Joey's is a weekly stop for Friday pizza night at my house because they do a classic New Haven style pie that can't be beat. A large mozzarella pie hits the spot every time. Don't miss their rotating desserts. We also love that we have the option to stop in for a slice in a pinch. read more

Joey's Pizza Pie - Calzone - Pizza Near Me - West Hartford, Connecticut

Adding some photos from takeout. Comfort food. It is also good left over heated up bc I can't eat all this in one sitting. read more

Joey's Pizza Pie - Eggplant fries - Pizza Near Me - West Hartford, Connecticut

See all

Joey's food is very delicious. They have a wide variety of pizza slices if you're looking for a quick lunch. Also, the pizza's are tasty, very good cheese. I've never had the pastas but that might be next. I definitely recommend their salads though, they make a great chef salad. read more

Always nice to treat myself to a large Spinach Patch pizza. It's nice to find New Haven style in West Hartford.

I order a Philly cheese steak from here like I've always done, when I got home to eat it there hair stands in my grinder. You lost a loyal customer. Im extremely angry about this read more

My go to is The Hot honey Bronx pizza, is my favorite!!! The taste the spicy n sweet it's so good!

Don't waste your money on any crust but the DETROIT STYLE. Detroit was great. Regular crust was just as terrible as every other garbage pizza joint in this area. read more

I love their mashed potato pizza! We did take out and it was still crispy by the time we got home.. as you can see there's a good amount of bacon on top too. read more

Joey's Pizza Pie - **NESm **NEW** Sm Mashed Potato Pie - Pizza Near Me - West Hartford, Connecticut

It was a Sunday afternoon (8/16/20), family from NY area in-bound from a long trying visit with the elderly in-laws. Good food paramount, excellent pizza absolutely necessary for the NYC Pie Aficionados!!! Joey's to the rescue! My daughter researches the options, we debate, diverse group and even more diverse tasty"piebuds". I learned Joey's now serves a mean Detroit style pie - BAM! Dealz dun Brudda. A regular Grandma's pie, a large Gary and Mary's Garden, a Detroit Red Top pie, and last but definitely not least, a thick Detroit White "cakepie". The Detroit's are typically small square (or if you're lucky rectangular) thick crust pies, they out rival the Chicago varieties. All four pies were heavenly and graced with many compliments, especially from our four NYC pie snobs! The regular pie great. The Detroit's a completely different beast: toppings tend to be the same, the crusts thick and if done well crispy with a heavy serving of "its not good for you" oily presence. Each little square nearly bite size, but if you control yourself, two or three eye-rolling bites. The Bro-in-law and I had been spoiled by true Detroit pie at Buddy's in Detroit (search and read that review), if you're there, you have to go!!! In comparison, Joey's is truly a runner-up for an out of towner, which by local standards is far above any other challengers in CT. Go ahead, invite me over and proven me wrong. read more

See all

Joey's has been a life saver during the Covid shutdown. They very quickly adapted to take out only with curbside delivery. Not only that but recently on FB they had a few contests to win some new pizza styles, the Grandma and the Detroit. I think they gave away like 30 pizzas. Starting today those pizzas are now on the menu and I'm certain I'll be trying the Detroit pizza soon. Try the calzones they're HUGE and a fantastic value. The grinders all rock as well and I love the standard pizzas. Keep kicking butt Joey's. I love ya for it. read more

We love joeys! Everything is so good! We got the meatball sub for my parents after a long day of watching their grandson. They had it for two meals! I love the salads, and pizza is never soggy, always crispy. Customer service is lovely read more

I ordered these carbs for delivery and was definitely satisfied! - garlic bread with cheese - eggplant parmesan with linguine: the sauce was not too sweet and was the right amount . Loved the amount of melted parmesan and the eggplant was crispy. The portion sizes are huge and you will definitely have leftovers for days (not a bad thing) read more

Joey's Pizza Pie - Pizza Near Me - West Hartford, Connecticut

See all

They now offer pizza by the slice!! I was able to score a free slice so I ordered a few more slices and a cheese steak. I got a slice of the regular pepperoni, and Sicilian pesto chicken (might have been a special) and veggie. I love these new Sicilian-style pizzas! The veggie was my favorite because it had some yummy breaded eggplant pieces on it. The cheese steak as always was great! I did curb side pick up and there was a bit of a wait, but the person who brought my order out apologized and mentioned how busy it was that day. read more

Joey's Pizza Pie - Pizza by the Slice! - Pizza Near Me - West Hartford, Connecticut

Get the barbecue chicken pizza! It is absolutely worth every penny. It's definitely one of my favorites I've ever had, and although I have not had it, my boyfriend absolutely loves the potato pizza. The calzones are also delicious and they are huge portions. it could take you three days to eat it! The quality of the food is high and the service is fantastic. I have not had any issues in the past, and the restaurant itself is very comfortable and not chaotic - even when busy read more

Delicious grandma pie. I'm from NY and miss pizza:( this is just like NY! And delicious homemade ranch dressing!!

Ordered grilled chicken Caesar wrap dressing on the side with side of sweet potato fries for the extra 2$, 16$ for soggy fries, tiny wrap and the side dressing was teriyaki, hardly any chicken. Definitely will not order again, also had the shrimp scampi, barely any shrimp, just ok. I'll stick to their pizza for now on which is a 4.5. read more

Joey's Pizza Pie - Grilled chicken Caesar wrap - Pizza Near Me - West Hartford, Connecticut

Pretty standard pizza spot that was my family's go-to for both pizza and salads when I was growing up. Growing up I had thought that their portions were HUGE and delicious and that the place was usually pretty empty, however I didn't like the food as much as I had nostalgically recalled since the ingredients were a lower quality than I had remembered. I got their "orange salad" and "chicken pesto pizza", so maybe I just ordered wrong though. I always got the orange salad when I was growing up however, as it is the best deal for your money because you basically get a salad on top of a pizza/flatbread Bowl with generic red & white mints for the way out! 6/10 read more

Not my first time here, but first review. Ordered lunch here online. Picked it up and it was on time. I love their bolognese! The portion is perfect for lunch. Wish it came with a salad or piece of bread. I also ordered the half chicken parm and that was not great. Looked like they left it in too long, bread was hard and chicken parm was dry, cheese was hard and the chicken wasn't seasoned. I've also tried their slice pizzas and it was ok. I'll try again though and give it a proper review. Everyone raves about the Detroit pizza and I didn't love it, however I know it's a preference so I'll try the regular pizza next time. Will probably just stick to the bolognese. read more

A small pizza restaurant with big flavor. This is a great little spot to grab a quick bite to eat for lunch especially if you are limited on top like I am. (30 min lunch) they sell pizza by the slice. They had a nice selection of beer and wine. (I'll have to go back when I'm not at work and grab some.) I got their chicken bacon ranch pizza and it's delicious. I recommend it if they're not sold out. read more

Joey's Pizza Pie - Chicken bacon ranch pizza!! - Pizza Near Me - West Hartford, Connecticut

This is fantastic pizza. Recently moved to Farmington from the new haven area. Been going to Naples but wanted to try something new. First time I got the Detroit Motor City. Tremendous. Will be coming back to try their thin crust. read more

Joey's Pizza Pie - Detroit Motor City - Pizza Near Me - West Hartford, Connecticut

I just phoned to order a large pizza and was told that it would be thirty dollars for two toppings. THIRTY DOLLARS! Only a couple of months ago I ordered two toppings and paid $19.00 plus tip. What are they doing now. to raised their prices SO outrageously? Putting gold lear in the crust? read more

Good Italian restaurant. Great selection of Pizza and pasta. The white white Bianca pizza was great! The small pizzas have 8 decent sized slices, good for leftovers or sharing. The warm goat cheese salad was surprisingly very good, great for sharing too! read more

See all

Really cute restaurant- small and cozy. Calamari was way too fishy and chewy for me but luckily we ordered two other things which made my review go up to 4 stars. My husband loved their eggplant fries- portions are huge. The star of the night was definitely the chicken parm grinder. The bread alone was fantastic- soft and buttery and definitely tasted homemade. The sauce and chicken cutlet were delicious as well. I can't wait to try another grinder from here and eventually try their pizza. read more

See all

We ordered delivery (Door Dash) from Joey's Pizza Pie tonight - two calzones. One of them wasn't made correctly, so we gave feedback via email. The calzones are BIG so we were able to split one and one of us were able to eat some of the incorrect one. Within the hour, they had replied to our email with a kind message, apologizing, and making things right. Mistakes like this happen, so we completely understood and appreciated their reply. In addition to their excellent customer service, the food was delicious! We cannot wait to order here again or dine in. read more

We picked up from there and the pizza was very solid. Nice thin crust , the buffalo was a little bit spicy (just how we like it) and the pepperoni and cheese were also delicious. We have stopped in there before to get a slice and the slices have been great as well. Definitely recommend trying this place! read more

Joeys to go is my number 1 go to spot for take out in west Hartford. Staff is always friendly and service outstanding. Always get the order correctly and cooked perfectly the way I like as well. Pizza is nicely thin & crisp and the Alfredo pasta is always delicious as well. my son who is a extremely picky eater will only eat take from a very very select few places loves their chicken tenders & fries. I also enjoy the Sweet Asian wings are amazing and so is the cheese steak grinder. Would recommend to anyone who wants to try out a different spot in town for a nice to go dinner or even quick slice to go during lunch break. read more

I can not believe I lived the down the street all my life & have never been here. I really don't need to say anything other than the fact that the pizza is amazing! One of the best spots in West Hartford for sure. Service is good as well. I'll be back. :) read more

Joey's Pizza Pie - Bbq Chicken Pizza (Large) with pineapples added - Pizza Near Me - West Hartford, Connecticut

Some of the best customer service I've had in a restaurant in a good while. Recently visited Joey's for a quick calzone for lunch and was so pleasantly surprised at how much I enjoyed the entire experience. My waitier was so friendly and brought me out a bowl of marinara when I asked for an extra serving of it. My calzone was piping hot, fresh and delicious. Definitely large enough for 2 meals. The sauce is made in house and was also delicious..I could have eaten it with a spoon. When I asked for a to-go container to take home my leftovers, my server brought me a fresh serving of marinara in a to-go bowl. I would highly recommend visiting Joey's and I definitely plan to return! read more

Joey's Pizza Pie - Cheese and mushroom calzone with extra sauce on the side YUM!! - Pizza Near Me - West Hartford, Connecticut

Outstanding New Haven Style thin crust pizza, Detroit style pizza and the eggplant fries are a must try!

Friendly staff, reasonable prices, huge portions, with great taste! Very limited seating, so you may want to pick up and go!

If you like New York style pizza, this is the place-the chicken pesto was delicious-a nice balance of ingredients. Crust was cooked to perfection! Their large pizzas are large-They have the take out process down pat and thinking of their customers-first restaurant, that I have experienced where paper towel dispenser was outside to use on entering the front door. Definitely on our list as a go to pizza place. Counter staff was friendly and made the transaction with gift card, seamless. read more

I purchased the meatball salad. The meatballs were very good but the salad was horrible, the cucumbers and red peppers were soggy in 2 days.

Great pizza everyone in the family will eat, friendly, helpful staff. The shrimp scampi pizza was heavenly!

We lived in West Hartford and have been going to Joey's for years, and before the WH location opened we enjoyed the other Joey's locations. The food is always good. Good sauce, healthy portions. Lot to love. We usually get take out and tonight was the 3-4 time over the last year in which our order the screwed up. One time it's ziti instead of spaghetti. Another time it's eggplant instead of chicken parm. Tonight I ordered a chicken parm grinder, asked for no peppers. Apparently this offended the chef as no peppers meant not sauce. A dry chicken cutlet. My wife told me to cackle, but that would mean a return trip and I was hungry and not in the mood to wait another hour to eat. The food gets 4+ stars. The service gets 0. I suggest you eat in as take out will be wrong. read more

Amazing food huge portions I seriously will get two lunches from my leftovers!! The penne ala vodka with sausage is unbelievable best I ever had! My daughter had the linguini and meatballs it was equally delicious read more

Joey's Pizza Pie - Pizza Near Me - West Hartford, Connecticut

I ordered from Joey's for the first time tonight and I'm definitely impressed. I recently moved to this area and have been searching for a "go to" pizza spot- this will surely be it! You can tell with the first bite that they use good, quality ingredients. Portions are great too! I ordered a small cheese pizza and their classic salad- I didn't want to order anything too "fancy" since it was my first time trying Joey's pizza, but now I can't wait to try some of their other pizzas! read more

Joey's Pizza Pie - Mozzarella Pie (Small) - Pizza Near Me - West Hartford, Connecticut

See all

It's mid-afternoon on a rainy weekend afternoon. We walk into the empty dining room, and a waitress in the corner booth looks up from her paperback book and says, "Sit wherever!" Oooookay. We ordered a bunch of different things and everything was pretty good. I've had worse, and I've had better. I must say that we all commented on how really good the bread for the sandwiches were. Nice and crunchy on the outside, soft and flavorful in the inside. Waitress could do with a bit of an energy boost. We had to pretty much flag her down for questions on the menu and refills. read more

I ate here tonight for national pizza day and the pizza did not disappoint. It was delicious and even better yet was the eggplant fries appetizer. They were covered in parmesan cheese, yum. The sauce they give on the side is really good too. My son likes the meatballs. You can't go wrong for $4.50. You get three big meatballs and they are quite tasty. Our waiter was so nice and friendly so I don't want to say anything bad about him. It was a very busy Saturday night, but he didn't come back and ask if we needed any more drinks even though my husband's glass sat there empty until we left. That was the only complaint. (he had to drink my iced tea) read more

Joey's has some solid pizza. I usually go for the basic cheese and pepperoni, but I've also branched out to the margarita pizza and chicken ceasar salad before which are also very good. Their large pizzas are huge. The sauce tastes fresh and there is no shortage of mozzerella cheese. They have a thin crust which they get to a nice crisp. On a couple of occasions it has been a little too crisp, burnt even, but the majority of the time they get it just right. I'd say they are a little pricey; maybe a couple of bucks more than comparable places in the area. I usually just get pizza to take home so I can't speak to the sevice other than the limited interaction it takes to pay. Regardless, the inside is cute and casual, and I can see it making for a decent dinner setting. read more

Joey's Pizza Pie - Large cheese and pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - West Hartford, Connecticut

During the hard times they seriously stepped up! Delivery to the IOL staff! So very appreciated! I've been a long time customer but now more than ever, I will sing their praises!!!! Thank you joey's pizza!!!!! read more