Definitely a hidden gem as it's not on any main road but I feel like you should make this a…read moredestination if you're from out of the area because it's a real Amish bakery! I feel like there is something for everyone here! My husband thought the Dutch apple pie was out of this world. I thought it was different because it was chopped oats. We were not a huge fan of the chocolate chip cookies, the texture kinda got me, and the chocolate chips were an interesting flavor. My mom thought the pecan tarts were so yummy. I could literally taste how fresh and homemade that dough was, I thought it was very good as well, but probably would try something else instead next time. The cinnamon roll was interesting because I thought it was a lot more Joey than we used to and it had an icing on top. I actually really liked it. I am not someone that likes the super glazed sweet stuff so this was the right amount for me. My husband and I were not huge fans of the Fry pies. They were glazed, which is a personal preference. But the filling was just too much for me, I like more writing than filling, especially in the middle. It was a little overwhelming. I also felt like they were filled with more of the canned stuff rather than fresh bc of the consistency. The fresh sourdough bread was out of this world. I'd definitely recommend getting a bread loaf!!!

This is a hidden gem off the beaten path, if you didn't know it was there you would never know it…read moreis there. It is very authentic and rustic. Get there early!!!!!! We have tried many baked goods in the area and I have to say the glazed donuts were one of the best I have had. So light, pillowy and full of flavor. I was not so much a fan of the chocolate chip cookies, but my family loved the molasses and ginger cookies.

Great eclair, little heavy on the cream but it's whipped and tastes delicious so we can look past…read moregetting to much . Coffee is good, service is great, very friendly.

Excellent pies, everything in the bakery is very good, there is no other bakery that compares to…read moreDutch Valley

Such great service from sales associate Kelly. Owner was so nice to let us come and hang out and…read morelook at all the yummy pasties. Macarons, brownies, and cookies galore. Shop was cute and bakery was very clean. Highly recommend try if you are in Poland, Ohio. Service was prompt, efficient, and kind. 5 stars for Kelly. Give her a raise, she deserves it!

This business recently closed. When it was open, it was probably the best bakery you could ever go…read moreto their cakes their cupcakes and their macaroons were the best I've ever It is an absolute travesty that it closed

To be fair I did not try anything…read more.. All I saw for sale were cinnamon rolls and pre-cut and packaged-in-clamshells carrot cake squares. Since there weren't any customers in the ginormous room I had the feeling they might not be that fresh. The whole place smelled strongly of cocoa butter lotion or something like it. Not really appropriate for an establishment selling food. Overall I had the impression that the place was run by someone who doesn't really know how to run a bakery/cafe/business. It needs a LOT on the decorative side. It needs to list price, names of products, what is available. The area of the huge room not in use should be creatively curtained off or something so it's not like you're just in a big warehouse. The location's great. I hope it improves.

I love being able to purchase a slice of this and a slice of that. They were in a clamshell, very…read morefresh and delicious! The almond cake was generous in size and my husband loved it. I had the cheesecake and pumpkin pie and enjoyed them also. The italian bread was more like a white bread rather than italian but it was delicious!

Maggies has been THE donuts of choice for my family for the last 40 years. I have NEVER been so…read moredisappointed and will never again buy a Maggies donut. I called on Saturday and the young lady told me they would be open til 1 pm on Sunday 5/24/26, and she took my order for a dozen and a half donuts for my Memorial day breakfast. We showed up at 12:32 pm on the 24th to find them CLOSED. No good Maggies. No good. She had my phone number, someone could have called to let me know you chose to close. We had to settle for grocery store donuts, that we had to make a special trip on a holiday weekend Sunday to get.

Ingredient changes , smaller products higher prices and never fresh donuts ( And i gave a few tries…read morealso ) It's no wonder they just recently got beat out of their location in front of Wal Mart by a amish bakery in the plaza behind where they was at and because of so ,,, moved out ,Also another amish bakery that just opened on the right going into downtown Middlefield is way better than Maggies , The kids working at Maggies when i went were clueless on when i asked what brand coffee they serve , Just goes to show why they lost a good location on what i mentioned above

Our wedding cake was so beautiful and tasted amazing!!! They were extremely accommodating and…read morehelpful!

They were able to take my order last minute and made us exactly what I asked for!! I can't wait for…read morethe baby to try it tomorrow! Inside of the shop, they have so many fun goodies that looked so good!! I will definitely use them in the future!

Quality donuts! I can see and taste why Oram's always shows up when I google best donuts in PGH!…read more I finally had the chance to swing by this morning and I'm glad I pre-ordered. There wasn't a wait but it was nice to be able to see the options and choose ahead of time, and everything was there and ready to go! My donuts today taste great so far, I had a seasonal key lime pie flavor that was spot on, though a TINY bit on the sweet side. Then again, I opted for key lime so I should've known! Fresh donuts are definitely the way to go. I tried a gas station Oram's cinnamon roll once and that was a real bummer. Only minus one star because something was off about the taste of the glazed raised donut, not off as in spoiled, simply off as in not quite to my personal preference. Would definitely stop by again if I'm around!

This is my favorite donut place they have the best and most delicious donuts. Staff is always so…read morefriendly. You can order online and they will have your order ready for you or you can go in and order weekends are very busy so go early or do your ordering online to make sure you get the donuts you want. Easy street parking in front of the shop. The quality and favor of there donuts is top notch!!

OMG!!! Theses cupcakes were an 11 out of 10!!!! I walked here on my break and ate two on the walk…read morehome they were so flipping delicious!!! All I can say it SHUT UP and go get some you will not be disappointed. Andes mint! Peanut Butter Buckeye!!!

Bought a dozen pumpkin cookies they were dry crumbly and hard as can be . Messaged first to notify…read morewith no reply

SHORT AND SWEET!!! This bakery is a welcome new addition to Ashtabula. It's short and sweet, a…read moresmall little spot, but with a fantastic variety of croissants, rolls, pastries, and more! I had the cinnamon roll, which they were kind enough to heat up for me, love it so much, I had to come back and get another one! Stacy, the owner, is quite knowledgeable on health foods as well. I explained my auto-immune issues and she introduced me to their turmeric latte with almond milk, which was packed with nutrients, and just what I needed. I love this place and I'm looking forward to ordering a great big cake! Thank you; Bakery on Main!