Wonderful ambiance in garden great food and service very special evening…read more Must try the pea and lobster soup

Longtime regular here -- 20 years -- and the food and atmosphere are still excellent, no complaints…read morethere. But something has shifted with the sommelier, Michael. He used to be warm and attentive; lately he's been dismissive and plainly rude for no apparent reason. It's happened more than once, so it's not a one-off. It's a real shame, because otherwise this place is as good as ever. Hoping this gets addressed -- this restaurant deserves better front-of-house consistency than that.

This is place is a joke. It was a terrible experience e and I will tel you why. 1) the service was…read moreterrace. Your spend 600+ on a table and get approx cubs. 2) the music and So fucking bad. It was is terrible. No good vibes an at a time. We spent 600 + and was like nobody's. If your coming to east hampton avoid this club at all costs it's not worth it . Weird crowns , and terribly hospitality. Go somewhere else where . Don't ruin your time here it's triable and should go int bankruptcy very soon. Lmk if you have any questions. TERRIBLE BAR PRLASE DONT ADVISE .

I would give it zero stars if i could. They stole $600 from us at an empty, misleading "club" and…read morecharged our credit card as soon as we told them we would like to cancel. The staff was nice and helpful, but the owner was extremely rude. This place is a scam, they tried to scam us out of our money over and over again for the hour that we were there. DO NOT waste your time here. Used to be a fun place, sls east and club Philippe were awesome, this was beyond terrible and unprofessional.

Came here for dinner and had the best time! We sat at the bar and the bartender (Ellison) was not…read moreonly so much fun but all around great and had great suggestions for what to eat! The antipasto salad was super refreshing, chicken parm was huge and SO good and the meatballs were also really good. I had wine and my partner had some tasty cocktails. The ambiance is good and I can't wait to come back and sit outside in the summer!

Murph's is the real deal -- the only true bar in Sag Harbor. No frills, no scene, just cold drinks,…read moregood people, and a vibe that feels untouched by the rest of the Hamptons. It's dark, divey, and perfect. There's even a cigarette machine, which feels like a relic in the best way. The kind of place where locals and visitors blend, the jukebox is always playing something decent, and no one cares who you are -- just what you're drinking. An absolute gem. Long live Murph's.

This is the coolest dive bar in all of Sag Harbor featuring an air conditioned interior, the famous…read morering game, darts, jukebox, and even an old school cigarette dispenser should the mood strike you to light one up. We didn't order any food so I can't attest to the quality. Bartenders were efficient, yet personable. The crowd was mixed but filled with mostly locals.

Very busy even on a Monday. Go early or expect to wait, but if you are not in a rush, it is worth…read moreit. The service is very friendly and accommodating. The setting is casual and the food is excellent! Fresh and well made and with many menu options. A must stop in the east end!

Went to try a hot lobster roll and also sampled the calamari. The calamari was perfect - crispy,…read morenot too heavy of a batter, well salted, and piping hot. The tartar sauce and marinara paired well too. The lobster meat was chunked rather than shredded (which I prefer) and really piled on generously. It was disappointed that the meat was super dry and not tender. Kind of disappointing for a $36 lobster roll when you expect the chunks to melt in your mouth and be succulent. We did ask for a side of butter to dip the pieces in and it did improve it slightly. I needed to also salt the meat since it was cooked in unsalted butter. Bun was a tad too toasted but otherwise held up well and was both crispy and fluffy. Side of fries were well crisped and salted. Service was great - our waitress was attentive and quick to address our needs while managing a very busy bar. Food came out fast. Had no wait when opting to sit at the bar (2 people) though a table wait would have been about 15 minutes.

The food was amazing. We shared the Tomahawk steak, which was gargantuan and delicious. The manager…read moremade wonderful recommendations for accompanying beverages. We sat outside under the stars and had a lovely night.

I had dinner with two friends on a summer Tuesday night. The restaurant is large and sprawling…read morewith a modern vibe and, was full with large parties with families and children running all around. Good for them - not what I am looking for!!! We asked to change our table as we were given a tight corner table not comfortable for three men. They graciously accommodated us but, the transition was not smooth. At the second location, in a front room, a lady came and we started to order - appetizers and entrees. She said she was actually the manager and was jumping in as a waiter because they were short staffed. She took our order and asked if we would like every thing to come out at once - we said no - appetizers first then entrees. What an odd question. Do they usually serve everything at once? I am not looking for a strict conventional order of serving but, something is off here. We never saw her again and, never really knew who our waiter was. We were served by a variety of bus people, runners and finally the General Manager. We did not complain. One of the gentlemen is our party is a professional chef. He ordered a coke at one point from the GM which didn't come for 15 minutes - so, we sent it back. The food was just OK - pizza nothing special - service disorganized and, for those reasons we will not be back. To his credit, noticing that we were not happy - he took our drinks off the check. Generally speaking, this restaurant suffers from mediocre food at EH prices, and the staff doesn't seem to work together is a smooth way. Respectfully submitted feedback - with hopes for improvement

A good spot for low key food and a strong drink…read more The margaritas are pretty good here. Those of you in. Your 20s will love this place because they have a bit of a heavy hand with the liquor. I felt buzzed after half a drink, and I'm no lightweight. The service is average (this is a good thing) The ambiance is very casual. I could see why most people in their 20s would love this place. I usually rate a Mexican spot by their Carne Asada tacos but they don't have them here. They Americanized it and call the skirt steak tacos. I wouldn't call it true Mexican, but I wouldn't knock it either because a lot of people don't speak Spanish out here so I can understand why they did it. The Parrot burger was decent. Perfectly cooked and tasty. 3/5 (good score).

Food was mid but the worst part was that the service was horrible and then after we endured through…read morethis horrible experience we had to face a 20% automatic tip (btw I wanted to tip 1% cause it was shit). Tipping yourself out of my wallet is incredibly disrespectful. If I'm ever back u can tip this dick.

Rowdy Hall is the best! Their burgers are really good and you should definitely try them, but we…read morereally love them for their wings. So many buffalo wings can be subpar, but not here. They are crispy and delicious and you can order extra sauce with them if you like. They moved from their spot in East Hampton to Amagansett, which is actually closer for us and ideal. We won't be going anywhere else for wings. Also, try the artichoke!

My group hung out here for the first Friday afternoon of March Madness and had a great time. They…read morehad all the games on when we got there. The staff was very friendly and didn't mind us yapping about our brackets. The happy hour had some great deals and our bartender took the time to help me find the right beer. The food was good too, as the fries had the perfect amount of salty goodness. I would definitely return next time I'm in the area!