Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Lost Key Tap

    4.5 (51 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    Lost Key Tap Photos

    Business Info

    LOST KEY TAP ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?

    You might also consider

    More like Lost Key Tap

    Recommended Reviews - Lost Key Tap

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Harvest salad with chicken
    Katie O.

    First time at lost key tap tonight in Wrightstown! The restaurant is clean and recently refurbished with a small but diverse menu. Service was attentive and quick. We went on the early side and had no issues with getting a table. I ordered the harvest fall salad with chicken and it was great portions, not too much dressing, and good flavor. We had the raspberry pot de creme (basically chocolate mousse) which was a nice wrap to the meal.

    a row of bar stools in front of televisions
    Sandy S.

    There were so many yummy choices on the menu, that we will have to go back and visit again! We were there on a night when they had live music and it was an incredible environment. We started with drinks at the bar and before long we were seated at our table. We had great service and enjoyed salad, risotto and a very yummy tiramisu!

    Sweet dessert Riesling
    Nick N.

    Absolutely wonderful dining experience! This was our first visit; we saw all the positive reviews online and decided to make the drive to Wrightstown to try the menu for lunch. As soon as we entered we were greeted by Danny, the very friendly and knowledgeable owner. The ambience is very attractive with a beautiful bar, table seating, and booth seating. Lost Key offers specialty beers, great wines, and impressive cuisine. We started with 2 ales: first a "Founders Dirty Bastard MI, 8.7%" (a scotch Ale, dark ruby in color and brewed with seven varieties of imported malts)--really flavorful, and then a "Central Water, Ouisconsing Red Ale, WI 5%" (mellow malty flavor and subtle flowery nose)--very good but we were spoiled with the "Founders". We opted for the 2-course lunch special which was a great way to sample some of the menu easily. For first course the Arancini (rice balls) are superlative: tastes of ginger, carrot, and coconut delicately seasoned and cooked in a tender rice coating served with a coconut curry sauce (so good and with a kick!) that highlights the ingredients so well. We also tried the Burrata-ta-ta which was an upgrade from usual salad Caprese fare at other places: burrata cheese so fresh it squeaked, mixed with prosciutto, ledgeview tomatoes, and pesto in a red wine gastrique served with fresh naan bread triangles perfect for capturing every drop from the plate (and we did!) The Macademia Nut Crusted Walleye was flakey and seasoned so lightly to let the fish be the star of the dish served with roasted potatoes and vegetables in a buerre blanc sauce. Also we tried the Risotto entree, so creamy with Parmesan and perfectly blended with tomato compote and sweet pea. We wanted to sample dessert but had to admit defeat we were so sated from the 2-course savorings. Danny surprised us with a complimentary post-prandial glass of the Late Harvest J. Lohr White Riesling that was to be served at the sold-out special event he was hosting; we promised to book tickets for the next chef's tasting menu before it sold out. A wonderful dining experience, relaxed atmosphere, great service--all to be found in Wrightstown. We will be back with friends to enjoy this newly-discovered treasure.

    Jacqueline C.

    Very cool atmosphere . We went without reservations and were seated right away on a Friday. Service was good. I thought the food was pricey considering the area and what was included. I probably won't go back due to the price not being worth the experience for me.

    Barbara S.

    Service here was Awesome, we were greeted as soon as we walked in. We had reservations so we were seated immediately. We ordered the old fashions first then a bottle of wine. Both were delish. We had the burger, ribeye steak, lamb special and bone marrow for dessert we had crème brûlée, chocolate brownie. Delish, we will definitely be back.

    Not your mama's mac and cheese
    Jimmy K.

    Great food in a cool location. The place is spacious with plenty of seats inside and on the patio. The bar are is huge with several TVs. The wait staff was friendly and attentive. The food was delicious. We started with cheese curds and bruschetta. For the main entrees we tried the burger, grilled chicken sandwich, risotto and the lobster, crab, sausage mac and cheese. Everything was delicious. We will definitely be back!

    Zulu B.

    Love doesn't begin to describe this place! My aunt recommended we try Lost Key. We found street parking within a block and made our way inside. Darling building with a trendy vibe inside. We were greeted and made our way to the bar for some cocktails. I ordered the LKT Old Fashioned and my husband ordered a Buffalo Trace Manhattan. Very good. We were seated within 10 minutes of arriving and ordered their nightly specials which consisted of the pork loin with cherry sauce, carrots & asparagus and I had the sesame seared ahi tuna and shrimp fried rice. We would definitely order both again! Before dinner we ordered the deep fried bacon because seriously, do you ever see bacon on a menu and not order it?! Of course not! For dessert we enjoyed the Tiramisu and took half of it home. It was wonderful. We enjoyed a few more cocktails and spoke with both the manager and chef. I loved the fact that they walked around and asked how things were. The cocktails the manager made were delightful - thank you!! We are in a monthly dinner club and this is definitely our next pick and we will be back!!

    Jessica L.

    So glad we pick the spot tonight!! Loved the ambience! Classy & live music The Wine was amazing food even better!! Super attentive staff A great place for a date night with the hubby! Leave the kids at home I didn't see a kids menu

    Lamb chops (one of the specials last night)
    Derrick S.

    The wife and I checked this place out last night for the first time and really enjoyed it! I love the huge wrap around bar. The drinks were really good and the bar tender was friendly and very efficient! There was some really good live music while we were dining and it was at the perfect volume. You can still enjoy a conversation while listening. The food was excellent! Great flavors and cooked to perfection. The server was very attentive and made recommendations. We will absolutely be back again!

    Inside

    See all

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of D H.
    0
    2
    0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Excellent and interesting food. Attentive and friendly staff. Great remodel. Well worth the drive .

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    A favorite date night place. The bacon appetizer is so unique and yummy. Love this place!! Do not pass by.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Great service. Very good Caprese salad as a table appetizer. I had the special, pan seared Branzino fish. It was awesome.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    3 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of C J.
    2
    31
    0

    4 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    4 years ago

    Had lunch on Friday with my Wife, she had salmon and I had walleye. Both were excellent. We will be back for dinner soon.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 2 of 2

    Ask the Community - Lost Key Tap

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    Get access to customer & competitor insights.

    Verify this business

    Amphora Wine Bar - Bar area

    Amphora Wine Bar

    4.7(44 reviews)
    14.9 mi

    We paused after dinner at this wine bar and enjoyed sipping a couple of glasses before heading back…read moreto our hotel room. I loved the interior design with the modern garage door window that opened up the whole side wall to the warm summer evening. The plant array on the wall near the bar gave an organic feel to the ambiance. While the initial entrance has limited cozy seating with tables and a long bar, there is actually a back room a well. The bartender was nice and got our drinks out to us right away. The snacks they offered sounded really good, but we were quite full. I was content to enjoy a glass of port, which was excellent. Neat little spot for sheet dinner drinks; I would definitely go again next time I find myself in Green Bay.

    We have been to Amphora many times prior to last night but after our disappointing experience last…read morenight we may not go back. The place was not busy and tables were open but we chose 2 seats at the bar. The bar was also not full. A server gave us water immediately and some menus. And then we waited and waited. Finally after watching the 2 bartenders clean glasses, walk back and forth, chat with others at the bar, we asked if we could order drinks. We got our drinks and were not asked if we wanted to order food. The service was at the lowest laziest point I've seen in a long time. The place slowly filled up and others were served. Not sure why we were invisible. We had to ask to close out and when she brought the check I explained our experience. She was nice and apologized but the service was so unprofessional and although we love to support small local businesses there are too many choices to put up with inattentive service. Do better Amphora.

    Photos
    Amphora Wine Bar - View of the bar area

    View of the bar area

    Amphora Wine Bar - Menus

    Menus

    Amphora Wine Bar - Cocktail

    See all

    Cocktail

    IVR Restaurant & Bar - Churro Cheesecake

    IVR Restaurant & Bar

    4.7(23 reviews)
    8.3 mi

    Even for a fusion restaurant this is the best Indian you can find in the area. Probably some of the…read morebest food in general. Fav Items: Butter Chicken Pizza -- Not only are they one of the few to do butter chicken pizza well, this is legit one of my favorite slices of pizza in the area in general. They also give butter chicken sauce on side for extra flavor. Chicken Malai Kebab -- Perfectly marinated & tender. Comes sizzling with green sauce on the side that kills. It feels like a creamy smoothbite that also has great chew,. Could easily eat multiple, some of the best chicken. Guac Chaat-- Really well executed that feels like chaat meets nachos and honestly can be quite addicting. Imagine a crispy creamy nachos with a bit of extra flavorful tang. Lamb Naan Tacos -- really enjoyed these, lamb seasoned really well and theres a tangy sauce they come with. The fluffy naan as a taco vessel works well here. Butter chicken version is likely also good. Lamb Birria Biryani -- Also very addicting, especially if you use the raita and other curries/sauces to mix. Also can come in higher levels of spice which is great -- Aside from the food the service is always on point and the spot has a great deal of space. Im surprised it's not as packed as it should be.

    Honestly, this was a surprisingly good place to check out. The idea of Mexican and Indian fusion…read morewas interesting. We were expecting a hole in the wall but legit a building on its own and parking lot. Very brand new construction. Deceptively huge! Walk right into the bar area and then you get a sneak into the dining area on the left but then you can keep walking and it kept going and opening up to make seating. Plenty for large and small groups. Dimmer lighting for romantic dates if needed. Service was quick, friendly, easy. Overall our experience was a good one. Food was good. Cheesy garlic naan not exactly as we envisioned but still good. Korma bowl was spicy as we wanted it, sometimes other places give the spice scale and it doesn't match what is expected. Next time, we'll have to try the really spicy! Plenty of protein in all the dishes. The gulab was interesting, I remembered my previous tries tasted different but it's definitely a sweet dessert. So many options to choose from on the menu. We will absolutely be back! Happy eating!

    Photos
    IVR Restaurant & Bar - Just their alcohol display which was beautiful to me lol

    Just their alcohol display which was beautiful to me lol

    IVR Restaurant & Bar - Coconut Korma

    Coconut Korma

    IVR Restaurant & Bar - Chicken Mali Tikka

    See all

    Chicken Mali Tikka

    Lost Key Tap - beer_and_wine - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...