I've been going to the nearby Stop and Shop for years but this is the first time I had ever stopped for pizza. I got one of their specials. Two slices with bacon and a soda for $8.95. Quite a good deal. The pizza was served quickly and hot. Extremely tasty. The rest of the menu looked intriguing so I will probably be back! read more

Wanted to have a quick lunch and I needed to try their good looking pizza instead. I ordered plain whole pie Large and I needed to take home leftover half. The pizza was actually great and I needed to try after kind of pizza and/or food next time. I will order next time cook a little more to brown chard a bit. Good price and they're very friendly!!! read more

See all

I believe Legends has the best Hot Oil pizza in the area. I love it and I've tasted all the other pizza joints in CT.

The best part about this pizza slice was that it was crispy. Unfortunately, overall, it was bland; precooked crumbled up sausage isn't for me, it lacks flavor. Moreover, I had to add oregano and parmesan cheese to wake it up a bit. My suggestions are these; their dough needs salt, and the sauce needs garlic, basil, oregano and salt. Also, this pizza could benefit from using raw Perri sausage. That's a review. read more

Ordered some takeout.. broccoli & sausage. Place isn't too much of an eye catcher Except this pizza is absolutely phenomenal and the best pizza I've had in ct in a long long time. Ingredients are high quality Service was prompt and friendly My belly is ... happy ... :) Will be BACK!!! Absolutely!! I wrote this review after TWO bites it was so good... :) read more

Legends Pizzeria - Broccoli and sausage Small Pizza (12") - Pizza Near Me - Shelton, Connecticut

These guys knock it out of the park every single time. Now matter what you order. 12 years for me! How do they do it??? You won't find better takeout ANYWHERE IN SHELTON OR STRATFORD. Period! ​ read more

Ordered a pizza with peppers, onion and garlic. Assumed the garlic would be roasted because who the hell chomps on raw garlic? I could only eat one slice it was so bitter and inedible and the garlic was tiny and everywhere so couldn't take it off. . Gave an extra star because my friend's meat lovers was very good apparently. I'm hungry though because I thre mine away. Booo read more

The food is absolutely incredible. My family and I have had a favorite Pizza Restaurant for over 10 years, but now that we found Legends, I think we'll be making a switch. read more

We do take out from here frequently. Really good thin crust pizzas, fresh salads and super friendly staff, reasonable prices.

Friday is our pizza night we started ordering delivery from Legends ...every other week we switch from Sicilian pizza to their thin crust that is divine..... If you're looking for a new place to get your pizza from Legends is our newfound favorite !!!!!! read more

Souvlaki was dry. Horrible Fries good Salad was best part. Probably won't go again read more

When did pizza delivery start taking 90 minutes, 3 calls and an attitude when there is frustration. 2023 service with a smile! Sign of the times - if you cannot accommodate an order in a timely fashion develop a system that says as such. read more

What's not to love about this place; it was amazing. We were on vacation and ordered food twice while in town, it was that good. The pizza sauce is home made, dough cooked to perfection and you can watch them make it. Simply the best New York style pizza I've had. Staff was friendly, food delivered quickly, very clean, and nice seating. When in town, I will certainly be back and recommend it to anyone traveling in the area. read more

LEGEND My family and I have probably eaten takeout from here hundreds of times, and I'm not exaggerating. I like the buffalo & bbq wraps and the cobb salads the most. In the cobb salad they don't skimp on the chicken which is refreshing. Highly suggest trying the pasta and mozzarella sticks too. It's one of the rare places that has pizza on the menu where I opt to get something else. read more

I called today at 4:45PM and ordered a pizza and a chicken salad to be delivered. At 5:45PM I called back to ask how much longer for my delivery. the girl at the counter said the deliveries (plural) are going out now. I asked is my order one of the ones going out? she confirmed my address and stated yes it would be 45 minutes to an hour. i said what were you doing the first hour? she said other deliveries. I said, don't you think you should have told me when I placed the order it would be 2 hours, she giggled and said that would turn people away. I said you don't think this won't turn people away. I asked is our food even going to be hot she laughed again (now I am pissed) and she says I don't know. i told her if it isn't I am calling you back for a refund. DO NOT ASK FOR DELIVERY! And maybe someone older should be answering the phone to take the orders for delivery. This was ridiculous, my husband usually picks up the order but couldn't tonight. Time to find a new Pizza place in the area. read more

I work down the road and order out often for lunch. Legend's is always my go-to! The staff is always friendly, and the food never disappoints! read more

I feel bad rating this place so low because the staff were so nice but..the food was just not very good. This place was once terrific. They were Villa Pizza and man they knew how to make pizza. I guess they are under new ownership now. My dad and I stopped in and had some pizza. It was thick sliced where Villa's was thin styled and also the pizza was just not good. Had not much of a taste. There was virtually no atmosphere in here either. I think I was also so let down because the place that had been there formally was so very good. It was also a let down because even though they were new ownership we figured the pizza would still be the same. But it wasn't. I usually give places a second try but honestly I doubt I'd come back here again. Neither of us found it at all enjoyable. Not many customers either and so different from what we expected. It's a shame but they are off my go to pizza list. read more

Legends Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Shelton, Connecticut

Legends has good food. Great chef. The problem is they cannot get an order right. The person who took the order over the phone was totally incompetent. It took a long time to get her to say she understood what we wanted. Even put my husband on hold while she asked if we could have extra sauce on the side. Then he goes to pick it up and the request was totally ignored. Rather than making the order 'right' as a good business would have done. All he did was separate the pasta from the dinner which was already covered with the wrong sauce. Exceptionally poor customer service and although I had recommended others to come for the food, unless you want to eat in, and it's not a pleasant place to do that, it's a take out place with a couple tables. I'd advise you to find another take out place where they have a competent person to take your order and someone with a basic knowledge of of good customer service. Not worth the drive or effort. read more

Order is for delivery. I cannot speak to the location specific information. Order was done via GrubHub which is my default when ordering delivery. I prefer to sending ordering this way to ensure there is no confusion over the phone. Delivery timeframe: grubhub estimated 40-50 minutes for delivery and the food came in that general timeframe. The food arrived hot and as specifically order. Food Quality: I ordered a pizza and wrap. The pizza was far better than I expected. It is a thinner crust pizza but it had lots of flavor and was cooked to my liking. The wrap was average and though I wouldn't order that specific one again, I would probably order another in the future. Overall - I would recommend Legends after my first experience... read more

Truly Legendary. A sight to behold. A diamond in the rough, one of my favorite pizza pie palaces in all of Connecticut. Need I say more?

I've never ordered from legends the engine down but the pizza place I usually go to, I don't like their grinders So I was trying to find a place that has a really good grinder so I thought legends well they're not out to a good start I ordered the chicken Parm grinder extra sauce it barely has any sauce and I ordered The fried mozzarella with, again, I asked for extra sauce and I didn't get it and I told them to call me when they got here which they didn't so apparently they have this website but they don't look at it. Not happy ! won't order from them again. I sure hope they didn't charge me for extra ! Already $30.00 ...it's not worth it! read more

Legends is always fresh and delicious. Staff is genuinely nice and very accommodating. Only comment is I ordered the same wrap on two different occasions and tomatoe is not a listed ingredient. However, each time it had tomatoe on it. Thank goodness not allergic to it. read more

I like the pizza here but they really suck at delivery! This is not the first time I have had the below picture happen to me. Unfortunately when you order through a third party apps for delivery they use legends substandard delivery. Such a disappointment. Will probably stop ordering from here. read more

Legends Pizzeria - a pepperoni pizza in a box - Pizza Near Me - Shelton, Connecticut

I've ordered some food to go from here a couple of times. The food is pretty good, and the prices are reasonable. I most recently enjoyed their gyro sandwich with some excellent onion rings. read more

Been coming here for lunch regularly (once/twice a week) for two years and I've never had a single problem. 90% of the time I get slices to go and they are always delicious, can't say I've ever had a bad one. Try the margherita or the buffalo chicken slice! Not sure why this place doesn't having wonderful reviews to be honest, the whole family is so friendly and I will continue to go back time and time again. read more

The pizza LOOKED picture perfect but wow, just wow. Me and my husband BOTH agreed- it had absolutely no taste. We ordered a Sicilian half cheese half hot cherry peppers. They gave us all stems of the pepper (which is inedible). The crust literally had no taste. We ended up throwing the entire pizza out and making a frozen pizza, yes, it sucked that bad. The interior of the place is a dump. They don't have any desserts. I really try not to leave bad reviews but just don't waste your time, go to planet pizza or just go get a frozen pizza. read more

Legends Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Shelton, Connecticut

See all

So disappointed, I was craving some pizza so I ordered Legends Pizza for delivery for the first time. The pizza showed up an hour later and was cold and it was almost as if the pizza was sliding around in the back seat of the drivers car because the cheese along with the toppings had flew off part of the pizza and was all over the top and side of the box. Delivery doesn't do this place justice. Maybe eating at this place would create a better experience and maybe my two-star review would be bumped up much higher. Completely not worth it never ordering delivery from here again. read more

Disappointing, I ordered a meatball parmigiana grinder on garlic bread. The meatballs were all mashed up, there was very little cheese! Basically I had marinara sauce on a toasted roll. Needless to say I was disappointed. I don't recommend Legends, it wasn't "Legendary"! read more

Clams casino pizza was good. Would have like the garlic a little more roasted. Besides that, the taste was good and crust was good. The burger club was delicious. I would order from again. read more

I have ordered from Legends and have been disappointed each time. The first time I ordered a salad and I gave them 45 minutes. When I got there my salad wasn't ready! I had to wait another 15 minutes out of my 30 minute lunch to wait for them to make my salad that I ordered 45 minutes ago. Second time delivery on baked ziti, epic fail again. I make Ziti, you don't find blocks of unmixed ricotta in my Ziti and it's not dry either. The final time was lasagna. 1/2 inch thick slice that was basically baked to the pan, hardly any meat and it was bland. read more

I've seen a lot of mixed reviews about this place which made me reluctant but I'm so happy I went in! The management was so kind and everyone there was so friendly. They accommodated everything I needed. (It's also a family business which gives it a warmer feel that your average pizzeria). I went around lunchtime & it was super busy inside, I didn't know what to get but Mark took his time to cater to my needs to find the best dish for my lunch break - I decided to go with the east side chicken & a chicken salad. My best decision for the day. For an extra 75 Cents I substituted for garlic bread on my sandwich. Which paired super well with cheese, creamy vinegar and peppers. I'm very happy with this pizzeria, I would definitely recommend to others and I will definitely be visiting Again. read more

Legends Pizzeria - East Side Chicken Signature Grinder - Pizza Near Me - Shelton, Connecticut

See all

We loved this place when they first opened and frequented it. A month ago we ordered and it was disappointing. We chalked it up to a bad day and ordered again yesterday. It was worse. The chicken Parmesan was like dry leather. It tasted like it had been related from the previous day or early morning. It had no flavor and awful texture. I actually had to throw it out because it was inedible. We also had a Sicilian pie - also precious.y good, that this time was not. Dry, not enough sauce and cheese. I'm sorry to say we gave it two chances and won't order again. read more

I love this place. Their wraps are absolutely delicious and the best in the area. I moved to Shelton in 2014 and this is still my favorite spot to order from 6 years later. read more

This as been some of the best pizza in Shelton. Nice thin crust and good flavor. I called them directly and place the order, the yelp site did not aloud me to place the order to be delivered. But they delivered the pie on time. I will be back read more

I am very picky when it comes to my grinders. Legends Pizzeria makes delicious Grinders and my wife loves her salad.

This guy at the front counter was either super high on drugs or drunk. I'm a regular walk in customer and never received the disrespect from this place than I have before. I went to legends pizza around 7pm on 12/12/23. It Took between 20-25 to get my food. I ordered a small chicken bacon ranch pizza and noticed when it got to the table that something was off. Like not right. Halfway eating through the slice I realize there's no cheese. So I asked the guy who was behind the counter if there's usually cheese on the chicken bacon ranch. He responded saying yes and said , "this is a new pizza maker" and then walked to the back. This guy I was speaking to was either high on drugs or drunk. "This guy said that there was cheese on it and that he just looked at the camera. The pizza maker put the cheese on top of the toppings instead of the base". Now that's ridiculous. I used to be a pizza maker. I know how pizzas need to be prepared. I started looking for the cheese while this guy was talking to me and he responds, "don't do that". I'm looking for the cheese and there's nothing there. Fine. I stop eating the pizza. Still half of it left. I use the restroom and then walk out and this guy starts screaming saying, " one person complains and then another get the fuck out if the restaurant". I have worked customer service all my life and never have been treated like this or even I've never spoken to someone like that. I will never come back here because of the customer service that I received. read more

I ordered a large lasagna pizza and two water bottles to my hotel. When the driver arrived half an hour later, he had forgotten the water bottles and I had to wait another fifteen minutes to get them. Mistakes like these aren't the end of the world, but I'm hoping this isn't typical of them. The ricotta cheese on the pizza didn't look appetizing at all: it looked like the pizza had gone bad, even though it was a fresh pizza. Overall, the pizza tasted meh. The kindest thing my Italian girlfriend could say about it was "it's food," but she's pretty critical of American pizza in general. Delivery is alright, but for the money I'm paying, I expected better. read more

When I first ordered something to pick up, they seemed rather upset with me when I arrived because they tried to call me while I was on the way there. There was a minor snafu, but they seemed almost angry with me. I went again and this time dined in, but I stupidly forgot to tip. It completely slipped my mind, and I am so, so sorry about that. I had a lot on my plate (no pun intended). I wish America would just streamline the whole tip thing somehow. Anyone who's had a job can tell that the servers work hard at what they do, though it almost feels insulting to tip someone, as if you're implying their job doesn't pay them enough or treat them well enough at the pay rate they receive. Who am I to judge this person graciously serving me, anyway? It's actually rather stressful, even if you don't hate the extra math. But I'm getting WAY too deep into this. I do want to give them another chance, though. I remember the food being good. They also have Orangina, which is this beverage that's ridiculously hard to find. It's difficult to describe, but it's sort of like carbonated orange juice almost. It's delicious. Despite the previous troubles, I really want to try and establish a better relationship with this location. It's your standard pizza place. No reason it should be complicated. read more

I have been meaning to review Legends for a while. I have had such bad experiences at businesses lately I figured writing a positive review would break that streak. First off, the pizza is much better than what most local shops make. Fresh ingredients, not greasy and great pizza. The salad pizza is good, and so is their meat lovers pizza. I have a low tolerance for bad pizza, but I like their food. They also offer a chicken nugget meal my son loves....I have to say among the best I have ever had. Other pros? Fast delivery. Cons? Price. They aren't cheap, so its not a regular dinner option. If you go there, they have a nice restaurant, but parking can be inconvenient at times. Overall, glad we found it and glad it's close by! read more

Stumbled upon this place while shopping at the Stop and Shop next store. Stopped by and ordered their hot oil pizza, hardy salad, and their Elvis Presley wrap. The inside looked very clean and had a cool vibe. Let me just say, I was blown away. Their hot oil was a unique pizza that everyone enjoyed. The salad was big and tasted really good with all of the toppings on it. The wrap I ordered also tasted great! Can't wait to try out the rest of the menu. I will definitely be back! read more