Villa Monte is kind of a hidden gem for pizza lovers. Nestled in a parking lot in Old Bethpage/Plainview area right near the Old Restoration Village, sits a pizzeria with so many different slices and varieties. The have everything from spicy grandma and pesto slices to Baked clam slices and other specialties slices. The interior of this place is huge and has a general seating area, a bar, and a restaurant area. It's decorated very well and authentic. The employees are attentive and ready to take your order. I totally recommend read more

Villa Monte - Spicy Grandma and pesto slices - Pizza Near Me - Old Bethpage, New York

See all

Unfortunately not for me. The slices were a bit too thick and greasy, doused in sauce (not pizza sauce, but sauces for flavored slices), and just weird to eat given how both tough and soggy the slices were. This was the case for the buffalo and french fry slice. Wasn't too fond of the other slices either though they were simpler. Unfortunately will not be returning. read more

We found ourselves for the second time after eight years dining at this restaurant, at the request of our friends. We sat in the dining room and were served by a lovely, friendly lady. She was very attentive, and I believe she knows our friends dine here often. I must admit, their portions are sizable, and their entrees are delicious. I am still amazed that pizza can be made and left in the open air for so long before someone buys a slice. In Florida, it's rare to find places that sell just a slice; they typically sell only whole pies. This pizzeria is quite busy, and I find it hard to believe their pizza in the glass cases sits there long. Overall, I highly recommend this pizzeria restaurant. read more

Villa Monte - Broccoli Rabe with grilled chicken - Pizza Near Me - Old Bethpage, New York

We get Villa Monte's Too Good to Go bags every once in a while, and everything I have tried from them is delicious. They've really mastered the art of the specialty slice. Their toppings are super unique, but the flavors are always spot on. Most recently, I tried a grandma with caramelized onions and mushrooms. It was delicious. A simpler but equally delicious slice is their Tri-Colored pizza with regular, vodka, and pesto sauce. I don't think you can go wrong with any of their slices. read more

My boyfriend and I walked in last minute Wednesday night expecting to find no little to no tables available. To our surprise, there was plenty of seating available. He had been to Villa Monte before, but I had not, so I was pleasantly surprised with how clean it was and how prompt the service was. The food was delectable, and I had leftovers for two more days. This was It was pretty good considering our entire dinner was only about $50.00. I cannot wait to go back! read more

See all

They have tons of different specialty slices and the overwhelming majority that I have tried have all been very good. Some of my favorites are the meatball slice (it has a few half meatballs on it) and a chicken bacon stuffed slice that tastes very similar to my favorite sandwich that has many of the same ingredients. The place is clean and the workers are good. Altogether, I find that this is a high quality pizza place with solid food. I highly recommend that you check it out. read more

Best deep dish marinara in this WORLD! And some of the best specialty slices in general. Staff is friendly. Prices are reasonable. Such a hidden gem! read more

See all

It's been awhile! Driving nearby and had to stop by! Chopped eggplant pizza. So good! Hands down still the best I've ever had. No eggplant slice comes close this. Highly recommend. Best to have. Order it cold and reheat 400 degrees 7 min bottom rack and 7 min top rack. Chefs kiss. You will thank me if your an eggplant lover. read more

Villa Monte - Chopped Eggplant Specialty Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Old Bethpage, New York

The pizza is really excellent and I love then variety! They are always prompt and kind. Great food and nice in store dining.

The food is typically great, but a few of the workers have a rude attitude. I'm someone who likes extra sauce with my slices, and will pay for the side if I have to. I ordered my slices with extra sauce on the side and one worker tells me okay. When the very nice lady rings me up, she said "you told the guys about the sauces right?" And I said yes. When I get my pizza, there's no sauce so I asked another worker for it, to which he completely ignored me and didn't respond. Then I ask another worker 5 minutes later and he says "it's already on the pizza" and I said "I ordered sauce on the side" and he mumbles something as he turns his back to me. I said "what?" and he says something along the lines of "the pizza guy already put it on the chicken" with a snotty tone and he walks away. So I paid for a side of sauce that they refused to give. Great pizza, horrible attitude. (They have given me a side of sauce in the past but it suddenly became a problem I guess). read more

Very happy with the food! Delicious! Also happy with the service, always friendly and attentive. To me it's a hidden gem in the neighborhood! read more

Self proclaimed pizza snob here...jumping right in...the regular slice was just fine...nothing great but fine. The sauce was ok but the crust was pretty good. The lasagna slice was a nice surprise though. Thin crust but not soggy. The cheese was nice and not gloppy. And not oily, which is important. So, if you're in the area already, it's ok but I can't see traveling out of the way to get here. A "neutral" thumbs up... read more

Killer sweet and spicy slice and from time to time, I get a bruschetta slice that is pretty good.

Just came back from dinner on a Friday night. The place was packed. It's a pizza place with an Italian restaurant in the back. The food was really good, but I have had better Italian. The prices are fantastic and you get salad and pasta with every entree, which is nice. I am excited to go back and try their pizza. They had the widest variety of types of slices I have ever seen. I ordered the eggplant parmigiana. It was good, but not the best I have had. For my sides, I got the Caesar salad and the whole wheat penne. Both were very good. My parents enjoyed their scallop and veal dishes and my husband's veal parmigiana was very good. Service was great! Will be back to try the pizza. read more

This place has one of the largest and most creative specialty pie displays I've ever seen. It's a pizza joint on one side and a restaurant on the other. I've been to the restaurant and the food is excellent.......but in my opinion, that's not why you should visit. It's the crazy amount of specialty slices you can get at the counter. Every slice I've tried over the years has been great. Highly recommend the chicken francese and alla vodka margherita slices. They are worthy of 4.5 stars in my book. read more

Food was good but the service could have been better. I didn't know that tip was cash only so I had to ask the man up in the front to break a twenty and he wasn't really that friendly. Didn't say a word and just threw the money on the counter without placing it in my hand. If you don't mind cash only tips, this place is for you. read more

See all

Very unorganized. There three different sighns one says phone orders one say to pay and one says to get pizza. I waited where it said to get pizza no one ever asked if they can help me. Someone that came in after was by a different sighn and they asked what they wanted and they ordered pizza before me. After wauting a while ine the line I finally gave up and left before even being able to try a slice. I only have 30 minutes for a break so couldnt wait any longer. They need to make it more organized..In stead of haveing people all over ordering from different areas. A little confusing for someone who never been there. With that said the pizza looked good but Ill never know. read more

Big fan. I usually stop in for a slice when I'm in the area. They have an amazingly large selection of creative pizzas by the slice. Pizza is well made, flavorful, with an excellent crust. read more

great selection of pizza, they have everything you can think of. Very nice family and fantastic service. it's worth the trip

The BEST pizza. Go there. Eat delicious pizza. Say "hi" to the friendly owners and dedicated staff! Ask for the pesto slice--you win't be disappointed! read more

Villa Monte - Mmmmmmmm....my fave specialty slice @ Villa Monte! "A corner of the pesto, please!" - Pizza Near Me - Old Bethpage, New York

I went there today, and the food was great; they have a lot of different types of pizza, and it is also super interesting. I loved the pizza. I got the garlic chicken parmesan and Koran Shrimp. The service was average because they had to heat it, which is perfectly okay. When walking inside it did feel dark in there. Although I would 100% come here again. read more

Villa Monte - Koran Shrimp - Pizza Near Me - Old Bethpage, New York

See all

My experience is limited to the Pizza part, not the restaurant. The pizza is the best I've ever eaten. This place is always packed, because people know the quality there. They do such a good business that they're not open on Sundays. Friendly staff. The biggest problem is that they have so many choices, it's hard to pick. read more

Originally found this place because of the too good to go app. Stopped by and grabbed a box with some slices. Got hooked. Ended up doing that same thing couple of more times. Worth every penny. One Friday night couldn't decide what sort of pizza to grab so came in for slices. Got the buffalo calamari, sweet heat calamari (I think that's what it's called), some sort of spicy lovers and shrimp scampi slice. The calamari slices were surprisingly not chewy when reheated. Of course utterly delicious as well. Shrimp scampi wasn't as amazing as would have expected, but hey reheated shrimp eh yea. Probably better when it's fresh. Spicy lovers slice a delight! In short if you want delicious variety this is the place to get it! Service is quick and friendly. Prices are reasonable. Pizza is very flavorful. Compared to a nearby pizza place that is well know and equally priced, I'd go with this one. So give it a try read more

They have a ton of variety when it comes to pizza toppings. I've been here many times with coworkers, and although everyone seems to love this place, I'm not a fan. The crust is too thick for me, and the flavor in the sauce is not that good read more

Went to Villa Monte's for the first time last night and they did not disappoint. The service was great, our server was Mike, and the food was amazing. We had a group of 14 people and everyone was thrilled with their food. Absolutely no complaints, will definitely be back. Highly recommend the Rigatoni Ala Vodka with fried chicken! read more

Villa Monte - Rigatoni Alla Vodka with Fried Chicken - Pizza Near Me - Old Bethpage, New York

Pizza is tasty and the sauce is good but the crust on the regular pizza is wayyyy too thin. The garlic knots (squares) are really good. It's ok. If the slices were a little thicker and not flop-over thin I would rate higher. read more

Mmm! Did you say you wanted a speciality slice?! Yes, I'm sure you did! Walking into Villa Monte (the pizza side) you will be greeted by pizza. Yes, greeted by pizza. So many speciality slices to chose from. Shrimp scampi, pesto, chicken Marsala, chicken bacon ranch, salad slice, white slice, bruschetta, chicken Caesar...the list is never ending! Something for absolutely everyone! I've been coming here for as long as I can remember, since childhood! Always had good slices of pizza...and not just speciality slices. Their regular slices are just as delicious. I know that during lent they have numerous shrimp pies and clam pies. So delicious and tons of options during lent. Last night I came here with my parents. We each got one speciality pie slice. One is enough because they are big and filling. I know, that's what she said. I had a white slice. So delicious and had the perfect balance of cheeses. Add some red pepper flakes and you're golden. My mom got chicken francese slice. She enjoyed it. My stepdad got a chicken Caesar salad slice. This slice is served cold. He said it was good. Filling also as he couldn't even finish it. Pizza is so good!!! The other side of the pizza place is the Italian restaurant. I've dined in on that side as well, but it's been ages. I do remember it being tasty though. read more

See all

Been coming here for years. Biggest selection of specialty slices you've ever seen. Staff is great. They come up with new pies all the time. They are all good. From lasagna to deep dish meatball to pesto to French fry and hot dog. Absolutely the best around for specialty slices. Oh, and Thursday and Friday they have at least a half dozen seafood pies to choose from on top of the other 2 dozen or so. Never had anything other than pizza here because I just can't get past it. read more

Absolutely love this place! The staff was friendly, attentive, and quick. Started with some amazing calamari with warm marinara sauce. Our main dishes were, Tortellini Alla Panna, Penne Fiorentina, and our kid had spaghetti with meatballs. Everything tasted perfect. Also ordered some garlic squares. They were so fresh almost melted in your mouth. Highly recommend this restaurant. read more

I recently stopped by for a quick bite on a cold winter day. I've only been here a few times. Very friendly, service. Clean. But I have to say, the food is Eh, nothing to write home about. My eggplant Parm hero was hot, but sort of soggy, like it came out of the microwave. And my large drink, was everyplace elses medium size. Really now, no reason to cheap out on soda. read more

Amazing selection! Bursting with flavor! Unique! So delicious! Best on Long Island. Best of Italy! read more

Villa monte is our go to pizza and Italian food. We consider them the best in at least a 2 mile radius from our house in Old Bethpage. Umbertos in Plainview is ok too but Villa is better. read more

I went to there for dinner of two. I order 6 bake clams they came to the table one clam shell ONLY no clam inside. Made with SOGGY WHITE BREAD. Sent it back . told owner and her son about the food .they didn't give a shit about the loyal customer . the owner wife and Don was so NASTY I would never come back to the pizza store .. IF YOU WANT TO CALL THAT . I feed my dogs better food I was served on 3/7/25 @7pm . $13.00 for 6 bake clams . over prices. TO EVERYONE READING THIS POST STAY FARAWAY. SERVICE AND FOOD SUCKS.. NEXT CALL TO THE BOARD OF HEALTH DIRTY INSIDE STAFF NOT CLEAN PLACE TO EAT.. MORE POST TO FOLLOW.!!!!!!!!! read more

My wife and I ordered a meatball pizza and a ham and cheese calzone. The pizza was very good although the crust was somewhat hard for my liking - I actually wanted it to be more breadlike - but it had the consistency of a really good breadstick! The meatballs were very flavorful and melted in my mouth - The sauce was nice and had a deep and rich fresh tomato flavor. Overall a very good NY Style Pizza - The ham and cheese calzone was baked to perfection - Check out the cheese pull in my pic below - absolutely incredible. I highly recommend Villa Monte to everyone that is blessed to live close enough to Old Bethpage My wife and I did a video review of our experience and you are welcome to view it by clicking on the link below! https://youtu.be/mMgio0y0ufQ read more

See all

Ordered delivery: cesar salad had no dressing, asked for plates and silverware none provided, no parmesan included. When i called for dressing they said it would be right out. It took over half hour and we were finished eating and had to leave. I called and asked the manager for a refund on the salad. He said he would refund only the dressing. Imagine loosing the cost of some lettuce, instead losing a customer and others I am sharing this with. read more

This pizza is amazing just as good as Brooklyn pizza I had a few days before and cheaper Great place aesthetically as well truly Italian 10/10 read more

What I love about this place is that it's one of the few authentic Italian Pizzerias left in NY. It's very rare now that one finds a real Italian pizza spot. I also love that one gets greeted in Italian. The pizza and food here is amazing and you can tell it's cooked with love. Definitely recommend this place if you are in Long Island and want tasty Italian Food. read more

Best selection of pizza in town. Large fresh home made portions Always our top choice for Italian food. Reminder: closed on Sunday's read more

They have a very large selection of slices in all sorts of combinations - its difficult to select just a few (I suppose this also makes one want to return). Pizza is very good and the toppings are fresh. Prices are reasonable. Ample seating area. read more

Villa Monte - Olive & Tomatoes slice - Pizza Near Me - Old Bethpage, New York

See all

Had a Veg Slice. $6.50 for a soggy...pizza with no taste... Yes, the pizza was loaded with vegetables... but 70% was undercooked eggplant... had better veg pizzq many many places... read more