We went looking for a late lunch and my son has heard good things about this place. So we decided to try their pizza. We all ordered 10" personal pan pizzas and each tried something different. Two of us loved our pizzas and the others said theirs were good. Each pie came with a pizza server. You can place an order with the cashier or kiosk. Spacious restaurant with bar, booth and table seating. There is street parking nearby. Service was friendly and pizza came out hot and fresh. We were looking forward to some gelato but unfortunately their freezer out of service. Love that they offer a vegan menu and gluten free options! Prices are a bit on the higher end but worth it. read more

See all

Came in last night for dinner for the first time. Pros - Restaurant is nice with fun, relaxed vibe - Clean - Speed of service (from time of order at counter to food, only took about 25 minutes) - Quality- dough is pretty solid, with a light and airy texture. - Girl working at the "bar"/taking orders was SUPER friendly. To Know Before Going - A bit on the pricy side for what you get, but not bad, as it is $16 for a 10" or $25 for 14". Could be worse, could be better. - They do have a "Build Your Own" option, but also a ton of "pre-built" ideas read more

Pizza Uncommon - Meat Monster pizza with sausage, pepperoni cups, and ham - Pizza Near Me - West Lafayette, Indiana

See all

The best pizza in Lafayette by far if you like unique and authentic crust cooked to perfection! The bread sticks are delicious the service top rate, for carry out! We eat here whenever we are in the mood for pizza, we had tried many other restaurants and establishments in and around Lafayette and for the price and quality there is no comparison for us, this is the best!! And even some of the craziest combinations are delicious!! Love read more

Wow! So happy we ate dinner at Pizza Uncommon while visiting Purdue. Top 3 pizza place I have ate at. Love the bright and airy inside of the restaurant. Very clean and modern and cute inside. You order at the counter, get a number, and pick your own table. We had the Dragon, Thai chicken, pepperoni breadsticks and a pepperoni pizza. Everything was phenomenal. Highly recommend a cup of marinara and garlic butter sauce if you like sauces like me. That garlic butter sauce is soooo yummy. My husband loved the Dragon pizza. The crust is excellent. Crispy and chewy. They do not skimp on toppings. An employee brought out everyone at our table a water, real plates, and napkins. I hope to be back one day if we are ever in town again. I also had the coffee gelato after our meal and it was really good as well. read more

See all

I was reminded again how bad the prices were and how slow the service was and decided to bring this review down even more. $24 for carry out. For HALF a portion of cheese sticks and the smallest plain cheese pizza they serve. They didn't deliver it, the portions weren't huge, and the was no special gimmick. Oh my lord, it actually hurt to pay for this. read more

Pizza Uncommon - $24 worth of a personal plain cheese Small and a half portion of Garlic Cheesy Sticks :( - Pizza Near Me - West Lafayette, Indiana

I love their pizza so much. I'm honestly kinda addicted to it. I crazy their honey pepperoni pizza. And we had their spring pizza and it was so good. And I also had their salted vanilla gelato and it was delicious! Seriously love their food so much. read more

Pizza Uncommon - Spring pizza/ Hot Honey Pepperoni - Pizza Near Me - West Lafayette, Indiana

The food was good but it was expensive for pizza. It was nice to try something different. I wasn't there to see the service or ambiance of the place. read more

Woww best pizza place around Purdue! We ordered the Hot Honey Pepperoni and Dragon which were amazing. The honey pep combo was perfect and the cheese was so melty. The crust was perfectly crispy too. The Dragon was very spicy but so unique and flavorful. The service was so friendly and attentive!! We got the ice cream too and my favorite was the Cold Brew flavor. So happy to have this addition to Purdue area. Delicious pizza and ice cream and will be back to try the other flavors! read more

See all

LOVE pizza uncommon! They have a variety of pizzas to try and I always get something different and it always tastes soo good. Even though it is a little bit expensive, the food is so worth it. The location is very convenient, and the service is incredibly fast. Even when I go home, I am always craving their pizzas. read more

Great pizza, ambiance is nice and service is great. I like the flavors a lot and they had a good selection.

Insanely expensive and well out of the average for the basic chain addicts, but with a little saving up and Self-Curating the menu, this is instantly the best take on the Italian pie in the whole area. Area. They opened up a campus location, parking is dumb, best to try Chauncey and walk right down. This is a lovely open atmosphere with industrial flair all over. A massive cement bar accents the ordering area from the bygone State 19 bar. The menu is very easy to read, plenty to treat all the finicky taste buds. My sister and I have dabbled around all of the goods here and can hardly fall anything except for the weird uncut arugula. I highly recommend they start chopping up the greens to better eat as well as some other toppings that constantly fall off immediately pulling out a piece. That would also help many pizzas not look like a salad. I'd like to see a good rewards program synced with Toast or similar to ease the big dollar signs. Teays and Black Sparrow are the only others to compete in the proper pizza dough, value is the main difference. When paying myself, I personally pick AJs, Town and Gown, and Noodles and I for the university restaurants however always happy to join and highly recommend Pizza Uncommon for the top tier. read more

See all

The taste is like none other and fantastic! Expensive but worth it. It overtook hotbox as our top pizza.

Wow! They have great regular and vegan options here. The garlic pepperoni vegan breadsticks and ranch were incredible as was the Meat Monster. A delicious vegan option for those craving this food coupled with more traditional pizza. Yum. Super nice staff. read more

Pizza Uncommon - Vegan breadsticks - Pizza Near Me - West Lafayette, Indiana

See all

A cute pizza place close to campus with a lot of unusual and unique options. The gelato was also delicious. read more

Pizza Uncommon - Pizza Near Me - West Lafayette, Indiana

See all

The best pizza & gelato anywhere near Purdue and beyond. Insane flavor combinations that will challenge what you thought. Pizza and Ice Cream could be. read more

Waited 10 minutes at the counter before anyone even addressed us. Pizza was ice cold.

My husband and I stopped by for a bite to eat and we were impressed! We had half lemon chicken pesto and half vodka sausage. The lemon chicken pesto was or favorite! They definitely nailed it on the presentation as well. Super delicious! The vodka sausage also had a yummy sauce! The staff was really nice and the manager Trent made sure we had a nice meal. He walked us through the different flavors of gelato and gave us some food recommendations! I really like the salt and oil gelato mixed with the cold brew. Delicious! Also wanted to mention the beautiful mural on the wall. The vibe was really laid back and modern. Super cool. We will definitely be back! read more

Pizza Uncommon - Vodka Sausage and Chicken Lemon Pesto - Pizza Near Me - West Lafayette, Indiana

Yum! We walked around Purdue then needed something to eat for dinner. We ended up walking to Pizza Uncommon and it did not disappoint. We got gluten free garlic cheese sticks and hot honey pepperoni gluten free pizza. It was so good! I would definitely come back if I am in Lafayette. It did seem expensive for a 14 inch pizza (25 dollars) with a 4 dollar charge for gluten free crust on both the breadsticks and pizza. We didn't save room for dessert but if we did there was ice cream in the same building. They had good service, the pizza took awhile to come out but the breadsticks were quick which gave us a nice snack. The inside is actually fun with some bright colors and fun booths! read more

Pizza Uncommon - Pizza Near Me - West Lafayette, Indiana

See all

By far some of the most unique flavors I've had at a restaurant at Purdue. I had a half Elote, half Honey Blackberry pizza and it was sweet, savory, tangy, crispy, creamy, fruity, spicy, and more - all in one! You would be hard-pressed to find anywhere with this combination of flavors and textures, let alone at a pizza restaurant. The people were extremely nice and went out of their way to make sure I was happy with my meal. If you're in town, I cannot recommend Pizza Uncommon enough! read more

Pizza Uncommon - Half Elote, half Honey Blackberry pizza - Pizza Near Me - West Lafayette, Indiana

A hip little spot in a great location with incredible customer service and if you can believe even better pizza!! My husband and I stopped on a whim as we were driving through town. We ordered some perfectly chilled XXX Root Beer, followed up with the jalapeño bacon breadsticks with marinara and cheese sauce, they came out quick and looked divine and somehow still exceeded my expectations with how delicious they were. Lastly we got the Hot Honey Pepperoni 14" pie, and boy oh boy, the ratios were all perfect, the crust was out of this world, overall a 100/10! We will be coming back anytime we are in town! read more

See all

Delicious spot, cute atmosphere and such a fun variety of unusual combinations. Favorite was the mushroom truffle and the vodka sausage pizza. We also tried the crab rangon which was interesting but not our favorite. read more

My son is a student at Purdue and I'm not sure now if I'm traveling to Indiana for him or for the pizza! Okay, it's for him but the pizza is a highlight. I have celiac so finding a pizza place I can actually eat is amazing. The wait is long but definitely worth it. read more

I loved my entree. I took my girlfriend here for a casual dinner and we got to order our own customizable pizzas. We both devoured our 10 inch pies super quickly! There was a bit of a wait but the place was relatively busy. They had a very cute vibe going on with their lighting and seating. I tried their blueberry soda which turned out to be amazing!! read more

Crab Rangoon pizza!!!! That would be all I would say but I need to type more for the review, so just go there and get it, you won't be disappointed. read more

Great pizza in a fun space! The menu is full of imaginative combinations. We loved the Honey Apple Sausage pizza. The crust is crispy with the right amount of chewiness. They have a great variety of craft sodas and kombucha. I was too full to try the housemade gelato, will need to make a trip back just for that. This is the perfect spot for Purdue parents to treat their kids to a meal. Service was friendly and helpful. read more

This was a great little pizza place we visited while touring Purdue. Creative pizzas. Great service.

The flavors of the pizzas are super delightful and fun. We had such a hard time choosing. The girls working the register were sweet and helpful and the food was brought to our table so warm and fresh. Only thing is the crust was a little burnt. read more

Horrible service - no acknowledgment when you walk in. Takes 10 minutes to get your order taken. The free water isn't worth it. This is my second time here and last because I believe the service should be as good as the food. read more

Pizza Uncommon - No one ever works only the front. - Pizza Near Me - West Lafayette, Indiana

Really good pizza, atmosphere not conducive to eating in. Although pizza was excellent they did not promote people to eat in. That could be better. read more