Came for brunch around 11 and I'm glad I made a reservation because the outside area was already full and the inside was around half capacity by 12. Highlights: the carbonara was absolutely delicious!!! Creamy but not heavy. The peas were sweet and well seasoned. It gave me the impression the chef seasoned throughout cooking not just at the end. The chicken and waffles was also a win. Waffles were bouncy and soft, the homemade whipped cream was addicting. Chicken was crispy and moist. The spritz flight I was not a fan of. Reading the menu it made sense why it tasted more like a mimosa flight but I was expecting mint in the Hugo spritz and a things a little more elevated. At the same time it was such a good price so simple made sense but a tad too sweet for me. Next time I would rather order the spritz individually and see if it's any different. Would love to come back and have the fun again! April 2026 read more

See all

The ambiance of "M Italian" is excellent. It combines the quaint vibe of Chagrin Falls with the comfortable energetic atmosphere of the establishment and the "coolness" of the glass blowing artists nextdoor. That all lends to a fun place to be. The service is always more than adequate. Our server last night was a very nice young man. Energetic, friendly, knowledgeable, effective. He did a great job all night. The floor manager seemed to be everywhere. Every time I looked up he was talking and laughing with customers. When I asked for something that was above our servers pay grade the manager quickly and kindly handled it with a smile. So I would definitely say the service was very good. But ... unfortunately we always end up at the same sticking point -- The food. I have never been impressed by the overall menu. The selection is limited and not very imaginative. Very limited meat and fish options. And the pasta is lacking... both in selection and quality. I ordered the "Carbonara" last night. And just like the "Cacio e Pepe" I had during my previous visit, it was lukewarm and stuck together like glue. To say the flavor was lacking would be kind. So, after several attempts, I think we're done. Which is extremely sad. With all they have going for them they could be fabulous, but alas they are not. read more

See all

First timer here! We had a mini reunion and was so excited to be able to use the separate banquet/party room. It was perfection. Our server was so knowledgeable and kind. A lot of us ordered different dishes and everyone appeared to be pleased with their dishes. Our bang bang shrimp were delicious. We enjoyed the zucchini frites too. I really enjoyed the atmosphere, the kind staff. Even the valet were courteous. It was complimentary valet. I will definitely be back! read more

See all

Fyi- this is a very late review of my lunch experience at M Italian, a beautiful restaurant in the heart of Chagrin Falls, Ohio. Hopefully, my experience still rings true to how it functions nowadays, nearly 10 months later! My friend and I went during weekend brunch in November of 2024. I ended up just ordering something off the regular menu though haha! I ordered a half size Sicilian sausage pizza and a half size Caesar salad as brunch and we nibbled on a couple very tasty bread rolls and oil while we waited for our main meal. So M Italian is incredibly fancy but also kind of chill - a vibe I can jive with as long as the price is right. It's a smidge pricey here but the food was tasty and we were blessed to have the most attentive waiter ever! Also, I am not used to getting valet parking when I go out to eat but I am glad M Italian offers it and it's free! Unfortunately, my memory of my exact feelings on the food is not quite there anymore but I think I remember the pizza being quite good! The pictures I have saved from the brunch are making me hungry again! I do remember that the complimentary bread was delicious and definitely worth the calories! While I dont remember the food that well, I still have good memories of the beautiful restaurant, our attentive and kind waiter, and the thrill we had when we found out valet parking was free! I would happily come back here - and make sure to write my updated review in a timely fashion next time haha!! read more

We celebrated our anniversary on Valentine's Day at M Italian in Chagrin Falls, and it was absolutely perfect. From the moment we walked in, the atmosphere was warm, intimate, and elegant without feeling stuffy. The setting in the heart of Chagrin Falls makes it feel special the second you arrive. The food was outstanding -- authentic, beautifully presented, and full of flavor. Every course felt intentional. You can tell they care about quality ingredients and execution. Service was attentive, professional, and genuinely kind without hovering. It's rare to find a place that delivers on ambiance, service, and food all at once -- especially on a busy holiday like Valentine's Day. M Italian did exactly that. If you're celebrating something meaningful -- anniversary, birthday, or just a night out with someone you love -- this is the spot. We'll absolutely be back. read more

See all

Service is terrible. Second time here. Second time getting the same terrible server. She is rude, not at all welcoming. She barely speaks to you except to ask what you want.. I actually saw her when we checked in and said to my husband I do not want her again tonight. Yet, that's who we got. The restaurant is not very allergy friendly. Things you can get one time you can't the next time. Food is ok not great. The last time we were there the bathroom was disgusting. One of the two stalls was out of order. The other had wet toilet paper everywhere and the garbage overflowing. They have a nice wine list. The Tuna Appetizer is delightful as well. read more

M Italian - Diners Near Me - Chagrin Falls, Ohio

Always been a fan of this place. Usually sit and eat with the family. Last night we decided to just sit at the bar and enjoy the nice weather. Initially was just drinks but we saw the cauliflower bites next to us and had to order it. Finally after a round of drinks, we just decided to get a pizza to stay for a 3rd round! Shoutout to Sam and Pierre who ran the side of the bar where we were at. read more

See all

Came here for the first time a few weeks ago and had a great experience! I came for happy hour (which they have everyday!) and it was such a good deal. They have some seasonal cocktails and a good wine list. The mushroom pizza was delicious and I also loved the cauliflower app. The zucchini app, I probably would not get again - it was more fried coating than actual zucchini. It's a bit loud inside but they also have a nice patio. Outside of happy hour, it's a bit pricy. But overall a solid spot for happy hour/early dinner! read more

See all

M Italian is a wonderful restaurant with good food & vibes. The bar is large & their bar servers are very friendly. The dining room is also large with an extended room to dine & view outside. Food is great. You can ask for the delicious bread while waiting for your entree. read more

The food has always been pretty good! Their bread is delicious and warm, the sauce for the yummy meal is sooooo good! The service has always been on top. The vibes are gorgeous, the place feels luxurious yet still has a kids menu and is in warm chagrin falls. read more

Great spot for dinner in chagrin Falls! We sat outside on the patio in 55° weather and were perfectly comfortable. There are plenty of heaters and I'm the type of person that is usually cold. It was a very busy evening, but our service was great. We had a cocktail, pesto pasta, and a pizza. The pasta had a little too much pesto for my taste, but it was still good. Would definitely recommend this restaurant and will visit again! read more

My girlfriend and I came here on a Wednesday evening right at the end of happy hour and sat at the bar. I asked the bartender if happy hour was still going on and he said yes, so I ordered two appetizers and a glass of wine. When my friend arrived at 2 minutes after, she asked if she could still get happy hour pricing and he said he'd take care of it since she was literally walking in as it ended. She also ordered an appetizer and a salad. My food was brought out within 2 minutes. It made me question how it could have come out so fast unless it was already sitting back there and not fresh. I wanted to wait until my friend's order came, so naturally my food got cold. At the end of the evening, we were charged full price for everything and had to speak with the waitress who had taken over for our original server. She was able to adjust the bill but it was just a hassle we didn't want to deal with. read more

Have been here a couple of times for dinner, sitting both outside on the patio and indoors, and both options have a lively ambiance! We loved the calamari, which is sooo tender and fried to perfection. The bolognese was so good, 3 people from the party ordered it and left not even a drop of sauce on the plate. I also love their fun cocktail menu, including the honey deuce which I was so surprised to see! One of my all time favorite drinks. The portions are generous, the ambiance chic, and all our servers have been knowledgeable and attentive. Also, free valet! read more

See all

We have been here twice and definitely think this place is a 3/5 restaurant. The recent time we came here, they were pretty busy. We had to wait 10 min despite having a reservation. To start off, they gave us house bread. The bread was amazing but we questioned if balsamic vinegar was a good dipping choice for the bread. For appetizers, we tried beef carpaccio, meatballs and calamari. The calamari were thick calamari strips. The breading was not flavorful and the calamari strips were somewhat chewy. You had to dip them in the sauce to bring some flavors. The meatballs had a kick to it but it was very good. The beef carpaccio seemed to be thick and not good quality meat. It did not melt on my mouth and so chewy. It needed a little bit more citrus flavor to it. For entrees, my cousin and I decided to get seafood. She got scallops and I got branzino. My boyfriend got cavatelli with meatballs. The scallops were good. My branzino was too sweet. It needed some salt. Both of seafood dishes were accompanied by lemon risotto and asparagus. The lemon risotto did not go well with both dishes. It was so lemony. I liked the asparagus because there was a bite to it. The cavatelli was cooked Al dente. I liked how they made it. The meatballs in this dish were same as the appetizer we got earlier. Overall, the place is cute but some of the food were meh. read more

Ya know my favorite restaurant just literally took the last shit on my takeout delivery order. Who the hell is packing your delivery orders? I ordered zucchini as a vegetarian and non seafood eater and you send mussels? Please read your orders and hire more competent people to pack them. Thanks for ruining my dinner for the third time in the last 6 months by sending the wrong food. read more

M Italian - Diners Near Me - Chagrin Falls, Ohio

See all

I really enjoyed my experience. They have complimentary valet , great atmosphere, wonderful service and an awesome location. I went during happy hour and it was amazing. Half off appetizers,pizzas and house wine. Me and my husband dined in for a very adorable price. I love how they serve the bread and water. Something so simple but it makes you feel welcomed . Definitely a hidden gem in Ohio. I highly recommend read more

M Italian - Fig & Prosciutto Pizza - Diners Near Me - Chagrin Falls, Ohio

See all

Very tasty Spicy Sicilian Pizza and A glass of Sangria. Service was excellent. The Bartender's were very attentive. The Bar was open to the outside. With a very interesting crowd. I will return. read more

M Italian - Sangria - Diners Near Me - Chagrin Falls, Ohio

The food was mid and service was mediocre. We sat at the bar and the server tried to remember our order without writing it down and needless to say, my food came out wrong so I had to wait while my friends at their food. I order the cauliflower but had to get them sautéed because of my dietary restrictions (GF). The sweet and sour sauce was tasty but the cauliflower might as well be raw. Then I got the Copa pizza on cauliflower crust. It was basic really couldn't taste the smoker mozzarella or the honey drizzle. As far as ambiance, it was nice until they opened the windows to the outside bar then we were sweating because it was 98 degrees outside. No one, including the bartenders understood who made that decision. The happy hour prices saved this from being a lower rating. I'd go back just to see if there's better tasting food than what we had. read more

M Italian - Cauliflower Bites - Diners Near Me - Chagrin Falls, Ohio

See all

The food was all so delicious and I was so happy to learn they have many gluten free options. Gluten free Penne pasta which I believe was homemade. Cauliflower crust pizza and meatballs (which was a little Spicey). The service was great and we sat outside which was very comfortable and rustic chic. (The inside is more chic because of the pretty lighting) they have a nice happy hour with food and drinks. read more

M Italian - Bolognese with gluten free penne pasta - Diners Near Me - Chagrin Falls, Ohio

The food was good, The service was good. Good place to get a quick meal. Will return.

Great food and even better service! All the wait staff is very attentive and helpful. 3 pizzas was too much for family of 4 (2 kids) so definitely happy with serving sizes! Calamari was really good as well, probably will skip zucchini string fries next time, but will definitely be back! read more

Not worth making a reservation... The service was mediocre, at best. Our waitress spilled bread & crumbs all over our jackets, did not apologize or even clean it up. One of the other patrons even came over to our table to share his shock in the incident. The portions were odd - HUGE appetizer, and then a tiny main. The risotto was undercooked and the fish lacked any flavor. read more

Sunday Brunch at M - A (Not So) Hidden Gem My wife and I had brunch at M this past Sunday, and it was a truly enjoyable experience. The atmosphere was relaxed--not too crowded--and we were seated right away. Our server was friendly and attentive, immediately offering us drinks. My wife opted for a mimosa, and I went with a cocktail. Both arrived quickly and were perfectly mixed. We started with the Zucchini Frites, which were absolutely delicious--crispy, flavorful, and better than French fries (seriously!). We enjoyed them so much, we boxed up the leftovers to take home. You must try them. For our mains, my wife had the Avocado Toast and I went with the Shrimp, Beans, and Greens. The toast was crisped to perfection and topped with fresh guac and vibrant ingredients. My dish was outstanding--flavorful, satisfying, and something I would absolutely order again. Overall, M is a great spot for Sunday brunch. With summer around the corner, their patio and bar will make it an even better destination. Highly recommend! read more

Nice place, dimmed lighting with tall ceilings. Valet parking as well. The food was very good, I ate so much my stomach hurt. Waitress was nice, didn't catch her name which is my fault but she was kind. When we left the hostess said goodbye and have a great night. Manager was also kind to us. Everyone there is nice which I love, good food, worth the drive and time. My only complaint is the volume level but that isnt controllable especially with grand ceilings and people everywhere. If you like a fancy place, don't mind noises, and want great food, go to M Italian. read more

See all

We came here for my brothers birthday and we had a great time. Paula our server was phenomenal! She paced our meal perfectly and made stellar menu recommendations. Ambiance: The bathrooms were clean and there was complimentary valet parking (although make sure to tip your valet). We went on a Sunday afternoon and made a reservation and I recommend you do that because the place was PACKED! Despite the rush of customers our server Paula (as stated before) was calm, collected and a pro at her job. Drinks: Lemonchello - 10/10 Martini - 10/10 House Red - 10/10 Food: Calamari App 10/10 The house aioli that you dip your smart sea creature into it to die for! The calamari was NOT rubbery which is impressive :) It was cooked to perfection! Mushroom Pizza 10/10 This pizza is handmade and fresh- you can taste the love it was made with. Pro tip - dip it in their house made gorgonzola ranch. Thanks for the vegetarian options Carbonara 10/10 Buttery, Bacony, Noodle perfection - if you are looking for a Food-Gasm this is what you want to order! Pesto 9/10 Delicious vegetarian friendly meal. It was well coated in pesto and real BEAUTIFUL pine nuts on top. Small deduction due to the insane amount of sun dried tomatoes- some people would have loved it but I am a pesto purist. Spaghetti Bolognese 10/10 Fresh and filling - it's hard to mess up but even harder to get absolutely perfect and M Italian did it! Tiramisu 9/10 Big enough to share with the table! Light and airy, small deduction because we felt like it had too much powder on top which made for a weird consistency. Gelato 10/10 THIS GELATO STOLE THE SHOW! It is a must have dessert! It is creamy and light! I would recommend this spot to any local or out of towner if I want to impress them with Cleveland's Italian food outside of little Italy. Thanks for the great service and food! We cannot wait to come back! read more

See all

M Italian in Chagrin Falls is a wonderful addition to the local dining scene. Whether you're craving traditional Italian comfort food or crafted pizza, this spot delivers on flavor, ambience , and service It's a place I'll definitely my go to and I highly recommend it to anyone looking for authentic Italian in Northeast Ohio. read more

See all

Not sure how I feel about this place. It seems with all reviews they're great but we did not have a great experience. We had a big party, so we were sat in the "not main part" of the restaurant. Our waitress was either overwhelmed or new because we had to flag her down and ask the same questions several times. Not blaming the whole experience on her tho. The food. Most things had good flavor but nothing was hot. I say this is probably due to the kitchen being on the other side of the restaurant and the food being brought out through the restaurant and OUTSIDE to our portion of the restaurant. We had to send back 2 meals to be remade. Everyone else just ate theirs even tho they were lukewarm at best. The desserts tho...100% would go back for! We did end up talking to the manager because our second round of drinks came out after our entrees and we had to ask twice for the meal for one of the kids. 6 years old and the last meal to come out. I will say, they tried making up for it by comping our desserts, but we were there 3 hours and it just felt like everything took forever to come out. Maybe don't go with a group. read more

See all

The food and the service was outstanding. However, we thought that we were going to a fine high-class restaurant where we could sit down, relax and enjoy a nice quiet dinner together, not a sports bar that is disguised as five-star eatery. For whatever reason, the so called "background music" and I use the term "music" here very loosely, was so loud that even our servers repeatedly had trouble conversing with my wife and I, during our entire dining experience. If we wanted to listen to music so loud that we couldn't converse with one another, we would have gone to a concert or a movie. Whatever happed to fine dining? read more

I've been here before for brunch but first time for dinner was last night. Our appetizers were great - cauliflower bites and meatball. I had the Burrata pasta dish, and my partner had the Basil pesto pasta dish. Both delicious! The actual pasta was very good too. Finished with the carrot cake which was served warm. Wonderful meal! Service was ok - it was busy. He was professional and made sure we had what we needed. Looking forward to coming back! read more

Back again for lunchtime drinks and pizza. We split the house salad and had the pizza bianco. We requested the Pinot noir onions on our pizza and they were delicious. Note to the chef: You should include these onions on the pizza bianco by default. They add so much to the pizza. We sat at the bar and I had a fantastic luxardo Manhattan. Grazie mille Dino for the fun and friendly service, you made our lunch special with your humor....you have your father's sense of humor! read more

M Italian - Luxardo Manhattan - Diners Near Me - Chagrin Falls, Ohio

I would rate my experience that M Italian is just OK. Friends told me that the food and ambience was average but I wanted to try it out for myself. The service was good but the noise level inside the restaurant is very loud. The pizza is actually surprisingly good. The lasagna is different in that it comes with red and white sauce. However, mine was lukewarm at best and better if it was served hot. The Molten Lava Cake was a disappointment. It wasn't served hot at all. I read reviews on Yelp that the cake was essentially a brick of chocolate cake with no lava inside. I experienced the same and the cake was more like chocolate pudding inside. I did ask the server to bring out a hot cake and she did, but it still was not very good hot as you'd expect. read more

M Italian - Molten Lava Cake - not so molten :( - Diners Near Me - Chagrin Falls, Ohio

Went to M yesterday for a late lunch, early dinner. Got there in time for happy hour which had some great deals like $8 cocktails, half price apps and pizzas, and other drink specials. Our drinks were delicious, I got the sangria and my partner got the smoked old fashioned. We shared the meatball appetizer and got chicken Parmesan and the bolognese as our entrees, both were phenomenal. So much flavor and huge portions. Not to mention the BREAD. It was to die for. The cherry on top was our server, Alec. He was hands down the best waiter we've had at any restaurant we can think of in the last several years. So polite, helpful, efficient, kind. I could go on. Can't recommend this place enough! read more

See all

This is my favorite restaurant in the local area and always great food and service! great date idea!

Fantastic food, great ambiance, quick service. What else do you want? Not a broad beer menu, but they make up for that with some interesting local options. read more

Staff was great. Tuna Nachos were great. House salad was very good. Everything else....Lasagna, Parm, Calamari was WAY too salty. I mean lip puckering salty, and frankly, not really that good. This was our second time there. Not impressed either time. Too bad. read more

We've been to M Italian multiple times for appetizers, dinner and dessert. It has been our go-to Italian restaurant near Chagrin Falls; we can always expect great prices especially during happy hour which takes place every day of the week from 3PM-6PM. Highlights we've tried - Mediterranean pizza, butternut squash ravioli, and eggplant Parmesan. Each time we have went, the food is consistently great and the service has been wonderful. The employees are always helpful and kind. Our favorite part of the restaurant experience, besides the delicious food, is the ambiance. Makes a wonderful date night especially when the weather is nice and you can take a walk in town and see the waterfall! Highly recommend gem of chagrin falls! read more

See all

Okay. We come here for the ambience and the convenient location. The decor is amazing, it's beautiful and even in the dead of winter, you feel like you're somewhere warm. However, I think the food is average (but this place is so pretty ). I think the service is just awful, especially at the bar. Year after year after year. It has never been good, never been comfortable, NEVER ever have our needs been anticipated. We are constantly trying to fight for eye contact, silverware for our food, extra plates, water, refills, salt, ketchup... whatever. Nothing has changed at the bar, not since opening day. BUT... this place is pretty, you always feel like you're outdoors, the location is convenient. read more

I have never been a fan. Others like it but it o me it's overrated especially in terms of value. The allure is location in Chagrin Falls and it is a gorgeous restaurant with great outside and open air space. The food is fine but there are so many Mom & Pop Italian restaurants in Cleveland that blow it away for far less cost. Again, good place for o go and be see. And have fun but far better menus and value elsewhere read more

The food was amazing!!! Bridget was the kindest, sweetest server! My family of four (husband, son, daughter, and myself) enjoyed our dinner so much!!! read more

Love the atmosphere and the food. Grabbing a drink at the bar with a bit of that fresh warm bread and oil hits well. The salad is very filling and refreshing which compliments the wood fired pizza well. Service was solid at the bar and we will be back again! read more

See all