Joe's Brick oven pizza was , hands down , one of the best pizzas we have ever had!!! We ordered a Siscilian pizza with 2 toppings. It was cooked perfectly with a great ratio of yummy sauce to cheese ! It was huge ( 16 pieces) and fed us for 3+ meals. The chicken parm sandwich was also delicious. It was real ( not breaded , pattied chicken ) with lots of cheese , sauce and toasted in the oven. Way to go Joe. ! We will be back. Meg read more

Personally my family believes this is the best pizza in the Poconos. We're Jersey people who relocated 34 years ago. I think his pizza is better than some of the places we used to get pizza in NJ. Many in Jersey have closed since then, but the few that remain, we prefer Joe's. He's a nice guy. Only issue is there are no guarantees he's gonna be open when you're in the mood for a good pizza. He will close without warning. read more

Best Pizza in the Poconos. As close to NY style as you can get. Service is friendly and fast.

Only leaving a 4 star so that I can keep this open ended for when I go back and try more. For today I only grabbed a plain slice and a white slice. Had some people I know tell me that Joe's Brick Oven was the real deal so I had to stop in and find out. I love a good white slice and figured trying the plain was necessary to gauge against others in the area. The sign says Brooklyn Style pizza and anytime a place says that I'm skeptical right off the bat. Well...this is in fact Brooklyn style, and it's good. Quite good. The sauce on the plain had just enough sweetness that it wasn't overly acidic. The amount of cheese was perfect, and the dough had good consistency and flavor. Nice crispy crust! The crust was even crispier on the white slice and the ricotta was seasoned up nicely. I'll absolutely be back to try out more but for now, Joe's Brick Oven in Cresco, PA - Didn't Suck! For the video from this location and hundreds more please check out my social media pages - https://linktr.ee/Didnt_Suck read more

See all

Best pizza ever.....and I've tried many! Great taste, friendly service and a great value. Will be back often!

Best pizza I've had in a very long time! Several tables available for dine in. Restaurant is immaculate.

Never seems to be open and they had 2 other places and sold and now opened another one? So they are competing with the new owner. Was never a fan of the first two establishments. Unless the owner changed his hours and attitude I cannot recommend. read more

Wow Great pie ! Had a half pepperoni pizza here the other day and it was fantastic ! We could not finish it so we took it home with us and It was just as good the next day for lunch. It heated up nice and crisp. The owner and the people working there are so friendly and they made us feel as if we knew them forever. We will be back soon. read more

The pizzas are delicious and so fresh. This place smells soooooo dang yummy and the guys who work here are always so friendly and helpful. Good food and good service!!! read more

Saturday evening. Drove into town looking for pizza. Lights were on but doors were locked. IDK. Pretty weird. Went to Capri which was decent but only make one size pie so maybe try a different town. read more

Joe makes some awesome pizza! The buffalo chicken was fantastic and so was the plain. The pizza was a perfect level of thin and crispy. It was ready on time and service is always great. If you're looking for the best pizza spot in town, I would stop here. read more

Joe’s Brick Oven Pizza - Buffalo chicken pizza - Pizza Near Me - Cresco, Pennsylvania

Best pizza in the Poconos. Legit NY/NJ pizza in the Poconos. I tried the plain and pepperoni. Both excellent!

We had an amazing pizza experience's at Joe's pizza restaurant! The pies were fresh and made just right! We had the run of the whole pizzeria for our family reunion and it did not disappoint. The salad, pizza and the service were awesome. We will definitely come back! read more

Best Pizza I've Ever Had Really Friendly guys , If you're in The Poconos and are looking for pizza this is the place to go.

Joe makes the absolute best pizza. It's delicious and the service is always outstanding.

Terrific service and pizza. We recently went with a big group and they very accommodating, delicious food and just the nicest staff. Highly recommend!! read more

We recently had an outstanding experience with this restaurant. Included with our order was pizza, garlic knots and the garden salad. Honestly it was great! We are from NJ where we have some fantastic pizza and this easily equals the best I have had. Friendly service from Joe and Jenna was greatly appreciated. Highly recommend that if you are in the area you try it yourself. Thanks Joe! read more

Joe is Back!!!! The former owner and Creator of Capri Pizza has opened a New Pizza Shop located not too far from where he was. Plain and simple...if you want the best NY style Pizza this side of the Gap this is where you want to go. New location is mostly set up for take out, but there are a few tables there if your like me, and like it fresh out of the oven. read more

Joe’s Brick Oven Pizza - Store front - Pizza Near Me - Cresco, Pennsylvania

New pizza spot In cresco. So good ! Great spot must check got. Service was great, had some chit chat and it really made my day. Place is clean and brand new read more

Joe’s Brick Oven Pizza - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Cresco, Pennsylvania

We love it here! Joe makes you feel like family when you walk in the door. His pizza is amazing! It is always fresh and hot. Prices are unbeatable. We do not get pizza from anywhere else..ever! read more

Grabbed another pie this time with pepperoni on it and still so far the best pie on this hill again the sauce was very good cheese all the way to crust ,and unlike the other pizza shops on the mountain the topping was on the whole pie not just thrown on and just from top to middle of pie plus the sm pepperoni was a hit some in every bite.if we weren't so hungry I'd throw a picture of it for y'all passer by could see it cheers again to joes brick oven pizza read more

What a great pizza, crispy thin crust, good cheese, great sauce, and tasty sausage! The best pizza on the mountain.

Amazing food and service! Comfortable atmosphere! Family friendly! Check it out if you are in the area!

Love the meatballs. Where is your menu, I want to try other things,Hope you have chicken rolls, sandwiches like meatball heros, veal Park and more thank you read more