Seen the reviews, I consider myself a pizza expert, so the natural thing to do was go to this establishment. Wound up on a Wednesday, half price bottles of wine. Wife was excited for that! Server was friendly and had just the right amount of attentiveness. The place was moderately busy and I can appreciate that on a Wednesday. It is casual and good for family dining. We started with the mozz sticks. Wonton wrapped and had a light garlic butter coating. Marinara was solid and they were tasty. Pizza was thin crust and cooked to my liking. The toppings were scattered, per the illustrations, and the taste was good. As a Racine/Kenosha (R-K) native, where you cannot take a step without tripping over a good pizza, I always compare places to them. How does the RMI stack up to the R-K pizza? It is lacking flavor in the dough and toppings. Is is good? Yes, but it is not R-K tier. I would love to come back and try other offerings. The meatballs looked good, as did the wings! I will be back and anyone else who hasn't gone should check out the RMI. Let your taste buds decide where this pizza falls in your past travels. read more

See all

Recently I completed a 7-day stretch of trying at least one new-to-me restaurant per day. Day six was at Red Mill Inn & Pizza. Red Mill Inn has been near the top of my places to try list for a while. It was a smoky day due to Canadian wildfires, so I sat inside instead of out on their nice looking patio and ordered cheese garlic bread and a large sausage pizza. I enjoyed the cheese garlic bread. It was a very thick piece of bread that was crunchy on the outside and super soft on the inside. I'd gladly get it again. The pizza was good, not great. I appreciated the crispy edges from the oven it's cooked in, but something about it didn't wow me. It was so thin that I ate more than I probably should in a single sitting. I'd likely try something else if/when I come back to experience the patio. Shout-out to Rosie. She was an awesome waitress and I actually called back to confirm her name so I could mention it specifically in my review. read more

See all

this was absolutely the worst fish fry I've ever had. i was forced to pay a convienence fee after having to park a street over and trying 3 doors to enter. I bring 2 fish frys home and there is no sides in our order. ordered kettle chip. none to be found. after paying over $38. , I went back to get them. got home and we ordered the beer batterred cod and perch. the perch was no longer than 2 in. per piece. it was fried so much there was no fish inside the batter. I guess they give the small pieces for take out because if you were served it at a table, you would return it to the kitchen. read more

Great friday night fish place- Busy and still enjoyable. Space at the bar to wait for a table. Great night out to sit outside as well. Waiter was friendly and attentive. My dirty martini hit the spot- and I loved my baked fish. Pizza looked fabulous- haven't had it in awhile here- but tables next to us ordered... and we wish we had, even as an appetizer. read more

Excellent dinner and brunch menus. We love their cocktails, two options and environment. We come here regularly and are always greeted by wonderful staff. Such great neighborhood restaurant! read more

We decided to have dinner with friends and we decided to order takeout pizza. The pizza was very good, the garlic bread was amazing, and the salad was very good as well. We ordered a large pizza and had plenty of leftovers for the four of us. Would definitely order from them again. Sorry I didn't get any pictures. We were too hungry! But I would absolutely recommend Red Mill. I've never been inside, so I personally can't speak to the ambience. But the service was quick and friendly. read more

It continues to be the best gluten-free pizza we found in a two county area The trio of Great craft cocktails, great pizza, and Saysha as our server and you have the perfect Hattrick on a Saturday night read more

First time trying this place. Inside is just a cool Bar to watch a game and grab a drink and eat, and there's dinning outside and inside for families and couples to get dinner. Service was quick, and friendly. I usually give places like this 4 stars. A solid gem you can go once a week. It's getting 5 stars because of the pizza. The pizza is the Milwaukee tavern style crust, but not flakey or soggy and flimsy. The crust was crisp and the sauce awesome. Best pizza I've had in the west allis area sense moving here. I got the Italian beef pizza and a order of wings. Both awesome read more

See all

We were excited to try this place out based on the great reviews here recently. Unfortunately, we didn't have as great an experience as others. We stopped in on a Friday night to try their fish fry because they had both perch and bluegill on the menu. Apparently, their hostess wasn't on that night so no one was seating people for quite a while. A manager stopped by and put about 3 different parties on the wait list. When we asked how long for 2 people, he just said "a while". Busy night, got it. After about 5-10 minutes, a very nice server, Jess, saw it was just the 2 of us waiting and got us a high top in the bar area. Service continued to be great by Jess. Got the french onion crock which was a little salty but not bad. The fish fry was awful. The cod lacked flavor and was soggy. The bluegill had an Italian seasoned breading that seemed unnecessary and the fish didn't taste too fresh. Should've just stuck with pizza maybe. We watched groups cycle through after seeing how long a wait would be just to leave, and for those already seated, many people sighing in frustration as it would easily be 10 minutes until a server would stop at their table. It was definitely a longer dining experience but you could tell that Jess was busting it out and trying to get to all of her tables quickly. Unfortunately, for the price ($18/basket) and the hassle, this place wasn't worth it for us. Maybe we will try again in the future but not in a hurry to go back. If you do go, ask for Jess. read more

See all

Food was awesome, def need to check out the rest of the menu. Server was great and seems like a cool place to get beers and hang. read more

The Red Mill Inn & Pizza - sausage & mushroom pie - Pizza Near Me - Brookfield, Wisconsin

This is great neighborhood bar. Friendly patrons and bartenders. Fish fry was great. Pizza looked really !

Beautiful outdoor patio and quite spacious. Indoor is like historic and service oriented staff. Average Italian and good thin crust pizza. Clam chowder was very good. Fish fry had a bland taste in my opinion. Unsure what it was as exactly but the batter is very thick. Calzone kinda bland unsure what would have helped it read more

See all

Great place except pizza is average. Very nice waitress every time her name is Tina. I ask for water every time since I really love water she brings me a pitcher of it very good red mill! read more

Fast friendly service. A complete menu with an array of options for pescatarian, carnivore as well as vegetarian options. The drinks are strong and the atmosphere is friendly and pleasant read more

We've lived within a 5 minute drive for years and never tried this place. Pizza was amazing, we had the pepperoni pickle pizza and olive and sausage. My young kids loved it and so did my wife and I. This will be part of our normal rotation! read more

I visited Red Mill on my last visit to Milwaukee and love the ambiance, the menu, and the drink special! We went on a Wednesday during half price bottles of wine - score! I ordered the filet dinner with a side of mushrooms. It was $24 and honestly I didn't have high expectations as I thought this was a pizza place; however, I was wildly impressed. I've paid WAY MORE for steak that was not good at all and this steak was cooked to perfection, well seasoned, and delicious. My friend enjoyed the margarita pizza which was delicious as well. I highly recommend stopping by! read more

The Red Mill Inn & Pizza - a plate of food - Pizza Near Me - Brookfield, Wisconsin

The food and service here is wonderful! Staff are kind and eager to please ! The manager, Phillip attended our guest's every need. I would definitely have banquet /party here again in the future. Thanks Philip! Becky L. ( different person that the 5/2024 post) read more

Good fish fry. Short ribs were cooked to perfection. Very good meal and drinks. Plenty to eat.

Good food, nice atmosphere to visit with people. Outdoor seating was refreshing. Friendly staff. read more

The Red Mill Inn & Pizza - Business sign - Pizza Near Me - Brookfield, Wisconsin

Great history. Old jazz club now serving up pizza. Za was good not great. Staff was super nice and the location opened up some conversation with my 83 year old mother who used to come here to listen to music. Good walk down memory lane. read more

I try to stop here weekly. I love this place. it's been around forever. My brother in law worked here in high school (mid 90s). The food here is delicious. I highly recommend the gluten-free pizza. Best crust anywhere in town for gluten-free. The service is super awesome here. All of the waitresses and waiters are on it. The bartender is so friendly and a good drink. I love Phil. He knows us when we call or when we come in. He knows exactly what we are going to order and he's just amazing if you tried the Red Mill Inn, you really need to. Their patio is beautiful.Makes for a wonderful outdoor meal. read more

I remember having a fish fry here in the mid 70's through the mid 80's. Easily the best beer battered fish I've ever tasted. I decided to try the fish dinner tonight. I wasn't expecting the same experience from 40+ years ago, but I certainly wasn't expecting what I tasted tonight. I wanted so bad to at least say it was "okay". The fish had no flavor whatsoever. With good tartar sauce some of the lack of flavor can be overcome. Not in this case. The tartar sauce was horrible. I could only eat 1/2 of one filet out of 3. My dog got the rest. No name bargain frozen fish sticks from the grocery store would have been better. I'd like to try it again IF they change the recipe, but I'll be bringing a sandwich just in case. read more

Sat at the bar and ordered pizza and garlic cheese bread along with a beer. The bartender was friendly and the food was served quickly. The garlic cheese bread was outstanding. Home made bread and dripping with butter, just how I like it. The pizza is real thin, nice sauce and good amount of toppings. I definitely will be back. read more

Love the atmosphere and the server was outstanding! We split a gluten free pizza which was over baked. We would still go back though!

Delicious cracker thin crust pizza. We got the magnifica which is basically the deluxe, specified light cheese, half no olives/mushrooms, add peppercini to the whole thing. Everything was perfect. Just the way we like it. We also ordered garlic bread. Decent size loaf of bread absolutely drenched in garlic butter then toasted. Perfect amount of crunch, buttery, soft goodness. I could eat 6 orders of the garlic bread alone. We ordered a large pizza for 2 of us. Usually we take home about half a pizza, but it was so good, we only took home a forth of it. We'll be back. Highly recommend read more

Very good pizza and service but very expensive for what we ordered. We were quickly seated and cocktails and overall atmosphere was nice!

Great food!! Very affordable and quick service! Will definitely come back. Patio seating is also available. Would recommend for dinner any night of the week read more

We love this place! Excellent fish fry! Friendly service and a neighborhood feel:) the pizza is delicious and a roomy bar:)

Great neighborhood corner bar type place. Great bartender, who worked her ass off while still interacting with everyone. Now, on to the pizza. I ordered a small cheese and sausage, which would be a medium anywhere else. Really crispy crust and it was great. Thank you fellow Yelpers! read more

The Red Mill Inn & Pizza - Small sausage pizza. Delicious! The bartender in this picture is awesome! - Pizza Near Me - Brookfield, Wisconsin

In lady and the tramp (the cartoon) They sit outside this Italian eatery, in the alley and have this cute little romantic spaghetti plate. That's what I imagine the Redmill inn is. Res hue interior red/white checkered table clothes, wine bottles, a nice bar and solid service. Friendly and charming tucked into an unexpected neighborhood. Ordered the meet meat pizza and it was really good. The edges were a little dark and crispy but that was insignificant to the flavor. Cut in squares and thin with a great sauce, solid meat like a lot but flavors worked. We also got the non traditional fried mozzarella and that was amazing. Like a fried green tomato in shape. Lightly breaded and fried so it had crunch and texture but wasn't a froze gordon foods mozz stick. Loved it. Will return to dine in! read more

See all

This is one of our favorite pizza places in the Milwaukee area - anywhere really! They have some unusual combinations on their menu, like the Italian beef pizza with white sauce and horseradish aioli that we had the last time we ate here. Drinks are good. Their salads are fresh - you can get anchovies on the Caesar salad if you like - and I do! On our last visit the only downside was the service. They've actually cut their open days to only Friday, Saturday and Sunday because of labor shortages and you can tell on a busy night like when we were there that they could use more staff. I really hope that they find a solution and are able to stay open and hopefully expand their hours - this place is too good to fall by the wayside! read more

First timer here! Went there on a Friday around 5:15pm. This place is truly a gem. There are a number of tables in the bar area and more in the back area. The server was good and checked in us to make sure we enjoyed our food. We ordered a basket of fries, garlic bread with cheese, a small pizza and a large pizza, which was more then enough for four people, with leftovers. The fries appeared to be freshly made, not frozen. The garlic bread with cheese was good, but if you love garlic bread, you might want two of those. The pizza is nice and thin, square cut, and the toppings were fresh. The sausage was so good, as were the other toppings that my family enjoyed on the other half. We got an old fashioned and sodas to drink. It was about $20/person which was a little pricey, but we would definitely return. We did ask the server when it gets busy and he said Friday is typically a busier day, especially because they have fish fry Friday's. He also stated they were busy between 5:00 and 8:00 and they only take reservation for tables of 8 or more. So, I would go early if you want to really enjoy the place before it gets too crowded. Enjoy! read more

Great pizza and nice for a quiet dinner. Inhaled the crunchy crust and generous toppings. For a Saturday night it was very quiet but actually nice for what we were looking for. They were short staffed and only offering pizzas and salads which was a little disappointing but would Still come back to try sandwiches or wings! read more

Food and services were great. Pizza was very good too! The staff was very good for carry outs as well

Hidden gem! Quaint bar and restaurant. Waitstaff was excellent. Wine was also great. But the pizza. The pizza was one of the best I've had in Wisconsin. It's thin crust crispy tavern style cut in squares. The pizza is so good it's on par with Vito and nicks in south chicago WITHOUT the 2 hour wait. My new favorite pizza place!! read more

The Red Mill Inn & Pizza - a pepperoni pizza - Pizza Near Me - Brookfield, Wisconsin

See all

If you're looking for a great pizza. This is the place. We have also had great fish fries from Redmill as well. Never disappointed. We highly recommend. read more

Great establishment. Down home feel but yet upscale pizza and menu. Simple menu which is what I like, I mean who wants 48 pages of every ethnicity imaginable, not I. I've visited 3 times now before writing a review. Experienced staff, Quality food, and great service. Now I was worried since the red mill closed, thinking, pizza place? But.... the pizza overwhelmed my expectations and the spaghetti and meat balls are upscale and full of flavor! I was impressed. I love Santino's and who doesn't know mama mias. I love zarlettis and even balistreri's but again this is unique place and delicious. I had the Margherita pizza and the meatballs, lasagna and salads. They were all amazing. It may just be my new favorite place! read more

See all

Really a great pizza bar experience! Our group of six out of town folks were made to feel at home. Even the small pizza is huge.

Great food, great prices, great service. They were able to fit my party of 10 in with no wait or fuss. And the waitress was prompt and friendly... even recommended where I could get a great deep fried calzone in Waukesha! read more

Okay I am from Chicago and was a little skeptical about the reviews for the pizza but boy was I surprised. This pizza is fabulous -I mean really great. I've had access to some of the best pizza and I will say this is in my top 5. The restaurant old and rustic,a little rough maybe, but has some charm. Don't judge it on that. Also, they were clearly short handed that night but they were hustling and I was surprised at how fast we were served. To note, they are putting the finishing touches on an outdoor patio. Looking forward to that. As I am new to this area, this will definitely be on rotation! read more