For the price we paid , elevators were broken, no amenities in bathroom (shower cap, hand lotion…read moreetc) Only had one shuttle working and AC was broken I expected lil better

Love this place very relaxing the food is good very…read more Beautiful view and the longest bridge nice spa and pool highly recommend this place

I can't recommend this hidden gem accommodation enough. This was our fourth time staying here, and…read moreit feels like Nirvana every time. It's a family run business, and you feel like family staying there. You're RIGHT on the water and can snorkel right from the dock! Amazing. They even have snorkel gear to borrow. Grill your own fish at the bbq's in each cottage, which was our best meal in the Keys. And the sunsets are simply epic on the water. Will definitely return.

I LOVED my stay at White Gate Court! We brought our sweet Daisy dog on our trip to Islamorada and…read morethe accommodations at White Gate Court truly exceeded our expectations. We stayed in cabin 7 and it was perfect - clean, cold (we love crisp, cold AC when it's hot outside) and absolutely precious! I would recommend staying here a million times over. Not to mention, the free kayak and SUP boards, floaties for lounging in the water, hammocks + outdoor seating, etc. The ONLY constructive note was that the beds were a little stiff, where I prefer more cushion/foam for comfort. Despite this - PERFECT STAY

Wow this is a hidden gem in Islamorada. We stayed for only 1 night but we regret not staying…read morelonger. The service is great. Upon arrival the lady in the reception is super kind and sweet. Was always smiling and attentive. The rooms were clean, the beds were comfortable. We stayed in a cottage and it fitted us perfectly. The atmosphere felt very relaxing and tropical, exactly what you want for a getaway in the Keys. It has many spots to watch the sunrise. We really enjoyed our stay. Definitely coming back.

The room needed so much maintenance . The bathroom had severe rusty shower head....shower had a…read morehole with plaster covering it not painted. The knobs were so rusty with a little blue and red painted or drawn on them . Very, very dated.... (Counters, curtains, AC, everything) In dire need of repair. I talked to management, but they did not care. I did take pictures . It was also 400 a night . On a plus - The grounds are beautiful and the pool area was very nice.

Good: family friendly very chill. Staff is very friendly. Pool was very nice. Tons of great…read morerestaurants close by. Bad: only cleaned out room once in 6.5 days. Ran out of towels and TP. Had to ask for our room to be cleaned. Never received the towels we asked for when we ran out. Bar is a "wine" based liquor. Not a full bar! Limited food on premises. Mattress need to be changed ours had a dip in the middle.

We had the best time! Lovely little resort with a free water taxi ride to their sister resorts. The…read moreboat was so much fun. The free shuttle bus to anywhere was also appreciated. We loved our casita right on the water. The pool was lovely as well and the people here were so nice. We will be back!

This was our second year staying at the Amara Cay, and what an enjoyable experience both times. We…read morewere allowed early check in which is such a nice amenity. Check in was quick, and very friendly with recommendations. Our room was on the second floor again, this time an ocean front and wow - it's worth it. We had the courtyard view last time and it's also a very pretty view - you can't lose. The pool area and bar is so wonderful - very scenic, and the service at the bar is great. They have a great menu for lunch options that they bring out to you. The room was very clean, modern, and spacious. You can request a microwave if you need too! There are bikes, paddle boards, and kayaks for rental for free. Lots of things going on in between the three resorts - we wish we'd had a chance to try the yoga! We will be back for years to come.

We just finished a 7 day visit to Amara Cay resort. This was somewhat disappointing in regard to…read morecustomer service and room cleanliness and supplies. After 3 days my wife had to threaten the front desk staff with using towels to wipe her ass if the maids didn't restock the toilet paper in our room. Totally unacceptable for a resort. They kept assuring us the rooms service maids were coming in daily, but they never did until she threatened to come down and make a scene. The staff seemed unmotivated to complete even the basic cleaning tasks. We only asked for two coffee k cups, clean towels and the two room garbage cans to be emptied on a daily basis. That was just too demanding and the staff tried to mean-mug us when we came and went but finally got it done for the final two days of our visit. I'd advise you visit another property because the service is nonexistent and a total disappointment. Their on site restaurant was a joke as well. Completely overpriced and out of touch given the location. Every other restaurant we visited in the area was excellent, but theirs was almost always empty. The menu was way overpriced and there were countless local options that were much better and less expensive. Nearly all the staff on site see to be unwilling to provide service to customers and displaying a shitty attitude overall. Leadership changes need to take place or this property will crumble. Good location, just bad service with inadequate leadership supervision.

To the person that rated this 5 stars simply because they needed AC.......don't write reviews when…read morethat's all you're looking for. This is not a resort......it's a cobbled together group of I don't know what. The pictures you see in the advertisement are of the best room on the best day of the year. Our room had sticky floors and a shower that I can't even begin to describe. The glass wasn't sealed so the water leaked out and flooded the bathroom. Office hours are 9 - 4 so you can't talk to anyone and they didn't answer the phone. Stay away.

Affordable and relatively clean . It is oceanfront but there's not really an access to the water to…read moreswim . There are lounge chairs and tiki umbrellas on a sandy area to watch the ocean . Pool was clean and decent with plenty of shade under tiki umbrellas and lounge chairs. Pool towels provided . Fully stocked kitchen with stove, microwave and fridge. Simple beach decor. Needs some updating and maintenance but overall not bad for the price point . Be advised that the office hours are 9:30-4pm . We tried to check out early and had to wait . There are actual room keys we had to return .

We stayed here for only one night while we were driving through to Key West. The place was better…read morethan I expected. Great location and old Florida charm. We had a couple drinks at the bar out back on the water. Was just a great time. Also ate dinner on grounds ( was a food truck with good Thai food and a nice covered patio) I really wish we'd booked this for more nights. * bed and pillows were great

Low key spot w/ killer vibes! The bridge leading over to the pool is its own little island of…read moreparadise. Our room was steps away from the sea. Breakfast is served until 11am. Kayaks and paddle boards are available are your leisure. 10/10! Beautiful stay!

We recently stayed at Sunset Inn in Islamorada and had a mixed experience. On the positive side,…read morethe room was clean and well-maintained, and the check-in process was very smooth and hassle-free, which we appreciated after a long day of travel. However, we felt that the property is quite highly priced for what it offers. Unfortunately, our comfort was affected by a few issues in the room--the bed made noticeable noise even with slight movement, which made it difficult to get a good night's sleep. Additionally, the air conditioner was quite loud, adding to the disturbance. Overall, while the cleanliness and easy check-in were definite positives, the noise issues and pricing did not quite match our expectations.

Well known and respected member of the community, the Sunset Inn was an interesting stay…read more Easy with check-in, parking was a breeze, and the unit was accessible to physically challenged. The hotel itself was very clean, and the room looked like it was recently remodeled. The bed had a European style bottom on it where I kept hitting my ankle and toes. The mattress was kind of soft, but the pillows were really nice and comfortable. The bathroom looked rather old, and the shower itself didn't have a door on it. So you risk getting water onto the bathroom on the floor when you're just taking a normal shower. I liked the rear room door which led to the pool area. The pool was a saltwater type and very inviting. This was a major plus for this Inn. Get the towels from the front office and pick a nice spot around the pool. This area really was well done Shopping is a breeze with the Publix grocery store just one mile south. Many great choices for restaurants are all within 2 miles. There are no places to cook inside the unit, but there is a microwave outback in case you wanna warm something. A small refrigerator is provided along with a coffee maker and Keurig coffee pods. Try not to book a room facing the street, as it gets rather noisy at night. Also, foot traffic during was rather loud up until midnight. There is a great value in staying here as the price for rooms are very reasonable. I think I paid $136 for the night. The two women at check-in were very polite and attentive to my needs. Questions were answered, I think I would stay here again if I didn't have a room up against the highway. Be sure to inquire first.

I booked an ocean view room and got the back of a building. I was told there was nothing that could…read morebe done because I booked thru a 3rd party site. You would have thought I committed a felony not booking through the hotel. over $500 a night and obstructed view with no one willing to help. We were told by this hotel to go to a sister hotel next door and see if they could help.

I'm really torn over this place. While the grounds are beautiful and serene there are hardly any…read moreamenities for the price and the rooms are deceivingly small. It was nice that it wasn't crowded like the sister resort, Postcard Inn next door, but you are literally on your own here. You even have to check in next door and the only way to contact the front desk is via text. If the rooms were $75-$100 cheaper I would've been ok with it. To be charged a resort fee daily for this place is ridiculous. The only consistency here were the workers at the kayak/ bike/ towel hut and Gayle the sweet bartender at the tiki bar (that closed early). Also they don't clean the rooms and the floor was dirty! I had to wear socks to keep my feet clean and then throw them away when I checked out. I requested via text for them to mop the floor and was ignored.

This hotel is complete garbage. I spoke with AJ about some money they stole. He basically said…read morethat since it wasn't a large sum of money I shouldn't worry about it. This hotel will steal your money. This hotel was booked on Kayak with the "Pay Later" option meaning to pay when I stay. Instead they charged me immediately. Then I had to call 4 times to get a refund. These people are trash. STAY HERE AT YOUR OWN RISK. This hotel & specifically AJ are trashy human beings.

Had reserved a room for me n my wife for several months they canceled us for no reason at all and…read moreonly found out the day of check in. When we had Southwest. Com call them to ask why the couldn't give an answer and later lied and said we cancelled but records prove they cancelled us. Adrian the manager was a jerk says they can do whatever they want. Found a much better place right on the beach so glad we didn't give these people our money. STAY AWAY! UPDATE wow now these people are actually LYING about us!! (referring to their response to my bad Google review ) I will def take this to a lawsuit at this point. Their post below says WE cancelled but Southwest.com will testify that we DID NOT CANCEL and they even admitted that when we had SW call them. But worse than that their post below claims we showed up and yelled and screamed yet THIS INCIDENT WAS ALL OVER THE PHONE!!! I have documentation showing WE NEVER SHOWED UP AT THEIR BUSINESS! These people are despicable liars and I will not stop until they are held accountable. PS I searched out several others who have had similar experiences with these people at this hotel. People who claimed the clientelle STOLE fgrom them and the front desk (same lying fool we dealt with) just dismissed it as nothing. LIARS AND CHEATS.