Wow! What an experience. I went to Jersey Mikes on a Sunday afternoon. It was decently crowed and there were about 10 guys working behind the counter. We were greeted right away and placed our order. It was obvious that most of the guys working there were new to the job. The guy who made the sandwich kept touching his hat/hair after placing my toppings on the sandwich. A big turn off for a germaphobe like myself. I may go back, but after a few months. I think they have a few quirks they need to work out. read more

Another new place to eat in the Warren dining scene. Jersey Mike's opened a few weeks ago in Warren right next to A&G. I actually had no idea they had opened until I saw a menu at the barber shop. I've been to a few Jersey Mike's locations around the state but this is definitely the closest one to where I live. I stopped in here on a Sunday afternoon and they were not packed -- no line and only one table being occupied. For starters, they have about 10 tables, fountain soda and a half decent chip selection. I was bringing food home so I went with a "Giant" original Italian sub. The giant is probably about 12-14 inches or so and a pretty perfect size for 2 people to split for lunch. The sandwich was pretty good. They do not load up the meats but they're not stingy with the other toppings and have a very good hot pepper selection (hot peppers, jalapenos and hot pepper spread). The sandwich tasted good and fresh -- no complaints from me there. They had a bunch of guys working behind the counter but only a couple of guys really doing anything. I'm sure they're still working some things out. It's not the most amazing sandwich in the world but they're tasty. We'll definitely be back from time to time. read more

waste of money because this store cant make hot subs like the rest of the jersey mikes. for 10$ each and they didnt heat my bread on the grill and its yesterday bread so it was gross, the cheese was cold and clumped in one spot all stuck in the paper. first bite was old bread and hard cold cheese. waste of money since this store cant hold the standards like the one at rutgers. this store used to be good a couple years ago. read more

Cheese steaks are soo good friendly staff but the place is an ice box so I suggest you take your food to go unless you like eating with a jacket on in a freezer. read more

I'm a huge lover of Jersey Mike's subs. However, this location has to be the slowest sub shop I've ever visited. Three people to make one sandwich in fifteen minutes. If it was one time I'd chalk it up to as an aberration. I use to make subs at various locations in my youth. I was timed at three minutes by myself. If you like Jersey Mike's the subs are good. You'll just have to wait. Also make sure they do it the way you like here. read more

Not the best but not bad(superb compared to Subway).I wouldn't eat here, the atmosphere is , lacking.I took out a Salami,Ham and Provolone sub ,ate it in my car and enjoyed while drinking Green Socha Tea acquired elsewhere.Read the Economist.Not a bad thing to do! read more

I went here for lunch and it was so disgusting. The price was too high. The workers carelessly made my sub too. They weren't focused at all and just put it together without any consideration. Because of that, I came back home after 2 minutes on the road, and came to find my sub half destroyed, cheese, sauce, and half of it already fell off. 2 whole minutes...and this happens. To top it off, the meat and bread were not fresh. Absolutely disgusting don't come here. There are plenty of other sub shops that offer better subs than this. I'd recommend subway. read more

Very very good subs. Service needs improvement as they are quite slow but the food is impeccable. Once you try it you'll want to tweak it every now and then just to find that sweet spot but once you do, they keep you hooked. My entire family now eats here: GOODBYE SUBWAY! read more

Excellent sandwiches. Especially there cheesesteaks. Staff is very nice. The line moves quickly read more

I grew up at the Shore some 50+ years ago and since have not had a sub that could match Sam's Sub on the Asbury Circle on Rt. 35 in Neptune until TODAY. The soft bread, freshly cut meat and cheese, mountain high lettuce and tomatoes, drenched with spices, oil, and vinegar brought back taste buds that I long thought died. A great tasting sandwich that rekindled old memories, despite workers now wearing plastic gloves, and not sporting grease stained aprons to wipe the knife against after cutting each sandwich as Sam did in the 1960's. Now if they only had Cott's soda. read more

Jersey mikes subs were great. Perfectly made and tasted great. Some of the best subs I've had lately

Unbelievably bad service at the Warren, nj Jersey Mikes! They forgot to put one of my subs in the bag so I got home and was short a sub. I called to make sure they had it went all the way back to the store to get it and no real accommodation for their mistake was offered! No, instead, please wait in line to pay. Terrible customer service.. .really read more

Love this location. They take pride in making the sandwiches well even when there is a line out the door. Topics are generous and very fresh!!! Keep up the quality guys!! read more

Recently went up to eat there. What an awesome cheesesteak sandwich very friendly staff. Staff member name Dan was very friendly. Defiantly would go again. Pam T. From Martinsville NJ read more

Not a wise choice. Place really needs to be cleaned better. Granted it was around 5 pm but they should be sweeping during the course of the day. Scraps of paper/napkins/straw sleeves. Both us us had to use the rest room. Based on my wife's comment it was as bad as the men's room!! Again it should be cleaned multiple times a day!! Sandwich was so so. Not even worth returning for that. Should have gone next door to the Italian deli A&G. !!! read more

Tons of flies flying around and the cheese slicer looked like it had not been cleaned in a long time .

If you're open until 9pm shouldn't you serve food until 9pm? I mean that's the point of going there right? When I walk in at 8:25 and have to wait for the counter help to finish chewing the food they were eating just to tell me they are closed tells me a lot about how you do business. read more

Service was horrible - the server there was a teenage girl who messed up our order, took forever to make the sandwich, and when it was finally made it was made incorrectly. She was also extremely rude to me and my friend when we went to pay, giving us a snide remark about how we dressed (coming from a funeral). She also refused to let us pay before she could "ring up" who I guess where schoolmates of hers since she gave all 6 of them free sandwiches. Overall the place was clean and pleasant but the sandwich maker, named Sarah (I think), was very rude and inappropriate. read more

Made a great sandwich, very friendly. Welcome addition to Warren.

First time last time! Meat cutter cut my bread on the actual counter no paper protection. Garnisher did everything on a cutting board?. Why did they have a cutting board and the one with the knife didn't? the Cashier took my money then without changing gloves took my naked sandwich from the garnisher and placed it on the paper and continually touched my sandwich as they rolled it up. Wrote comment on their site but no courtesy of a reply. You think if someone writes about food cross contamination on their internal website the owner would respond. Wrong, now I am doing it publicly. read more

I could not wait to get home and write in about my latest Jersey Mike's experience. Recently a location opened up down the street from where I live, in Bernardsville, NJ. In the couple of weeks it has been open, I've gone a good handful of times. The customer service and freshness of food I've gotten there so far held a high bar for any other Jersey Mike's location I would visit. From the moment I woke up this morning, I was craving my favorite sub specifically from Jersey Mike's. My mom and I happened to be running errands in the Warren area, and when we pulled into the strip mall we were pleasantly shocked to see a Jersey Mike's right where we were shopping! I commented on our way inside that I hoped the Warren location had as friendly staff as the new Bernardsville location. I will tell you, the Warren location was as fantastic! This was all thanks to a specific team member named Dan. From the moment we walked in, we were promptly greeted. Needing time to decide, after a few minutes Dan took the time to help us decide which subs were right for our palates. I had been craving my #7 so I decided to stick with what I came for, but Dan suggested the #8 and gave such a great description/recommendation that next time I am for sure trying it! When we debated over which sizes to get, he let us know about each size, including the mini size which I hadn't been aware of previously! He introduced us to the Warren location's Rosemary Parmesan bread, which I plan on getting with my #8 next visit. He even answered some of our questions about how long the store had been open, and the most popular subs of the menu. I have seen signs about a loyalty program, but the Bernardsville location had never mentioned it during any of my visits, (about 4 visits so far.) I was so happy when Dan brought it up. By the end of our transaction, I was starting to earn my points toward a free sub. (I can't wait!) I am so, so glad we stopped in. I am completely sure that it was Dan's continuation of what I assume is the Jersey Mike's "way" of outstanding customer service that has now given me the confidence that I could go to any location and receive a warm welcome with knowledgeable staff. Thank you so much, Dan! See you soon! read more