Had no idea Oyster Bay was so fast to deliver to Syosset... in 30 minutes or so we had an…read moreEverything pizza delivered... feared the worst because I ALWAYS pick up.. Under the weather had to default to delivery... this Everything Pizza arrived hot and with tons of delicious toppings.. bottom crust a bit dark... but better than raw for this heavily topped pizza... Delivery man was energetic and friendly. Nice vibe all around here. Would get again.... Thanks for the perfect stay at home dinner tonight.

What' a disappointment. Sometimes you have to give a place a few times before you are ready to give…read moreit up. Time to give up on Mana Mia's. The food is average. The pizza looks and tastes under done. But worst of all the counter staff is rude. About the only positive thing I can say is at least it's easy to park there.

If you haven't tried the Vodka Pizza at Mario's yet, you are seriously missing out! It is…read morehands-down our favorite spot in town. The sauce is perfectly creamy with just the right amount of kick, and the crust always has that ideal crunch. What really sets Mario's apart, though, is their exceptional customer service. The team here truly goes out of their way to make sure their customers are happy. It's rare to find a place that cares as much about the experience as they do about the food. We're customers for life--thanks for the amazing meal! Thanks for taking care of us! Mario's is our favorite pizza!!!

2-16-25. Stopped in for lunch because I had an errand to run…read morein the immediate area. Ordered a chicken Marsala slice and a regular slice. Both were very good. My friend had a Sicilian slice and said it was excellent. Plenty of seating in a comfortable and casual atmosphere. Staff was very friendly and they had quite a large selection of specialty pizzas. Prices were reasonable.

I went to Stellina last night. My 1st time there. An amazing experience. It is a small restaurant…read morewith maybe 12 tables. We Had a reservation which I would recommend as it is small. After we sat, our busboy, Matteo brought us bread and water. He was adorable and very attentive. Our waiter Ghent couldn't have been nicer. We ordered rice balls to share. Absolutely delicious. My friend ordered Cacio e Pepe that she thought was outstanding. I had the pappardelle ragu. The pasta was homemade. It was such a delicious dish. For dessert, Strawberry sorbetto. It was a terrific experience. The restaurant has an amazing menu. Can't wait to go back and try something else. Go. I'm sure you will love it.

Very nice looking restaurant with decent attentive service for the most part. The food selection…read morewas limited and it was just okay. There was a salad on the menu that had charred romaine lettuce, with marinated artichokes and reggiano cheese. I asked for just plain romaine and they poured olive oil and lemon on it. They didn't char it and it was still $25 for a plate of lettuce. The bread was tasty and came with butter loaded with too much garlic - the whole place was overrun with garlic as a matter of fact. The baby chicken was okay but not great and quite tiny which was fine. The dessert choice was limited to things that were all creamy and rich. We ordered gelato and it came to us like a bowl of soup - melted. The server didn't seem to notice and just put it down on the table. It was my birthday and my husband asked for a candle for the dessert but they didn't bother to remember. They did remove the charge for the melted gelato after I mentioned it. Since it was my birthday and it was expensive - and a bug came in from outside and landed in my hair it was a little disappointing. The bug was not the fault of the restaurant - it flew in from the parking lot where the outdoor tables were set up.

I live off this place. Nest options are chicken parm,stuffed rigatoni, and Ziti Pizzaread more

Ordered a vodka pie yesterday and it had some of the worst crust I've ever had on Long Island. It…read morewas dense and dry... I could make better dough at home. The flavors were good but the crust was just THAT bad.

Of course we are back! We brought my son's friend who just moved here and had to introduce him to…read moresome awesome coal fired pizza. As usual, it was perfectly thin crust. We ordered a new to us pizza: Speck and it was delicious. It was our guest's favorite! This time we also tried the Depequa pie which my daughter because it was crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside. Patio seating is now open since it is summer but we chose to sit inside where it was less noisy. Service was efficient and attentive. Highly recommend!

Desperate for neapolitan pizza and not willing to sit through traffic so we landed here again. The…read moredough isn't exactly what I was craving for which is thin, chewy. We ordered: Broccoli Rabe sausage Fig arugula Speck with truffle oil Meatball ricotta

Putting in my 5 star to counteract the douchebag who gave a 1 star review cause he didn't like the…read morehours, lol. Good for them closing at 8pm, pizzamen deserve to have a life too. Anyway the Pizza here is amazing and the Sandwiches are downright formidable. Yeah its expensive, yeah the parking is a joke, its crowded. but take a bite and you'll see- it is worth the hassle

The pizza was solid. I don't think it lived up to what I expected but it was still a really really…read moregood pizza. The crust was good but maybe I don't love sourdough pizza doughs. The cheesesteak was a bit of a let down. I really didn't love the bread and it needed more cheese. Compared to your average cheesesteak this was great but I am comparing this to Angelo's in Philly and it's just not in that league. We pre ordered our pizza and cheesesteak. When we walked in there was no sign as to where to wait if you had ordered ahead of time. We stood to the side for a few minutes until we were yelled at by the cashier for taking up space. Luckily the owner saw this and quickly interjected. After that poor start everything else went well. The owner let us change our order to sit down and they made space at a table for us. Someone even nicely boxed our leftovers for us.

Good pizza good service and friendly personnel. It is close to where I live but what makes me go…read morethere is the pizza is delicious

This pizza spot offers a large variety of slices to pick from. We tried the buffalo chicken slice,…read moreziti slice, sweet chili chicken, and chicken parm slice. Everything was delicious, but I highly recommend the sweet chili chicken. The garlic knots were excellent too, and they weren't overcooked, which was great. They have a few tables inside for dining in and plenty of parking available. The staff was really friendly as well.

The place is amazing. The service is fantastic. The meatballs with sauce are phenomenal, the wings…read moreare amazing, and all the pizzas are delicious. Cheese, pizza, pepperoni and mushrooms, sausage and 50 others. I can't wait to go back again. Also, all the wines and beers are amazing. A little costly but worth every penny. Last of all, it's a very cute place in a beautiful area.

Bad pizza. Bad baaad pizza. Nice people but baaad pizza. You can drive 3 miles north south east…read morefor west and have many options for very good pizza. Crust bad - no taste , weak in the texture category as well. Sauce NG - sweet Temperate - not hot - kinda soon temp ... why? For a place that not only specializes in Pizza that's pretty much 99% of the menu options you would think that they would be servicing amazing pizza. Or possibly really good pizza. How about decent pizza ? Nope Channeling my Nike spirit I'd say " Just DONT do it "