The ice cream and service at every Kelly's is basically standardized. You know what you're getting when you approach that counter. What's always different, though, is what each location has to offer you on the outside. I haven't been to too too many Kelly's, but this one was the nicest, I think. Outside was a whole fenced in playground area with soft, fake mulch, nice little park benches, some games like giant Connect 4, and dainty little fairy lights that probably look very nice at night when they're turned on . The flavors they had this time were exquisite, which I know has nothing to do with the location. But it certainly helped this trip be very, very good. read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orlando, Florida

I have driven by this location so many times and was thrilled to finally try it out. I've been to many others but this location is very intriguing. It is nestled in the heart of a neighborhood and really brings the warm and cozy vibes of a neighborhood ice cream shop. There is no seating inside. Outside has many picnic tables with string lights above. Super cute. Inside the workers greeted us right away. I appreciated sampling a few of the monthly flavors. I got a waffle cone cup with 2 scoops - key lime and blueberry cobbler. I was excited to find out that with the rewards account I have, I finally earned a free scoop on my next visit. Definitely sign up for rewards if you haven't already. We went to sit outside and it was nice atmosphere besides the flies. There were hundreds of flies it seemed to we opted to sit in our car that was parked right outfront of the shop. It looked like several other guests sitting out there also were having issues waving off the flies. The ice cream itself was great. I thoroughly enjoyed the blueberry cobbler. Also my waffle cone broke apart nicely so I appreciated the freshness. Thanks Kellys! read more

See all

I visited this location last Saturday, and unfortunately it was the worst experience I've ever had at a Kelly's. This is my local location, so the disappointment was even greater. Upon entering, my party and I were ignored by staff. There were only two employees working: one actively helping the line of customers, and another who appeared to be doing nothing. When the employee assisting customers finally reached the person in front of us, the second worker walked up to her and said, "Take your time," despite the line continuing to grow. The comment came across as rude, unprofessional, and dismissive of the customers waiting. The overall service was extremely poor, and this experience has made it clear that I will not be returning to this Kelly's location. read more

Love this location. It's in the center of the neighborhood. Always busy. Always friendly staff. Love the monthly flavors but my go to is o-dough. Love the cute summer vibes it gives off. read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orlando, Florida

The best ice cream I've ever had! Tastes creat and I feel less guilty having good quality ice cream. I may or may not have been here every day while I was in town. Service was fast friendly and in a nice part of town. It was busy every time I was here but I can see why. read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Butter pecan one scoop - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orlando, Florida

This is one of my favorite ice cream stores. They are always friendly, generous with samples and the products are consistent. They also support the community! I was able to buy some girl scout cookies a couple of months ago in front of Kelly's! I had a Mexican Hot Chocolate, which the base tasted like Abuelita. Abuelita if you don't know is a Mexican Hot Cocoa. I grew up on it, and it evokes child hood memories. So this ice cream made with that base is FIRE! How can ice cream be fire? HA!! It's amazing. The guava cheese was also amazing. The rich sweet and savory aspects were very satisfying . They also sell koozies for your ice cream which is very handy to keep it cold. They also give loyalty points. They change their flavors a lot, which makes it always more interesting because you might make a new discovery. read more

See all

Pros: Typical Kelly's building inside, but the outside bench area is really cool. Nice squishy fake mulch for kids to safely play around in. Fairy lights strung all about. Very cool space. Service was standard. Very friendly. These guys gave us very large scoops. The ice cream was amazing as always. Cons: No cons. Tips: Keep track of what flavors you try. They come out with so many new ones and bring back so many fan favorites, it's hard to keep track. Lol. read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orlando, Florida

There was buy 1 get 1 free on Uber eats that I added to my bundle order. I gotten the banana pudding and it was really good! A perfect blend and not to sweet! I have had Kelly's before and they always have great flavors. A must visit! read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Kelly's Ice Cream is always a sweet treat. All the ice cream is packed with flavor and is so creamy. This location is small but it has a nice patio area to sit and enjoy your ice cream. The workers are always friendly and happy to let you taste any flavors. Kelly's always has great banana splits and they are a good size. The milkshake and scoop of strawberry were good as well. Whenever you're in the mood for quality ice cream you gotta go to Kelly's. read more

See all

If you like ice cream, this place is a must. I got a caramelized pineapple ice cream and kiddy cone . It was very creamy and the pineapple compote is sweet juice and full of flavor. This does not have cake chunks. Which is great for me. The staff here is also super sweet and helpful, and they even gave us as great advice for the amusement parks. Their waffle cones are also amazing. There's a huge outdoor picnic area that you could hang out after ordering your ice cream . The parking lot, however, is very small . But it is free. read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

Kelly'sssssssss We've been able to live within 2 miles of a Kelly's at every house we've lived in; and it's been both a blessing or a curse. The OG Kelly's is a cute spot for dessert and has a great outdoor seating area with yard games. I love their monthly different flavors -- last month, they had a melon flavor that was even better than Melona (high praise). The parking here is pretty limited, but we've luckily been able to find a spot every time. read more

See all

Ice cream was superb!!!! Coquito flavor was the chocolate was pretty good too! Service was good and the ambiance perfect at this event read more

See all

Da OGGGGG! This behemoth chain wouldn't exist if not for this initial shop! They have a cute outside area - not too feasible during the summer hots, but the winter lows, I can see this place being super busy. The inside is pretty no frills and also does not have a lot of space. Parking is also a bit of a pain as it's small and you have to back into a main road to get out. So these pain points really reduce it from the full five. But if you're able to walk here? I would be here everydayyyyy. If you're not familiar with Kelly, this is essentially an American style ice cream scoop shop. They have really fun monthly flavors, mostly tailored to the American tastebud. You may occasionally find a more colorful flavor, but they generally stay true to their roots. Their collabs are also great (Parlor!) but my favorite special? DUNKAROOSSS!!!! A blast from the past from when I was in elementary and I would just dunk my entire fat finger into the dip and suck on it like a babie. Thank you for bringing the nostalgia back for me - that flavor was so bomb. read more

Great place for homemade ice cream. I'm a member of the pint a month club. They do unique ice cream that is not available on the public menu. Great place. read more

This is one of a few reviews I've written for Kelly's but I just have to keep singing their praise! I was at an event recently and Kelly's had their truck there. I got a scoop of confetti cake ice cream and it was absolutely delicious as always! The service is always quick and friendly and it was the same at this event! I've never had any flavor I didn't like from Kelly's and will continue to be a loyal customer! read more

Absolutely happy to support this local business. The staff was friendly and helpful, I ordered quickly and was able to try a few flavors. I ended up getting the toasted coconut and Mexican chocolate- and what a combo! I'll be frequently OFTEN. read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Talk about poor customer service. Went on 07/16 and the lady who served me seemed like serving me was the end of the world. Attitude like she didn't care. Ice cream was fine but when service sucks; you don't really enjoy anything else. read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orlando, Florida

This is my go-to Kelly's location. As usual, amazing tasting ice cream (that doesn't kill my belly!). The service was great, they employee was kind and attentive. Price is great for quality treat and service. Outdoor seating area is a plus w picnic tables and family inviting. Delish and peaceful! read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Chocolate PB w almonds - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Staff was rude, they refused to take my order. They were more concerned with where I was standing in the store than taking my simple order for a vanilla milkshake . read more

How can you not stop at Kelly's!? We were in the mood for a sweet treat after shopping and happened to be near the sodo location. They had so many flavors to pick from! The staff assisting us was also very kind and provided quick service. This location didn't have a lot of space indoors, but had a beautiful outdoor seating area! Overall we really enjoyed our treat, and are looking forward to our next visit! read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Cookie Monster with M&Ms in waffle bowl (left) Cake batter in waffle bowl (right) - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orlando, Florida

This is exactly what you want from ice cream... rich, creamy, made with love, and downright delicious. Every bite felt like a hug from a dairy angel. Honestly, I want to drape my body in it--but since that's frowned upon in public, I'll settle for coming back as often as possible. Absolute gem. read more

July 19/2024: Ice Cream with my Al. What a cool little ice cream spot! It's small but staffed by a very polite helpful young man. I ordered a chocolate shake. It was what I expected...thick, chocolatey & delicious. Almost a meal replacement. The location itself was small with zero indoor seating but plenty outdoors. A little too hot for my enjoyment, however. It's a do over. read more

See all

Finally redeemed our complimentary scoops from a Yelp event last year! Came here after dinner at 50 Mills because we were both craving chocolate. Walked right in before closing (I am so sorry), but was greeted with a smile and "Welcome In!" Flavors chosen were cake batter and Oreo. Both were so creamy and heavy, that the one scoop was more than enough to satisfy our cravings. Definitely coming back here again. read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

I'm a fan of this location, out of the buzz and fuss of downtown Orlando despite technically located in downtown Orlando. It is surrounded by trees and the seating area outside is just lovely. Like I said in a previous review of Kelly's, and sorry not sorry for being repetitive because this is worth emphasizing: Kelly's monthly flavors are amazing and January's Alligator Tracks (an orange based flavor) won my heart this time. read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Alligator tracks. Delicious! - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orlando, Florida

I loveeee this ice cream place ! I can't talk about Kelly's everyday ! The employees are nice & helpful. The Ice cream flavors are prefect. And I love each month they have 4 monthly flavors. This time I had the Strawberry Shortcake ice cream. It has in cookies and vanilla swirl. Not to sweet and creamy. There is outside sitting on patio tables. Great for date day/night or if you just want a nice sweet treats Kelly's ice cream will always get my business !! read more

See all

I love the fact that this is a mom and pop stop. I also like the fact that it's a cream ice cream. Store, they got a backyard here. Where the kids can play and where you can relax and enjoy your ice cream.Kind of cool read more

See all

They have the creamiest ice cream. The coffee was rich and flavorful. Th Cookie Monster was buttery. read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Coffees - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

I'm new to Orlando and tried Kelly's for the first time a few months ago. I've lived in several states and Kelly's hands down has the best ice cream. The ice cream is fresh, creamy, and delicious. The cones are always fresh (nothing worse than a stale cone). They always have new and seasonal flavors. Depending on the time of day, the lines can be a little long but it's so worth it. The employees are friendly and it's always clean. Highly recommend! read more

I found my new favorite ice cream flavor! It's Cookie Monster! I was quite skeptical at first because at a first glance it looked like mint chocolate chip. I do not like mint flavored ice cream at all. But the Cookie Monster flavor is blue velvet cake batter ice cream mixed with Oreos. How awesome! read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Cookie Monster - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orlando, Florida

The ice cream at Kelly's is always delicious at all of their locations. The service is very friendly and they don't hassle you about samples so you can decide on the exact flavor you want. Standard ice cream shop atmosphere, but you can't go wrong with their delicious, high quality ice cream! read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Toasted coconut and chocolate peanut butter brownie... Ginger snap and affogato. - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orlando, Florida

I absolutely love this place! Even though I've sampled many of their delicious flavors, I always find myself coming back to the chocolate peanut butter brownie hands down the best ice cream flavor in my opinion! My husband has his own favorites: Ore-dough and banana pudding, while my son is a big fan of Cookie Monster. The shop is mostly run by very young adults, but the service is always great. The outside seating area is so cute, making it a perfect spot to enjoy your treat. Also join the rewards program, I have gotten many free single scoops. Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream is a gem that never disappoints! read more

See all

Not sure which location catered our work event but it was in Orlando. The ice cream was amazing! I had the key lime pie and it had just the right amount of punch you in the mouth! The staff were friendly and they had everything needed even for a popup event! I would have gone back for more but they served me enough the first go round I was too full to try the other flavor! read more

I went to the standalone location on Fern Creek/Kaley St. I was able to take my golf cart which I'll admit was a frivolous purchase but came in handy because there is minimal parking and it is always packed, understandably (I would never take ice cream to go). Like with any ice cream shop you get the rush of walking past of the flavor options and deciding which you want to choose. I went with coffee/oreo, it happened to be one of several dairy free options but I just chose it because it combined by two favorite foods! The cup in the picture is the junior size, which I thought was perfect to feel satisfied and avoid stomach ache/guilt/etc. Makes me more motivated to go back and try more flavors. There is a refrigerator inside with to-go pints - they are pricy but a great idea if you have family in town or are celebrating a special occasion. The inside is quiet at this location because of the seating outside. There is corn hole and big connect four outside in addition to tables and benches. The restrooms are also located outside. This is the only Kelly's location I've eaten at, but I've been to several Foxtail locations that they partner with (Winter Park, Hourglass district, Milk district) so if you're a local you shouldn't have to travel far to try some of Orlando's best ice cream! read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Coffee Oreo junior scoop - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Kelly's ice cream is absolutely delicious! I have tried a few flavors, but the one flavor I always come back to is the Banana Pudding flavor. The Banana Pudding flavor consists of banana cake batter ice cream with marshmallow cream and Nilla wafers, and it is one of the best flavors you can try especially if you love banana pudding. I was able to try the Pumpkin flavor during the month of October, and it was absolutely delicious as well! Overall, I am definitely going to continue to return for the Banana Pudding flavor once I finish my pint. read more

Five stars for a place that keeps my wife happy. Because we all know a happy wife is a happy life, right? Lol date nights always somehow end up at Kelly's. But in not complaining. Blondie is a staple. Ore-dough is my wife's go-to. I always make it a point to try a seasonal flavor or flavor of the month. Never disappointed. Service is always fast and efficient. This particular location has a nice outdoors space that's inviting. read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orlando, Florida

Everything was had here was amazing- so good!! And the service was fabulous!! Not just the people working there but just the people going there and ordering everyone was cool and nice! I was super happy. They had ice cream dairy free but I did taste the best flavor there, Mexican chocolate!!! So so good- like slap yo mamma good!! my new favorite ice cream spot in Orlando read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all

We stopped here after lunch while searching for Vegan ice cream. This place is cute, especially the outside seating where the woodchucks is actually tires shredded which was super cool and good for the planet. They had a very small and limited number of Vegan options (1-2). My boys ended up having the cookies and cream ice cream and sorbet. My sister had the banana pudding which had actual cookies and bananas in it as it was so good. My son dropped his sorbet and they was so nice to give him a new scoop after noticing her dropped it. That was very appreciated and the process in and out was smooth as they allow you to taste flavors as well as we tired two before deciding. read more

See all

Toasted. S'mores. OMG. I could go back for this flavor any day. I also had the malted vanilla chip which was also very good. I'd like to come back and try the guava and cheese which I heard was to die for but I haven't had the chance to try. They rotate their flavors so make sure to follow their IG for current menu items. Service was great - I was able to try some samples. This place is cute with some outdoor seating and games. Parking is a little tight but just be careful getting out of there as it is right by the road. Worth the drive though :) Support local! read more

Awesome, great ice cream and fun flavors. A bit pricey, but good stuff usually is. The staff was great read more

3 stars for the ice cream. The service has gone down unfortunately and prices have increased A LOT! The ice cream scoops are smaller and the waffle cones are smaller as well. The employees aren't friendly like they used to be and just seem to be there to be there. They also seem irritated when you ask for samples. Used to be my favorite place to come for ice cream and drive pretty far to come out for it, not too sure anymore. Great flavors and like to try the different ones, but getting pretty pricey for a whole family. read more

Kelly's Homemade Ice Cream - Tiny scoops - Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt Near Me - Orlando, Florida

See all