We come here regularly with kids but also our friends. Everyone likes their pizza! Service is friendly with a very local vibe. It's not a quick meal, except buffet days, but yummy. There's spacious tables with bar stools or regular chairs. Our senior adults from church like to meet up here for lunch and stay a while. The buffet offers decent variety and includes dessert pizza. Be sure to check out the local pics framed in the hallway toward restrooms. read more

Delicious pizza and very quick! We ordered pickup but the inside looked very nice and clean. They have a big parking lot too

Good basic pizza buffet. Nothing special bet will satisfy a pizza fix. If they are not busy buffet pizza is slow but if you ask they will make whatever you want for the buffet. read more

I ordered meals for my students and the meals were great. They had the food prepared and ready on time

The chicken bacon ranch pizza is to die for we get it everytime and the classic cheese with red sauce is like a cartoon pizza... you know how juicy and cheesy they are in ninja turtles?? Well they made that pizza! read more

I work at a chain pizza place...this places food is better!!! Our table ordered a variety of food. We had a Meatza Calzone, 2 choose your own toppings pizza, wings, mini butter bites and a sub sandwich. The chicken BLT sandwich was good, the roll they put them on was sooo very soft, I even thought it was their restaurant that made it. It tasted like it was freshly baked just out of the oven. Their mini butter balls, small dough balls with plenty of butter for the rest of them to dip in, I added parmesan cheese and ate some with a spoon The wings I got, admittedly weren't very lemony or peppery, but definitely had an amazing crunch skin and so juicy and tender on the inside. I tried a slice of my boyfriends jalapeño, olive, pepperoni and mushroom pizza with extra cheese and just like you see in the movies you pull a piece and it has the LONGGGG cheese string. The jalapeños were spicy not more than I can handle just more than I enjoy. If your in town this is worth a trip here. We will definitely go once more before we leave town!! read more

The Pie - Whole medium make your own pizza with sausage, jalapeños, olives, mushrooms, pepperoni and lots of extra cheese. - Italian Near Me - Thomaston, Georgia

See all

We stopped in on a Friday for lunch for our party of 7. They offered a lunch special for 6 drinks, the garlic knots, and a 24inch party size pizza for only $46 which was a great deal. I got the lunch combo with a side salad (upgraded to a Greek salad), a small pizza, and a drink for $10. Great deals for great food. Everything was delicious! The food came out quickly and was hot & fresh. When we went it was pretty slow and there wasn't a lot of people but it seems like it would be a fun place to go and hang out on a weekend night. Definitely recommend giving it a try if you want a yummy pizza night! read more

See all

I recently took my son to The Pie to help him feel better after a doctor's visit, and was pleasantly surprised by the friendly service, delicious food, awesome atmosphere, and comfortable seating in this cool pizza joint near downtown Thomaston. From the outside, it looks pretty plain, as it's in a shopping center right next to a Badcock's furniture store, but the inside will blow you away. If you order your pizza to go, you can sit on beautiful benches made out of surfboards. There are also surfboards and boogie boards on the walls, as well as other surf and tide related decorations throughout. There are several tvs to watch the game on while you chow down, and the whole place has a laid back, chill vibe to it. They do have a buffet on Tuesdays and Wednesdays, but I was not there on either of those nights, so I can't yet comment on the quality or amount of pizzas served with that particular dining option. We got the kickin' chip appetizer, which is fried pizza dough tossed in their kickin' sauce, which to me, was more of a rub than a sauce. For the main entree, we got the large meat craver's pizza, which had pepperoni, bacon, sausage, and a couple of other meats piled high on a delicious thin pizza crust with a delicious sauce. With a light dusting of parmesan cheese, the pizza was a delicious meal that was more than enough for the two of us to fill up on and take home leftovers. All in all, while I love some of the other pizza options in this town, The Pie will be one of my go to restaurants from this point forward. I would highly recommend it to anyone looking for a solid, cool pizza joint for a family meal or event, as they do have a party room on site. read more

The Pie - The meat craver pizza and kickin' chip appetizer from The Pie are both must tries during your visit. - Italian Near Me - Thomaston, Georgia

Family owned, locally owned, small business. Great food, great service, very clean. Wings were on point, cold beer.

Good pizza. They have those gigantic pizzas you can't fit in your fridge at home but whatever. They have a pretty good sized place inside for like very large groups and they do an all you can eat buffet style bar inside. And they serve beer and ice cream too ( hopefully not together) read more

Not recommended. Food was awful and they had no unsweet tea. Drink area had numerous spills and lots of flies.

Love the cheese sticks. People are usually very nice and service is quick. I wish they still had the spaghetti!

Food is amazing service is good and people are nice seating is good place is clean the ice cream is on point and party room is huge bathrooms are clean the shows on the tvs are entertaining overall place is amazing! read more

Awesome!!!!!! I love this place!! Friendly,great service/staff Very Youth/kid friendly and food is off the chain!!!! My whole family,friends, and staff all love it. read more

Worst tasting blandest crap ever! Bought 2 party pies and was a complete waste of $60. Had no flavor, hardly no toppings, and the dough was as tough and chewy as stale chewing gum. Honestly don't see how this place is even in business. Will never eat here again and would suggest that no one else waste their money like I did. read more

Best pizza in town hands down!!! They have a wonderful environment as well very relax and casual.

Empty cavernous restaurant on a Friday lunch hour makes you wonder? Pizza tasted all the same and served on weak paper plates- I should have just called Dominoes. Only channel on their 8 televisions were cartoons with no kids in the restaurant ?? The cashier was friendly. read more

Good food and you get what you ordered! Love their pasta and salads. Pizza is always a winner over other local pizza places.

We always enjoy coming here with family when we are in town. You order at the counter, fill your own drinks and pick your seat in the roomy dining area. They bring your pizza to you. The pizza is tasty with a good crust. This is a great place for a group. read more

We were down for a canoeing trip in Thomaston and decided to stop here on our way back. The pizza was great. I particularly liked the sauce. Some of the best marinara I've ever had for my pizza. The other toppings were great in the staff were very polite. read more

Can't rate the pizza because we didn't stay long enough to eat. Friday 3/3/17, we walk in around 9:15 pm after our boys had just played a basketball game. We were a group of 15 and when we walked in, we were greeted with eye rolls from the back. You could tell they weren't happy about us coming in. The girl that came to the counter was sweet, but as I was asking her what time they closed (which was 10), the two in the back were still looking at each other and rolling their eyes. Dear manager, I hate we didn't get to try the pizza because it smelled delicious. We were a large group, hungry and tip well, but some of your employees need to improve their customer service skills. We left, drove down the road to Chili's where the service and food was excellent. read more

Ordered up one of their huge spicy chicken calzones & was immediately impressed with the fresh taste of all ingredients/toppings. Place is super clean and the service is very friendly here; I would definitely recommend a visit if you ever happen to be in the area! The manager made his rounds here. He's a very interactive guy with his customers. Lunch prices are affordable & portion sizes are very good. read more

Good hand tossed pies. Try the baked potato pizza.

This review is for their Betty salad only. I neither know nor care why this salad has a proper name, I only know it is an amazingly appetizing piece of culinary joy. Its cheap and feeds two. The thought of it is making me hungry so enough reviewing, more salad chewing! read more

Great pizza, excellent service. The owner would come out and say hello and make sure we were satisfied and also give my kids a popsicle. Good price for food also. read more

No wonder they are always empty. They do not even have the decency to greet the customers when you walk in. My wife and I left because of the terrible customer service. Worst restaurant in Thomaston. read more

I stumbled upon American Pie after waiting over an hour at another restaurant before leaving because I never got seated. I wish I could rate this place with 10 stars. From the atmosphere walking in to the great pizza, I had a great experience there. I'm about 45 minutes away from this pizzeria but I will do be best to visit this place often now! read more

I've come here twice in the past two weeks, the lunch buffet is a great deal and they have some excellent pizza. The staff has been very inviting, the manager/owner walks around and speaks to all the customers like a old friend. Great food, great service, nice staff, and very clean; what else can you want. read more

The pizza is rubbery inside the dough, as though its not cooking through enough. Bad dough to start with. Want great Pizza go to Tony's of Brentwood, off I75 below Atlanta GA These people here in Thomaston could learn a thing or two about how to treat ppl and make REAL pizza! The girls they hire here stand around and gossip and only work when the boss comes in! Pathetic!! I drive 1 hr to get to Tony's because it 's great! read more

So far my best restaurant experience in thomaston! We just moved here and I found my new favorite place. The owner is super nice and was very friendly to us as soon as we walked in. And he was very helpful in helping us decide what to try first. Food is fresh and delicious, the restaurant has a very cool inviting atmosphere, it's very clean and family friendly. I can't say enough about this place YOU HAVE TO EAT HERE AND TRY THE BAKED POTATO PIZZA ITS AMAZING! read more

This place used to be part of the American Pie Pizzeria chain, but the owner went independent a few years ago. It's a large store in a strip mall. The owner came by and told us about how he'd built the place from the walls in... from hand-made tables and flooring to the walls separating the kitchen from the dining area to the large party room in the back. Thomaston is a small town, supporting seven pizza places. Domino's and Pizza Hut can't hold a candle to The Pie. The handmade dough, pizza sauce, bread for subs, dressings and the variety on the menu makes this place special. It's great to see places like this where so much pride, love and quality goes into the food. The sauce is delicious, the pizza dough is light and crisp. The dressing was smooth and tasty. If you are on US 19 between Atlanta and SoWeGa, stop by The Pie for a meal. We just had pizza, but I'm betting the pasta, subs and other fare meet the same high standards. Give it a try... You won't be sorry... read more

Good pizza with a hometown feel. Lunch buffet worth the trip.