Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Love Thy Cookie

    4.0 (1 review)
    Closed Closed
    Updated 2 months ago

    Love Thy Cookie Photos

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Love Thy Cookie

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    9 years ago

    I just tried the GF lavender lime cookies. Beautifully packaged. Very unique and tasty!

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Ask the Community - Love Thy Cookie

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Desserts 9,802 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Sugar Vault Desserts

    Sugar Vault Desserts

    4.2(202 reviews)
    0.8 km
    $$$

    Yummy! Banana pudding was delicious, the butter rum cake was absolutely amazing.. I also got the…read morestrawberry crunch cake( will come back and let you know how it is) Met the owner and she was a sweetheart! Definitely recommend

    The dessert combinations are creative AF, presentation is good too, the flavor execution remains to…read morebe desired. Several desserts were way too sweet. For the price it really should be on point every time and with every item. Pumpkin Cupcake Not nearly enough pumpkin. Yellow cupcake was extremely dry. The caramel on top was good. Just an okay cupcake. Peach Cobbler Stuffed Cheesecake I loved that it had fresh peaches. The cheesecake again was overly dense and cream cheese could have been whipped longer. The Graham cracker crust was too sweet and a bit too thick. Very nice to look at. Cobbler pieces were delicious and made well. Brown butter Cinnamon Roll Plenty of pecans on top, which was appreciated. I also loved that they weren't skimpy on the frosting. There wasn't enough brown butter or something went awry because you couldn't even taste the nutty earthiness that comes from browning butter. While the roll was soft, it had a strong yeasty taste. Good amount of cinnamon inside. Out of all of the items this was the best. Maple Red Velvet Cupcake Overly sweet. The combination of the alcohol and the maple syrup resulted in a way too sweet to consume cupcake. The red velvet just okay. This was the opinion of 3 different people that tasted the cupcake. Buttercunch Mini Cheesecake I liked the Biscoff cookies on top. The cheesecake was overly dense. The cream cheese was not blended well enough. The caramel on top was nice. I'm a cheesecake snob so I have high expectations. Service was excellent. Store is only setup for Carryout. Menu rotates each week, check their website the night before for the menu. I love a rotating menu. Only open on the weekends, again check their social for hours of operation. All in all I spent over $100 and it wasn't worth it to me. I appreciate the presentation and how all the dessert look really good. I'm a foodie, I need everything to knock my socks off with every bite. Not a place for me, maybe it is for you?

    Photos
    Sugar Vault Desserts
    Sugar Vault Desserts - Zebra Cake Cheesecake

    Zebra Cake Cheesecake

    Sugar Vault Desserts - Biscoff brownie cheesecake

    See all

    Biscoff brownie cheesecake

    Manifest Bread - Pear Crumble Roll!!!

    Manifest Bread

    4.5(70 reviews)
    1.6 km
    $$

    I've purchased their baked goods at regional farmers' markets and wanted to see the brick & mortar…read morestore for myself. It's located in a convenient, small shopping center off of Route 1. Parking is challenging at peak times. The selection of baked goods is varied and fresh. The line to buy items can get long. There's a decent-sized space to "eat-in", should you want. The sweet potato/chili/pistachio bialy is quite a creation, really like it, zings big time. I've never seen that flavor combo in a bialy before and hope they keep making it. The gingerbread with meyer lemon glaze has a very deep ginger flavor that's quite memorable. Not as keen about the breads. The community sandwich loaf is too plain for me and the sourdough breads are tame.

    This place is open all day. It is next to a train station, albeit the kind of strange suburban…read moreriverdale area that I don't know sees a ton of commuters. The parking lot is crowded and a bit of a mess. Coming on a weekend meant waiting in line, and it was not a speedy line. The selection was interesting, but they were struggling to keep up with demand. I ordered the last piece of multiple styles of baked goods, which I suspect was upsetting for the people behind me but which was a decision that worked out well for the recipients of my haul. The loaf was richly sour and the butter I got with it tasted cultured, the other pastries and things I tried didn't quite leave the same impression. Maybe coming at a less busy time yields a better selection.

    Photos
    Manifest Bread
    Manifest Bread - Fig and goat cheese sandwich on seeded baguette. Wonderful chew on that baguette

    Fig and goat cheese sandwich on seeded baguette. Wonderful chew on that baguette

    Manifest Bread

    See all

    Love Thy Cookie - desserts - Updated May 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...