Best bagels within 20 miles of LBI. I'm a bagel snob, trust me. The line gets crazy, but for good reason. You can always call ahead!

We tried a blueberry bagel with veggie cream cheese and it was delicious and fresh. It's a busy place but they were efficient and did a great job. They have lot of other options too. read more

Bageleddi's - Blueberry Bagel /Cream Cheese - Bagels Near Me - Ship Bottom, New Jersey

I purchased 3 ice coffees, 3 breakfast burritos. I spent over $60.00 The burritos were tasteless and coffee was water down. I will never go back again. read more

Outstanding bagels, coffee and sandwiches in a very cute shop. It's a busy shop but all get served pretty quickly. The owner here was super nice and the service was fantastic. Definitely five stars for Bageleddi's. read more

See all

This place has really declined since the owners sold it two seasons ago. The subtle touches that the old owners must have implemented made a significant difference. There aren't enough staff to keep things moving quickly, and they frequently run out of bagels. The staff they do have are very friendly. Prices have increased, which is understandable due to inflation. However, they've added a tip request on the credit card machine that requires multiple steps to bypass, even for something as simple as buying a T-shirt. While I don't mind tipping for services, it should be a choice made on a case-by-case basis. Overall, it's still a decent spot for a quick dozen bagels, but it lacks motivation for breakfast sandwiches read more

Best bagels on the island!! Can't go wrong with this spot. The bagels come out SO hot and fresh, it doesn't get better! I am usually an everything bagel person, but the blueberry bagels here are something special. Highly recommend read more

Been going to them for years (1990's) would never think of any other place. LBI trip.never complete until I stopped off at bageleddi's Mike read more

We enjoyed our bageleddis bagels both times we visited while on vacation. It's definitely pricey, though, and they don't display prices on their signs which is annoying. We got 2 bagel sandwiches and 14 bagels and it was over $40. Great BEC though. read more

Bageleddi's - Bacon egg and cheese on an egg bagel - Bagels Near Me - Ship Bottom, New Jersey

Yum, yum yum 2nd best bagels I've ever had. #1 is still bagelman in danbury ct only better because theirs are bigger. Staff here is great as they process a massive line out the door and phone orders all morning long. The 6 of us started our day here with sandwiches and iced coffee and the bathroom is so clean! The French toast bagel is unique and very tasty. A great beach location read more

Bageleddi's - Perfect way to start your day at the beach - Bagels Near Me - Ship Bottom, New Jersey

Outstanding bagels on the Shoar. Take some to go, grab some breakfast and your favorite coffee drink before heading to enjoy the best place on earth LBI! read more

Bageleddi's - Bay gull lol - Bagels Near Me - Ship Bottom, New Jersey

See all

Awesome bagels, lovely staff, yummy coffee. My daughters loved the rainbow bagels. They even put out pieces of bagels for when you're waiting in line! 10/10 read more

Our stay at LBI is coming to an end and decided to go here for some bagels and scallion cream cheese. Great bagels and quick service as always. Go here all the time during our week stay right up the block. read more

See all

One in a long line of bagel places who can't handle toasting the bagels! I thought we had liked Bageleddi's when we went there last year. Maybe it was just because everything else was closed last year when we were here, because this year we were not impressed. It was fine, but the bagel being untoasted, the contents of the sandwich slid out with every bite and had to be readjusted. It was annoying. They were also out of Splenda and when my husband asked one of the employees if they had more, he was kind of a jerk. Bottom line - it's fine if you're desperate, but there are better places on the island for bagels. read more

Bageleddi's - Sesame bagel with veggie cream cheese - Bagels Near Me - Ship Bottom, New Jersey

See all

We have gone to Bageleddis multiple times over the summer already. There are always tons of people standing around waiting for their orders. The people that work in the store are all very nice and helpful. The way the shop is set up now is kind of confusing. You can't tell who is in line to order and who is waiting for their food to come out. I'be ordered the iced coffee a few times recently here and I add flavoring to it. The iced coffee is $5 after adding a flavor, which is reasonable. I also normally order a plain bagel with cream cheese and it's almost $5, which is pretty pricey for just a standard bagel. The last 2 times we have been in the past couple of weeks we ordered breakfast sandwiches and the wait was over 30 minutes after we ordered to get them. The bagels and sandwiches are good, but not worth waiting 30 minutes for. Unfortunately, we probably won't be coming back as often due to the wait times. read more

See all

Bageleddi's is one of a few bagel spots on Long Beach Island. They have vegan butter (but no vegan cream cheese). We got a couple bagels with vegan butter and enjoyed them. The bagels cost $1 each and butter is $1.50, so expect to shell out at least $2.50 for a bagel (which is still a good price). The coffee here is decent, but not great. It would be awesome if they started offering vegan cheese, bacon and egg in addition to the vegan butter. read more

Bageleddi's - Toasted whole wheat bagel w/vegan butter ($1 + $1.50 extra for butter). Pretty good. And only $2.50 total. - Bagels Near Me - Ship Bottom, New Jersey

This is definitely the place! The owners are genuinely hospitable and gracious; their staff is attentive and personable and the service is excellent. The bagels are amazing. They are so fresh and delicious. I had an everything bagel and unlike most places, the toppings were not only on the top of the bagel, but they were also on the bottom. Perhaps the best bagel I have ever had. And at my age, that is saying a lot! My husband had a breakfast sandwich and just loved it. Coffee was piping hot and freshly brewed. For breakfast at the shore, this is a total win! read more

Decent bagels ... no prices on the board so no way to see what you'll pay .. odd ... Used to be a long line everyday for years .. now under new ownership and no lines ... maybe the new owner , Mr muscle guy with a scowl , stopped coming in and making customers feel unwelcomed. read more

Fresh bagels good spreds lot of options omelets there's espresso & coffee's are all top notch

Bageleddi's an impressive bagel bakery. I was fascinated watching them pull them out of the pot, apply the toppings, and put them in the massive oven. What a production! This place has tons of varieties. Shoppe is modern and clean inside. People moving through the line. The bagels here are more crisp on the outside, compared to the other well known bakery in beach haven. Not gooey. Salt ratio was good on the "everything". Wished this place were more welcoming to eat within. There are a few tables towards the front. I'll be back. read more

Bageleddi's - Time to make the bagels! - Bagels Near Me - Ship Bottom, New Jersey

See all

Seriously delicious bagels. Busy and well organized, the line moves quickly. Loose bagels and bagels with cream cheese come out fast (in the event there is a hangry person in your crew). read more

New management - friendly staff, great bagels, really good coffee. Hope they stay open all year.

Pros: Super cute bagel shop with homemade cream cheese. Bagels come out warm. Typical lines for a bagel store. Cons: Cash only which doesn't fit the modern look of the bagel shop. I wish they had put the cash only sign at the beginning of the line instead of where you order as we had already waited in line to order. When we got to our drinks after we paid they were out of decaf so if you're looking for something specific make sure they have it before you order or if they can prep while you're waiting in line. It is definitely a buzzy atmosphere and I completely forgot to order one of my bagels or I ordered it and didn't get it. I don't even remember. They have great options for lunch that you can take to the beach. They also have a good selection of donuts. read more

Bageleddi's - Coffee bar area - Bagels Near Me - Ship Bottom, New Jersey

Had a very bad experience here. How is the restaurant in business with no menus and no pricing? I only went in since Beyond Bagels was closed. I asked for what it costs for coffee and certain bagel sandwiches and the owner couldn't tell me. He said price of supplies always change and they never provide pricing or menus. I don't understand why anyone would solicit this place not knowing what things cost. Terrible business model. read more

Two knocks on this place- it's 2021 you should have a dairy alternative for coffee and you don't toast bagels after applying the cream cheese. It makes the cream cheese softer and runny like mayonnaise. That being said it may be your best option for bagels on the island as it's slim pickins over here. There are a lot of bagel options but not as much cream cheese options. The ham, egg, and cheese my boyfriend ordered had an over cooked egg. read more

Sandwiches are always on point and love the crew that works there. Sometimes it takes awhile, but it's understandable by how consistent and delicious the food is. I recommend stopping in at 8am if you want to skip the rush. Iced coffee is good too! read more

See all

While the bagels are delicious- the service fee for debit card transactions is a bit much especially when it's only for credit cards and when I questioned them they said yes for debit cards too... you're obviously wrong. read more

Bageleddi's - Bagels Near Me - Ship Bottom, New Jersey

See all

Cutest, cleanest, friendliest bagel place you'll ever find! Best coffee on the island for sure, and the sandwiches are delicious!!! We love the Fat Eddie. Great chef and great bagels! read more

They put cheese on my sandwich when i specifically said not to. It takes forever to get your food and the service is bad. It was so hot in there and it was terrible. I don't recommend going here. read more

I wonder there wasn't a line. All the bagels are mini bagels. Disappointing, not like it use be.

The service is terrible and it takes forever to get your food. The owner is not a very nice guy. I will say that the bagels are good.

Love the bagels, they're crispy on the outside and doughy on the inside. Great version of NY Style bagels. The service is super friendly, it's clean and well organized. I'm grateful for this place, just wish they were open yr round. read more

The bagels were good/decent. They are pretty small compared to most bagel places I've been to even if they are boiled and made in house they could spare to make the bagels at least a bit bigger. The staff of younger kids working were nice. When I had to deal with (what appeared to be a manager or possible owner) I was met with complete rudeness which Im not one to complain much about because I come in contact w rude ppl all the time doesnt really phase me. The bald dude with the glasses was very rude though and theres no reason to come pay good money for small bagels and dickhead attitude. read more

Got a bag of bagels...there was a cockroach in the bag. Last time for me. Gross. Done.

I really want to like this place but didn't blow me away. We went a couple of time throughout the week. The first time we went my bagel was rock hard!! We came around 830/9 so it wasn't super late. The second time we asked for 2 toasted bagels and it wasn't toasted at all so they made them again..... still not toasted. Not the best service and the service fee for cards is ridiculous. read more

4 or 5 stars for the excellent coffee (latte actually - so good) and bagels/spreads but really weird and not-so-good service by a clueless staff. tasty white-meat chicken salad and decent egg salad, too. Just be prepared to have to thoroughly explain your order. Note: closing every day by 12 noon end-of-season 2021. read more

I love Bageleddi's . Love , love, love their fresh bagels! We got 3 with cream cheese, toasted and I got mine toasted with butter. Can't beat them ! Service was fast ! Thank you Bageleddi's for staying on LBi , hope you stay for a very long time. read more

Stopped in the Saturday of Chowderfest knowing it was probably the last weekend they'd be open. I heard there were new owners and wanted to check them out. In a nutshell... no better than last owners. First off, for me it's a red flag when I see menus posted on the walls, but no prices. I walked in, stood in front of the counter without being acknowledged. There were 2 guys behind the counter checking coffee, doing their morning setup etc., I was standing at the wrong counter but neither of them said anything. I finally asked is this where I order? They then said no over there. Ok, I walked to the other counter. The man in front of me had a big order to place, I patiently waited. The girl behind the counter (Katrina was the name on the receipt I received) then picked up the phone and took a large phone order. While taking the phone order, she was making faces and losing her patience with whoever was on the phone. She asked the person on the phone for a name for the order. She asked again for a name for the order this time with hand motions and an eye roll, as if she was being put out by the person on the other end of the phone. She might have asked a third time, I'm not sure, I just know that She then hung up on the person. I looked at her as if what the heck and she said, "she hung up on me." She then went on to tell anyone that would listen to her that the person on the phone hung up on her. Why would the woman give her entire order then hang up when asked for a name for the order? The phone rang again and she didn't pick up. I've been in the food industry a long time. This was pretty rough to see. I knew that woman placing the order on the phone would come in to pick up her large order and nobody would know what she's talking about, (except the girl behind the register.) The woman placing the order thought she was doing the right thing by calling ahead, only to find they didn't make it for her because the girl behind the register can't deal with people. She has a house full of hungry people waiting for breakfast and now has to stand around and wait another 40 minutes for her order to be made? Not acceptable at all. I know that hiring and service took a hit after covid but this is just ridiculous. Being nice to a customer should be a given, common courtesy should be a given, not taking your bad attitude out on a customer should be a given. Epic fail today and I won't be back. P.s. I just started a yelp account today because this was so disturbing to see and felt the need to share. #dobetter bageleddis read more

My parents have been regulars for years. Today was my first time in the new location. The wait was ridiculous, and hanging around watching food prep gave me the chance to witness what is probably the worst display of unsanitary conditions I've seen inside a deli in a long time. NONE of the people preparing food were wearing gloves. I witnessed employees answer phones, take digital orders (or something on what looked like an iPad), and then return to food prep without hand washing. The ultimate was when an employee pulled a full trash bin from under the counter, toss something inside, then slice a bagel open without batting an eye. This was all in full view of a packed store. This is beyond unacceptable--and how can they even pretend to offer gluten-free products if everything is being handled and prepared by the same hands on the same surfaces? read more

Excellent. Bagels are hot and fresh. Hard working mom and pop shop. The best on LBI. Delicious hot coffee and crumb cake is off the hook!

I choose to go here because they gave gluten free bagels. I waited about a half hour. Paid $3.75 for one bagel and it was the size of a mini bagel and had about a drop of cream cheese on it. Very disappointing. Try other bagel places for your gluten free needs. Bacon was barely even cooked and we threw it out as soon as we got home. I called and complained and all she said was "I'll let them know". Never going back here read more

Bageleddi's - Bagels Near Me - Ship Bottom, New Jersey