Wife and I just moved to the area and are trying to check out all the local places. This one unfortunately missed the mark pretty big. Might be tempted to give it a second chance but it'll be awhile. We both got a meal and a drink and it came to $35 so already not off to a great start. There were only 2 other people eating inside but it took 40 minutes to get our food. A lot, a lot of to go orders, but still, expected some kind of priority for dine in. The cashier and the woman who brought our food said a quick apology , but that was about it. My wife didn't finish her food, took it home just to toss it out. She got the Italian sub and pickle fries. The sub was incredible dry according to her. I took a bite and thought it was extremely lackluster for the price point. It definitely could have used mayo, oil, vinegar, etc though. The pickle fries were okay, very crunchy but decent flavor. I got a specialty menu item that was a 1/2 pound burger with various toppings and fries. There were so many fries I could barely see my sandwich. However, the fries were cold, despite the long wait... and unseasoned entirely. They reminded me of fair fries which isn't the end of the world but some salt would have been nice. The burger was very good and I enjoyed it, my wife also liked it but unfortunately that didn't make up for 3/4 of our order not being very good and taking a long time. Also a note that it is VERY loud inside. Phone ringing off the hook. Clanking of the spatulas on the grill. Some games next to the booths. Definitely not a quiet place. We were very disappointed with this visit and hope next time is better, if there is one. read more

Magic Subs and Gyros - Fast Food Near Me - Barberton, Ohio

One of a kind, family owned and community oriented business. Food (robust flavor, generous portions) and service was impeccable. We especially enjoyed the house made hummus and sauces, gyros, magic philly and the crispy coke. We topped it all off with a slice of the magic cheesecake - a must read more

See all

Great overall place to eat in or take out. Awesome family runs the place. Service was friendly and great conversation. Food all fresh and plentiful along with a very reasonable price. I tried the gyro, Hawaiian and the antipasto salads and the larges which allows for another meal the next day. Will come back again and highly recommend it. read more

Fries were simply amazing. Perhaps ranking with the best ever. My Italian sub was fresh, meaty and good flavor. Perhaps better sub buns would improve the experience. Very friendly family run business. read more

Small place with giant quality food. Excellent personal service. We loved our food. If you order anything large size, expect leftovers read more

The food was delicious the service was fast and polite had no problem it really hard to add eighty's five words

We were disappointed with our sandwiches. Another patron asked if we thought our food was good because he didn't think it was good either. Seems to be a good local place aside from that. read more

Had never been here before. Nice looking super clean restaurant. We got steak subs. I'd give them 6 stars if I could. Going back today for Gyros. read more

The service was quick and everyone seemed pleased to be serving. I ordered a rueben and it was huge not too salty, and one of if not the best rueben I have ever had. The dining area was comfortable and nicely decorated. The building has memories for me going back to when it was built as a donut shop and one of my friends worked there. read more

Why this place doesn't have a line out the door is beside me! Food is amazing. The place is small but hot damn if that Rueben doesn't make you smile after you eat it your just really depressed. 10/10. 5 Stars. 100%. Grade A. GO EAT HERE. read more

Had the Houdini, grilled. Fast,friendly service. The sub was absolutely awesome! Give them a try, they don't disappoint!

The food was amazing!! Will definitely go back. Everyone was very friendly. I got the gyro salad and my husband got the Major sub. The ingredients were very fresh. read more

Stopped here after watching a review on Tik Tok. We really enjoyed it and will return. We never heard of this place! Houdini sub was great and our friends really enjoyed the steak sub. Location is now on Wooster Rd. Hopefully the TikTok review brings more people here because this place is a gem. read more

Tucked away next to the convenience store on 5th st. Form the out side, it might make you think twice about going in, don't let the cover fool you. What's inside is what matters. I walked in and was promptly greeted by the Gal running the register. She asked what would like to order and I went with the regular sized Gyro and the cheese jalapeño poppers. They have the regular and large Size gyro, unless you're really really hungry, I would get the large. The regular gyro is more then enough food, I couldn't even finish my poppers due to the regular gyro, it was too much for me. Gyro comes with one container or tatziki sauce, not enough, ask for a 2nd one. Overall the food here is awesome and definitely be back for more. read more

See all

Fantastic subs, great customer service too. I ordered a small Italian and they accidentally gave me a large. It was HUGE. And great prices too. read more

This my new favorite sub and gyro place! You will not get a better sub, or gyro for the price. The magic sub (Philly cheesesteak, half steak half chicken) is so crazy good. read more

I have ordered this place three times through door dash and they are quickly becoming my favorite place to order. Their Italian subs are chefs kiss. The chicken Philly amazing . Fries like carnival fries . Potato teezers spicy but delicious. Reuben to die for. This place is top notch!!! read more

I heard about this new joint in town and wanted to check it out. We have plenty of fast food, Chinese, Mexican, Greasy Spoons and Chain restaurants in and around town. This place was something different. It was popping up amongst all my local FB friends' pages. It must be good. Out and about a few days later my husband suggested we give it a try. Let's just say, we weren't disappointed at all. What a refreshing and yummy change of pace. And, the best parts, local and run by locals. Always support local small businesses. It keeps communities going and forms lasting foundations. So, onto our experience. We found the location easily. It is well marked. Walking into the establishment, you will find a new, clean, and well lit friendly atmosphere. The menu is simple. Items are priced and displayed for easy decision making. The display case of sauces, salads and dessert is well lit, well organized and clean. The work station and cooking area was clean and well kept. Now, onto the food. Gyros, subs, salads, appetizers and baklava. That's it. But believe me when I say less is more. The portions sizes are incredible. The food itself is top notch. Your order is made right in front of you. The quality of the products used is superior. Fresh, fresh, fresh. If you leave here without trying something, you are missing out big time. If you leave here hungry, you are a bottomless pit or have a hollow leg lol. The baklava.....OMG!! It is out of this world delicious. It is perfection to the max. The staff is warm and welcoming. Local people making our community tastier for sure. They are a breath of fresh air. Just what Barberton needed. Something different. Something unique. Just like the Magic town itself. Well done! Why are you still sitting there?? Get in your car and get there now! You won't be disappointed. Be sure to tell the staff you heard about their establishment on Yelp. read more

See all

Delicious and great price. Adding toppings is only a quarter instead of $2 like other places. Friendly and fast.

Fries weren't done , super greasy Philly cheesesteak sub and watery tasteless ranch .

Great food. friendly. Fast service. Plenty of food for the order. Great prices. Helps with the community. Supplies jobs for people willing to work. Really good family. read more

Whenever I crave a local gyro, I always come here! Great gyros, quick service & friendly people!!

This is my new go to when in Barberton. First of all the food is delicious, and the restaurant is clean. The staff has been friendly too. They have fresh Gyros and lots of other choices too. They offer fresh salads, yummy desserts and even kids meals for the kiddos. read more

See all

First time eating here and was very impressed with how everything was made and prepared fresh! My sub was hot and the staff was a joy! Highly recommend the Magic Philly with chipotle sauce on it! read more

Went with my son and hubby. The gyro was delicious and with no shortage of meat. My husband ordered the philly steak and could barely finish it. It was huge! Will return read more

I get a gyro here pretty much once a week. The restaurant is clean, the service is super fast and friendly and the food is great! 10/10 -- will return next week read more

Best value and portion size in town. Really cant beat it. Get the philly.

i read the reviews about this place on facebook,& was impressed with the good reviews,so,while me & my mom were out driving one sunny afternoon,i asked her if she was hungry.she said yes,& i saw the magic subs sign,so,i figured i'd check them out. the only thing that sucked about the place was the subs themselves!!!! you get more meat on your sub at subway!!!! giant eagle's pre-made homemade subs are also wayyyyyyy better!!!! i WILL NEVER go here again!!!! plus,the mom and her teenage daughters ,who no doubt,own the place,obviously felt the need to settle some domestic squabble,was more important than taking my order. the sub even tasted bland!!!! you guys want to stay in business much longer,you better act accordingly,& remember to wait on the customer WHEN YOU SEE THEM!!! and,have someone ELSE make the subs from now on!!!! read more

Tried their large gyro for lunch last week. It was Huge! Prices are good, portions are large & it tasted great. Highly recommended.