Pizza stop #61 We ordered a small cheese and pepperoni with what they call "cup and char", weird. I know them as old-fashioned pepperoni or little pools of pepperoni grease. The pizza was good as the sauce was a little heavy but tasted fantastic. Also had chicken fingers (5) tossed in mild sauce. Always good. We had ranch not that garbage Bleu cheese. read more

Place in Alden is filty. Workers are rude. Messed up my order and manager would do nothing, but apologize. Never go back

Very good food service. Delivery is good too. Highly recommend this restaurant Staff are amazing read more

How can you mess up an order of 2 steak hoagies and an assorted sub. well they did. Received 1 steak hoagie and 1 assorted and 1 some kind of plain chicken dry with nothing sub. WTF no more John and marys for us read more

Food is fantastic, always great. Service is very friendly. Usually get things out pretty quick but you might have a bit of a wait around dinner time read more

I ordered royal sub and assorted. Roll was fresh and perfectly toasted. Lettuce fresh perfect amount of mayo. Excellent

Customer service at John and Marys is horrific. We have ordered from this place since we moved here several years ago. Mediocre place, not my favorite - wanted to order from Papas pizza but they do not open until 3. Anyways, they give us the wrong pizza. Okay, we call to let them know. The best they can do is have us return the pizza so they can remake OR half off our next order. So option 1 is return old pizza that was a mistake so we can wait and pay full price for the new one or pay full price for wrong order and have to patron them again to get half off next pizza ... lol what a joke...the right thing to do in my opinion would have been to discount or comp the wrong order .The owner did not find that as a reasonable resolution as she quoted" it may not have been what you ordered exactly , but your bellys will be full". By the way no sorry at all either for the inconvenience. The girl who took our order argued that we ordered the wrong pizza- no accountability. Like we have nothing better to do with our time than to make up lies... my husband and I just fed our kids the pizza as they were hungry for lunch and excited for pizza. If it wasn't for that factor I would just drove back and asked for a refund. We will not patron this business and will be supporting other local pizza businesses in the area. read more

John and Mary's is the best pizza you can get in the area, full stop. The food has always been a solid "okay," but we preferred Carbone's for a really good slice. Something has definitely changed recently. I asked who made ours and was told it was "Elijah." This man must be employing dark magic to accomplish whatever we just experienced. Give this kid a raise, maybe let him run the place. I don't know. Regardless, this is what you want if you want awesome 'za. Don't hesitate. read more

I don't come here often but when I do I usually order the chicken finger dinner... the food is not the reason why I decided to write this review, as it is pretty basic. The past couple of times I got food from this restaurant I had the pleasure to interact with a wonderful young lady, Brittany, who took my order over the phone, cashed me out and gave me my food when it was ready. She was a breath of fresh air, a true example of hospitality at its finest... great job, Brittany, and thank you for your kindness... you are a gem! read more

After unpacking at Sleepy Hollow Campground, we decided to get pizza & wings. John & Mary's is a known name & we weren't disappointed. Our pizzas were delicious, one plain cheese and the other cheese & pepperoni. We asked for 30 plain wings, crispy. They were perfect. Took longer than the quoted 45 minutes, more like 75. Only one person was working, that we saw. read more

Food was ok but girl taking the order was just miserable. Took forever to get the food and there were only two people in the place. Told us they don't have French fries. read more

Most of the time, I'm very please with the food that we get from here. Yesterday was an exception. I had ordered a whole chicken, mushroom and onion hoagie. I also ordered an additional half hoagie of the same. The whole hoagie was beautiful; plenty of chicken, and TONS of onions and mushrooms piled high. The half hoagie was a disgrace. Four or five 1" cubes of grilled chicken, with about 6 mushroom slices and a small bit of onions. The contents were completely hidden deep inside the roll. When I opened it to look at it, I was truly disappointed. Next time, PLEASE don't be so skimpy with the toppings!!! You're making more money on that half hoagie than on a whole one. There is no reason to skimp on the toppings. read more

I was unimpressed by the food here and also by the service. I think the guy working there had a cold and was in a pretty bad mood when he served me. It's nowhere near me so I wouldn't go back anyway, although service is never a reason I stop going somewhere. But it seems like a popular little place out in the middle of nowhere that is bringing joy to the community, so more power to them. I got a sub, some wings, and some pizza slices, and none of it was memorable or impressive. Pretty standard fare, and the pizza was particularly disappointing. WNY actually has the best Pizza in the world - check my "best Pizza in the world" list to see all the best Buffalo pizza places, lots of my choices are Buffalo based. read more

Best pizza IMO in the Alden area! Most consistent, double cheese double pep cup and char is our favorite!

Kids love the pizza and we love the subs. Fast service and prompt delivery. Be prepared to wait read more

They need to be consistent. Sometimes it's excellent and sometimes it's no so good! I guess it's a gamble.

Food is pretty good, service is nice, and they have a good sized dine-in area. They also have a couple arcade games for the kids, and it's always clean. read more

Good food and family atmosphere. Love the pizza!! Love the old school video games. Not much to look at but the food is good. read more

John & Marys - This is a quaint like place with awesome pizza. Not too far from Darien Lake Park. Check it out. - Pizza Near Me - Alden, New York

I ordered around closing time last night, and the staff went above and beyond to make subs for us. The lady taking my order was so kind and patient. Really appreciate the customer service guys. Thanks read more

Best homemade soup in town!! Friendly staff, good food quick service. My "go to place"!!!..... read more

This used to be my go to when I got out of work and wanted to having something quick for dinner. The amount of mistakes that has happened in the past few visits is enough for me to go somewhere else. I've had people mess up my food before but never a completely raw pizza. And everything they make is completely not what was ordered. I understand there is new management so I was patient and nice about it. It's a shame what's happened at this location and all of their old staff that had taken care of this town for years has left because of it. :( read more

Ordered a steak hoagie and was ask if I wanted oil or mayo? I told them it's a hoagie and wanted hoagie sauce on it and why would I want mayonnaise. Wtf that's what I get from working at the original John and Mary's. I guess they do what they want now. read more

John and Mary's has been at this location for as long as I can remember and the food has always been very good. In addition to subs, Pizza, chicken fingers and wings and other food items they also have ice cream which I haven't had in awhile but looks good when others order it. It's a great choice for lunch or a quick dinner. read more

Today Andy made it right! My order tonight was overcooked. He not only made it right, he personally redelivered it. Great customer service!. read more

Some of the John and Mary's have kept up their excellent tasting and prepared food and some not so much. This is one of the good ones. I moved away from Buffalo for 20 years, I'm back and ordering from this John and Mary's is just how I remember it. Excellent tasting, prompt service and wide variety. read more

Ordered from work, said 7:45 pm, finally showed around 8:10, all the food is cold, just plain horrible. Two guys is always on time and food is always good and hot. Will never do john and marys again and will pass that around read more

Chicken Finger pizza is amazing! Soups are homemade, subs are what subs are supposed to taste like! Love this place! read more

John & Marys - a pizza with cheese and sausage - Pizza Near Me - Alden, New York

Place is the ideal for deep fried goodness. Mozzarella sticks and fries with cheese are astounding. Pizza is also that greasy wonderful taste you expect(Not overtly greasy). read more

I love this place. It's not fancy, but there's great food and the staff are friendly. Pretty good value too.. Large pizza, 20 wings and a big grilled chicken salad for about $40. Best wings! read more

Went there for a milkshake yesterday, my friend thought that the milkshake on the counter was his, and was screamed at by the manager and then kicked out. When my other friend tried to explain what happened, he was also kicked out of the restaurant. No wonder this place is going down the toilet, they kick out their customers... I came here for food quite often, but I will not be returning to this establishment read more

Called our order in early. Got there at the time we were told and waited an extra 45 minutes still. Probably 10 employees working running circles around each other yelling and trying to figure out who was doing what...real coordinated/efficient way to run a business. read more