This was one of the best pizzas we have had in a long time! The crust was cooked just right, the amount of toppings were perfect, not too much, but just enough. We did order extra cheese, which was well worth it. Pizza was done at the quoted time. Will definitely be back! read more

Have been an avid Mad Mushroom buyer for years. Just ordered POTM and cheesestix for dinner. Took 1 hour and 45 mins to arrive. I actually called to check in and see if the pizza had left the store or if there was an estimated time for delivery. I was told they they were short staffed and trying to learn a new computer system so they don't know what they are doing and have gotten a lot of complaints today. My issue is with the way I was treated when I asked if there was a way they could see when the pizza left the store and how long it would take to get to me. I then informed the worker that I have a health condition where I cannot eat food that has been out past a certain timeframe and that I have never had that issue in the many years I have ordered from this store (one of the reasons I order from them). That timeframe had passed and I said that I wasn't happy about paying over $50 for a medium cheesestix because I couldn't eat the rest of the food and if there was anything that could be done considering I wasn't given an appropriate wait time. I was passed off to a manager who was ruder than rude to me and told me that it was basically my problem for having health issues and he wasn't going to do anything for me. It's also ironic that during the 8 mins I had to wait on hold to even be able to speak to someone, they were advertising for every available position in the store and the ad said something to the effect of "basically, if you are friendly and can show up to work we want you" yet the few members of the skeleton crew they seem to have didn't give two craps about keeping a loyal customer onboard. read more

Not the best and not the worst pizza spot. It is quite pricey for the quality but it's fairly good pizza. The salad is absolutely not worth it. Paid $8 for a small salad and it wasn't even the correct one that was ordered. The delivery took awhile (about an hour) but a correct time estimate was given. I probably will be ordering from another pizza place in the future. read more

See all

Ordered from here last night at about 620p, and got delivery about 750p. Here is a high and low, but overall not super impressed with their delivery/time to receive order/food temp... Highs Price- wasn't terrible, $11 for a small cheesestick with added pepperoni and two side cups of pizza sauce. Lows- took an hour and a half, was delivered by DoorDash, and when I finally got the food, it was barely warm (the make you tip before you pay, so I should have figured it was DoorDash, but oh well) Overall an unremarkable experience, and I probably won't be ordering delivery again. read more

Mad Mushroom Pizza - Cheesesticks with a little pepperoni and two pizza dipping sauces - Pizza Near Me - Lafayette, Indiana

First off the guy at the front can't listen, couldn't get the order correct after he even repeated back. And we went asking extra items we ordered and he was a douche about it. Learn some customer service skills bud. read more

Mad mushroom on underwood is the best pizza in my opinion in Lafayette. It's like papa John's pizza but taste much better.

We were hungry on the road traveling back down to Indianapolis, and decided to try the Mad Mushroom! The guys working in the kitchen are super friendly and took our order quickly. We got a large half cheese/half mushroom pizza as well as an order of plain wings with ranch. The pizza was delicious! I loved the pizza sauce they use and the cheese was perfectly broiled. We thought the prices were very reasonable for a pizza restaurant. Although not the most welcoming building at first, we had a great experience and will definitely be back if we find ourselves in Lafayette again. read more

Pizza was good, XL sausage and mushrooms on a Friday night, done fast and easy, good and friendly service. Will come back for sure. read more

Listen... is it great pizza? No. Is it the perfect greasy, bready, cheesy dinner after a long day of a long day of hard work? Yes. With the pandemic, they are doing deliveries and takeout, and are pretty fast (we did take out on a week night and it took about 45 minutes to get to my door). The main component of their pizza is the cheese, so if you are a sauce or crust person, you probably won't really be a fan. The cheesy bread everyone recommends is... cheesy, but not anything to write home about. read more

See all

Mad Mushroom's a middle of the road take-out pizza place. No tables available, order-ahead recommended. The pizza wasn't particular notable, but not bad either. The garlic sauce (extra sauces $0.71 each) was very tasty and creamy. On the downside, we included one pizza with no cheese and extra sauce, and ended up with cheese and no extra sauce, which was a problem for the dairy-intolerant folks among us who were supposed to have the pizza for dinner. They did offer to either remake it or give us a credit for next time (which we took) so we'll see if that happens. I wouldn't veto ordering another pizza from Mad Mushroom, but it's not something I'd go out of my way to order again. read more

Delicious food, perfect crust! I had delivery so I can't speak to the restaurant itself but everything about the pizzas was delicious!

Great pizza! Greasy but so tasty. And the cheese bread! Mmmmmmmm. Sadly this location can't deliver to me in West Lafayette but I still order from this location and I drive over there and pick it up. All the staff are great, even late at night. Actually going in the restaurant is a quick in and out process. Always back in my car in 5 minutes or under. read more

Stumbled upon this spot with my husband and son while out on an adventure. Ordered boneless nashville hot wings and a small cheesebread with sausage The wings were great loved them The pizza was decent for chain style pizza.. Typical college food in a college setting.. Cannot complain.. The wings were worth ordered again for sure.. Dont forget the ranch its pretty good.. Skip the cheese sauce.. Not that great read more

I ordered this pizza due to lack of options being open for late night delivery and knowing the chances of it cleaning me out was pretty great. The buffalo ranch pizza was pretty good and after eating over half, it didn't disappoint. Sitting on the toilet questioning my decision making and shaking my head in disgust. read more

Pizza and Breadsticks were amazing! Great food! Service was on point with taking our order and in good time to get our food!

Large order of cheese sticks. Enough said. Always fresh, soft, and enjoyable. Stop by almost every time passing through. Recommend anyone who hasn't tried it to try and enjoy the cheese sticks read more

BEST CHEESY BREAD EVER!!!!! I love the classic cheesy bread with their cheese sauce. My boyfriend prefers ranch/marinara/garlic. I love how fresh the cheesy bread is. I have had their pizza in the past which is good (no complaints but nothing to rave about either) but the cheesy bread is definitely worth every penny. Have stopped twice now on my way to Chicago just to get this! Right off 65 and worth the stop. read more

Mad Mushroom Pizza - CHEESY BREAD!!!!!! - Pizza Near Me - Lafayette, Indiana

Seriously, the breadsticks were a religious experience. I've lived all over the country and I haven't had pizza and breadsticks this good for over 30 years! read more

Ah... Mad Mushroom. One of my favorite pizza places. I have always enjoyed the taste of cheese stix and pepperoni pizza at mad mushroom. But this time the pizza was mildly disappointed. The pizza was way too over cooked. It felt so thin I might as well have gone to pizza king. However, the cheese stix were just fine. I understand the challenges that restaurants have during the Coronavirus pandemic, but Mad Mushroom could do better on monitoring the pizza for sure. Nevertheless I give all my support to this restaurant. read more

Lafayette has not been known for Grinders, if you love subs from local Pizza joint than you have to get a Grinder from Mad Mushroom Pizza! Trust me they are excellent!!! read more

Second time I ordered pizza delivery from them... After 45 minutes of waiting, I called to cancel my order. "Manager" confirmed. 25 minutes later, the delivery guy showed up with a pizza. I told him that I canceled my order, and he asked, "You don't want it anymore?" Duh! But there's still a charge on my credit card! $26 for nothing! I want a refund, or it's going to small claims court! Go ahead and hire some knowledgeable people! And seriously work on your customer service! read more

Placed an order for a medium pizza and it took an hour and a half to be delivered. I called twice to find out where my pizza was. First time told it would be there shortly. Waited 15 minutes, still not delivered. Second call was to ask for a refund. I was told by the person on the phone that he could give me a credit, but not a refund. I explained to the person that I was from out of town and a credit wouldn't be acceptable. Again asked for refund and was told that refund could not be given without permission from owner. I asked to speak to owner or manager, was told that owner was out of town and that i was speaking with the manager. I asked the "Manager" what he was going to do, his reply "your pizza should be there shortly", with attitude. Told "Manager" that the attitude was not appreciated when he replied "I've had a busy night. A hell of a night." Explained to "Manager" that that was not my fault and didn't appreciate the attitude. Customer service was terrible and their website lied about fast delivery. read more

I used to order from Mad Mushroom after having a particularly bad or stressful week at work. An emotional breakdown is the only way to rationalize consuming that much fat and calories. The pizza sucks, but the cheesy bread is delish! read more

I am from Chicago, IL and a huge pizza fan. I eat alot of pizza and I can tell you this pizza palor is one of the better pizzas I had in Lafayette. I tried a few local pizza places down here and was in depair because they were all nasty until I got a magnet at a party for Mad Mushroom. I love this pizza, it was so yummy even the day after. the crust is wonderfully soft and the garlic butter sauce that is put in the box is a perfect dipping sauce ... thank you Mad Mushroom for bringing me joy in this little town :) read more

I have to say, my expectations for pizza are not high. I lived in New York for two and a half years (and miss the pizza badly), but I am not hard to please. However. There is no excuse for sweet tomato sauce on a pizza. The thin crust pizza was so sweet that our pizza-loving 13-month-old wouldn't finish even half her piece. The cheese amount was good, but there was a sad lack of toppings on the everything pizza. It was also doughier than I like. read more

I had high hopes for this place when I first ordered. I had Chicken Bianco. The box was soaking wet and I couldn't tell if it was a pasta or soup. Threw the whole thing away. Waste of my money. I'm never ordering from here again. Disgusting. read more

Mad Mushroom Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lafayette, Indiana

See all

Best cheese sticks ever. Grinders are good also. Pizza is so so. Depending on which one you call the staff can be nice or really rude. At Purdue they are jerks and off campus they generally are friendlier. Can not say enough about the yummy cheese sticks. So freaking yummy read more

Ordered here after reading reviews I have to say fastest Hottest food EVER..my wings was SO hot I could not pick them up Right out the fire...pizza SAME..HOT VERY TASTY dipping garlic butter is BOMB...YOU CAN'T GO WRONG ORDER THIS PIZZA STOP WASTING TIME IT'S GREAT. read more

I had high hopes based on a recommendation from the hotel. However the pizza and cheese sticks were delivered at room temperature. You could tell it had been a while since it left the store. I received an email that the order was out for delivery 5:24pm and yet the driver showed up at the hotel around 5:50pm. If your going to charge 28 bucks for pizza and sticks, at least try to make sure it shows up somewhat hot. read more

Ordered online a salad and cheesesticks. Marinara and ranch for the sauces. After an hour, they deliver. Open up the cheese sticks, no sauce. Called the restaurant, the man who answered was very apologetic, said they have been busy and he'd send them right out. 50 minutes go by, call again and ask. A girl states, they are still on the way. Mind you this is about 10 minutes away (just lazy and wanted delivery for the night). 10 minutes later (an hour after I called about the sauces) a girl who sounded exactly like the one who answered (which makes me think they had forgotten) came and apologized for the long wait. We had to reheat the cheese sticks in the oven because after an hour of waiting they were not warm anymore. Open up the bag, and they gave marinara and cheese sauce! They didnt even send the correct sauce!! I called back to let them know they had messed up AGAIN, and the guy on the phone did not apologize whatsoever just said, ok I will let them know. Yes it's something simple, but to me its very poor customer service. Will not be ordering from here again. read more

Went there after a coworker recommended the cheesy bread and grinders. They messed up our cheesy bread (how do you mess that up?). Told us sorry and remade it. So we waited a little longer! Cheesy bread was really good, but can't say much for the grinders. I had Italian with so much mayonnaise on it, that it squished thru the top bun. You couldn't even taste the meat for all the mayo on it. Also bread was plain, no flavor! My husband had the Roast beef and cheese, with sooooooooo much mustard. Not much flavor, other than the taste of mustard. I guess they like using condiments! Lots of employees hanging around, not real sanitary for food prep. read more

I live 5 minutes away from this mad mushroom and ordered delivery, after waiting over an hour i called the store and the driver couldn't find my apartment, i told the person that took my order to make sure the driver calls me, i call the manager and he tells me he is trying to find my apartment and i told him it is extremely hard to find and that's why i wanted him to call, the manager told the driver didn't have a phone? Why would you deliver anything and not have a phone? Why would you hire a pizza delivery driver that doesn't own a phone, extremely poor management and extremely poor career choice for the driver, on top of telling the manager my thoughts on it being a hour and a half since i ordered he started being a smart ass, and i immediately told him to cancel my order and credit back my credit card, lesson learned, plus secondary lesson, NEVER pre tip your driver on your credit card read more

Call order a pizza, get told it'll be 30-40... Call after an hour of waiting. Told the pizza would still be fresh, 20 more min, I receive pizza. Cheese has harden and the pizza is warm at best! Thanks for the let down guys! read more

Was getting decent quality food at good prices, but never again. Either them or their delivery service decided to send my order far away from where I live. No apology, explanation, nothing other than the one hour+ I had already waited it was going to be another 30 minutes. More than that had come and gone. Cancelled the order and I really don't think I am doing business with them any more. read more

Not bad service, and the cheesesticks are excellent. The pizza and sandwiches are mediocre, needed perhaps a bit more flavor as it's somewhat bland compared to the competition, but big kudos for the late hours for those of us who work nights! read more

Based solely on cheese sticks!!!! We made a stop before basketball game. Had a couple beers and cheese sticks. Simply delicious

Every pizza I have tried from this place has been yummy. They have a crazy big delivery area too and at least one of their delivery guys is totally cute. If only I could remember his name. Oh well. read more

We just happened to find this pizza place on. Yelp as we drove thru Indiana wow. It was amazingly good. Hit the spot. I will go there again. Fast service. And. Great price I also found it refreshing to see the young people managing this place do it so well. Good luck to them read more

I did not get the breadsticks ;). I know it's a big deal there, but I took a chance. Let me begin by saying I lived in NY for a couple of years and now I'm a pizza snob. I discovered Marco's near campus and it's pretty good, but they've been closed for almost a month due to a, hmm, "technical violation". So I gave this place a chance--and a chance it was considering when I called I was on hold for at least 5 minutes before I hung up and called again. I ordered a small pepperoni and a small Gouda spuds pizza (I'm not really a gourmet pizza person so this was a chance). I wound up waiting 10 minutes AFTER the 25 they suggested on the phone, and the guy told me I was getting a med pepp because he made that by accident. But when he told me the total was $20 I thought for sure I must be paying for his mistake. When I finally got my pizza (and it didn't seem like they had that many orders, though there were at least 4 guys there) it was a small cheese and a med spuds. Come on guys! Anyway the Gouda spuds was good, but no Gouda taste. It was just a mozzarella, cheddar, potatoes (and mostly they'd all gone to the middle of the square cut pizza), bacon, ham, and onion. I think I was supposed to get ranch for dipping, but that didn't happen. It would been good. The cheese was pretty bland and a bit greasy and oversauced, but I don't think it was too greasy or too sweet like some of the reviews mentioned. It wasn't a spicy sauce, but it wasn't as sweet as Papa Johns either. Oh, and the pizza was pretty good the next day cold. In the end I would go there again, and definitely get the Gouda spuds, but I'd check the pizza before I left and not be in a hurry. read more

We get pizza at least once a week from Mad Mushroom. I love the regular breadsticks and all the pizzas rock. We have friends come down from up north pretty often and they always make us order pizza from here. read more