We absolutely love this place. Great prepared foods, amazing steak cuts & pork chop cuts. Service…read moreis wonderful & since they've remodeled the inside is great. Lots of Italian grocery selections inside toi (pasta, coffee, biscotti, as well as great cheese, soppressata, etc). This last time hubby picked up a bone in rib eye & dill potato salad. Wonderful cut (& he cooked it perfectly too) & tge potato salad was creamy and delicious. Highly recommend! It's small inside & busy in the summer months but sooooo worth it!

The staff at Midshore is the absolute best. They all make you feel the vibe of a mom and pop store…read morein your home town. Love going in every week to grab fresh meats and chat with everyone. Highly recommend!!

Lennys always has wonderful cuts of meat, prepared food, & a great staff. The store is very nice…read moreinside. Got a beautiful cowboy cut porterhouse. 2.5" thick! Hubby cooked it to perfection.

I haven't been to Lenny's since I lived in Silverton prior to Sandy. I was amazed at the extension…read morehe added to the market! The food I enjoyed was gourmet. He turned it into a goldmine. I would love to hear the backstory.

I have been a customer since Mike reopened it. Sadly my health has deteriorated to the point where…read moreI can no longer get to the store, I REALLY miss it!

I love the meatloaf mix..better than any other I have tried. Also very tasty..chicken breasts,…read morechicken patties...I appreciate that I can irder in advance and it is ready for pickup the following business morning! No suoermarkets to contend with, and I know everything is fresh. SHOP LOCAL!!

Joe and family are super people. They treat you right. Great recommendations for steaksread more

Wonderful experience! Cooked up 2 ribeye steaks for the wife and kids. Our night started with some…read morebaked potatoes that were crispy on the outside yet creamy and exciting on the inside. The ribeye had excellent marbling, you can see the dedication that this butcher shop puts into their craft. (I can also recommend the pork chops *my favorite) the service inside is amazing, couldn't find nicer people. The store is amazing. highly recommend, great family. -Tom Kim, Five out of Five.

I came here the first time at Christmas to buy my sons Christmas gift of meat lol I bought 300$…read moreworth of assorted cuts and every last one was top quality. The fresh base Italian sausages are the best I've ever eaten in my life. They fresh ground 90/10 beef and fresh cut my steaks. The prices are better than anyone this is my new go to place. I also bought venison but they have a great assortment of game meats. Family owned and local need I say more

Great mom and pop butcher. Family owned and great people. Good butchers are fading away but this…read moreplace was a nice find. Close to the shop rite. The meats look nice and the prices were really good for a butcher. I was eyeing that tomahawk rib eye I'm definitely gunna get that in the summertime to grill. The make their own in house sausage which looked fabulous. I ordered a couple of pounds for my Sunday gravy. And they also grind up burger meat for u for a nice price. And you can also mix meats to grind. I will be coming here for some good meats. The staff there was very friendly and helpful.

Unbelievable find!!!! Seafood so fresh…read moreSpotless store Good prices Employees were so helpful and Friendly Will for sure be back

We were visiting the shore and had the inclination to make our first seafood boil. Thankfully we…read morefound Ortley Seafood Market. The fish was incredibly fresh and the pricing was very reasonable. We tried to ask some qs, but didn't get a lot of help. That being said, it was a Saturday morning and very busy so we won't fault them for that. I'm sure that's not the case on a normal day. Definitely head to Ortley if you're in need of some very fresh fish!

Food is always fresh & delicious. I ve never had anything there that that wasn't awesome. Service…read moreis pretty good, & the store is very clean & easy to shop. Help is courteous It's a winner all the way!

Love Lenny's in Toms River - was down in Spring Lake so I stopped the new Manasquan spot... they…read morenever disappoint! $11.95 and that's a half... I don't do veg on my sandwiches & I didn't ask for extra meat... that's standard Lenny's! All in with a bag of chips & side of pasta salad $21 and change... plus - the staff is awesome! Glad I skipped the place 2 doors down and went to the new Lenny's location!

If you have the opportunity to have the seafood tower, take full advantage. It's excellent compared…read moreto other seafood restaurants at the Jersey Shore. My previous favorite was at Rooneys in Lonf Branch but Runners hit the mark really high. I give them top honors at the Jersey Shore.

Clams are ridiculously small with almost no clam.. Guest bought 4 dozen complete waste of money.read more

Amazing. Amazing quality of meat and a large variety of choices. Love this place and recommend to…read moreall my friends to go and support. Go support this amazing veteran owned market.

Nothing but top quality products available. Matt, Michelle and the staff go above and beyond to…read moreprovide amazing service and they are a great addition to our town. Well worth patronizing this veteran owned local family business.

If you're looking for good pizza, look no further. The first time I ordered from here I just got…read morepizza and was not disappointed. I ordered from here tonight, and this time I got a personal pie and tortellini alfredo. When I ordered for pick up, the girl said it would be an hour, but then she called back and said it would twenty minutes. The service in the restaurant was exceptional. The pizza was once again the star of the show. The tortellini itself was good, but the alfredo sauce was somewhat disappointing. It was a bit watered down, and lacked flavor. It wasn't bad, just wasn't good enough to order again. The portions were large and they even gave a side of bread which was absolutely delicious. You could eat the bread without anything, and they gave us a large piece which was very generous. I would come back here again! They have indoor and outdoor seating and it's casual but charming.

Great place good food good service. The owners are good guys running two different places,…read morecastaways and Lennys Pizza kudos to the server page who always goes out of her way to make the experience exactly what you would want inside is nice. They're moving to a new location soon which will be great. I'm sure they do it upright.