I ordered the fried zucchini, lunch portion eggplant parmesan and a Diet Coke. The fried zucchini was hot and crispy and the ranch that came with it was perfect. The breading could have used a bit more seasoning, but they were pretty good. The eggplant parmesan had a great flavor and was a good size for being the lunch portion. The Diet Coke was average. The place was clean and the staff was friendly and helpful. I will be sure to visit this establishment every time I am in town. read more

Johnnie D Pizzeria - Lunch portion Eggplant Parmemsan. - Italian Near Me - Pinetop-Lakeside, Arizona

Went out to ShowLow AZ to visit my sister. She recommended Johnnie D's and it was fantastic. I had spaghetti with Italian sausage and sis ordered a pizza. Both were very good and I even asked where the sausage was sourced because it was the best I've had. Chicago! The portions were big enough to make 3 meals and the price did not break the bank. In fact, I couldn't believe how inexpensive it was. I'll be back when I'm in ShowLow again. read more

This was REAL pizza, not your chain pizza shops. Absolutely delicious! Go and enjoy your wontbregret it. read more

Johnnie D Pizzeria - Everything pizza...without the green peppers - Italian Near Me - Pinetop-Lakeside, Arizona

See all

My wife and I went out for pizza and decided on Johnnie D's after seeing the rave reviews. We weren't disappointed, in fact it was fantastic and the waitress was amazing as she handled the entire dining room herself and did it with poise and grace. We had a medium gangster and honey bbq and garlic Parmesan wings. We will definitely return when back in town. read more

Johnnie D Pizzeria - Front entrance - Italian Near Me - Pinetop-Lakeside, Arizona

See all

We had pepperoni pizza, lasagna and spinach ravioli. Everything was very good. My side salad huge but only downside was mostly iceberg. I did get lunch portion of ravioli and glad I did because portions are large :) Small place but comfortable and great customer service. Our waitress made sure we were aware meal was a bit delayed due to being short staffed. She checked on us frequently and refilled drinks as needed. She also checked to see how everything was ;) read more

Affordable and delicious pizza and the garlic parmesan chicken didn't disappoint. If you're in the area get some so good

I think Johnny d's has the best chicken wings and anything you order will be the largest dish you've ever seen in any restaurant. I kid you not. I can eat a lot but I have never been able to eat a dinner size meal at Johnny's. They are big enough for 2 or 3 people to eat This is the only Italian restaurant we ever go to. read more

I rarely leave negative reviews, but unfortunately our experience here was very disappointing. From the moment we were seated, our waitress seemed irritated that we were there. She was short with us, rushed through taking our order, and acted annoyed when we asked simple questions about the menu. Throughout the meal we felt like we were an inconvenience rather than customers. The service only went downhill from there. Drinks sat empty for quite a while and I had to take our cup to the counter to get the attention of the waitress that was on her phone.When our waitress did come back, her attitude was still very dismissive and unfriendly. On top of the service issues, the overall experience just felt disorganized and unpleasant. Going out to eat should be enjoyable, but this visit left us frustrated and uncomfortable. Courtesy and professionalism go a long way, and we did not experience any of that. read more

Great food, great service ,great prices I love this place for the quality of their food the friendliness of the staff and the prices are amazing I recommend this place they're chicken alfredo pizza and sandwitches read more

I am not sure what is the deal with the 1-star people but this pizza is delicious. Crispy, slightly sweet crust and lots of fresh ingredients. The sausage "kibble" just means you get sausage in every bite, yummy! read more

Delicious Italian comfort food - reasonably priced, generous portions and friendly folks! Just had the Veal Parmigiana for take out - loved it! THANK YOU and we'll be back!! read more

Johnnie D Pizzeria - Delicious and plentiful Veal Parmigiana!! - Italian Near Me - Pinetop-Lakeside, Arizona

Finally had the opportunity to try this pizza. I was welcomed by a beautiful and very nice lady who took my order. I got a large pepperoni pizza to go. It was excellent. I loved the sauce and crunchy crust. So far the best pizza on the mountain. read more

This is by far absolutely the best pizza in the white mountains. I would call it a New York style pie with good undercarriage and excellent crust. Dine in or takeout, either way you're going to enjoy this pizza pie and the salads are really good too. read more

Lunch Special Pizza. Tell me this doesn't look delicious and it was. Brick Oven, Best Pizza up on the mountain. Must try when you're in the area. Not overly expensive and never disappoints read more

We ordered a few pizzas and salads and everything was delicious! Their pizza is NY style and the ingredients were fresh. Highly recommend it. read more

Great food, good price, large servings, much better pizza than the Pasta House. Cheaper too.

Great pizza, they don't skip on the toppings. Nice waitress, we will certainly be back. read more

Johnnie D Pizzeria - 1/2 meat lovers 1/2 veggie. - Italian Near Me - Pinetop-Lakeside, Arizona

Great pizza and good service, would definitely go there again. Good ambiance. Will return to there soon read more

Split a pepperoni calzone, still had to take some home. Delicious! Cozy dinning area like a hole in the wall big city secret.

Solid pizza!!!! Not the best I've ever had but this is a small mountain town and it was good! I'd call it 4 star pizza. Wings though? No thanks. We even ordered them "extra crispy" and they were soft, the skin was chewy, and they were overwhelmingly unsatisfying. Small place, consistently busy. They helped us move tables to accommodate our group which I appreciated. Only 1 (fairly clean) bathroom and everyone in the restaurant seemed to need to use it at the same time as us so had to keep waiting. read more

A local recommended Johnnie D's when we mentioned we were going to order pizza at another popular pizza place.. our kids enjoyed their pizza. My husband thought it better than the other place. I thought the pizza sauce was so flavorful, which isn't usually something that stands out to me. The pizza wasn't greasy and the meats weren't floating in oil. FYI-the pizza was even better as leftovers. We popped it in the oven and the crust had the type of crunch we like. We'll order again. It's worth the extra 15 minute drive. read more

The best Pizza on the Mountain bar none. I love the fact it's crunchy, not soggy. They also have great lunch specials. I will be eating here on a regular basis. read more

Best pizza we have had in a long time! Lots of cheese and sauce and perfect amount of pepperoni. The price is great too! read more

Johnnie D Pizzeria - Pepperoni pizza - Italian Near Me - Pinetop-Lakeside, Arizona

They did not know how to fix a margarita pizza. The pizza they made was terrible. Had to order another pizza from another store.

Really good pizza and the spaghetti & meatball dinners are so tasty (And huge! Be hungry!!! You'll still have leftovers). Once my pizza was so good I couldn't stuff it in fast enough. Unsure what or why but it was beyond delicious to me and my husband was laughing. We e eaten in and picked up - both with awesome results. Sorry no photos - we always dive in too quickly! read more

THIS PIZZA IS WONDERFUL. Crispy chewy and oils like NYC. Just visiting the area, I am a pizza SNOB and almost didn't order from here bc of the 3.5*s. I don't care. I've lived in NYC, Chicago, LA and now Phoenix and I cannot recommend this pizza more. Really pleasantly surprised. We took it to go. Half pepperoni and cheese, I dressed it there w parm, garlic powder, oregano and crushed red pepper. They have an old school pizzeria dining vibe if you want to eat there. No frills but with charm, not cheapness. You are up in the mountains. The air is fresh. The pine trees are plentiful. AND. You can eat Johnnie Ds pizza. Life is good. Ciao! read more

Johnnie D Pizzeria - Cheese w my dressings. PERFECT - Italian Near Me - Pinetop-Lakeside, Arizona

See all

Wings- I didn't like- my husband did. Pizza- good. Nothing spectacular- although ALOT of toppings. Would eat again- but it would definitely be take out. Wait staff- hasn't been trained. Dirty tables, long waits for menus, boxes, check, etc read more

Johnnie D Pizzeria - Meaty Combo - Italian Near Me - Pinetop-Lakeside, Arizona

See all

Consistently great pizza. I order take out, and it has always been ready when they said it would be. Generous portions, and friendly staff. I'll be back! A 5 star place except they add an extra fee if you use a credit card. Either be cash only or suck it up... So lame. read more

This place is a hidden gem in the White Mountains. They have the best pizza in town!

It's the best pizza in pinetop and it's not even close. We have gotten their pizza and wings twice this week.

Best pizza around! Actually everything we have had has been really good, wings and the garlic cheese bread are excellent also. Always quick friendly service too. read more

Great experience! Visited my sister who lives in the area. We called to make sure they were open and they were. We were tired of being cooped up so we drove over. We were greeted outdoors by a young server. We were informed with the current health crisis we could order from outside and wait approximately 15-20 minutes for our order. We ordered their version of a combination pizza with meatballs. We also ordered their white sauce and pesto sauce on the side to dip our crust in. We were served before the 20 minutes were up. We rushed home to eat her pizza while it was hot. The pizza was tasty. I was a little bit disappointed that the meatballs were chopped up tiny. I would have like them a bit more chunky, to get the true meatball affect. The pizza was good. Their pesto was amazing The White sauce really had no flavor. It appeared to have chopped up basil or some type of herb in it, but you could not detect a taste of it. Great customer service. read more

Great pizza!! Also their chicken parmesan is really good and a portion big enough for two people. Will definitely go there again

We were recently in pine top Az and we were looking for a good pizza restaurant. As everyone does, we looked on line and read the reviews. Johnnie D came up as excellent pizza... what a disappointment this was! I don't know what criteria others use to rate pizza, but OMG what am I missing here? The crust was flavorless and tasted like cardboard, low quality cheese and not very much of it. The sausage was a frozen product, little chunks I call kibble. No flavor at all! The salad was old, looked like a poor quality salad mix out of a bag. Finally, If you want to make great pizza, DON"T CUT CORNERS! for the sake of food cost... Buy quality products, make great pizza and charge for it...I will be your best customer and advocate. read more

Me and my wife both feel that Johnny D's has the best pizza in the Pinetop area and they're hot wings are amazing

Best pizza on the mountain. We have tried most of them. Then found Johnnie D's. Will be staying here, for sure!

AMAZING pizza, zucchini, and wings. Restaurant was quick, food was hot, staff was friendly. We waited maybe 15 minutes and other customers were coming and going. It was a great vibe overall. We loved it and will be back next time we are up in Show Low. Highly suggest. read more

Johnnie D Pizzeria - Pepperoni pizza with black olives in to-go box. - Italian Near Me - Pinetop-Lakeside, Arizona

The food was good. Are server helped us greatly. The wait time was kinda long and took awhile. It was a great experience.

Very tasty Italian lunch, generous serving and clean dining space. Service was great. Pay in cash if you can to help reduce the cost of credit card charges. read more

Excellent food, we've ordered several times while vacationing in Pinetop and have always been happy.