may get a little soggy with the dressing. So this time I put in the notes section that I wanted the oil and vinegar mix kept on the side. They did exactly what was requested. They had a small container of oil and vinegar ready to go wrapped in plastic wrap to put with my order when I picked it up. The staff there is always so nice and they are efficient with getting your order done quickly and right the first time. I really like their system. This is my husband's favorite go to place for a sandwich and will continue to go. read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Side of oil and vinegar! Keeps the sandwich from getting soggy! - Fast Food Near Me - Matawan, New Jersey

I helped a friend move this weekend, on my way home i asked my son if he wanted lunch. He asked me to bring him Jersey Mikes, he loves this place. This was my first time here i got a mini Italian and chips. He got a turkey club-mikes way. They were pretty busy, they said nothing to the stoner that came in to get his pickup order. He paced the store for 3-4 minutes without a mask before he realized that his food was on a shelf. Oh well, everyone else knew how to follow protocol. The first thing that blew my mind was the Low budget cold cuts they used ....yuck. The second thing was the price, $19.00 for a mini (like two bread rolls)and a regular sub with a bag of chips. No drinks. Was the sandwich terrible? No. Would i go there again, probably not for myself. I usually go to Demarcos up the street and get their equivalent of a king Italian sub, made with boars head on fresh baked bread-Price $12.00 No idea what all the hype is about. read more

I love Jersey Mikes, but today was so disappointing. The guy making the subs after he wrapped them would pick up any left over lettuce that was on the counter and just throw it back in the with the fresh lettuce. What topped it off and I walked out was he then scraped everything off the cutting board back in with the lettuce too. When I asked why he was doing that his reply was "the subs are on the counter too"... Well they shouldn't be !!! REALLY... someone needs to retrain him. read more

Truly the best Jersey Mikes we've been to. Consistently good, with friendly service. Customized sandwiches are always perfect. So happy we found it. read more

So our favorite place for subs, DA Subs closed early as a result of COVID-19, we tried Jersey Mike's in Matawan. We ordered the regular cheese steak while our kids got the Italian sub. My wife and I likes the bread, the cheese, peppers and onions but the main ingredient, the steak was horrible. The meat contained gristle with almost every bite. Gristle is the fragments of the cartridge and is often indicative of a cheap cut of meat. Since the kids enjoyed their Italian subs I gave it two stars. Otherwise this particular Jersey Mikes did not even deserve the two stars for their cheese steak. read more

I purchased a whole roast beef sub and could not be more disappointed! This is not up to Jersey Mike's standards very small meat and fixing. If I want this crap I'll go to Subway! Done paying full price for subpar product. Bye bye read more

Way over priced when you pay $28.00 for one whole sub and one 1/2 sub. Same quality as Subway that's cost 1/3 more, never will recommend or step one foot inside this franchise again read more

god i love jersey mikes so much. the man who's there every god damn day always makes my giant #13 the best i have ever had. He must be holding the store together with his pinky finger or something. That man needs a raise or something, i don't know what he's making but i KNOW it needs to be more. this place is getting 5 stars simply because of him. if hes not the manager he better be soon... or else they'll be loosing A LOT of business. UPDATE. i went in there and the food was even better wow he just gets better read more

Came for a sandwich.. but left with an open heart. I came in on a random Monday morning, in a bit of a rush as I was about to drive to CT to a hospital where my niece had just been born.. My first nibling. I knew I needed something good to eat for lunch so wanted to grab it before I went. The 2 guys working the counter did something that's never happened to me while purchasing a sandwich anywhere.. They asked me how my day was going and what my plans were with real authenticity and curiosity. When I told them what my plans were, they suggest I ask the new parents (my brother & sis in law) if they wanted food, since they probably were eating hospital food the last day or two. I hadn't even thought of that. I was in such a rush I didn't even think of anyone but myself. I made a call to them and they were thrilled that I offered, my sister in law hadn't been able to eat ham for the last 9 months and was very happy that I called and asked. When I went to pay for the 2 subs, the guy insisted that they were on him. Truly, my mind and heart are blown at how cool that was. I was so glad I stopped into Jersey Mikes to get subs that morning. For a place called 'Jersey Mikes', these guys don't act like the average strangers you meet in NJ. My heart was wide open and I left there with the biggest smile on my face and drove to the hospital feeling amazing at how beautiful people can be. Thank you guys. read more

Slightly smaller setting than most JMs. It feels much smaller when the line starts to form mixed with people waiting for their food. It's a little confusing of who's waiting and where the line starts/ends. The food is standard JMs (delicious!) My only real beef with this place is the one female staff member (blonde hair) was rude while taking my order. It was if I was annoying her. And the staff member assigned to the grill completed a transaction on the register with his gloves on and then went back to the grill without changing his gloves. I watched as he proceeded to make sandwiches with those contaminated gloves. Gross! and no thank you. I will not be returning to this location again. read more

The sandwiches are pretty good. If you order a cold sub "The Mike's Way", they will top it with onions, lettuce, tomatoes, oil & vinegar, and spices. I've only ordered the turkey breast and provolone so far, but I keep going back which is a good thing. I would hate to compare them to any other sub shop, so I won't. I do think they can stand out from the others. I'm interested in trying one of their hot sandwiches, maybe the chicken parm, on my next visit. The customer service is pretty good, and the store is clean with a decent seating area. Great location since they are in a strip with several other, but very different, fast casual food restaurants. They're open M-Sun 10a-9p. read more

I personally go about 2-3times a week to get my number 9 sub with American cheese and they know my order and make me feel welcome! Always asking me about my day and giving me fantastic customer service. I have been to a lot of jersey Mikes and this one is the best so far!!!! read more

Jersey Mike's Subs - Fast Food Near Me - Matawan, New Jersey

The food is great. Everything is very fresh, and the staff is just awesome. The number 13 Mike's Way can't be beat.

There was a misunderstanding when I ordered online. When I got to the store and we realized there I wanted a sub rather than a tub, the gentleman made the sandwich in seconds. Thanks for helping a hungry person out!! read more

I have a regular joint I go for subs but figured I would give them a try. Went with the club sub which is roast beef, turkey, Swiss and bacon. They offer three (3) sizes for some unknown reason and I always go with a 1/2 sub which is just that a half of a sub loaf. Four (4) slices of each meat, that's right four (4) measly thin slices of turkey and roast beef. In essence I had a lettuce sandwich because they don't skimp on that. If not for the convenience of their location they would not make it a year. What a joke and way pricey for about 4oz of meat. No extra lettuce please. The one (1) star is only to allow me to write the review I give them 0.0 stars. read more

Every time I walk into this store I feel so welcome. All of the workers are so kind and friendly. The floor is always clean the workers are always shaved and we'll kept. I have no worries about hairs getting into my food. All the workers are friendly, a little too friendly sometimes haha. Hella sick ass submarine sandwiches I would definitely go back read more

Jersey Mikes is the most precious thing in my town. It's so amazing and clean and the workers really know their way around a sub. I come here at least everyday. It's like a healthy addiction due to all healthy food. I highly recommend this sub shop. It might not be a $5 foot long but you're still getting the bang for your buck ;). read more

Subs are really good, store is very clean and staff are very attentive. We order here once a week. A little pricey when you add drinks and chips, so sign up for their rewards. You frequently get free subs. read more

Big fan! Love the fresh bread and great customer service! I come here almost every day and am always very happy with everything! Very clean too! read more

I wish I could give a 0!!!!! ABSOLUTELY DISGUSTING! Bread completely soggy.. threw out entire sandwich. First and last time at this location. read more

Great customer service, food fantastic! We were extremely impressed with the new location and how well the staff was trained. Very knowledgeable and friendly. We were greeted when we walked in, and acknowledged on line while staff was making our sandwiches. We have also used the online service, place your order, pay in advance, and run in and pick it up, so easy!!! read more

First time and last time ordered a chicken parmesan when I opened it it was ice cold they don't know how to make a sub

This is one of my favorite sub shops in the jersey shore area. They have amazing subs and have the best workers around, all of them are so nice and make you welcomed. It is truly a great experience and I recommend. read more

Food always comes out great but the staff is what makes this location 5 stars. Everyone who works here is happy and makes you happy to be there. read more