This was not a first time for us. In the past we have enjoyed the food and the vibe. Last night, we had friends visiting and decided to do take out. Placed order and was given a very reasonable time frame for pick up and no issues for pick up. Once home, we realized it was the wrong order. Now when we were handed the bag of food, we were also handed the correct receipt with my name. so one would assume they went together. I understand they were busy, and stuff happens. We live around the corner so not a huge deal. The problem began when we stated what happened. A woman, assuming hostess, didn't say a thing. No apology, nothing. We were made to feel like we were in the wrong and it was an imposition to fix the problem. She took the bag and roughly 30 minutes later we had to go hunting down someone to find out where our order was. Again no apology, just handed the bag over. Very dismissive! For the most, everyone liked the taste of their sushi. Unfortunately, I ordered the baked hand Grenades. Such a disappointment!! It is supposed to be shrimp and scallops. No scallops, a tid bit of shrimp with a lot of rice. My husband ordered the wave roll. Said it was good, but very tiny for $16. Needless to say he was still hungry. Will we be back, hard to say. I've been to few other restaurants on the Cape for Sushi, and in my opinion, Macs has some improving to do. read more

This spot came highly recommended by everyone, tv shows, and many blogs. We had such high hopes for this restaurant. The service was very friendly and they have created a cute atmosphere under a tent. The food really could have been so much better. Littleneck Clams- The broth was so salty that we couldn't eat them. Had to send them back 2) Fresh Oysters- they were so poorly cleaned. I couldn't eat two of them and really was on edge if I would get sick. Wellfleet oysters are supposed to be the best so I was disappointed that they weren't cleaned properly. 3) Whole Lobster- this was cooked perfectly and was delicious 4) Arugula Parmesan Salad- good I would give this restaurant another chance if I was local. read more

Been here only once, but first impression was that quality standards and service is the base for this restaurant. The menu features very inventive, or standard item seafood choices; either way you choose you won't be disappointed. I've been very excited to try this place, and it sure left me very satisfied. I can't wait to go back and try more items on the menu. read more

See all

Excellent food. Large outdoor seating (not dog friendly unfortunately). Service was on point.

The spot to be in wellfleet! A beachy spot offering seafood classics and scrumptious sushi. My go to is a painkiller (yes to the rum float!) and lobster roll with the truffle fries. To start their oyster are always perfectly shucked, the cauliflower app is yummy and you really can't go wrong with any sashimi or sushi. All the fish is fresh! Make a reservation or push for a seat at the bar. Otherwise be prepared to wait long. Don't sit inside, outside is much more exciting, enjoyable and fun! read more

Mac's Shack Wellfleet - Wellfleet in wellfleet - Sushi Bars Near Me - Wellfleet, Massachusetts

This place has been very inconsistent for takeout food. We ordered for the third time yesterday and I was very disappointed with the portion size. The poke salad that I got came in a tiny appetizer sized container. You can see it next to a hand roll for size comparison. Rice, seaweed salad, and a small scoop of salmon. Considering this is not listed as an appetizer on the menu, I expected a full dinner sized portion. We have previously ordered other food there and it came in larger bowl-sized containers that were half full. Pretty disappointing considering the prices. read more

Mac's Shack Wellfleet - Hawaiian Poke Salad in a tiny appetizer sized container - Sushi Bars Near Me - Wellfleet, Massachusetts

Sushi here (TUNA is like nothing else on the East Coast. Yumm! Get any sushi roll you want and it will be delicious. They really hit it out of the park with their fresh fish. Personally I would stick to broiled fish here because it's so good. Tried their fish tacos and think they're good but they're not going to woo you like their other entrees. Just get their food as raw as you can and enjoy!! It's the best place to try sushi if you haven't already. Beet poke bowl was also awesome! Same great flavor as their other poke bowl. read more

Mac's Shack Wellfleet - Tuna poke. Have you been to Hawaii!? It's that good. - Sushi Bars Near Me - Wellfleet, Massachusetts

We stopped by per Yelp. We sat at the bar. The food was good and fresh. Kind of pricey but we expected as much for fresh seafood. The bartender was ok. The customers that we meet at the bar is what made our experience better. We ordered sushi to go and it was good. We had to remind the bartender we needed to go items , Chopsticks and soy sauce. They have plenty of free parking. No views of the ocean. read more

Mac's Shack Wellfleet - Hot lobster roll - Sushi Bars Near Me - Wellfleet, Massachusetts

See all

I've been coming here for years now. The food is amazing and the drinks fantastic. I especially love sitting at the bar for a cold Bloody Mary and a dozen oysters on the half shell read more

This place is one of the best on the outer Cape...IF you get to sit outside. Sitting inside might be one of the worst experiences ever. I've eaten in nicer cafeterias. Once again DO NOT sit inside. Outside, 5 stars. Inside zero. read more

When I first read the menu for this place I expected the food not to be that great since the menu is SO diverse. I was mistaken because Mac's exceeded my expectations. Decent amount of parking, but kind of tight if you don't have a compact car. The place itself is very cape cod - with outdoor and indoor seating, outdoor raw bar, and outdoor bar. Service was okay, our waitress took a while to take our order but the food all came out very quickly. The food overall was some of the freshest seafood I've had while visiting the cape. We were a group of four and started with the oysters on the half shell which were excellent quality fresh Wellfleet oysters. We also all split a crabby crunch sushi roll just to try some of the sushi and it was SO good! Made with real crab and again very fresh. We all had a cup of the clam chowder which was good but not great - too thin for my liking. For entrees two of us both got the fish tacos and they were amazing!!! HUGE portion and served deconstructed so you can put whatever toppings you'd like. The fish was so fresh and had a great coating. The other two in our party got the lobster roll and the fish sandwich. They both said the quality of the meals were there but felt the portions were too small. Overall, I really enjoyed my visit to Mac's. I will likely return to try more of their sushi rolls and next time split the fish tacos with someone! read more

See all

I always find their food tasty and satisfying. They always have a huge crowd especially in the summer time so be sure to go early! The seafood tastes fresh and even as take out, which is what I usually do, it stays nice! The have ample parking and outdoor seating which is great because they are so close to the water. Definitely a must if you are in Wellfleet. Their fish and chips were said to be great by my guests from Ireland so I guess that is the best compliment one can get! read more

Causal and comfortable - Cape Cod fried food with an Asian twist. There are other things on the menu, but this is a great place for Shrimp and Scallop Dumplings and fried seafood. The dumplings are served in a rich broth and are delicious. The seafood is fresh and fried well. The onion rings are heavily breaded. The service is attentive. read more

Mac's Shack Wellfleet - Shrimp & Scallop Dumplings - Sushi Bars Near Me - Wellfleet, Massachusetts

See all

I would've given this restaurant a higher rating if it was based on my first experience, but sadly tonight's visit was quite a disappointment. The sushi was a bit expensive for what we got. Didn't taste that great. And my swordfish curry was just ok. It was supposed to have sweet potato in the dish but didn't. We planned on dining outside but decided against this because the place was packed. I get it that it's a holiday weekend but the bar area you couldn't move and the outdoor tables were on top of each other. If you care at all about social distancing definitely choose the takeout option. They wouldn't even give us water to go. Said they didn't have take out cups when we saw at the bar there was indeed plastic cups. The first time I came I got the tuna poke and lobster mashed potatoes which were both great so I guess it's hit or miss. read more

Mac's Shack Wellfleet - Lobster mash to go - Sushi Bars Near Me - Wellfleet, Massachusetts

Absolutely incredible! The staff is so friendly and attentive and the food is worthy of a final meal, a great way to go abundantly with a smile. The flavors are savory, from the chowder to the sushi rice. The Toro poke bowl melted in my mouth and the Halibut was the best I have ever had, served over Lobster Mash Potatoes! Oh my goodness! Even my 4 year old mowed down the gluten free chicken strips and fries. I'm not one to photograph food, but after a few bites it was clear that the moment was special and needed to be captured both in core memory and film. Thank you Mac and your restaurant family, you're amazing! read more

Mac's Shack Wellfleet - Half demolished Halibut over Lobstah Mash potatoes and Clam Chowder, yum! - Sushi Bars Near Me - Wellfleet, Massachusetts

This was our first visit. We had dinner and drinks at Mac"s shack and were amazed at how good the food was. We went earlier 5pm so there was no line to get in. As we were leaving there was at least a 1 hr wait for a table. They do not take reservations. We started with the tomato and cheese salad which was terrific. We had a sushi roll called The Kraken. It was perfectly balanced with flavors and textures. OMG. The grilled Sea Bass was also perfectly served on a bed of lentils and peppers. WOW!!!! read more

Great meal and service ... staff was so kind and watched them help an elderly gentleman to his car. makes great drinks highly recommended

Excellent lunch served by gracious staff. Steamers were done to perfection and chowder was delicious.

A must-go for us each time we're on the Cape!! Best oysters/raw bar with extensive sushi selections- fresh and fairly priced for the quality. Wait can be long at times... order drinks and raw bar apps and enjoy while you wait for your table. Cheers! read more

What an interesting place. The quintessential New England summertime spot. The place gets busy, there is a hectic parking lot with an attendant, there is a bar area where you can wait for your table and get oysters and drinks. (You will wait for your table at this no reservation spot) The menu has all of the expected items. Lobsters, local wellfleet oysters, shrimp cocktails, chowders and steamers. But they also tackle things like sushi and Harrissa and curried swordfish. In most cases this leads to catastrophic results, where the restaurant offends multiple cuisines and cultures. But this was not the case, the food was 5 times better than what I was expecting. As a family of four we were able to try all sorts of things. Well we waited the hour for our table, we had the super fresh wellfleet oyster platter, their well cooked and chilled large shrimp cocktail. We then moved on to a two lb lobster for my daughter, some sort of handgrenade sushi thing, their Caesar salad and curry swordfish. The lobster was perfectly cooked, drawn butter, with a side of corn. This was perfect and exceeded expectations in a place of this size. The Caesar salad was well dressed. An addition of a commercial brand bagel chip was genius on a couple of levels. Firstly, it's hard to keep bread at the Beach, so a crisp chip was nice. Second, it introduced the umami bomb of msg. I have a strong opinion about Caesar salad and places that serve boquerones or white anchovy in acid are wrong. I mean maybe you can do a combo of salted and marinated anchovies but, no it's not inventive and you aren't being cutting edge by just using vinegar anchovies. You are removing the very soul of the dish. But, the addition of msg, may have slightly changed my opinion. You still are wrong but, at least you saved some of the umami. But I digress, bagel chips sent me down a rabbit hole whether they meant it or not. We then tried the hand Grenade sushi or whatever it was called. It was some fraken-creation that was probably made with a little TLC and a little bit more THC. It was like a shrimp tempura roll that was topped with spicy scallop salad mixed with fish eggs and eel sauce maybe. Whatever it was, it was over the top and delicious. Deep fried crunchy things with Mayo, fish eggs and a sugar sauce. Capturing the mindful simplicity of zen culture. The swordfish curry was embarrassingly uninspired but this place may have been the whitest place I've been in many years so maybe that tsp of commercial curry Paste in a vat of coconut milk is all they are ready for. It needed lime juice, chile, fish sauce, fresh herb like cilantro or mint, or kaffir. My son's chicken fingers and fries were also maybe the worst version we have ever been served which was strange as it's a family restaurant with many multigenerational tables. A simple fix on the dried out measly offering of chicken fingers seems simple enough. A huge basket of fries with three dried out shriveled things, resting atop. My daughter wanted dessert without even looking I just assumed this would be the type of place that has a chocolate lava cake. Shockingly they did not. Servers were super nice/game face summer mode. Everyone was hustling and I hope clocking loot. I was impressed with how this place ran. It's an impressive operation. I would go back for sure. read more

Great staff. Great food. Warm, friendly. Welcoming BUT more importantly, great ambiance and good food.

Well-prepared, beautifully presented seafood. Great service. Beachy atmosphere. Can't wait to go back!

My favorite love the icecream and it's overall great been going here for forever! And it's always quick!!!

The sushi has completely fallen off. Used to be great and now its tasteless and mushy. The spicy tuna in two of the rolls we got we genuinely we're concerned it was bad. read more

The food and drinks were absolutely delicious. We tried the halibut, bluefish, and tuna hawaiian poke bowl, and everything was phenomenal. We are huge fans of seafood and everything tasted extremely fresh and looked presentable. Drink wise we chose the Da Nang, Mac's Manhattan, and the Orange Blossom, and were impressed with the drinks, and thought the pricing was fair. Overall this restaurant has a great atmosphere and ambiance, and we will certainly be returning the next time we're on the cape! read more

We were so excited about going here, because the food looked pretty good, BUT we were forced to leave because they didn't let us take a car seat frame inside the restaurant. They have weird "policy" against strollers and ours was not even a stroller, but a frame for a car seat, super compact one (and btw there's pleeeenty of room between tables there for any size stroller - we got a table outside under the tent). So they gave us a "choice" - put baby on the ground (not acceptable, it was cold and dirty and not safe) or they give you a chair where your car seat wont even fit. Just very very unpleasant experience with this place...and honestly I've never seen anything like that, and never been treated like that, they are not customer oriented at all. Such a shame! Apparently if you have a baby you aren't welcome there (would give zero star if I could) read more

While in Massachusetts and in Cape Cod we went to Mac's and glad we did. The oysters were great, the clam chowder was amazing and the lobster toast was very good. Being from the South I gotta say that the Ice Tea wasn't that great. But we would go back in a second and I'll just drink water. Great atmosphere and very busy. Try it! read more

Mac's Shack Wellfleet - Great stuff. - Sushi Bars Near Me - Wellfleet, Massachusetts

Enjoyed our first time to Mac's. The food selection was tremendous making it difficult what to choose. The oysters were spot on with that ocean fresh taste. Too bad I only had 1/2 doz. My group picked fried clams and halibut with lobster mash potatoes (Huge chunks of lobster). We enjoyed our beautifully created sushi rolls and hand roll always go better with beer. I suggest the Mac Kolasch super taste & refreshing. I will return again before I return to California excited for my next selection . Good Times! Good Eats! read more

See all

Really underwhelming experience. I would describe the charred octopus flavor as burnt. The plating showed no effort. The fish tacos were not very good, and it came unassembled with the tortillas sticking together. If I wanted to put tacos together I would make them at home. Also, the rice in a scallop dish was hard, undercooked. Other reviews say the raw seafood is good, I definitely would not recommend the meals prepared by the kitchen. Service was okay at best. Dont sit inside, wasn't impressed by interior. read more

Our server Madeline was so great! Excellent service, delicious gluten free options with a contentious approach to allergies, and a general great vibe. Fun sushi specials and top notch drinks as well. A Tuesday evening well spent! read more

Mac's Shack Wellfleet - Martini - Sushi Bars Near Me - Wellfleet, Massachusetts

Best place in wellfleet. Food and drinks are always fantastic, never disappointed Everyone I've introduced to this restaurant, has always talked about returning asap read more

Covid-19 phase 2 compliant outdoor lunch under a canopy. We were able to get immediate seating at around 1:30 pm after completing a hike in nearby Cannon Hill, and it was a welcoming oasis where we quenched our thirst and enjoyed a dozen of their famous Wellfleet oysters! The oysters are served with a horseradish cocktail sauce, and a clear spicy broth, and these were so fresh and superbly delicious! I washed mine down with a superlative dry hard cider from the Stormalong Cider Brewery from Sherborn and Leominster, MA. It was strong in ABV and with a dry, almost Champagne-like finish, and the perfect beverage to enjoy with the seafood. I also had their flounder BLT sandwich which included the best and crispiest fries I've had during this pandemic! My only criticism was the small sized flounder fillet in my sandwich, but the flavor of the aioli sauce made me forget this rather quickly. read more

Mac's Shack Wellfleet - Sushi Bars Near Me - Wellfleet, Massachusetts

A long wait for fish. It is a happening place. But ridiculously long time to get in. As for the food it's ok. Fresh yes. But I've had better fish in small shacks in Maine. The oysters were good. Right from the bay. As for the service it is very slow. read more

Mac's Shack Wellfleet - Sushi Bars Near Me - Wellfleet, Massachusetts

See all

This spot is serving take out as well as outdoor dining. I felt very safe with both. This is one of my favorite places on the cape, the fish is always super fresh and they have endless options. I highly recommend the Big Mac (my fav) and the swordfish curry (both still amazing). They also have nice cocktails, the blueberry lemonade is very refreshing. read more

Mac's Shack Wellfleet - Swordfish Curry - Sushi Bars Near Me - Wellfleet, Massachusetts

See all

Worst experience ever. Arrived @ 5:45pm, and told 75min wait. Waited 15 minutes at the line to the bar to order 4 drinks and a shrimp cocktail. After 75 minutes, went to check on reservation and hostess mis typed my cell phone #, told me they texted 40 minutes earlier but it did not go thru. Seated us at 7:15. While being seated, watched the family in front of us leaving having finished dinner. Waited 30 minutes for food. Oysters were very small. Ahi Tuna has so much salt it made my tongue swell. At 8pm, we left. For first timer, spending 300 for this terrible experience, I give it a Zero.ZERO! Avoid this place. Many other Wellfleet restaurants offer a much better experience. read more

Oysters great of course 1199 for 6. Get them to go and head to the end of the docks to a bench. Shucked perfectly. read more

Mac's Shack Wellfleet - Sushi Bars Near Me - Wellfleet, Massachusetts

Great experience overall! We were walking around the area and asked some other walkers for recommendations for a lunch stop. They enthusiastically recommended Mac's Shack as a local favorite. We were pleased to discover the restaurant had converted much of its parking lot into outdoor dining under a beautiful, huge white tent. They even had decorative tables, candles and plants set up inside the tent- very classy vibes. We were seated at a table in the middle of the tent at ample distance from other diners. Very good social distancing here! We're ordered a dozen oysters to begin our lunch and they were excellent: served with a spicy horseradish accompaniment and a sweeter, clearer sauce. Quite tasty. For our entrees my bf ordered a fish sandwich and I ordered a sushi roll. Both of these were good, although our waitress forgot to bring soy sauce with the sushi which was kind of odd and we had some difficulty getting her attention to request some. Food and great atmosphere are the standouts here. Decent selection of beers and some cocktails. The main elements detracting from a full out five star rating are the service and the unfortunate bathrooms which were quite cramped and not very clean. Otherwise, this place was great and we'll definitely be back here on future trips to Wellfleet. read more

See all

I don't usually do that thing of checking Yelp to see what's around, but we were coming through Wellfleet back to Ptown on our way from a hike in Great Island and I did it, came up with Mac's, texted some local friends, who gave it the thumbs up. Although the menu said there were vegan items, usually vegan food from a fish restaurant are just poor consolation prizes for vegans/vegetarians unlucky enough to end up at a fish spot. Not so, Mac's Shack. We had veggie sushi that was lovely, some sides (miso soup, edamame, seaweed salad) that was also quite good, and a chickpea burger with a gluten free bun that was delicious. We took out and they were a little slow, but it was a holiday weekend, and we were just so pleased that this fish place had clearly really thought through pleasing people with plant-based diets. Would unequivocally recommend and would return another time. read more

I've been here a few times, but the first time for the family. Everyone loved it! Oysters, calamari and clam chowder to start and then fish tacos, lobster roll and fish and chips for everyone. Delicious! Even the tent setup for outdoor dining was great! The only downfall were the drinks. They could have been a little bit better, but didn't ruin the experience. read more

I've been to Mac's Shack ever year since it opened, for indoor dining initially and for takeout since 2020. Tonight's takeout was notably worse than the last two summers'. They forgot one item from my order. When I called they quickly issued a refund but didn't apologize. The sushi was tolerable. The fish could have been fresher but was certainly not spoiled. The rice was lousy: flavorless and completely lacking in vinegar. This was the first time I've thrown out the rice portion of chirashi. The sautéed littlenecks were very good but not as good as last summer since they changed the recipe. No sign of any covid precautions when I picked up the food. Because Mac's has such a good track record I'll be back but I'm pretty disappointed. read more