What a hidden gem! It is located in a commercial area right off the freeway. We came upon it by searching for bakeries and decided to give it a try. The lady in the office was helpful and explained all of the flavors and sizes they offered. We bought 4 of the smaller cheesecakes so we could have a variety to try. Our choices included: rocky road, NY with chocolate on top, key lime and lemon. All were tasty but my favorite was the rocky road, so chocolatey! Definitely will be returning when we are in the area again. read more

John and Jill's Cheesecake - The delicious rocky road cheesecake! - Desserts Near Me - Novato, California

This is my go-to cheesecake spot--and my friends love it just as much! They offer a great variety of flavors and sizes, from deluxe assortments with multiple flavors to mini bite-sized cheesecakes (a box of assorted minis is just $25). They also sell larger individual cheesecakes for around $3-5 each. We've tried several flavors, but my favorite so far is the ricotta cheesecake. I even brought a blueberry cheesecake to a friend's party and it was a huge hit--everyone loved it! Their full-size cheesecakes are very reasonably priced, around $9-11 each. Everything comes frozen, and it takes a couple of hours to thaw before serving. I highly recommend this local gem if you're in the area! Just a heads-up: they only accept cash or check at the moment. Hoping they add credit card payments soon. Also, the lady and gentleman who helped us were incredibly sweet and friendly--such a nice experience all around! read more

John and Jill's Cheesecake - Desserts Near Me - Novato, California

Awesome price on 2nd and cheesecake. Our party love it and gone within minutes. No one know is a 2nd cheesecake.

The sweetest local cheesecake place! Tucked in a business center, I did not know the best cheesecake I've ever had was a few miles away from me. The lady in the front was so sweet to us and answered all our questions. Their prices are affordable and the people are very nice. I have tried the mini sampler and a few flavors of their cheesecake. My favorite would have to be the turtle and the ricotta. So delicious! They have a random selection of cheesecakes when you walk in but you can order ahead of time for specific flavors and sizes. I know exactly where I'm going now when I crave cheesecake! read more

Truly divine cheesecake. These cakes (plain, chocolate, and berry) fueled our group in the midst of creating a show and we are so thankful. It is very apparent that cheesecake is their specialty. read more

All time Favourite.i left hamilton for 15 yrs..but i always buy this cheese cake every time im visiting my family in Hamilton.or asked them to bring me cheese cake if they visit me read more

Always delish cheesecake!! Service great. They offer firsts and seconds! The seconds (slightly damaged) are at a great price!!

Absolutely love these cheesecakes! I have been going here since 2014 & so not plan on stopping. They have a wonderful variety of full size cheesecakes, personal size & mini cheesecake bites. All equally delicious! The minis are perfect for all events I use them most for baby showers, potlucks & birthday desserts! If you are in the area stop by, the service is always welcoming! * don't forget to bring CASH to pay read more

John and Jill's Cheesecake - Personal size Rocky Road Cheesecake - Desserts Near Me - Novato, California

This is the best cheesecake you can find and the most cost saving one! They are in a little office space (not a store front) but they have many favors you can pick. From bite size to whole cake. The whole cake is $8-$10 each with 16 slides! They have individual size for $2.5 and bite size tray for $24 with 42 bites. They are not super sweet and they have favor for everyone! The lady who worked there is super sweet and I cannot stop myself to go back and buy more. My family love their cheesecake. Don't forget to bring cash or check! No credit card, or apply pay! read more

I don't know what kept me from coming to John and Jill's sooner. I used to work at a bakery that sold their cheesecakes, but never been to their location in Novato until recently. My mom wanted a cheesecake for her Birthday and she mentioned the Cheesecake Factory. I wanted to get her a better quality cheesecake and I thought of John and Jill's, which I have been meaning to check out for quite some time. I stopped by with my boyfriend to see what flavors they offer. We were greeted by Jill and she showed us the two freezers with their cheesecakes. The first freezer has "perfects," a variety of cheesecakes with four different flavors. Each box has a different mix of flavors. There are also "talls" which are 92oz cheesecakes. All of the cheesecakes except for the small sizes are pre-sliced. The other freezer has what they call "seconds." The cheesecakes have minor imperfections and are marked down even more than their already great prices. There are all different sizes including Johnny's that are bite size cheesecakes, 6oz Jewels, and 6" and 8" cheesecakes. On our first visit, we took home a seconds matcha cheesecake for only $6! What a steal!! It was full of matcha flavor. When I came to pick up the Dulce de Leche cheesecake (60oz for $20) for my moms Birthday, we also took home a few Jewels to give as gifts for our family. Their two freezers are constantly being changed out so you'll find something different every visit. John and Jill's is not a bakery so they don't provide any kind of writing on their cheesecakes. There is street parking and they have two parking spaces right next to their building. Jill is the sweetest lady and truly appreciates her customers. You can't beat the prices, flavors, and stellar customer service. read more

See all

I love this place Their cheese cakes make great gifts for friends, family, accountant & staff!! When i ran my business I gave them as gifts to my suppliers! Amazing desserts! read more

One of my friends purchased me a cheesecake from this location and holy crap it was delicious. I've honestly never heard of this place before and didn't know what to expect. The cheesecake I had was a combination of 4 flavors: 1. New York: I honestly thought this flavor was the best. Basic cheesecake with no other flavors diluting the natural flavor of how a cheesecake is supposed to taste. The cake is very rich and creamy yet not super heavy and dense. It's very flavorful and you can really taste the natural texture of the cheesecake and the end crust which I love. 2. Cherry Almond: My second favorite flavor. Almond flavor is very good and the cherry jam on top isn't too sweet and overpowering which a lot of cheaper cheesecakes have. Great balance. 3. Pumpkin: Great pumpkin flavor. Not a huge pumpkin fan but if you like pumpkin then give it a try! 4. Italian Ricotta: Really good! I liked the rich ricotta flavor. It was very very creamy and delicious. ----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Overall, excellent high quality cheesecake. Traditional type if that is the style that you like. Great balance between rich and creamy but not too dense or sweet like cheaper cheesecakes taste. Also love that they seem like a small mom and pop store which I'd choose any day over a chain. read more

LOVE, LOVE, LOVE their cheesecakes. Best prices in the world. !! Seasonal flavors and and standard favorites. A winning dessert for additions to dinner parties. read more

Each day is a brand new day, you never know what it will bring! This 4th visit to John and Jill's Cheescake Warehouse factory where everything is handmade and then shipped out to restaurants both local and internationally, as I was told when I first came here. It's basically a small store front office with two freezers to your right. And a big desk in front of you. Normally workers in the back and when they here the front door bell rings, then they will come out. I get totally get giddy and excited when I start to open the 2nd rejected cheesecakes freezer lid because I will have no idea what treasure I will find inside!! As the lid opens today! I see so many flavors, I thought I died and gone to heaven! They had mini bite sized cheesecakes for a tray of $14. There was one brownie tray! Who knew they made brownies?! That would be great for a party! I saw a normal Size turtle and New York cheesecake for under $10 each! I saw a boxed sampler with 4 flavors inside which I bought had the NY cheesecake, mint chocolate, cookies and cream chocolate and strawberry swirl! Sorry I forgot the price because I bought the sampler and 3 jewels which is a personal size cheesecake that fits in the palm of your hand with the flavors key lime, turtle and rocky road! :-) So bring cash with you to pay for them. Guess how much it cost me?? Drum roll...$19.50!! Can anyone say Bargain bin!!?? The way to my loving heart is a cheesecake! I can't wait to eat one!! Is it just me or are people really nice in Novato? Again staff was really welcoming and friendly and gives good suggestions in what to get. This place is Truely a special gem and Novato is lucky to have a place like this. Thanks to Yelp for helping me find this place many years ago! read more

See all

I'm going to be honest with you guys. I don't really like cheesecake. However, my family loves it and they have bought John and Jill's since I was a kid. You go to the offices and they have a big freezer in the front where you can buy their 'seconds'. They are great, maybe they have a crack but usually they look great. Their prices are insane. You can buy a personal size mini one for $1.50, and small/medium for like $6/7, and a large for maybe $8? Somewhere in there. It's a crazy deal. A lot of the cheesecakes don't have crusts which makes me sad bc that's usually what I like best. However, I recently tried their green tea one and I would come back for that. The pumpkin one is beloved by those who like pumpkin pie and cheesecake (my family, I like neither so it is lost on me). They have a new york that is pretty good, and the key lime is a family fave as well. If you like cheesecake you should absolutely give them a try (cash or check only!). While I don't appreciate cheesecake in and of itself, I love being able to support a local company (they are open during covid - one person in at a time and they take the cheesecakes out for you) and being able to make the people I love a little happier by bringing it home to them. :) read more

Delicious cheesecakes at very discounted prices; some only slightly imperfect with a crack on top.

Been going to this place for 10+ years. If you want amazing cheesecakes this is the spot. I was in the area and decided to pick up a cheesecake to celebrate my birthday. I looked around in the freezer and I decided to try a mocha cheesecake with chocolate frosting. This this was freaking amazing and was great quality (not all cheesecakes are the same). Shared with my family and they all agreed! Additional positives are that it is right off the freeway, has ample street parking, and John, Jill and the staff are amazing people to chat with! This business is a (not so) hidden novato gem! read more

Wow! This is easily the closest I've found to NY cheesecake in Marin! I'm impressed and I love the extensive varieties and toppings. If you like cheesecake, you'll love the options and authenticity, here. No frills, but delicious! read more

I just hosted my first Cha Cha Cha party - cheese, charcuterie, chocolate, champagne - to enjoy my favorite foods and celebrate my b-day with a small circle of friends. Each guest brought her favorite cheese and my mom and I provided the rest. I got the cheesecakes (cherry and blueberry) as "seconds" from John and Jill's Cheesecake in Bel Marin Keys - $8 each (32 oz). Everyone enjoyed them, but my family most of all (for several days), because at the party we all got so full on cheese (and a fruit pie my friend had made) that we only had tastes of the cheesecake! Since my Cha Cha Cha theme came off so well, I am thinking about hosting another one around Valentine's Day for Marin Foodies...and if I don't make it myself, I would definitely get more cheesecake from J&J. I'd like to try their larger "perfect" kind that's taller and comes in more flavors (like key lime), including an assortment in one box (chocolate raspberry sounds especially good). The woman who served me was friendly and helpful. It's just a small office, but there are two large freezers where they keep the cheesecakes. She instructed me to take it out in the morning to defrost for a few hours, and that worked well. They also stayed fresh tasting after that when I stored them in the fridge over the next week, as we savored the remainders. read more

John and Jill's Cheesecake - Cherry and blueberry cheesecakes in front - "seconds" were $8 each - 32 oz. - Desserts Near Me - Novato, California

They are a commercial baker that has a over produced freezer for items not sold. Variety of flavors. Very good cheesecake in a few sizes and many flavors . Office open until three. Super yummy cheesecakes and occasionally brownies too. Great prices. read more

Amazing cheesecakes! If your first time I suggest the assorted tray. You will get to experience creamy smooth cakes with wonderful flavors. These are seconds so they may have small cracks or defects. But, what they sometimes lack in beauty they more than make up for in taste. They are in the commercial district so parking can be tricky. read more

I've purchased John and Jill's Cheesecakes for many years. They have many delicious flavors in several sizes and a freezer full of bargain priced seconds in their office. I guarantee that you will have trouble finding even the smallest cosmetic defects in these items. We purchased trays of their bite sized little beauties in five flavors for our daughter's wedding. The guests gobbled them up with enthusiasm. The flavors are fabulous, the prices insanely low and the owners are great folks. This is a wonderful local business. read more

An organization gave me a Chocolate Celebration single serve cheesecake. Absolutely the best I have tasted!

Now I'm no experts on cheese cake but it sure taste good here and I have had average tasting cheese cakes before. They are not all the same unless one thinks chocolate chip cookies are all the same. They offer many variety and flavors. Perfect and 2nd with the same quality goodness, just not in look. Mini and slices sell for 1.50 which is up by .50 for quite awhile now but still much cheaper than buying comparable size at a bakery, even those at supermarkets like Safeway that generally sells them for 2.99 and up per slice and do not taste as good. It's located in an office building at the business area of town. Private parking for two vehicles but one can park on the street. It's generally not busy so it's not a problem. And it's not a sit down place - you buy it frozen and leave. Thaw in room temp and then enjoy! Nom nom ^_^ read more

See all

This is not a bakery, it is a commercial cheesecake operation. So, don't expect a fancy storefront. They supply restaurants in Ca, Japan, and the US military. Along with an occasional world leader. This is not fluffy, light cheesecake. They have seconds for sale, the ones that have a crack in the cake as it baked etc. Tastes the same for next to nothing compared to $6 a slice in a restaurant. And since it is a commercial establishment, not retail, bring cash but not much is needed. read more

$5 for a small cheesecake. Price is right. I'm a 3rd generation N.Y.C. boy, my cheesecake exeprtise is going on 55 years. The cheesecake here is Not very good. Frozen cake is flattened down 3 inch high disc. Texture is gummy, flavor is flabby. PASS. read more

Thank you yelpers! Who knew there was such deliciousness in Novato??OMG, I dug around in John and Jill's freezer and found an incredibly dense cheesecake with chocolate on top! It was a "second" (frosting a bit smeared), but it was a #1 in taste/flavor! I gave a slice to a friend who bakes and she agreed. The tall cheesecakes are $14 and worth every single penny! Located right off of the freeway with ample street parking AND super helpful customer service. I live in Novato and will say that this is the best service AND best taste in town! read more

YUM! A friend brought over a John and Jill's Cheesecake for dessert at our house last night and we could not get over how amazing it was. I've only tried the plain, but it was perfection, right down to not having a crust (I'm really in it for the cake, not the graham crackers). I live in San Rafael, but will gladly drive up to Novato for these for a special (okay...any) occasion. What an absolutely wonderful treat. read more

I was grabbing some lunch when I saw a sign for John & Jill's. I walked into their little unassuming office to see a few ladies digging through a freezer. You can't buy unfrozen cheesecakes there, but you can get deliciously fresh frozen products right off the line. You can peek in and see some of the people working next door if it's ajar a bit. Insanely reasonable prices as well. read more

John and Jill's Cheesecake - Baked then frozen! Mini cheesecakes for $1 - Desserts Near Me - Novato, California

Good thing this place is in Novato or else I'll be coming every week and end up with a big behind. My favorite so far is the original and chocolate raspberry. How do they make it so smooth. The price is so right with their seconds. I owe it all to Lucca Ravioli for their parting gift to point me to their direction. I'm so hooked. Need to buy refrigerator space to keep a supply. The people are super nice. read more

Be very careful about visiting this place even once, because I guarantee you will be back, over and over again. Every single cheesecake they make is so delicious, made with perfection. And they have so many to choose from! My personal favorite is the Key Lime. They even sell these teeny little bite sized cheesecakes, but don't even try to fool yourself, you will never eat just one! LOL read more

Still supper happy with John and Jill's! I stopped by to pick up a few things to share with my buddies at the office. I grabbed 3 personal size turtle cheesecakes. As always they were only $1.50 apiece. The lady that helped me was all smiles and very helpful. I would have liked something with more chocolate but that is the thing with buying the seconds you don't get to choose from their entire stock. You only get to pick from the ones they decide aren't visually perfect. In some ways it is a blessing. I try flavors I may not have. Did I mention everything I've had is spectacular?? read more

See all

First, don't be fooled by the interior when you step inside John and Jill's Cheesecake. You might think that you have entered some mundane office space, but know that the real goodies lie in the ice chests on the wall to the right. Flip them open and prepare to be bedazzled by an array of cheesecakes. They come in a variety of sizes depending on your needs, but I have found a happy size and price ($1.50) in their Jewel line. These are about the size of a hockey puck except taller, and are perfect for sharing or getting you to the point of comfortably full. They only accept cash though, so come prepared with some greens. I love their Key Lime and Lemon Biscotti flavors. Both are gently topped with their respective lime and lemon curds and sit on a thin layer of graham cracker crust or lemon cookie crust. The flavors are subtle, not overpowering, while allowing the slight tang of the sour cream to come through. The cake is a delightful velvety, creamy texture, cuts cleanly and didn't crack. Next time you want to get a cheesecake, skip over Safeway or whatever grocery store, and go straight to John and Jill's! read more

Is it an office...a factory...or a diamond in the rough? I'd say it's a blend of all three which makes John and Jill's a unique "must try" for any dessert enthusiast. Upon first walking into John and Jill's, don't be steered away by the office appearance because the freezers on the right side hold the little treasures. $1.50 for a single-packaged cheesecake keeps me coming for more on a reg. read more

Another visit. For the money, their "seconds" cannot be beat. Wonderful, and well worth the trip to Novato! For the critics who say stuff like "I'm from NYC, so I know cheesecake", yeah, that's like saying I live in Houston so I know NASA. J & J makes their own style. Don't like it? Go enjoy the NY cheesecakes...in NY. read more

People work there just AMAZING! Their cake is absolutely 10 points - 5 stars!!!! You can't miss out!

Mmmmmmm...cheesecake! Counting my calories after each bite, but what's life without self indulgence. You can work off the calories tonight with some cardio. $5 for a slice of cheesecake is worth the paper it's printed on. As this place is commerical you won't see another like it near your neck of the woods. Thankfully I work around the area and fortunate to run into this place. read more

Super amazing cheesecakes! Q: Where else can you grab a different selection of delicious cheesecakes for such an amazing price? A: Nowhere! When I was just there they had New Yorks, chocolate covered NY, Kahlua and pumpkin cakes. Plus a lot of the smaller "individual" cakes and slices. Awesome, amazing local company. Seriously go. read more

Nice little shop. The mini cheese cakes r fun to try. Love how this is local and small opration

Unbelievably great cheesecake at amazingly low prices!! I grew up in New York and learned to love cheesecake. I consider myself an afficionado of cheese cake. The cheesecake at John and Jill's Cheesecake is equal to or better than the cheesecake at the best restaurants in New York City. They have at least 6 or more different varieties for all tastes. I buy seconds at $1.50 for a slice or a small cheesecake. Even the seconds are better than the best New York has to offer. read more