This is hands down my favorite pizza place! The pizza is always amazing--perfect crust and great flavor. The garlic bread is just as incredible... honestly some of the best I've ever had. You can tell they use high-quality ingredients, which makes such a difference. And now that they accept credit cards, it's even more convenient to stop in and grab our favorites. Highly recommend--this place never disappoints! read more

Lalli's Pizza - Sausage, onion and cheese pizza. Pepperoni and cheese pizza Cheese pizza Garlic bread - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Lalli's is the best pizza in town! The crust is great, and great ratios of cheese to sauce to toppings. We get sausage, giardiniera, and mushroom pizza and it is SO good! They are a Tosa staple and our go-to. We typically do pick up and they always give an accurate estimate of timing and it's ready every single time when we show up to pick up. They are to-go only and do not offer dine-in. The payment process is easy, but I think they only allow cash if you choose delivery. read more

Get the garlic rub on the crust it is delicious!!! Love this crust has some depth and not paper thin. Delicious ingredients. Wish there was maybe a little more but overall we order often read more

So far - the BEST pizza in Tosa! We had passed it many times but never ordered there, but finally decided to call in dinner. After a large wood fire pizza and an order of some of the best garlic bread we have ever had, we are sold!! We ordered on a Friday night and pick up was 30 minutes. Got there almost right on the 30 minute mark and they had just got it out of the oven! I'm not sure if they even offer dine in, as the door we went in was just for carry out. No matter what, we will be going back asap!! read more

It's a to go for place no sit down eating smell amazing the food was good I had the meatball sandwich and fries I would definitely return just remember to add cheese to your sandwich cause they don't automatically add cheese to your meatball sub read more

Lalli's Pizza - Ordering meatball sub on garlic bread - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

See all

The actual pizza is very good to excellent,however I have not been able to get a delivery,despite living within their posted delivery area.Very disappointing,have enjoyed their product,going back to their Center Street location. read more

Once again great. Our go-to in Tosa. Sausage is excellent fresh hand pinched. Delicious. Nice balance of thin and thick crust; crunchy and chewy. With enough heft to be more filling than more traditional Milwaukee style pizza. read more

Lalli's Pizza - Large Sausage and Pepperoni extra cheese. - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

This is our go-to pizzaria in the midtown-Tosa area. They've been in business for years and have a great reputation in the neighborhood. There's no indoor seating, but if you like, you can have your pizza at outdoor tables on North Avenue or next door at Club Tap and enjoy a drink or two with your meal. Their pizzas are delicious with ample toppings, and nice thin or hand tossed crusts and are reasonably priced. read more

pizza was very good! cute little hole in the wall with friendly service! def would go back!

Truly outstanding pizza. Hand tossed crust is perfection and the Italian sausage is delicious! Great sauce and generous toppings. Maybe the best pizza in Milwaukee area! read more

We were pleasantly surprised with Lalli's. We have lived in Tosa for years and always drove past but only recently thought to try it out. We are so happy we did! They have coupons on their website for a few bucks off and their pricing is comparable to more authentic pizza places. We got a large 1/2 pepperoni 1/2 sausage (total of 1 topping which not all places do) and the sausage was the showstopper. We ordered takeout and the order was ready in the estimated time and nice and hot. The leftovers were awesome in our air fryer. True test of pizza. We can't wait to go back and try more! read more

See all

Lalli's is a community establishment - and I see why! The thin crust pizza is classic. It feels like a nostalgic slice of my childhood - simple and delicious. Great price too. I also love their salad - fresh, crunchy and bright. read more

Pizza was delicious and the employees were very nice. It was a change for me on how you dine in, but it works. Don't change it if it's not broken. Meet some new people and threw a round of darts while I waited for my food. Friendly place and they serve spotted cow on tap. read more

The pizza is very good and reasonably priced. The staff is super nice and respectful. The pick up place is a nice set up and easy in and out

We moved from Tosa a couple of years ago and Lallis is one of the things I miss the most. I love the crust, chewy without being like bread. The sauce has a great flavor. I'm happy they started taking credit cards. This is our Wednesday before Thanksgiving tradition. The only disappointment this year was that they messed up the toppings on one of our pies which was supposed to be vegetarian. They put meat on the whole thing. I know they're having staffing issues so I'll let this go read more

BIG NEWS They now except CREDIT CARDS NOW yea!! Went twice this past month pizza was Great! On spot They offer hand tossed or thin Both are good Stop in on the way home like me! read more

I started grabbing za to go prior to COVID-19 and also during. Prior to, I enjoyed the ease of ordering and the pick-up method which was always a breeze for me. The pizza, itself, was tasty--a great not-too-thick crust with ample flavor and toppings (my go-to is typically SMO, FYI). Staff was always friendly and attentive. During COVID, the curbside/pick-up ordering process has been very smooth, with similar order and prep times. As for the pick-up, I greatly appreciate their approach to ensuring both their safety and that of their customers. I never thought I'd be writing a review that incorporates something like COVID but, it's our reality and also the reality that some businesses are handling this with more care and attention than others. Additionally, this is a local business that remains open during 'these times' so it's nice to show them support. Thank you, Lalli's! read more

Excellent hot fresh pizza. We had a free pizza as the last delivery was in error. Pizza was still delicious but not what we ordered. Restaurant was more than gracious to offer a free pizza that was originally ordered! Love this gem in our neighborhood. read more

WOW- this Pizza was delicious. We ordered the smallest one (it was just 2 of us) and it could have easily fed 3-4 people. Half "hawaiian" and half sausage, black olives and mushrooms. We also ordered a salad (one size) that we shared and also could have easily fed 3-4 people. I will 100% be coming back. read more

Lalli's is delicious and consistent. They are one of the few pizza places that deliver near me and aren't a chain, and I am glad that they do. Only have had the pizza and garlic bread but it's definitely a great place to stop. read more

Best thin crust pizza ever! Best pizza in Wauwatosa for sure. Slow at busy times. Best to order in house and wait on site. Have hamburger available which is rare but my fave topping . Don't worry about ambience it's the food! read more

Taken from One Bite App review by Tony the "Pie Guy" One of the tastier sauces I've had recently. Cheese was also packed with flavor. The crust was cooked almost to perfection with the right balance of crisp and thickness. Sausage and pepperoni was also of quality. One of the best spots in Tosa. 8.5/10 read more

Lalli's Pizza - Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Used to LOve this place! Lately pizza is soggy, mushroom taste old and unwashed. Plus the girl Courtney who u have answering the phone and taking orders just lost you business. After never picking up the phone from being on hold, i had to call back after 4 min she Couldnt get that I wanted a 1/2 and 1/2 pizza. Literally keep say "ok wait so on the whole pizza what do u want?????" Literally 5 times I told her 1/2 pep 1/2 saug. So when it takes 8 min to order a pizza cause you staff isnt trained, We go elsewhere.. Update: Jan 1st 2019 Made the mistake if going tonight. The pictures below show that the cheese is WAY below the crust. $20 for a 1 topping large pizza and they put cheese of a Medium on it. They have kids working every post, they answer the phone "Hello please hold and we waited 7 min for them to come back on the phone to tKe our order. I expected it to be slammed, nope not busy at all and when I got there they had messed up a ladies order. This place has gone down hill, Balisteris from NOW ON!! read more

See all

We had pizza (cheese and sausage& onion), cheese bread and a Sicilian salad. The pizza was hit and delicious. Cheesy bread was gooey and flavorful. The salad was very fresh and included butter bread and a very tasty dressing. We ordered pick up and the order was ready when I arrived. Definitely a winner in Super Bowl Sunday. read more

Surprise! Tasty crisp pizza. I was expecting a soggy mess for onions/mushroom pizza this turned out well cooked with no floppy ness at the tip/center. Sauce is sweet. Great weather for eating outside on the Sidewalk patio. Most of the people were call in orders for pickup. They looked very busy that's always good. Food 4 Amb 3 Service 4 Location 4 Value 3 66/2014 read more

Lalli's Pizza - Brian About to Dig in what a treat! Onion and shroom - Pizza Near Me - Milwaukee, Wisconsin

Lalli's has the best pizza in my area. My issue is my address shows up on their delivery map, but they won't deliver because it's a block away from their area. I tried to compromise with them but they said their older driver won't allow me to deliver to the next corner for delivery and give me a call. I'm happy to pay in advance, tip well and make the two second walk. I ended up picking up last week and had to wait around 45 minutes because they just put my order in after I was there and had arrived on time to pickup. I wouldn't make a stink normally, but my address is clearly shown on their website. I LOVE THIS pizza and am bummed that we need to get delivery elsewhere. read more

Delicious pizza, the best in Tosa, and it's always ready when promised and staff is super friendly!

Another awesome experience last night. Every Saturday is my fiancé's "cheat night" so once again we decided on Lalli's Pizza. It was made perfectly. It's been a couple of times when we ordered extra cheese, but it didn't seem like there was enough. For the BEST experience grab a pizza on the weekend. That's where I find it too be perfect. Since I can't order green olives I just wait for the pizza to get here/or until we pick it up and get home then I add my own olives. They do have black olives, but I'm the weirdo that likes the green ones on my pizza. lol. 5 stars again!!!! read more

They used to be good. I ordered a pizza and salad on 9/8/23. The pizza was not baked all the way. The crust was doughy. I also ordered a big salad which was obviously prepared hours earlier. The lettuce was rubbery and turning brown at the edges. Both my girlfriend and I felt sick perhaps one hour after eating. read more

Picked up pizza to go from this spot a few months back. The pizza was ready on time and still warm, great news for takeout pizza! Not only did we enjoy it hot, but it was delicious. The cheese almost melted in our mouth, the sauce was the perfect consistency, and the toppings added some pizzazz. Definitely found a new favorite local pizza spot and looking forward to my next order from Lalli's Pizza! read more

We ordered a sausage and mushroom pizza for pickup on a Friday night. Pizza was ready right on time. This is the first time we have tried this restaurant. It was very good. Crust is excellent. Sausage had great flavor. Employees were very friendly. read more

I love the pizza from this place! have to stop in every time I'm back in town. Their sausage, cheese and onion pizza with the garlic butter crust is to die for! read more

Awesome pizza! Tony and the crew know how to do it right. Tons of cheese. Very generous toppings. Best sausage in Milwaukee. The overall rating is way too low for how good this place is. read more

I live in the Pasadena neighborhood , where Lalli's is located; for over 25 years. We order there about once every 2 months and it has been a disaster for the last couple of years - wrong orders, under cooked, employees who just didn't care. I was ready to give up but ordered tonight (Wed) and it was a great experience. I know they are short employees but order taker over the phone was pleasant and double checked the order. Pizza had the correct ingredients and was cooked to perfection! Due to staff shortages they have limited their menu- my suggestion is keep the limited menu and continue to make a great pizza, efficiently! read more

Typically when u order food for delivery it gets delivered. Not at Lallis ... ordered a pizza and some garlic bread over 2 hours ago ... told it was would be a little over an hour ... took over 2 ... if they are that busy they should tell you ... and when are they going to switch to boxes in bad weather read more

Great people. The owners very friendly and very understanding. able to compromise on needs and able to help guide through the menu. Seriously recommend this place. The inside is amazing and just the entire atmosphere! read more

Lalli's is definitely in my Top 5 for Milwaukee pizza. If you have not yet ordered and live anywhere nearby, stop reading this review and focus on their menu instead. Prepare yourself for dinner now. Other things to know: **Toppings - simplicity defined. Do not expect fancy-dancy offerings. **Quoted pick-up times are often longer than actual. I like this, because it is less time I need to wait before ripping open the old-school paper bag and devouring everything in sight. **Cash only. read more

I ordered a extra thick pizza with five toppings. They don't spare the toppings at all. One piece and I was already full. Great pizza!

Wow! I had Lalli's for the first time last night (Carry-out) and it was incredible. I had the cheese pizza with sausage. The ingredients tasted super fresh and it was the perfect crust, sauce, cheese balance. I think I would be happy to have Lalli's for the rest of my life and only wished I had stopped in sooner. Really fabulous pizza and the order was made quickly too! read more

I normally don't write reviews but I finally got a chance to try Lalli's and I can say it most definitely lived up to the hype. I don't usually order pizza out but this hit the spot in all the right areas -- sauce, freshness of ingredients, crust, cheese, and customer service. I will be ordering again without a doubt! read more