Tom's Market has the best macaroni salad, potato salad, and sandwiches in this area. We travel…read morefrom Montgomery because it is just that good. The service is excellent. I place orders by phone and they are always ready on time and exactly as ordered. The catering experience is the same. We have been to several events they catered and the food and service is always very good.

A small deli on cozy corner of the street. All basics at fair prices. Got an Italian combo and a…read morepasta salad, the sandwich was good and plenty of meat, unlike the salad sandwiches elsewhere . The guy behind made it perfectly and just right, since I had stuff removed and added. As for the pasta salad it was good, nothing moving the needle forward in taste. Still a great to go lunch on the move.

This place is the closest to a NYC bacon egg and cheese. Delicious. They also have friendly staff.read more

Clown show being run by basically a child at the front, staff took zero action to make the food…read moreupon ordering, and the place is not clean making me think there's hygiene/food hazards. Go elsewhere.

Fresh, best quality meats and roll. Service with a smile and generous portions, all at a fair…read moreprice. Place is clean and coffee was hot and tasted great.

I tried to get a roast beef on a roll and side of macroni salad at Ambers Sub Shop. They were…read morehaving electrical problems, they couldn't make a sandwich. So, I went down the street to Toms Market and got it. Cost $11.95, It was delicious. Two days later I wanted the same thing so I went to Ambers Subs. I got the EXACT same thing, same size that I bought at Toms Market. Except Ambers charged me $17.66, The counter man keep pusing to buy sodas or chips. I am very dishearten.

Had a great chopped cheese off the menu. The man behind the deli counter was AWESOME!read more

All the ingredients are super fresh and clean. Perfect to come here for lunch and feel ready to…read morecontinue on the day. The owner is super nice and helped us with recommendations! We will def be back

Holy burger is tasty. I enjoy ordering food from here sometimes. I really like their spicy chicken…read moresandwich.

Service here was very nice and patient since first time trying them and did not know what to try…read more Got say they have decent menu and like ice cream cooler and the soda coolers since they a larger variety of choice. The double onion holy burger was delicious, definitely fresh and meaty, sort of remind me of a five guys burger but way less greasy. For spicy chicken juicy chicken and had a lot heat, which is great since most places have spicy chicken but it's muted, not here it's powerful. For the spiced fries, great and not too salty.

Best subs in the Middletown/slate hill area if you ask me! The bread is always fresh, and they…read moreoverload the sandwich with fresh boards head meats. They load the sandwiches so much we usually have to take off some of the meat in order to eat it. You can literally make a 2nd sandwich out of all the meat they put on one sub. The sandwiches are affordable, not expensive and definitely worth the price. I always try to call ahead and order because they are so busy. The sandwiches are always ready when I get there though and I don't have to wait at all.

New to the area and was unable to find a new 'go to' deli. Checked out yelp and this place was…read morethe closest to me that was open on a Sunday afternoon. I decided to take a ride w my moving buddy. GPS says we are getting closer but all we see is a gas station. Wait, looking closer...the deli is in the station..expectations drop. Pull into parking space, see 'live bait' sign and wonder if we dare go in. Squishy deli area but decent selection of sandwiches so we order. I got the chicken cordon bleu on a roll and my friend got a grilled chicken bacon ranch type combo. The staff while not talkative was pleasant. Service was quick. Prices were excellent and sammies were so good. Generous portions and both the grilled and fried chicken were hot, fresh, and juicy. The rolls nice and fresh That was 6 months ago. Since then we've also had the ruben, godfather (roast beef and provolone on garlic bread), and countless Boars Head cold cut creations. Yummy Chef Salads and my mom always has me get her the tuna salad platter (makes 3 meals and she is not a light weight). Their potato and mac salads, like the tuna are made on site. Perfectly seasoned, not drowned in mayo and neither too nor too sweet. Only detractor is the horrible print menu. Things seem to be listed twice in 2 spots w 2 diff prices, and the breakfast section is pretty much one giant run on sentence with some numbers between the words. Frustrating if you want to order ahead.

Simply wonderful…read more This is the kind of place you could drive past a hundred times without realizing one of the best meals in the area is waiting inside. We ordered the chana curry and goat curry, and both were outstanding and deeply satisfying. The flavors were layered and beautifully balanced. You could taste the individual spices, but none competed for attention. To top it off, hot fresh naan. Halfway through our meal, the man behind the counter walked over with a bowl of butter chicken and said, "I brought this for you to try." It wasn't expected, and it wasn't a sales pitch. It just felt like the natural generosity of someone who takes real pride in feeding people. That small gesture told us as much about the restaurant as the food itself. And, it was also delicious - creamy and rich and fragrant. I write this with a full belly! I hesitate to call it a hidden gem because hidden places deserve to be found. If you love remarkable curries made by people who truly care about what they're serving, go. Then bring someone else back with you.

First time trying here, really appreciate a fully pictured menu so you know exactly what your…read moregetting. Beside that service was friendly and fast. As for the food, the fried chicken was good, very crispy and well seasoned. As for the kabobs, tender,juicy, and flavorful. Rice was alright, little under seasoned. The salad on the side was great. This place reminds me of a nicer version of like Kennedy chicken.

The highball tavern is a local bar and eatery. The food is amazing. The staff is wonderful. We go…read moreevery Friday night. Happy hour is Monday thru Friday from 4-6.

Today was my first visit, but as far as I'm concerned, I'm a regular! I feel like I discovered a…read moreculinary goldmine. From the second you step inside, you leave the world behind and enter into the mind, kitchen, and heart of the owner/operator. You can't judge a book by its cover, so don't be put off by the modest building he operates from. Dark roast coffee was was great! Biscotti?! Superb! The bread? Like angels dancing on my tongue. He prepared my lunch hero like assembling a work of art to be displayed in the Louvre. Stacked to high heaven with gourmet deli meat, I almost felt guilty ruining this spectacular sandwich with a bite. To call it a sandwich feels disrespectful. I can't wait to go back. Tomorrow can't come soon enough.

This is an absolute find!!! Highly recommend, food is freshly made and presented beautifully- you…read morecan tell he enjoys cooking and is proud of his food. Pastries are wonderful, chocolate croissant was crisp on outside and soft and buttery inside with just the right amount of chocolate. Call ahead, unless you are prepared to wait.

The only thing I dislike are the prices. I return because my subs consistently taste good, and the…read moreplace isn't dirty like Subway nor do I have to check my order for errors before I leave like I do at Quickchek. At most sandwich places I don't get fancy with my orders because I can't always trust they'll follow the directions, but I've never had that issue with Jersey Mike's. What I order is what I get every time. The receipt makes my heart sink but I always end up coming back.

I frequent the Middletown NY location often enough that one or two employees might recognize me and…read moreare aware that I may ask a person to change gloves if I notice something I feel unhealthy. There is one girl who works on the meat slicer. I wish I would have walked out when I notice her because she is a sly one. She stood in front of me picking at the corner of the refrigerated meat counter then rubbed her pointer and thumb together before stepping forward to get bread to make my sandwich; never changing her gloves!!! SHE LOOKED ME DEAD IN THE EYES WHEN DOING THIS!!! My brain didn't compute it at that moment because it was blatantly done in my face and normally I'm watching for handling money and not changing gloves. My mind was somewhere else even though I was looking directly at her at the time. That was on Saturday, August 29, 2026. Today, August 30. 2026 Sunday, I am well rested and in hindsight it sickens me to know that a sly, slick and wicked person is working at Jersey Mikes in Middletown NY. It's unfortunate because the sandwiches are usually well made. Except when someone decides to SWEEP the floor during food preparation. I wish I was thinking in the moment because I certainly would have spoken OUT LOUD about seeing what she was doing. THE REASON I AM WRITING THIS REVIEW IS ME SCREAMING THAT. I SAW YOU AND THE THINGS YOU DO ARE NOT INVISIBLE. BECAUSE OF YOUR ACTIONS I WILL NOT BUY JERSEY MIKE'S SANDWICHES AGAIN. FYI: It's entirely warranted to not want to get unwell by mishandled food. If a employee takes offence to that chain of thought perhaps they should find another job. It's unlawful to intentionally mishandle food sold to the public.