This is the best rated key lime pie in key west according to chatgpt, so we had to try it! It was a small shop with the pies already packaged and in a showcase. The server was nice and just handed us our prepackaged slice. We ordered the strawberry limeaid and a slice of the key lime pie. The strawberry limeaid was a little too concentrated for me and a little too tart. The pie was delicious. I wish the put more meringue on top. read more

Was driving by and decided to pop in because when you're in Key West, you have to try key lime pie, right? Plus, the place caught my eye right away. It's super cute and inviting. I originally went in planning to try the chocolate covered key lime pie on a stick, but Diego, the cashier, suggested I start with a traditional slice since I was a newbie. I appreciated that recommendation! For context, I'm not a big key lime pie person. I love key lime flavored things like cookies and candy, but the pie itself has never really been my favorite. But again... when in Key West, you know the rest, lol! I gave it a try, and honestly, I was surprised. It was actually good. Probably the best key lime pie I've had. It tasted very different from the ones I've tried in Dade and Broward County. Its ike they used real key lime, which made a noticeable difference. The crust was my favorite part. It was perfectly crunchy and tasted homemade, which paired so well with the filling. Even the whipped cream on top was delicious. I will say, if I were a true key lime pie lover, I'd probably be obsessed, if that makes sense, lol. Overall, great experience. Diego was friendly and helpful, the place was clean and adorable, and they had a nice variety of treats. I'd definitely come back. Next time, I've got my eye on a key lime cookie! Btw. There's a 3% charge if you use a credit card. read more

See all

My aunt was on the hunt for some key lime pie. She always comes here to get the frozen pie that was dipped in white chocolate on a stick. I saw that they had pineapple dole whip and key lime dip. The woman was kind enough to let me sample it. If you like the pineapple, you'll love the key lime even more. It's a cute little shop. If you are thirsty, there is a cooler full of drinks. I almost bought the t-shirt that's in my picture for my daughter. It's totally her. A shirt with an attitude. read more

See all

You have to visit Kermits whenever you're in Key West! The Keylime pie is excellent .... but the star of the show was the chocolate covered Keylime pie bar! read more

See all

It's only $6/slice, and there's not too much meringue, so that's good. But the slice is pretty small. If you need a slice without feeling like you're pigging out, this is a good option. read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

The pie was decent and the decorations inside cute. Slices are pre packaged and just seemed more like an assembly line chain then an authentic Key Lime experience in the Keys. Would look for a restaurant or somewhere else to try next time. read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Key Lime Pie - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

So I visited Key West and on my must try list of food is KEY LIME pie in Key West! We asked local folks the best place for pie and they recommended Kermit's. We enjoyed all the samples of flavors just to try. We visited in October but it was hot enough to hangout inside and enjoy our slice of pie in the AC. The pie was very good and limey! Service friendly. Totally recommend a stop here when visiting Key West. read more

See all

Me and my friend were on the hunt for the best Key Lime Pie spot and Kermit's definitely took the cake! I thought the taste was perfect, the right balance of being tart, but also sweet, and I loved the texture of the pie crust, which I know is hard to get. The store also had other lime-flavored items. I've been to the other Kermit's location which had more things to shop for, but both locations are good. I do wish there was more seating as this location is a bit small, but it was fine. Highly recommend! read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

Shari and I popped into Kermit's Key Lime Pie Shoppe while in Key West on way to Rum Distillery Tour. It smelled like a slice of Heaven in there. We sampled a few cookies and a few pieces of Key lime candies But we bought nothing we were In a rush to the tour read more

See all

Such a cute little bake shop! My day in Key West wouldn't have been complete without a frozen, chocolate dipped key lime pie on a stick so of course we stopped in Kermits. The young lady behind the counter was friendly and helpful and they had a whole table set up with samples of all their delicious cookies, crackers, nuts and candy. They have 2 small tables inside and a few more out back. This is a clean, bright spot perfect for satisfying a craving for anything key lime! read more

See all

Loved the Key Lime pie experience . Lovely choices but our favorite was the original. read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Key lime - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

Having been to the Florida location I thought I would try the real deal in Key West. The store is a little smaller than the one in Deland, which is like a factory outlet so of course they're going to have everything. I didn't see the salad dressing, which was a little disappointing. I love the mango dressing and we'll have to have it shipped. Keylime pie here is probably my second favorite on the island and pretty solid. read more

See all

Wonderful store on Duval Street offering delicious cookies, pies, ice cream, lemonade and more. They had several free sample areas and we got hooked on their cookies. My favorite was the key lime coolers ($9+ for a bag) They're coated in powdered sugar and taste like key lime pie, they are so delicious. We struck up conversation with the associate working here her name was Tracy and she was such a sweetheart. She gave us a lot of great information on where to get happy hour deals and which restaurants to avoid. The store is very clean and brightly decorated, blends in lovely with the whole Key West vibe. If you were in the area shopping, I highly recommend stopping in to check them out.Try some of their cookies, you will be hooked. read more

See all

When compared against Key Lime Pie Co, Kermit's was the clear winner. The key lime pie has the right balance between tart and sweet, there was a good pie to crust ratio, and the whipped cream was delicious. They also sell a variety of cookies, nuts, and other lime-flavored goods in store. The decor is cute, but there could be more seating available inside and outside since you can't really eat pie while walking. read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Key lime pie - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

Fantastic keylime pie. I honestly didn't know I could get keylime honey (which I bought). read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

Nice person at the counter who helped us. They charge 3% extra for credit cards. Pro tip, go to Cuban coffee queen and enjoy your pie with a cup of Cuba coffee. read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Slice of pie - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

The pie was okay. Not the best I've had in the Keys, or even on the mainland in Florida. Cute little seating area in an enclosed patio, but the pie wasn't worth the hype. I only ate about half a slice, and when I tossed it in the garbage, I saw about a dozen half-eaten slices in there. Try it in one of the little roadside restaurants along the highway on the way down. read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

Key lime pie in key west..prigional and coconut pie was great. Free samples of cookies were also great. Wish we would have gone to the other location for the full experience. This one is a smaller version. Service qas great. Only a couple tables inside. read more

If you're looking for key lime pie you've come to the right place! This shop is located right on Duval street and most likely you'll walk by it. Once you enter the place is really cute. They offer a variety of cookies, crackers, and the best part is they have free samples of it all! My favorite cookies were the key lime coolers. Give em a try. They also sell key lime pie by the slice or the whole pie. And if you want the pie to go, they do have thermal bags available which will keep your pie chilled. There's a fridge with key lime pies dipped in chocolate which are quite tasty. Another cool thing here is Key Lime Pie beer! Now that was an interesting find. I had never seen this before so I had to taste it. Yes, it's sour, but pretty refreshing especially on a hot day. I tried a slice of the original key lime pie and it was delish. Perfect amount of tartness and creaminess. The whip cream was delicious and the graham crust tasted fresh. They have some seating indoors and also have a cute key lime colored patio area where you can enjoy your goodies. read more

See all

Delicious key lime pie! Do it! They also have other yummy treats you can take back to your hotel for later. read more

Located in the heart of key west Duval street. This place is so cozy and cute with seating area inside and the back. They many options to try like keylime cookies to drinks. The cookies are amazingggg. But you gotta try the pie. Super delicious. If you're in the area, come in and try it. The employees are super nice and friendly. read more

See all

Kermit's is really cute! I wish the pie was as amazing as the cute store. had high expectations for their key lime pie that weren't really met, but it was good! I just expected fireworks and it was kind of an average pie. The slices are also a little small for the price. The store was cheery and colorful with a couple Instagram spots throughout. They offer a lot of different items, like jellybeans, honey, and cookies, although I didn't see anyone purchase these. They also offer three flavors of fresh pie slices and four flavors of frozen pie on a stick. There isn't a lot of seating, but it is comfortable and cute inside. The store quickly got crowded and the line was disorganized. The staff were nice and friendly. I just wasn't blown away by the pie. read more

See all

Cute shop with many foodstuff items with the expected key lime ingredient -- pies, cookies, honey, salad dressing, peanuts. There were also many items featuring the logo --wooden cutting boards, charcuterie boards, and even a special edition themed monopoly game. We selected a whole frozen key lime pie, which we placed in our home fridge to enjoy later that evening. We ultimately were able to share individual slices with our group of 8 and portions were perfect. Pie was creamy, sweet, and tart and the graham cracker crust was firm and a nice semi-crunch texture as a counterpoint to the pie filling. Everyone was complimentary. The shop was clean and had a very cheery welcoming atmosphere. Staff were friendly and helpful. Dining tables and chairs are available if someone wanted to enjoy pie at the time of sale. Outside counter height stools are also available to enjoy treats while watching Duval Street patrons. Interesting side note: Check out the glass window behind the cashier's counter. It's an opportunity to see one of island roosters up close and personal with a small chicken coop experience. We also saw a small abandoned egg, which was a first. Key lime pies can be purchased whole or by the slide in several flavors. read more

See all

DELICIOUS!!!! If you are a fan of Key lime pie or just love them like I do since this is a must visit for you. They have so many other goodies which you can sample. They have key lime cookies, key lime jelly beans (not my favorite) and even key lime marmalade. The staff was friendly and the shoppe is cute with colorful decor pretty much it's the island vibe. I highly recommend stopping in if you are visiting the area. read more

See all

Came in store. They had a variety of key lime pies - whole pies, frozen pie, pie on a bar, slices in different flavors. Pretty casual since there are people browsing and others eating. Service is at counter to pay for your goods. Got a slice of key lime pie - got to try some when you are in key west. It was very good albeit too sweet for me. I like the coconut flakes on top that gives it more texture. I taste a little lime flavor. The crust also provide a good contrast to the soft pie texture/ flavor. read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Frozen key lime bars. - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

I'm not an expert on what key lime pie should taste like but we enjoyed it! They had free samples of the key lime cookies and they were delicious. Picked up a couple bags for gifts. Super cute shop. read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Free samples - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

Another Key West key lime pie recommendation. I liked that I could get it frozen and was able to bring a whole pie onboard my cruise ship. We had it that evening in the dining room. I felt like their version was a tad more tart than I would like, but still delicious. I would like to go back and get a fresh key lime slice rather than try the frozen one to compare taste. read more

3.5/5 When in Key West, a key lime pie is a must. Seeing I was on Duval Street, I decided to stop here since I know this is one of the top places for key lime pie. The store inside is quite neat. There's key lime everything including pie, pie bars, ice cream, and it includes different flavours such as coconut and strawberry. Obviously I had a slice of the original key lime pie. My dad went with the chocolate dipped coconut key lime pie. I liked the original, it definitely struck the perfect balance between sweet and sourness. My dad was lukewarm over his chocolate dipped coconut taste, he said there was a lot more chocolate than coconut. Portions were pretty small. You're definitely getting a better bang for your buck by buying the whole pie. I'd say it's good to stick with the original slice (or buy a pie), don't bother with the additional gimmicks here. read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Kermit's Key Lime Pie - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

It was my first time in key west so of course I had to have at least a slice of key lime pie. This place had a lot of reviews but honestly I was disappointed. The guy working there wasn't the friendliest. There was a picture of another flavor of key lime pie and she asked what flavored it was and his answer was "what does it look like?". Probably not the way you want to respond to a customer and maybe simply answer the question kindly instead of with a smart remark. The key lime pie was ok, I think the one from Publix actually has more flavor to it. A slice is $6+, it comes out better if you're get a full pie and divide with whoever you're going with. They have original key lime, strawberry key lime, and coconut (which seems is mainly just coconut flakes in it). At the end I kind of wish I would've tried a different place. read more

See all

Kermits Key West was a fun little experience we got the chocolate covered key lime pie. read more

Kermit's Key West Key Lime Shoppe - Desserts Near Me - Key West, Florida

See all

It's my birthday and wanted a sweet treat and I have ordered key lime pie from here several times before. Searched the internet and found lots of places that celebrate birthday appreciation in Key West and Kermit's is one of them. The counter girl gave me one pre-packaged slice of key lime pie which I gobbled up inside. My friends ordered a frozen chocolate key lime pie popsicle. Both were very sweet. The air conditioning here is always on freezing and was helpful on this hot night. They have a secluded enclosed outside patio with big chairs to relax if you love the heat. read more

See all

Key Lime is their thing. If you want just a slice or a whole pie, they have it. Or maybe some different flavors added to the Key Lime, they have that too. And also, in ice cream form ... they have it. How does it taste? I tried the original, and it was quite good. Was it the best? Not sure. But again, it was really good. Would I go again? Absolutely! But I would be inclined to try some of their other options. read more

Best key lime pie in Key West--hands down. We tried a few others, but Kermit's was the clear standout . The filling bursts with fresh lime flavor, perfectly sweet without being overpowering. The crust is buttery and crisp, and the whipped cream tastes like clouds. We also tried the white chocolate strawberry key lime pie bar--delicious and a fun twist. The strawberry lemonade juice on its own was way too sour, but I saved it and turned it into a margarita later--perfection. Don't miss this spot! read more

See all

We had heard about Kermit's via a internet search. We ended up arriving approximately 7 min before closing and there were a few people in line already. Service was quick and all about getting these customers taken care of so 'we can close up'. Not warm and friendly but I understood. I enjoyed my slice but hubby thought it was too sweet and too tart. I can't say it stood out in comparison to other establishments because I've not had enough to compare. read more

This is the best key lime pie in key west (if you prefer a more tart KLP). We bought a frozen pie and paid an additional $10 to have it packaged so we could bring it home. The best souvenir! read more

The pie is by far the best key lime pie we've ever had. The only problem with Kermit's is there was very limited seating.

There are different products sold here. From the original key lime pie to its variations - with strawberry, frozen, cookies, and candies - they're here. Check out was quick when I went here at about 9pm. There are tables and chairs for those who want to eat inside. The key lime pie was too sweet for me. read more

See all

This place was awesome. Loved the key lime pie and the variety offered with strawberry and coconut on the menu. Truly a treat for being in such a touristy spot! read more

This is the one!! On Duval Street. To us, the best key lime pie in the state of Florida. I've had more key lime pie than I care to admit. The perfect amount of flavor, creaminess, and crust. read more

KEY LIME PIE GALORE...Small shop on the Duval Strip in Key West. They boast an old blue and lime colored tryck in the center of the store. A nice outside patio area to chill and eat their famous key lime pie on a stick for $6.40. read more

See all