Tried the fish taco special tonight and it was awesome! So glad I saw it on Facebook! The picture…read moreis just showing 1 of the 3 tacos you get! The pieces of cod are big, meaty and very filling! Great service as always.

Just finished another great meal here. This time it was chicken Parmesan and baked ravioli. YUMMY!!…read more Our server Lori was phenomenal, she waited on us the last time we were here. She is so friendly and attentive, very welcoming. Two thumbs up for Armelis and Lori!!

I'm not going to lie, I did not expect the food to be soooooo good. Listen they actually have jumbo…read morewings. I feel like when places say jumbo wings they just mean regular wings. This place ACTUALLY has jumbo wings and yes they were delicious. I got the Buffalo and it's not spicy at all. So if you're the type that wants to enjoy Buffalo without the heat, this is it. I would prefer it to be spicier but they were so good. Ranch dressing was good because let's face it not all ranch dressing is good. Now on to the pizza. Although for what I wanted the pizza was a bit pricy, the ingredients were fresh! And the pizza was so flavorful and just delicious!! I'm definitely coming back. Especially for wing night.

Pizza on moving day is a tradition! We decided to try the local pizza place in the new area we…read moremoved to and I'm so glad we did! It was delicious and I particularly liked their pizza sauce. The service was very fast and friendly too! We got sausage, mushroom, and onion!

A great choice if you are craving Italian food with a nice ambiance. As mentioned by other…read morereviewers, it can get crowded and reservations are definitely a better idea then chancing a walk-in. All of the servers that we have ever had here have been really, really nice as well as well informed as to the menu. The lasagna here is PHENOMENAL!! My wife and I usually order different dishes so that we can try new things, but here we always both order the lasagna. A typical night for us looks like an order of the bruschetta as an app, two lasagna entrees...and maybe a few vodka sodas and captain and diets to wash things down :) I have also tried the pizza a few times, and it is good...but the heart in my stomach is in love with the lasagna.

Food: we started with some beer battered cheese curds that were unusually good. The cheese was…read moretender and warm unlike the cheese curds we have been used to. We tried a cranberry and apple salad with scallops. The scallops were the best part. The beer list was more interesting than the wine list, but they did have several wines available by the glass. 4/5 Service: Both the bartender and Andrea our server were very attentive 4.5/5 Ambience: huge parking lot surrounding the restaurant. There was apparently a birthday party for a six-year-old with some very wild children running about. Once they left, the place was much more pleasant. 3.5/5

Seen the reviews, I consider myself a pizza expert, so the natural thing to do was go to this…read moreestablishment. Wound up on a Wednesday, half price bottles of wine. Wife was excited for that! Server was friendly and had just the right amount of attentiveness. The place was moderately busy and I can appreciate that on a Wednesday. It is casual and good for family dining. We started with the mozz sticks. Wonton wrapped and had a light garlic butter coating. Marinara was solid and they were tasty. Pizza was thin crust and cooked to my liking. The toppings were scattered, per the illustrations, and the taste was good. As a Racine/Kenosha (R-K) native, where you cannot take a step without tripping over a good pizza, I always compare places to them. How does the RMI stack up to the R-K pizza? It is lacking flavor in the dough and toppings. Is is good? Yes, but it is not R-K tier. I would love to come back and try other offerings. The meatballs looked good, as did the wings! I will be back and anyone else who hasn't gone should check out the RMI. Let your taste buds decide where this pizza falls in your past travels.

Recently I completed a 7-day stretch of trying at least one new-to-me restaurant per day. Day six…read morewas at Red Mill Inn & Pizza. Red Mill Inn has been near the top of my places to try list for a while. It was a smoky day due to Canadian wildfires, so I sat inside instead of out on their nice looking patio and ordered cheese garlic bread and a large sausage pizza. I enjoyed the cheese garlic bread. It was a very thick piece of bread that was crunchy on the outside and super soft on the inside. I'd gladly get it again. The pizza was good, not great. I appreciated the crispy edges from the oven it's cooked in, but something about it didn't wow me. It was so thin that I ate more than I probably should in a single sitting. I'd likely try something else if/when I come back to experience the patio. Shout-out to Rosie. She was an awesome waitress and I actually called back to confirm her name so I could mention it specifically in my review.

My wife and I drove up from Chicago to have lunch with our Grandson and his family…read more We both agree that this restaurant is deserving of a 5 Star Review for the following reasons: 1. Friendly proprietor 2. Cozy environment 3. Good appetizers 4. Great Pizza We will definitely be back when in Sussex.

Excellent service! Excellent pizza and garlic bread!…read moreBeer was cold! We arrived around 6 PM. We will be back! Great place for the family too.

I've been here twice now, and both times was an excellent experience. The food is delicious, very…read morebig portions. You can definitely split a dish with one other person. They accommodate large parties. They have a nice bar that you can have a drink while waiting for your table. The service has been good both times. It's got a nice Italian restaurant atmosphere. The pizza is really good, thin crust and made to order!

This is one of our regular stops when we want Italian. The pizza is the best and has never failed…read moreus. We decided to deviate from our normal order of pizza and order pasta. We went Friday evening and split cheese garlic bread and one special menu pasta dish. It was Lobster, shrimp stuffed manicotti. The idea was there but in the description it states pieces of lobster etc. But...the filling was similar to a pate/minced filling. It was also very dark in color and extremely fishy flavored. We both didn't finish it and decided to stick with pizza from now on. The pasta wasn't cheap either. After this happened I remembered another time the mushroom ravioli had similar filling. No thanks. Come for pizza and just order pizza!

Been here a few times before, but it has definitely has been a while. Came late on a Wednesday…read moreevening, around 8:30, and they close at 9:00. Plenty of tables when we got there, and were seated right away. It's a converted home (remodeled long ago), and there are multiple rooms for dining, which give it a more relaxed feel. The design/decor does look a bit dated. Our server got right to us. Got menu and ordered a couple of Sangrias. The Sangrias were red, refreshing, and a good amount. Given the lateness of the evening, we didn't get any appetizers, but I would have liked to try the Calamari (next time). We ended up with a small "special" pizza and the Lobster Ravioli. There were several choice for sauce of the ravioli and I chose butter garlic. While waiting for our entrees, we were served a basket of garlic bread. The bread was fresh, warm, and plenty of butter and garlic. A nice treat. The ravioli also came with a small house salad. Good, but nothing out of the ordinary. It didn't take too long for the entrees (we were the only customers), and they were hot, flavorful, and good portion sizes. Both were good, but if I had to be honest, not great. The pizza crust was thicker than we like. And the ravioli pasta was very good, but the filling was more like a paste with small pieces of lobster. Definitely could have benefitted by having more lobster. The service was very good, up to the point that we got our meals. After that, we never saw our waitress, until we were finished with our meal, and even then we had to ask someone to find them. Maybe they were busy cleaning up? Not sure. Overall, okay, but with some attention to some finer details could be so much better. Didn't end up on our "gotta get back to that place" list :(

Cozy warm and you feel you are at grandmas. And this used to be grandmas home back in the day…read more Family owned and it's so nice inside. The food is good. I enjoyed the garlic bread, linguine with clams, pizza, the salad, and sausage. The red pasta sauce with the sausage was a bit too salty and I wished it had fresh cut tomatoes in there. The pizza had the best stringy mozzarella cheese I ever had. I could not believe how stringy it was. It was so good. Free open parking. Right across the street from a car dealer.

I'm impressed with the individual pizza for one. It's large enough for 1-1/2 meals or get several…read moredifferent pizzas to try if you're with a group of friends I'd probably like to see the pizza cut into 8 slices instead of the 4 slices Was not busy at all for a Saturday lunchtime on this particular weekend but I'm sure that by dinner time it will be rather busy It's all street parking but a public parking lot is available 1 block over Prices is average for this small business in my opinion

Lovely pizza place with character and a homey feel. I ordered a make your own with mushrooms, the…read moredough was perfect, light and fluffy dough with crispy crust. The pizza had just the right amount of mozzarella and the portion was enough to give me some for leftovers. Good prices and they offer vegan and gluten free!