Very good pizza with nice staff! Located across from the highschool with no official parking lot. Just park by the church, they don't pay taxes. Don't use the online menus for asking about the prices! They are outdated! My friend and I did that once when we were in highschool and we almost died of shame because we were short on cash once we went to pick up our order. The owner was kind and gave us the pizza anyway, but I still occasionally remember that shameful feeling. read more

I haven't been in a year. But as I begin to draft yelp reviews I'm compelled to tell the world how great the single slices are at lucys. I loved them when I was in high school across the street; in college when good pizza was hard to find; when I moved to Brooklyn, no one believed I was serious that lucys was still among the best. And still after the reopening when the same Tony was there to greet me and ask what I'd been up to in the years since graduating (and amazingly to remember who my siblings were and ask how they were). I didn't learn much in high school, but I learned there's no better sausage slice around. read more

I stalled in terms of trying this spot for a long time after moving to the area, but always heard good things. So, I finally tried it out...then again in the same week. I've only had three things on the menu so far, a plain regular slice, a Sicilian, and their signature pepperoni roll (twice), but all have been surprisingly great! I'd fallen into the trap of thinking that their pizza would taste as generic as the place looks, but I was terribly mistaken, and really wish I'd tried this place much sooner. If you're looking for a great slice spot in Ossining, skip Capri, Sal's, and maybe even Ossining Pizzeria, because this is the best you can find in town, believe dat! read more

They feed my kids daily as they attend the high school across the street. Thanks Lucys for being there

The pizza here is very delicious. The prices are reasonable especially for the pizza they give you. The pizza can be sometimes very greasy. The wings however are amazing there and you get a lot for what you buy. The employees are okay. They can be great sometimes but horrible some other days. read more

Such unique pizza here so close to home. Always get a thick crust and the cheese slices are cheaper than most local places. Service here is very friendly and they get your pizza to your table fairly quickly. If you are craving some pizza and driving through Ossining, definitely stop by Lucy's. You won't regret it! read more

Ordered delivery and had a rude delivery guy who lied about the cost of the pizza and added in his own tip. I called and brought this to their attention and received sarcastic apologies. Be careful with delivery or you might get ripped off! Although I've supported this business for years (way before the fire), I will take my business elsewhere from now on. read more

Excellent pizza. Nothing beats a plain cheese pizza from Lucy's. That large cheese pizza will set you back around $14. The only thing that has disappointed me there is the garlic knots, which used powdered garlic as opposed to fresh garlic. However, the pizza more than makes up for it. Yum. read more

ok, so I maybe among few that give this place four stars, but it was my first time and for something to get five stars on the first go round I feel like you would have to blow my socks off. I've had an abundance of Italian food in my 34 years so if you know the right places, Lucy's isn't a stand out. What Lucys' is though is the best Italian I have had so far in Ossining and in upper westchester. I believe one of m patients may have told me to check them out several months ago, and now that I have, I have found my spot? Everyone raved about the pizza slices...well, put it this way, there is nothin better than attempting to bite in a slice a pizza to suddenly realize that place on so and so street is so much better. So instread I got chicken francese and the baked ziti..another two staples.....review - baked ziti...is where its at..the chicken francese was good but I prefer my chicke a little less dense. I had it delivered so Im not sure what the place looks like, but I imagine it is a little pizza shop, but if that is the case, then I understand why my chicken francese will not be restruarant thin - melt in your mouth thin...but as not to sound like this place was a no bueno....let me say this! If you want Italian in and around Ossining, Lucy's is your stop...the moment i took a breath from the massive inhaling of food I was doing, all I could think about was what I was going t order tomorrow for lunch! Lucy's is now my Italian place near home!.. I highly recommed! read more

Pretty good pizza. Was a bit doughy but that might have been because they took it out of the oven a little early... will ask next time to leave it in a while longer. Better than Chappaqua pizza for sure. Were friendly on the phone and in the place. read more

Their large pizza is delicious (I order with eggplant and mushroom) and it is a great value at $17

Pizza is not good, crust is very thin and slices are way 2 small just do not look fresh. If you want a quick slice when you r at OHS watching a game it is convenient other than that I would not recommend this pizza shop read more

Awesome classic pizza take out joint! One of the Best pizzas I've ever had! Simply put, the crust is awesome! and the sauce is a home run. The Garlic Knots are also a 10 The Male owner is nice, accommodating and courteous wile the younger counter guy seems a bit scatter brained. (he's screwed up my order more than once) Be that as it may, this is still the only place I buy pizza from. read more

Best pizza in the ossining area. They're the only guys that use real pizza dough. They've messed up a time or two but always did the right thing and made the best of the situation The entrees are pretty good too, better than Capri and the other "Italian" spots around. read more

Doesn't look like much from the outside and is easily passed by but this place has surprised me. Personally I enjoy their slices though they are quite popular for their pizza rolls. Especially their chicken rolls but I didn't find anything all that special about the chicken rolls. It feels like an old-school pizza joint so I recommend read more

Completely rude and truly disgusting staff. Saw a guy making the pizza, stop making the pizza, and then take cash from a customer, use the cash register, and then go back to making a pizza. Never washed his hands. Didn't wear gloves. Watch your ticket and bill too...multiple times have been overcharged $2 here, $2 there...and the last time I said something about it and the guy was so rude to me, I decided to never return again. Not worth a food infection nor is it cool to overcharge people. read more

Rude! I used to like Lucy's when I was downtown. Not any more. Ordered a large pie - 1/2 pepperoni & garlic, 1/2 mushroom & sausage. $29 and change? when my husband innocently questioned the price, the surly person re-did the math and said $31 and change!!! And then said "it's 4 toppings. you wanna pay the higher price?" 4 toppings? Not really. 4 different items, yes, but 2 on one half, and 2 on the other half. Pardon the slur, but it seems the Mafia is in control of Lucy's now. The crust was chewy. Not soft and tender. Nor thin and crispy. Just chewy. Like the dough had been over-worked. It's a shame Pizza Corner closed. They were friendly and had good pizza. read more

Great pizza, great price. We've tried a few other things on the menu here too, and it's always delicious. They gave me a discount on pizza for my daughter's birthday when I ordered 5 pies. read more

Best pizzeria in Ossining. Prices are great, sauce is excellent. I was raised in the Bronx so a good pizzeria is hard to find. read more

Ordered pizza from Lucy's Pizza for the first time after reading the wonderful reviews. Pizza was very disappointing. It was overdone, dry and hard. I would not recommend this pizzeria to anyone. I ordered a plain cheese pizza. PS Price for large pizza is $13. read more

Lucy's Pizza - Overdone, dry pizza :( - Pizza Near Me - Ossining, New York

Amazing pizza friendly staff and get reasonably priced food love it here. Best pizza in ossining

Pluses: Fast delivery on a busy Sunday night ahead of July 4th. Good phone interaction with somebody who wasn' t distracted. (Ordering pizza on busy nights can be a bit of a trial for everybody, but Lucy's was right on the ball.) They got the order just right. Minus: The pizza was badly underdone, no doubt on account of the busy night. Overall: Order pizza from Lucy's on a quieter occasion. read more

Just doing this again because it showed 0 stars before which is not true, Wrong on Yelps part... Lucy's is the best...The service, The food, the owners and workers are very courteous... They make you feel welcomed.....I dont trust this YELP website....Hopefully they will put this thru.... read more

5 Stars isnt enough to give Lucy's. Hands down the best pizza place in ossining and no one compares. They had a little mishap and were out of business for a few years but they kept me and quite a few other OHS students well fed for all four years of high school. I saw many detention days just to get a slice in the 9th grade when we werent allowed off campus (does anyone remember?) I would reccommend the chicken salad in a heart beat! read more

Great buffalo and chicken parm slices. Gotta try a pepperoni roll (make sure it is an end piece) and the garlic knots are best in town. Great staff as well. Love Lucy's! read more

Great pizza, and always excellent staff. Tony is awesome. Herman makes great food. Good ingredients always. Meatballs are delicious. Mozz& tomatoes salad always fresh. Never a disappointment in general read more

Lucy's makes my favorite thing crust plain pizzas in the area. Their bean soup is also slammin!

I live 5 mins walking from here. I am glad I live near a decent pizza joint! Good place when I am too tired to cook.

This a follow-up to my review a few years ago. It is still the best pizza available in the Croton/Ossining/Briarcliff/Pleasantville area. There are a few much better places in Yonkers and Mount Vernon, but they are too distant for a spur of the moment decision and delivery. The Sauce and dough are distinctive and the cheese is good quality. If you live in these areas don't waste your hard earned $ elsewhere on a lesser pie. read more

This is my favorite pizza place in Westchester. The pizza's delicious; I've never had a single complaint with it or any of the food. It's the best pizza I've had in the county, and maybe beyond. read more

Was in there a few times recently for a few slices. Pizza is ok, but thats it. Gets the job done. Good service. Made me wonder how the place would fare if the high school kids didn't flock there due to the convienence to the school. read more

Lucy's is my go to place when I'm in the mood for some pizza. Plus, the prices are cheap and the food, I would say, is probably worth more than what they charge. But hey I'm not complaining. The service is excellent there and they get you your food as soon as possible. I usually get the buffalo chicken slice because in my opinion, it is made just right. I highly recommend this place if you're ever just looking for a place to get a quick lunch. And I definitely recommend if you are just in the mood to eat some nice Italian food. read more

They have superb wedge sandwiches here. This restaurant is my go-to for an affordable, delicious chicken club sandwich. The pizza is good too, and the staff is welcoming. read more

I ordered take out 3 slices of cheese pizza. Flavorful cheesy thin crust old school new york slice 100% to a T. Satisfied doesnt begin to describe how i feel now :) read more

Simply the best pizza in Westchester with good prices.

After living in Ossining for 20 years, i came to find out that lucys is amongst the best pizza around. The quality and time they put into there food and how greater there employees and boss are! They greet u every time and attend all your needs! I would say that theres no better pizza around like this. Thank You Lucys read more

Lucy's is definitely a hit! As someone who grew up in Buffalo NY, these are probably some of the best chicken wings I've eaten since moving to the area. Very meaty and flavorful. Delivery is always on time and I have yet to get an incorrect order. I had one bad experience with a delivery driver who got lost and apparently didn't know how to use a phone, but I never saw him again so I assume that issue just kind of worked itself out. I highly recommend if you're in the mood for great pizza and wings! read more

Staff is very nice, although they do have to keep things moving as it gets very crowded during the day. The garlic knots are amazing, great food for an amazing price. read more

Excellent pizza and great service. The rooms are generous and the food fresh!

Great pizza and amazing galic knots. They also have salads, pasta, and more. But there are a few flies during the Summer: they sty up to date and change their decorations twice or one a month read more