Went to try some unique pizzas and ice cream. This place is creative with both their pizza toppings and ice cream flavors. Tried the crab rangoon (my fave), blackberry goat cheese, Nashville hot chicken, and vegan meat lovers pizzas. And couldn't leave without trying the salty vanilla and blackberry goat cheese habanero ice cream. Such a fun experience! It is however a small resistant and gets packed but the employees are so accommodating. Can't wait to go back! read more

See all

Great pizza... worth the price! It ain't Domino's and that's a good thing. I'd eat there again. PS: This was a DoorDash delivery , I did not eat on-site. read more

Loved the pizza! There was a really good crust on it, but just beware the flop is heeeavy. Youll need to support it the whole way down. My brother (congrat grad!) got pepperoni and it looked great, the pepperonis CUP (!!). Mine was the truffle mushroom, and it was good but a little oily for my own preference. The only reason im docking a star was the wait time, it was a little severe. But great service :). Take a box home just for the look of em! read more

Pizza Uncommon - Small Shiitake Mushroom Truffle - Pizza Near Me - West Lafayette, Indiana

See all

Stopped for a quick bite and we were not disappointed! Ordered two small pizzas because we couldn't decide. Sausage and mushroom and a delectable fig jam, goat cheese, arugula, olive oil, mozzarella, sea salt, parmesan, prosciutto and walnuts pizza that was out of this world. These two IU alums will be back, Purdue!! read more

We moved to West Lafayette less than a year ago and had been in search of a truly great pizza. No luck at all until we tried Pizza Uncommon! Holy moly is this fantastic pizza! We ordered the Margherita, the hot honey pepperoni, the fig prosciutto, and a more traditional sausage/pepperoni. Our crowd loved the pizzas. We all loved the delicious crisp crust with a bit of chew. Just wow! Great flavors. The fig prosciutto was everyone's fave with the hot honey pepperoni a close second, but all 4 pizzas were delicious and completely devoured. Highly recommend! We finally found our fave pizza place after 10 months of looking! read more

Easily one of the best pizzas I've tried. The sauce for the Shiitake Mushroom Truffle was rich and creamy. They were very generous with the mushrooms. The dough for the pizza and breadsticks was insanely flavorful and soft. I think on the menu it said the dough ferments for 100 hours. The Doritos Taco Sticks has a strong Doritos flavor and the nacho on top of the breadsticks also has hints of the Doritos flavor. All the ingredients felt really fresh. We also tried the gelato and got the dark chocolate flavor. It was very creamy and reminded me of mousse almost. When ordering gelato, the person behind the counter was so sweet and let us try different flavors. Their strawberry honey and salt and oil gelato were different and I would get that next time. One thing to look out for is that seating is limited, so on a weekend you might have to take your food to go. Overall, the ambiance and service was really nice. Would definitely come back to try all the different pizza flavors. read more

See all

I've ordered from here at least four times. My preference is for pick up instead of delivery since I had some issues with them leaving pizza out on my porch in the cold and not knocking which was frustrating. The best pizza so far is the Vodka Sausage! The flavors burst across the tongue. The combination of the sausage with the vodka sauce makes it easy to finish the whole pizza in one sitting. My mouth is watering just thinking about it and I had it last night! The Lemon Pepper Bianca was an excellent second pizza to order as it was light and fresh, the kick of the pepper and the tangy lemon were exceptional. I wasn't particularly impressed with the Meat Monster or Chicken Bacon Ranch. They were good, but nothing particularly special about them and I wouldn't order them again for the price. Typically I want something more specialized when I order from here. I wasn't as enthused with the Bacon Apple Sausage but I think it just didn't measure up in comparison to the Vodka Sausage. read more

See all

Love the bread sticks here, so many options of flavors. Always suggest this place to my pizza and bread stick loving friends. They recognize phone number when I call my order in. Quite a special place! read more

We had an everything pizza minus green peppers on a Saturday afternoon before Mother's Day. You place your order at the counter, then they bring the pizza to your table. The drinks are by the can or bottle and they have an interesting selection with some unusual drinks along with old standbys. I had my first Pellegrino. The dining area is not too large at this location, but it looked like everyone who wanted a table got one. We both loved the crust, super delicious! We like our pizza with more sauce, but this was still delicious overall. Easy, free parking in the lot outside this strip mall. Oh, and they also have ice cream which we were too full to try. Next time! read more

Pizza Uncommon - Everything pizza minus the green peppers - Pizza Near Me - West Lafayette, Indiana

The pizza is great! Ordered the hot honey pepperonis pizza. Like the sauce and the over all flavor. The dough tastes great. Pick up was fast and service was friendly. Little bit pricy read more

Stumbled upon this gem near the Purdue Campus! We tried the Spicy Hot Honey Pizza and it was an amazing choice! It was honestly SO GOOD!! It had the right amount of sweetness, spice, and just the right amount of crunch. The team in there was extremely helpful and choosing the right busy was hard! Lol read more

See all

I was adventurous and ordered toppings I wouldn't have dreamed of combining on a pizza.... It was absolutely DELICIOUS!!! Sausage, Apple, Arugula with honey drizzle. We tipped over our cherry pizza and the staff was so kind in helping us clean the mess and made a fresh one for us to enjoy. We ate in the restaurant in their small dining room which was clean. All in all a great experience for baby's first outing. Thanks! read more

Pizza Uncommon - Sausage, apple, arugula with honey drizzle! - Pizza Near Me - West Lafayette, Indiana

The best pizza & gelato in Indiana by a long shot. Everything is made from scratch and the flavor combinations will challenge what you thought pizza and ice cream could be. read more

Truly unbelievable pizza. 2nd time ordering. Dragon, Buffalo, Garden and a build your own were phenomenal. 1st time around we had some mix ups with our order resulting in us having pizzas we couldn't eat due to having Ingredients on the pizzas that some members of our family couldn't eat. Reached out to the owner to let them know, they recommended doing build your own instead of notes to remove toppings on the order. Worked this time, pizzas were perfect. Highly recommend using build your own and do not modify an existing pizza, if you end up with an inedible pizza due to them missing your instructions you will be out your money. read more

Great pizza! Love the different speciality pizzas that I prefer but that you can't find in the Lafayette area. Crust was great as were all of the topping flavors. This is definitely my new go-to pizza place. According to their website, this business helps them help kids so it's pizza for a good cause too! read more

Fantastic pizza. I'd like to try all the combos! Went back the next day for gelato which was excellent too.

Amazing! One of the few pizza places I have ever been to in the past decade I would come back to with my own money. I make my own pizzas frequently and feel weird spending big wallet pads for cheap ingredients, compared to other cuisines, even for great service, atmosphere, and unique pies. I can happily say Pizza Uncommon strikes a rare chord for the Lafayette area serving up original dishes and amazing combinations of flavors. We have had two specialty pizzas here now and both treated the tastebuds right. I somehow forgot to write a review in my food coma. Can highly recommend to all especially gluten and dairy free diets, save up and dive in! read more

This place has stolen a place in my heart from the sea salt breadsticks alone. Then, you get to the cherry pie dessert, and I'm realizing I finally know what I'd request for my last meal if ever on death row. Everything was delicious and super fresh. Will definitely be back often. read more

See all

This place has the best pizza I have had in a very long time. All ingredients are fresh and are placed with intent. You have to try the seasonal specials I have tried (2) already both were amazing... super excited to try the others. The service is always with a smile. My spouse is on a Gluten free diet and this place provides a crust that is super fluffy and nothing like we have encountered before. read more

Highly recommend visiting if you're a fan of pizza!! The options are so unique and creative. I opted for a more basic vodka sausage pizza, which was very tasty and not too oily! My bf got the Elote pizza which had a kick to it, but overall really good. The pizzas ate pretty expensive, so it's more of a splurge meal but I'd go again to keep trying the new flavors! read more

Pizza Uncommon - Vodka Sausage - Pizza Near Me - West Lafayette, Indiana

See all

I went to this location for dinner on a Friday night a month ago thinking it was a sit-down restaurant but we ended up being the only people eating in the restaurant for the whole time we were there. Meanwhile, there were at least 15 to-go orders. It's not a sit-down restaurant for sure: you order up at the front, there are no servers, and you don't even receive glasses of water or anything. This was something that just wasn't communicated well on the website or at the restaurant itself. The pizza itself has a nice crispy crust and compelling flavor. There are plenty of vegetarian options on the menu, and we got the Lemon Pepper Bianca and the Elote Pizza. The Elote was a personal favorite for us. However, the awkward experience of dining in an empty restaurant while trying to eat pizza without having anything to drink kind of ruined it for me. I was seriously so parched after I left the restaurant. read more

Pizza Uncommon - Elote - Pizza Near Me - West Lafayette, Indiana

See all

Pizza is the best in Tippecanoe county. It's our #1. Where's the beer tho?! I really want a cold beer when I'm eating pizza. I prefer a good Italian lager (Peroni) if I may suggest. Anyway, the only drawback for me. Otherwise pizza is a 5 star, solid. read more

Located at the end of a strip mall, Pizza Uncommon lives up to its tag line "uniquely crafted". They change their menu frenquently and offer an amazing number of pizzas. It is a simple but fun interior. Not a high end restaurant but a great gourmet pizza. I had the Everything - which includes their made in house sausage. I will come back to try some of the more adventurous offerings. read more

Pizza Uncommon - Pizza Near Me - West Lafayette, Indiana

Seriously, the best pizza in the Greater Lafayette area. The crust is just divine. We live over 40 minutes away, but it's worth the drive each and every time. read more

Pizza Uncommon replaces a chain pizza store that occupied this small strip mall location. The staff were friendly and provided good communication. Higher prices but this is craft pizza and lots of ingredients. There is a seating area but during my visit everyone was there for take away orders. Lots of unusual combinations. I like the personalized service and friendly staff. The dough appears to be made on site. My only complaint is there was burnt flour or cornmeal on bottom of pizza. Not a big deal. Not sure if the oven needs swept out or adjustment of dry flour/cornmeal in the final stage of recipe. I will order Pizza Uncommon again, likely for special celebrations when "common" pizza won't do. read more

See all

The crust of their pizza is soooo good! I would definitely come back for the cheese sticks and margarita pizza! read more

Unique pizza toppings and sauces, also has a lot of vegan options, crust is very good, the breadsticks and wings are definitely oversalted though. read more

Love their pizza dough! It's nice and doughy and full of flavor. I've tried a bunch of their pizza flavors like the dragon, hot honey pepperoni, and sweet chick, and hot honey has got to be my favorite. Their wings are pretty good too and I appreciate how they actually are pretty spicy! Mango habanero is my favorite and the buffalo one is not bad. read more

Pizza Uncommon - Hot Honey Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - West Lafayette, Indiana

1st time in area and saw excellent reviews of the pizza spot close to campground State Park. Ordered on line it allowed us to pay and give tip on line before arrival. The order was acknowledged and we were given a pickup time 1 Hour 15 minutes. We arrived to a very busy place. Wife went in and used rest room said it was nice and clean. She said the pizza was ready on time given via on line order. The pizza and bread sticks were cooked to order and order was correct and hot. Next time we would have them hold the salt on the bread sticks. The dough was made in- house. Would highly recommend giving Pizzauncommon a try when in area. read more

We had take out which of course with pizza is never as good as fresh out of the oven. That said it was good, the crust being the star. We have the vodka sauce with sausages which was ok but in my opinion not saucy enough a little too salty and lacking in sausage. That said the crust tastes like real artisan dough. Great flavor and crispness. another plus is the unusual selection of toppings if that's your thing. Would I order again? Maybe but only if I was eating in. read more

Rely liked this place. We had excellent service, prompt product, very interesting and "uncommon " menu, and you need that because how many times can you do pizza? Wings were gigantic and the mango habanero had the right competition of heat and sweet. My pizza was the Thai and I loved it. Will be back and want to try their desert pizzas. Also have a good selection of craft beer. read more

Very good pizza. We had the pepperoni and it was solid. Probably the best option in the area, so if you are visiting this should be your first option. read more

My wife and I did a short RV trip to Madison. We were looking for a casual dinner and decided on pizza. My wife has many food sensitivities which include tomatoes and cheese which makes pizza normally almost impossible. She was thrilled to see they offered olive oil as a sauce and a vegan cheese. We each had a small pizza. The crust was amazing, airy but with a good chew. We read about the company's mission and that made us even happier about our decision to have our meal at this restaurant. I recommend if your looking for pizza this is the place to go. read more

Delicious pizza .. the wings were so good . I enjoyed every bite of my food . The waitress she was so welcoming and very energetic . I could feel she loves what she is doing . Def go back again read more

See all

I'm a fan of untraditional pizza, various pizzas and vegan options to choose from, we ordered the honey garlic chicken, dorito taco pizza, and Alfredo Cajun chicken pizza. Honey garlic was my favorite, the rest of the group preferred the Doritos. Would highly recommend. read more

My new fav pizza place!! I love the unique toppings and you can make your own too. The crust is amazing and we enjoyed the wings as well. We'll be back! read more

See all

I said we would give this place another try, and I'm so glad we did. The next time I placed an online order, the owner recognized my name from Yelp (eek!) and offered to give me a gift card when I picked up. I insisted it wasn't necessary, but I did appreciate the offer. He also said that after reading my previous review he held a training day for the staff to ensure quality control. That really impressed me. But ... how would the pizza taste this time? In a word, excellent. Both of our pies were perfectly cooked and not overdone. This time we tried the Cuban Cobb and the Sweet Piggy. Both were delightful. Garlic cheesy sticks were awesome, again. Although reading other reviews ... it looks like burnt crusts are still an issue. Guess we got lucky this time. read more

If you're looking for gluten-free pizza, or interesting pizza in general, this is the place to go in the Lafayette area. The service is great and the pizza is amazing. Unfortunately they close surprisingly early for a pizza place, but so does everywhere else in town. Ever since finding this place shortly after they opened, whenever we order pizza it's Pizza Uncommon. Disclaimer: My wife is celiac but doesn't have any near-term reaction to gluten, so if you react violently to gluten then our experience may not be a good indication of your experience. That said, I believe the owner told me at one point that he has a celiac family member and takes it seriously. read more

This is hands-down the BEST gluten free pizza and breadsticks I've ever had. My husband has celiac and hasn't bit into a chewy thick crust of a pizza in 6 years. It DOES EXIST! Amazing! Tonight was our third visit. We had specialty breadsticks (as our pizza) with BBQ, bacon, and Pulled pork--better than most regular gluten filled crusts! Wow, wow, wow--this is an undiscovered gem in West Lafayette. If you eat gluten free, once you've tried these breadsticks, you won't miss gluten again! I can't wait to support this family-owned business again, as proceeds go toward helping them adopt! read more

Over all, not a bad pizza. Definitely better than Pizza Hut or domino's, but needs a little refinement. The reviews about the burnt crust are correct. On ours, the bottom itself was burnt by the rest of the crust was cooked well. The crust, bizarrely, tasted like burnt Einstein's bagels. It is definitely cheese heavy. We got a custom pizza with pineapples and red onions with regular sauce. The pineapple was too large and canned, or at least notably sugared, which was disappointing. If it wasn't burnt it would be the best pizza in town-cheese heavy, but not greasy, with a lot of flavor. They need to figure out the cook times before we go back again. read more