A small deli on cozy corner of the street. All basics at fair prices. Got an Italian combo and a…read morepasta salad, the sandwich was good and plenty of meat, unlike the salad sandwiches elsewhere . The guy behind made it perfectly and just right, since I had stuff removed and added. As for the pasta salad it was good, nothing moving the needle forward in taste. Still a great to go lunch on the move.

Sandwiches are always great! and the Prices is real good. Tom works everyday running the place…read morealone, He's a good guy.

Adriana was such a helpful person…read more We were two ladies not sure what to eat and she recommended food for us and made us feel so Welcomed! The food is great and the service was great! I highly recommend this place for the food and the service and I came all the way up here from NJ for their Gyros Thanks Adriana!

Grilled spicy chicken cutlet on whole wheat wrap was delicious! Go early as they get crowded. The…read morevarious sandwiches are on point!

Love this new location coming from the owner of Mr. croissant. It's a new and fresh concept in…read moreMiddletown and we now have a beautiful spot in town to get a delicious sandwich and enjoy some wine. Love the self-pour station for the wine and service was excellent as well. Prices reasonable for the quality of the ingredients used. Will be back!

I love the ambiance, it's classy and the I love the Italian offerings of cola, sparkling juices and…read morecold fruit/tea drinks and of course the wines and beer. There's also Italian pasta and other Italian items for sale which are worth trying. The service from the staff was excellent and attentive. The best part was the freshness of the sandwhich--house made bread, fresh hand cut meat and cheeses. Highly recommend this eatery!

All the ingredients are super fresh and clean. Perfect to come here for lunch and feel ready to…read morecontinue on the day. The owner is super nice and helped us with recommendations! We will def be back

Food was excellent and server Justin was very attentive to customers needs. Would recommend.read more

First time here and we really enjoyed the food. The burger was really good. The fries are amazing…read more Be cautious with the chicken sandwich. If you order the non spicy, the chicken still had a mild spice to it. The sandwich was still great though. The business owner/ employees are very professional and friendly. The interior is clean and has plenty of space if you want to dine in.

The food was decent, but incredibly overpriced. The soda included with the combo is a tiny little…read moremini can. Highly recommend the fries-they were the highlight

Best subs in the Middletown/slate hill area if you ask me! The bread is always fresh, and they…read moreoverload the sandwich with fresh boards head meats. They load the sandwiches so much we usually have to take off some of the meat in order to eat it. You can literally make a 2nd sandwich out of all the meat they put on one sub. The sandwiches are affordable, not expensive and definitely worth the price. I always try to call ahead and order because they are so busy. The sandwiches are always ready when I get there though and I don't have to wait at all.

New to the area and was unable to find a new 'go to' deli. Checked out yelp and this place was…read morethe closest to me that was open on a Sunday afternoon. I decided to take a ride w my moving buddy. GPS says we are getting closer but all we see is a gas station. Wait, looking closer...the deli is in the station..expectations drop. Pull into parking space, see 'live bait' sign and wonder if we dare go in. Squishy deli area but decent selection of sandwiches so we order. I got the chicken cordon bleu on a roll and my friend got a grilled chicken bacon ranch type combo. The staff while not talkative was pleasant. Service was quick. Prices were excellent and sammies were so good. Generous portions and both the grilled and fried chicken were hot, fresh, and juicy. The rolls nice and fresh That was 6 months ago. Since then we've also had the ruben, godfather (roast beef and provolone on garlic bread), and countless Boars Head cold cut creations. Yummy Chef Salads and my mom always has me get her the tuna salad platter (makes 3 meals and she is not a light weight). Their potato and mac salads, like the tuna are made on site. Perfectly seasoned, not drowned in mayo and neither too nor too sweet. Only detractor is the horrible print menu. Things seem to be listed twice in 2 spots w 2 diff prices, and the breakfast section is pretty much one giant run on sentence with some numbers between the words. Frustrating if you want to order ahead.

First time trying here, really appreciate a fully pictured menu so you know exactly what your…read moregetting. Beside that service was friendly and fast. As for the food, the fried chicken was good, very crispy and well seasoned. As for the kabobs, tender,juicy, and flavorful. Rice was alright, little under seasoned. The salad on the side was great. This place reminds me of a nicer version of like Kennedy chicken.

First time trying them. Establishment is nice and clean, including the bathroom. I got the lamb…read moretikka wrap combo. It was really good. The fries were nice and fresh, the seasoned kind, a little spicy. The lamb also has a kick to it and the wrap was very generously filled. I also got the mango lassi which was very tasty. Definitely will come back.

The highball tavern is a local bar and eatery. The food is amazing. The staff is wonderful. We go…read moreevery Friday night. Happy hour is Monday thru Friday from 4-6.

I am so happy that my family and I came here and checked this cute spot out. I fell in love with…read morethe owners' homemade chocolate chip cookies. I had to try his lunch, and my mother and I decided to try the quiche with a side salad. You can taste it that it was all homemade and fresh, and the salad tasted as if it was from the farm. I absolutely loved it all. The prices were amazing as well. The owner was very nice , down to earth and you can tell that he loved what he was doing. I would highly recommend coming here and checking it out. You will love it as well.

The rotisserie chicken that I ordered for myself and two family members was incredible. And the…read morepotatoes, magnificent. The service was wonderful and walking into the deli, the pleasant food smell was overwhelmingly wonderful!

The only thing I dislike are the prices. I return because my subs consistently taste good, and the…read moreplace isn't dirty like Subway nor do I have to check my order for errors before I leave like I do at Quickchek. At most sandwich places I don't get fancy with my orders because I can't always trust they'll follow the directions, but I've never had that issue with Jersey Mike's. What I order is what I get every time. The receipt makes my heart sink but I always end up coming back.

This was my first time at a Jersey Mike's Sub and I have to say, I really enjoyed the subs here. I…read moreordered a very basic sandwich ham, cheese, and turkey on a plain sub with mayo and that was it. I have to say that I am not a fan of oversized sandwiches. The sub here was perfect for lunch without leaving me feeling like I over ate and it just hit the spot. I am definitely come here again for lunch when I am in the area