The reviews brought us here, but didn't meet up to expectations unfortunately. We were very disappointed in the quality of ingredients they choose. read more

I really liked the NY style pizza. My daughter and I stopped by and had a great lunch there. We each got a couple slices. The guys were really nice, greeting us and saying goodbye. I'll be back! I recommend. read more

$88.00 for pizza for Father's Day that was a doughy, underdone mess. you would think out of 3 large pizza at least one would have been fully cooked, really disappointed this place didn't live up to the reviews we read before trying them. read more

Best pizza in Suprise hands down! Great quality! Amazing pizza New York style pizza soooooo good!

They don't lie when it comes to the name. Everytime I bring a date to this restaurant I always end up getting lucky in the restrooms. And the best part is the dim lighting and close quarters where no one will even notice your getting head under the table. read more

Lucky's is your typical New York style pizza.. thin, chewy crisp crust.. ample toppings, great calzones and prices! They also make this lasagna pizza, ground pork, mozzarella, red sauce and ricotta.. oh yeah! read more

Tonight I had the stuffed shells. I also ordered a pizza for home. Pizza is NY style and is always great. I've been eating here for over 10 years and this place remains consistently good. Four shells come with the dish. Stuffed full of flavored cheese, super silky. It was covered with mozzarella, melted and bubbling. The sauce is just slightly on the sweet side but you can still taste tomatoes all the way through. The dinner plates come with a loaf of bread and a big side salad. The dressing seems to be a creamy Italian which I really like. I drizzle the garlic bread with the dressing, rip a piece off and get to dunking in the tomato sauce surrounding the shells. Yummy. Staff are beyond helpful and very friendly. The place is very busy this Friday night which I love to see. I support local businesses. read more

See all

just happen to drive by and noticed this pizza joint hidden on Reems! So since i have been trying to try out every pizza joint out in the west valley! I stopped by and had a slice. i usually have my pizza well done, since I like the crust and doe to be crunch! But since I was in a rush and didn't ask for it. Pizza was still great, sauce, cheese, and peperoni had a lot of flavors! Everyone was very friendly, seemed like all the customers were having a good time. I will diffidently come back with the wife and try it again!! read more

Best pizza in Surprise, so yes that's as good as it it gets! Great pepperoni pizza, nice crust, great flavors, and they give you a large amount of pizza. A large is actually a large here. I mistakenly bought 2 large pizzas and have enough for 2 days. I love the pizza here and great specials on wings and pizza if you need to feed a small army. I only have one wish, offer delivery??? I would get pizza form here more often, but it is a drive for me. I am accustomed to pizza being brought to me, just seems like a normal business practice for pizza now. So if that did not make any sense they do not deliver. You will have to go get it or sit and eat. read more

Best pizza in town and can't go wrong with the $3.95 2-slice + drink lunch special. Good prices all-around. Great salads. Update: Lunch special is now $4.50,but still a great deal. This is the place for NY style pizza (Chicago Style pizza lovers need not apply) read more

The closest I've ever had to real New York pizza outside of new york. this place is a total hidden gem, I'm leaving a review here so I never forget about it! Gonna come back when I'm in the area for sure read more

Mostly average, but I would give 3.5 stars if I could... Crust was boring, sauce was bland and minus a point for canned vegetables :( On the positive side, they are generous with the toppings and the service was pretty good. Find a new dough recipe, add some spice to your sauce use fresh vegetables for 5 stars. read more

for dinner really not that great to be honest. the pizza at tailgater's was so much better. for the most part I would pass on coming here again. had 2 pieces out of a large took the rest and gave to a homeless panhandlers. pizza was bland, greasy , and doughy. I forgot one of the first rules of trying somewhere new check out the bathroom when you first walk in, if it's not clean time to leave. needless to say the bathroom was like a truck stop. read more

Lucky's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona

I love everything there from pizza to wings. My favorite has to be the pepperoni roll. My whole family loves it! read more

Lucky's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona

Tried this pizza for the 1st time. I'm a NYC pizza snob. The plain cheese pizza was close but not that close. Ordered extra crispy wings over the phone and got wings that were not crispy at all. They didn't have blue cheese dressing,.but that's an AZ thing. Don't know if I'll try this place again. They don't deliver. read more

Lucky's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona

I really am trying to make more of an effort to stay local when buying anything. Tonight, I tried Lucky's Pizza... and (I hate it when people say this, but...) O - M - G!!!!!! This place is obviously run by a family, and when I said it was my first pizza from them, the three men behind the counter all had something to say from "you'll love it" to "you'll be back". They weren't wrong! The smell alone was so delicious, I called two family members on the way home to tell them about it. If you're in Surprise - forget the chains - go to Lucky's Pizza!! read more

Let me preface this one by saying I only went here because a friend of mine chose it for her celebration. There are just way too many fantastic pizza places around the valley and nearby to sort of waste your tastebuds on Lucky's. The pizza was extremely bland and lackluster. My friend and I shared a jalapeno and meatball pizza. Thankfully, the jalapenos and nice seasoning to the meatballs saved it. But the sauce was seriously lacking. You may be wondering why I gave it 3 stars? Well...that's because their hot wings were delicious! Their sauce was so tasty that several of us dipped our pizza crust in it. Boy what a difference it made! If you're in the area, you may want to just grab up some of these wings of theirs and take them home. Lucky's is just too plain and boring to order much else there. read more

We like Lucky's. We like Lucky's because the family that owns it is great. They are friendly, customer service oriented and work at producing great food for a good price. We have used Lucky's as our go to pizza shop for the past year. We have tried a lot of different pizzas on the menu, and have had the Chicken Parmi sandwiches. Excellent. Having had pizza all over the U.S., I can say that I am content with having used Lucky's as our only pizza shop for the past year. Large pie, large wings, usually about $25 and we're set for the night. 2 pies, one with everything on it, an additional 1 topping pie, and 25 wings will usually run us about $38. We get smoking hot pie that tastes great, and leaves us with a smile on our faces. What more could you want? When I mentioned customer service, we had an experience that allowed us to drive BACK to Lucky's from Wittmann. We ordered 2 pies. Upon arrival back at the house, SOMMMMMMEONE "forgot" there was a pie on the back seat. Upon opening the car door, Someone watched a large pizza tumble from the back seat, out of the box, sliding down and along the back seat, down the door frame, and onto the ground. Dirt pizza anyone? Nope. A quick call had a new pie ready to go in 20 minutes, faster than it took Someone to drive down to atone for their sins. Why the review now? Because I've read about Ray's and we've decided to try it tonight. A review WILL be written. read more

I have been to this place 3 times and each time it has been just great. Great pizza - I've had the same pizza each time; the Lucky Special, and I tell, it just can't get much better. Great sauce, great crust and the toppings are thick and tasty. I have recommended this place to all my friends and to a lot of people that I meet from out of town. (I am in the travel business so I see a lot of out of town visitors). read more

This is authentic NY Pizza. I drive all the way from Peoria to get my pizza cravings satisfied. Try it !

Finally found a local pizza place that the whole family enjoyed! Walking in, they were all so very kind. Ordered a liitle bit of everything just to try the place out and was not dissappointed. We have tried a lot of pizza places in surprise but this by far has been the best. The wings werent mushy or full of fatty skin and cooked just the way i like it. Sauce was perfect. The steak hoagie was ammmazing. The meat was full of flavor and juicy with the warm bread,peppers and cheese. Picky Kids loved the pizza which was a win! Worth every penny. We will be back for sure and can't wait to try more dishes! read more

We just love to come to Lucky's, we love the Lucky's Special. We have been coming to Lucky's since arriving here 7 years ago from Wisconsin. The Special has oodles of fresh cut veggies, pepperoni, etc. We are seniors and get the medium, enough for us to have for lunch the next day. read more

We were looking for GOOD NY-style pizza and great wings. We found both at Lucky's Pizza! It is PERFECT for a sit-down family meal or get together with a few friends. Their pizza, calzone, and wings are awesome! We love the delicious and fresh pizza with great quality ingredients. Service is quick and even "to go" orders are just like we like it! We are "regulars" there and are never disappointed! We are definitely fans and feed our family of 6 (with leftovers)...very filling and tasty. HIGHLY RECOMMEND! (Delivery would make it PERFECT, but it's WORTH the drive...about 10 minutes each way....we pass by (4) other pizza joints on the way so I hope that's saying ALOT!) read more

See all

We've been picking up pizza from Lucky's for years! Best pizza ever! They are super friendly and the pizza is always ready in under 20 minutes. We love this place!! read more

We've gotten take out a couple of times and while the wings are very good, my primary complaint is that the pizza crust is soggy. There is nothing worse than soggy crust on a pizza. It doesn't matter what we've gotten for toppings...the crust isn't crisp or even remotely having that bite to it that makes pizza crust so yum. It's not like the pizza is sitting around long. It takes us less than 7 minutes to get home and we eat it immediately. One day soon I'll come and dine in to really see if it's the crust or if its just the fact that I've gotten it as take-out. But all in all, a decent enough place to try out on a Friday night if you are looking for something beyond the typical chains. read more

Literally the BEST pizza in Surprise. It's also the closest to NY pizza. Get it a little well done, and it's perfect. It's even better the next day. read more

I thought the pizza was pretty good, but nothing mind blowing. Until I had the mushroom, pepperoni, meatball pizza. AMAZING! Plus, we loved their pizza deal: 1 large pizza & 20 wings for $20 (if I remember correctly). I actually really liked their wings & I'm not a big wing person. And their lunch special looked pretty cheap. My favorite by far though was the cannoli. It's the only dessert they have, and it's the best cannoli I've had. Super crunchy and fresh & sprinkled with cinnamon, you can't go wrong with the cannoli. read more

Love this place. 2 slices and a coke for lunch great deal. It's my style pizza. Have been there many times and will be back. Family operated this place is the real deal. Been coming here a few years now. The year regulars great and the good is consistent. I'm from Chicago. This is New York style and it's so good. I come in at least twice a week. 2 slices and a pop in under 5 bucks. read more

Lucky's Pizza - I - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona

I've been searching for a good pizza place for years. I've tried over 10 different places and Lucky's is the only place I go. There pizza and subs are excellent. It's family owned and everyone there is very helpful and friendly. There wings are also excellent. I've been going here for over 10 years and they never disappoint. There prices are very reasonable. This is a gem in the city and I really wish more people could try it. If you want a high quality pizza, this is the place to be! read more

So my son and I decided to stop by and get some lunch. We walked in and noticed it was bigger than we thought. Tons of tables and bench seats including TV's to watch sports. We both ordered the special which was a slice of pizza, 6 wings (Any flavor) and a drink. (Free refills)Tea and soda available. When finished paying the gentleman started a conversation and we talked a little about how his dad and himself started the business. When the food came out it was fresh and hot. We both had the pepperoni slice which is New York style so it was thin. Loved it. The wings came out about a minute after the slices. My son's medium came in a bowl which had a little sauce in the bowl. My hot ones came with a lot of sauce in the bowl. They were super tasty a little crunchy and perfect flavor. They could have been a little hotter but I will have to get the next one up from hot. Had a great lunch with great owners and will be back for sure. Thank you Lucky's pizza for an outstanding lunch. read more

Great family owned business that's been serving surprise for over 2 decades, Every-time me and my wife walk in there the owners treat us like family. The best pizza and wings in the valley hands down. read more

Went here on a whim and was glad we did. Good NY style pizza that is made to order. Not greasy and had that familiar taste from the east coast. Similar to Rays pizza and I'd say it's in the same ballpark as Rays when it comes to flavor and price. Clean facility, easy to find and plenty of parking out front. The staff was very friendly and helpful with all my questions. I would say this is a winner for the Surprise pizza scene and would encourage people to visit this place. read more

Good NYC pizza. Tons of cheese and meat with great flavor. A little pricy, but worth every penny. read more

Lucky's Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Surprise, Arizona

One of my favorite places for pizza in Surprise! I also love that I can order a slice or two as opposed to a whole pie! Wings great ask for them crispy! read more

Good pizza. I wouldn't say it is anything too special, but for $4.50 for the two piece lunch special, the value is definitely there. Service was fast and adequate, and the food was hot and fresh. As a side note, they do make calzones and sandwiches, so there are options available. read more

Really good pizza, friendly staff, fair pricing. I'll be back soon. I like my pizza a little extra crispy and they are one of the few places that seemed to get it. A little more cooked without being burned. You all are great. Also the sauce and toppings were flavorful! read more

A few years a moved from surprise to Maine and spent 2 years dreaming about a pie from Luckys. We eventually moved back and the first place we went to was luckys to get a broccoli pie. Delish. Now I'm that we moved to the east coast again, I'm dreaming about a broccoli pie and one with green peppers and olives because they don't make em like Luckys here on the north shore. I'll be back soon and will be sure to stop by for my favorite pie. read more

Ordered the meat pizza and told them we did not want the extra cheese- it came with extra cheese anyway. Too much meat, it just made the crust too soggy. I think it was the ham that tasted spoiled so we pulled it off and didn't eat it. We are hoping we don't get sick. The garlic bread was a small loaf of Italian bread with a bit of butter and garlic brushed across the top of the loaf - almost tasteless as no garlic or butter made it inside the loaf. My son liked his slice of cheese. They had Coke products which was a plus. Everyone was polite but I don't know how this place gets 4 stars. Maybe it was an off night. It was really warm inside as well. Sadly we won't be back. read more

I've had cheese steak, meatball sub, chicken parmesan sub and pizza here so far. All of it has been the best I've had. Eventually ill make my way through the whole menu and i dont doubt ill love it all..ive been coming here for a couple years now and I've never had a bad experience or bad food. All of the staff is super friendly and helpful and it's also very clean. I won't go anywhere else if pizza is what im craving read more

Not terrible but it didnt meet up with the expectations I have read from some reviews online. Pizza was ok, wings were small. I still prefer Barros but really hoping to find an authentic NY style pizza joint here in town. read more