Ambiance - 5 Food - 3 = Overall score of 4 Cute little spot in historical area of town. It does remind you of an old tavern. They serve lots of hearty, homey dishes - including homey deserts such as banana bread pudding and apple crisp. I thought my food was so-so. Their Caesar Rodney was really enjoyable. After all the excitement around the pot pie, I was excited to try- and I think I was oversold. It was rich - in a strange way - with very little beef. The peach cobbler was disappointing- I wished for a crunch and I got a sponge cake on the bottom. read more

See all

Love the historical significance of New Castle, it's Main Street and surrounding area. Jessop's Tavern is a neat little Tavern that has a wonderful beer menu, an amazing menu of bar food and a full menu of dishes, sandwiches, and dessert selections. Servers are friendly, food was well presented and delicious, and we loved the ambiance of this place. If visiting this area would strongly recommend Jessop's Tavern for a cold beer and a hearty mean. Yes, please!! read more

See all

Great food, great service in a fun pub! Highly recommend this place for a great meal- read more

Jessop's Tavern - Dutch Pastrami Reuben- delicious! - American Near Me - New Castle, Delaware

Delicious food and friendly service! Love going there! But make a reservation they get packed!

One of our favorite places in Delaware! Food is exceptional and it would take five years to get through their beer selection. Always on point! read more

Had lunch here. What an amazing colonial style pub. The menu was totally amazing. Great Belgium beers. The 2.5 lb shepherds pie was amazing. The mussels steamed in Belgium beer were off the hook. The lobster pot pie was to die for. Overall great service & fantastic food. The servers & bartenders dress in the colonial attire. We will be back. read more

We discovered this restaurant by accident while wandering the historic colonial center of New Castle, Delaware. It is a colonial tavern full of historic memorabilia and great food. The atmosphere is amazing by itself, but both food and service were excellent. We had the crab dip baked in sourdough bread, salmon perziken, and roast duck halfling. The crab dip is probably the best I've ever had, incredibly rich and flavorful, my duck with green beans and mashed potatoes was excellent, my wife loved the salmon. I had the wonderful Washington's Porter, my wife the Bonny Doon Rose. I wish it was local, I would like to try the rest of the menu, and sample more beer and wines. I highly recommend this place. read more

See all

Excellent food, service, and in general a great area with a lot of history! Jessop's Tavern has been around for A LONG TIME, and there's a reason why... Love you guys, just the best! read more

This place is amazing! The staffing is so knowledgeable about anything on the menu. Eaten here 3 times in a week and can't wait to go back when I'm back in town. This is a must place to eat when in the area!!!! read more

The lobster pot pie is out of this world. The beer selection can't be beat, especially when it comes to Belgian brews. The ambiance takes you back in time without feeling phony. The service is prompt and friendly. 5 stars all the way! read more

Great food and drinks, recommend making reservations or sit at the bar, service is excellent regardless

My husband and I love to come here around Christmas every year because the Colonial atmosphere lends itself to the spirit. The food is very good and the drinks are yummy. read more

Not only was the food amazing, the Belgian beer terrific but the staff was attentive and kind. Atmosphere was old world colonial. We were a group of 30 and Jessop's had a private room to accommodate us. So special. I left a pair of vintage sunglasses and was so upset. Manager located them morning after and fedexed them back to me. I am so grateful!!!!! read more

Great place filled with locals and tourists alike. Largest selection of Belgian Nails in all of Delaware

Jessop's Tavern is somewhat of a historic tourist trap. The staff dress up like colonial workers and the décor is done up to give the feel of Revolutionary times. While the building has been here over 300 years, Jessop's itself is only 20 years old. We came in here after touring the Courthouse that morning and took seats at the bar. They have a huge selection of Belgian beers including the Tripel Van De Garre which is their house beer. The beer has 11 percent alcohol by volume so it packs a punch but was also very refreshing. For lunch I ordered the Dutch Pastrami Reuben which was hot pastrami, swiss cheese, grilled onions and mustard on a pretzel roll. It came with sweet potato fries and a pickle. The meal and beer were delicious. The atmosphere is really cool but because the place is somewhat touristy, there were some little kids screaming which makes the "Tavern" part seem like a misnomer. read more

What a cool spot!! Really great beer selection! The food, the bartenders, the staff, etc... I cant say wnough good things about this cool tavern!!! read more

Food is always wonderful and plentiful I love the tavern salad and the skip jack shrimp Server are great lovely atmosphere read more

I was eager to try this place and honestly I thought I was going to be impressed but that wasn't the case at all. I called ahead for reservations for lunch and we were seated immediately Points for having an available reservation during the pandemic. We ordered the crab dip. Kinda bland and it was room temperature. Caesar salad was fresh and delicious. We were super excited about the lobster mac n cheese but again bland and sadly not much lobster. Waitress was sweet. I also ordered ice cream here another time and the oreo ice cream was freezer burned. read more

Jessop's Tavern - Caesar salad with walnuts - American Near Me - New Castle, Delaware

See all

Random selection on our way though back to VA, and so glad we stopped! It's a small place so if you don't have reservations you might need to sit at the bar, it was just two of us so it worked out well! Great beer and cider choices. We split the Sheppard pie it was delish and it's a HUGE portion!!! My husband also enjoyed a cone of the maple ice cream in our way out. Would recommend to anyone passing by to try it out!! read more

See all

Visited yesterday (Sunday) @ 2:30 to 4:00. Upon entering requested a table, only two tables were occupied. I was told all the tables were reserved for the entire day and only seating at the bar. Visited the bar, great bartender and service. Upon leaving, almost all tables were still not occupied???????? During this period of time many people were turned away. Charming place, great bar service, can't review food because there were no tables available...although unoccupied during the entire length of our visit? If I was a potential buyer, the first thing I would do is fire the management team! read more

Cool atmosphere, great location near the delaware river. Service was quick and helpful. Food was delicious! Would def recommend! Will be back! read more

Hard to write a full review, as we were kicked out the place... My wife and I were waiting for 2 others and had a beer and an appetizer. Both were very good. But our friends showed up with their young son, and the staff said we could not get an extra chair for him. Now the place is not big, but he was a child and we could have fit him in. It would have been tight, but no big deal. The staff REFUSED to allow all of us to stay and sit. After 10 minutes of 'negotiating', or trying to, they said they could not accommodate us. Really... Ridiculous. Never been treated like that anywhere, ever. read more

Had a reservation for a week then 3 hours before our arrival they accidentally cancelled it. When I got the notification I called immediately and their only response was that we could eat at 8pm.... instead of cancelling the other reservations they made after cancelling mine. Done try and get a reservation it will be cancelled because they can't figure out how to run a business. read more

The food was excellent. However the place is literally a small basement. Today there were extensive repair projects being done. A big business lunch was being held (about 8 loud talkers) and with a virtually empty place otherwise we were seated Right Next to them The Health Department should inspect the single bathroom- it's as big as a very small closet The construction related obstruction was almost too much to get through Food excellent but the place is a terrible mess We'll never go back read more

Came in today for lunch and enjoyed two of the lunch specials for the week. We started with the Scottish egg as an appetizer, it was really good and served with a really yummy mustard. The beef stew in the bread bowl was delicious, it was warm and filling on a cold winter day. Our waitress was Sarah, she was so nice, helpful and friendly. read more

Jessop's Tavern - Scottish Beef Stew in a Bread Bowl - American Near Me - New Castle, Delaware

See all

Great food with great atmosphere. The service is always top notch with a friendly staff. The owner is always appreciative of everyone of his customers and isn't afraid to show it. You'll feel transported back in time while enjoying a great dining experience. We've never been disappointed in all the times we've dined at Jessops Tavern read more

They have Great service food was awesome will visit again great location nice environment

Great atmosphere and quality food. Apparently the owner insists on making sure the meals are enough for some to take home. We tried so many things --all deliciously made. From the mussels , lobster Mac and even the bread were all served piping hot as well as culinary level good. Main dishes including the duck w the sweet cherry glaze were crisp and delicious. Great stop while visiting historic 1600s town on the water here. Definitely would be back even for a business meeting. They even had a Jefferson Ale there along w a compendium of beers. Atmosphere was very 17th century down to the real candles lit and service was fantastic. Packed even on a Wed night. Definitely will be back read more

Jessop's Tavern - Mussels in crock and lobster Mac and cheese as appetizers. Perfect - American Near Me - New Castle, Delaware

See all

We very much enjoyed our visit to Jessop's. The interior decor is very much in line with the historical neighborhood are is the food offerings. The staff wear period costumes which also set the tone. There was a short waiting time for a table when we arrived and we opted to sit at the bar. The bartender came over after helping some other customers, took a drink order and asked if we would like to see the menu, which she brought right over. My cup of coffee was huge and very strong. Just what I needed. The milk was served in a small milk pitcher; right in line with the historical theme they have going on in here. We both got the pot roast dinner which is a huge portion served on a pewter plate. Again, nice touch keeping that historical theme going. The green beans were fresh, not frozen, and still had a nice crispness to them. It was a tasty and filling meal. Real 'home made' food. I absolutely recommend this restaurant if you are in town. The staff were all very pleasant and professional, the restaurant itself feels like you could be stepping back in time and the food good quality. read more

See all

RJ and I had dinner here on New Years Day. We started with skipjack shrimp. They were big beer battered shrimp, and very delicious. RJ ordered Fish and Chips, and I ordered the New Sweden Meatloaf because I can't NOT get the meatloaf. I just can't, no matter how hard I try. It is the most amazing meatloaf on the planet with vodka cream sauce and lingonberry preserves. RJ said the fish and chips were good but he wished he had ordered the meatloaf. Our server was wonderful, as usual and we finished with creme brulee cheesecake, yum! read more

See all

Best lobster mac and cheese ever! Fantastic blonde female bartender! Very old style and full of history!

Love the old theme in the restaurant, live music there is always pretty good. wait staff is very nice and the place is overall very clean for its old fashioned interior. i personally love the blue cheese steak sandwich. super filling and high quality. read more

Enjoyed a lovely dinner here tonight. We love the atmosphere and the beer selection is like no other restaurant I've ever been to. Food and service were phenomenal! And did I mention the bread pudding?? Yum. Everyone we eat here, we have a really good experience. Highly recommend Jessop's. read more

Everything here is perfect. Huge beer selection. Pot Roast & Meatloaf were amazing. I haven't had peach ice cream this good in ages. Sarah provided excellent service. Building is super cool, historic. Ecstasy. read more

Fantastic fish & chips and maple walnut ice cream to die for, in an old English pub setting.

Five stars for food, service and ambience. Jessop's is nestled in Old New Castle with all its charm. The selection of hand crafted beers are the best around. read more

The beer menu is endless and to die for. Many choices and delicious food. Good sized portions at a great price. Love the attire worn by staff and the colonial cozy feel. I ordered the chicken chesapeake with green beans and mashed potatoes. It was heavenly, the mash potatoes were bland but the lump crab meat smothered with cheese on chicken did not dissapoint read more

They sure know how to market colonial America. If you are the historic center of New Castle and want a colonial experience then east here. The building itself is over 300 yrs old and tavern staff dress the part. The menu does have typical colonial food items along with local seafood. read more

The food was very good at the Jessup Tavern for lunch on a Saturday in June and the service was excellent.

Oh, wow. This kitschy historic tavern exceeded my expectations tenfold. I saw it was rated highly here and my mom's friend had also recommended it, so we stopped in for an early dinner. It's right in the heart of Old New Castle (near the Delaware River/Battery Park) and offers a large menu of old-timey fare. I didn't have the biggest appetite so I ordered the caesar salad. My mom contrasted with the Pilgrim's Feast, and my friend chose the middle ground with the pulled pork sandwich. Once the food arrived, my appetite jumped quite a bit, and I ended up stealing sweet potato fries (so good!), pieces of pork (so good!), mashed potatoes in gravy (so so soooo good!), turkey (ugh so good), and stuffing (yep, you got it -- so good!). My salad paled in comparison...but was still delicious. For dessert, I ordered the chocolate lava cake. My mom and friend got ice cream. The cake was incredible beyond words, so I'd say I won the dessert round. Not to forget, I didn't plan to drink anything here until I noticed de Garre on tap. Like, what? How? I was just in Bruges and it was the best tripel of my LIFE. I didn't expect to be able to try it again so soon! But be warned: Since it's imported, it's not exactly like the Bruges version. There was minimal head and the pour was much more generous. As an 11% beer, that can be good or bad depending on your preferred state of mind. Beyond de Garre (which you really should try; $12), they have a massive Bible of Belgian beers, plus some locals and even an exclusive Brambleberry (which was too sweet for me). Wine and cocktails are also available but beer is the star. So basically, not only is Jessop's a kitschy tavern, but it's also a hidden Belgian beer mecca and a great place for a top-quality meal. New Castle is close enough that I can safely say I'll be returning...and hopefully soon. read more

See all