I ordered a Sterling special with hamburger. It came out excellent Great cheese, pool and all of the ingredients taste great the service was quick and fast. when walking in you get ment with the most loving people, people here and so kind and welcoming, also very excellent clean job, and kitchen always looking great read more

Magpye's Pizzeria - Pizza Near Me - Sterling, Alaska

See all

Great place Great food Amazing staff Always love this place and will go back every time I get a chance read more

Lots of different options on the menu Good home cooked food blots options. Very generous portions Weekly specials lol s to choose from. Pizza pastas burger egg rolls and deserts Kind & courteous staff. Good local spot here in Sterling. read more

Our cabin host suggested this place so I took my family here DESPITE seeing the Confederate Flag flying outside their restaurant. As soon as we walked in, the waitress told us that we wouldn't be served for over an hour because they're busy. We noticed that the restaurant wasn't quite full and that they had tables. Fine. Maybe they were short staffed that day. BUT we came out with mixed emotions because of what they chose to represent. read more

Magpye's Pizzeria - Confederate Flag - Pizza Near Me - Sterling, Alaska

See all

We routinely get take out from here as we just moved right down the road. It's always delish and the staff is great!

We decided to go into this establishment with an open mind even after seeing the confederate flag display outside, that was a big mistake. As soon as we walked in, there was an awkward feel and awful ambiance. The waitress was rude and we decided to take our business elsewhere after a terrible interaction with her. Do not go here. We should have known better then to step foot in this establishment and glad we did not stay. Save yourself and go just 12 minutes down the road to Soldotna. There is a nice brewery with amazing pizza just down the road. read more

Magpye's Pizzeria - Do not go here! The outside of this establishment says it all. - Pizza Near Me - Sterling, Alaska

Food was great! Disregard the confederate flag reviews as they are ignorant. Service was just as good as any other "decent" places. Considering this is the only pizza joint and good one with that in sterling is awesome. Not only that I prefer small businesses first! Highly recommend! read more

Food is great, service is great, atmosphere is great! A must try- have a beer and get to know the awesome locals who are so welcoming at this unique chill Alaskan restaurant!! And cold beer mugs from the freezer- enough said! read more

Magpye's Pizzeria - Shamrock Sammy - Pizza Near Me - Sterling, Alaska

See all

Awesome pizza, also sells by the slice. Can't wait to go back for more... very busy but completely worth the wait

Best pizza on the Peninsula.... Enjoy it every time I stop by!!! The salads are huge and the pizza's are cooked perfectly read more

Amazing customer service and food, I ordered a sterling special one time I went in there and it was great!!!!! Sterling Special you are highly recommended!!!! Maggie you are really nice and please don't care about what anybody else says or feels about you. You are you people are people!!! Ohh and a couple more things to say facilities were very clean had everything in it everything was filled. Have a great day and keep it up Magpyes Pizzeria!!! read more

The pizza was very good and service was well also! It's in a nice cabin building and in the perfect location

Best pizza we ever had. The crust was amazing! We got the namesake pizza, The Magpye, very very good. Can not wait to try something with a red sauce! I wish they were open a little later. Service was good, just had to take our pizza as take out because we were there 15 minutes before closing! read more

Waited 1.5 hours for an over cooked pizza that was hard to eat. Severs were terrible. Rude, and not accomdating whatsoever. I will not return. read more

Awesome pizza with an attitude. As an airline pilot I travel around the world and I love pizza. This pizza is in my top 2 pizza places ANYWHERE! They PILE up on the fresh toppings and cheese. If you are a pizza lover and pass this place up you've done yourself wrong. This is NOT "California pizza kitchen" pizza, with one piece of topping per slice. The pies are heavy!! The owner might not meet you with a big smile, ass kissing and a "customer is always right" attitude, but she is the first to help when someone in the community is in need or there is a natural disaster. As stated her 9PM closing time is NOT the latest they take an order, it is when they close and expect customers to be gone. It is just the price you pay for awesome pizza. read more

Always great and worth the wait. Maggie and staff are the best. Nice little bar also, serving local draft beer.

Here from Idaho! What a great place. The pizza was delicious and the gals working were great!

Awesome pizza, really great service. I've eaten here many times and have never been disappointed

Best place to eat and the people the work there are the best ever , there funny , it's homey and the food is always delicious and the beer is always cold read more

Great (winter time) hamburgers! Great service! Friendly server! However!! I didn't look at the printed receipt that was handed to me just before we left by different server(paid on card reader). Once I got home & looked at receipt & saw we'd been charged for 2 drinks each, when the 4 of us had only had ONE! $21 over charge! Not to mention I'd given a 20% tip! Decided not to return to ask about overcharge. Just be sure you check your receipt be for you leave! read more

Everywhere on the kenai is under staffed. The pizza is great. Salads have been great too. I absolutely don't mind take out. We will be back to eat inside when ever you guys are read more

Thanks to other Yelpers reviews we stumbled on this place. Sooo happy we did!! We will be back! Heck, we may just drive down from Anchorage to get some for the day - when gas prices calm down a bit. Customer service was great - friendly & happy! Even offered to throw our pie on the oven closer to closing time so we could stay on the river fishing a little longer. But if you think the customer service is the best thing about this place you clearly haven't had a slice of their heavenly pizza. The crust is delicious! I don't think you could go wrong with ordering anything off their menu! A month later we are still raving about this place to our friends in Anchorage! Out of all the places we have travelled in the US, This place is in our overall top 3 ever!! We can't wait till next time! Give them a try you won't be disappointed! read more

Nice, friendly staff. Prices are a bit high and pizza is just okay. Greek salad was fresh and well made.

Walked in @6:30 group of 5. 3 open tables wanted to put tables together and told they were full and then a couple that had a large group told us that one of they tables they had for they're group they didn't need and offered it to us. But the waitress then started yelling at one of our kids that tried to get a chair to sit with us that he couldn't have the seat. Frustrating. I understand your busy and overworked but that's no way to treat customers, better yet locals that keep you in business during the slow winter months. Sorry Maggie but we won't be supporting the business anymore. Went to 3 bears grabbed some frozen pizza, took it home and had a better meal, definitely friendlier service and didn't have to tip the waitress so we saved a bundle!! I 100% love to help out local businesses but I don't enjoy getting belittled and made to feel like I'm not welcome. PS I love the confederate flag out front!! read more

We didn't have a great experience here, unfortunately. We ordered around 6 and there was only one other customer. It took 1 hr for 2 pizzas and a salad. Also unfortunate was that my veggie pizza dough was completely raw. Like I could wipe raw dough off and it tasted very unappetizing. I ended up eating the veggies off the top. Very disappointing. read more

Great people! We go here a few times a month and they always take good care of us! Get the potato skins! Yum!

Cold beer and the best pizza on the kenai peninsula. More than pizza there is a full menu. What more could you ask for

We ate there last night and the pizza was awesome! To comment on some other reviews re: poor service, etc. the owner/ server was a bit gruff but sometimes you just have to roll with it and look at it as entertainment. Kind of like the Soup Nazi on Seinfeld :) And the liquor laws in Alaska are pretty stringent too. I'd absolutely eat there again! read more

Very tasty pizza! We had a half Greek special and meat lovers pizza. The crust was good and the sauces just right. We also had the jalapeño poppers and they were also really good. Parking lot is big enough for an RV. read more

The "Cook's Creation" pizza is one of my all time favorites. Always fresh ingredients.

Fantastic pizza. Fresh tasty ingredients and lots of cheese. Absolutely heavenly. I've never been inside but I've used the drive through several times. Every pizza I've gotten here has been great! read more

Terrible customer service. We walked in at 8 and sat in the bar. We tried making small talk to the bartender to see if her attitude would warm up. Her response to a simple question was, "all orders placed after 8:30 are to-go." I see this is a theme in the reviews. If they don't want customers to eat at their restaurant then maybe they should make it to-go only. Just a thought. Oh and the food is sub-par at best. I will never eat there again. But thats what it seems they prefer anyway. read more

Consistency might be an issue, but I'll tell you right now, I had the best pizza of my entire life, (and I've had a lot) at Magpies. Bbq chicken, jalapeños, pineapple, bacon, onions. I also love stopping in here for a quick brew when coming in, or heading out of town. Great local joint with awesome food and beer. read more

Magpye's Pizzeria - Where every beer is frosty!! - Pizza Near Me - Sterling, Alaska

The customer service was extremely poor and they chose not to serve my buddy alcohol even though he presented his military ID. Rude and poor poor customer service, definitely will never eat there again read more

The pizza, service, and beer were excellent. The place has a great small town feel and I look forward to returning.

We went their on a Thursday the two women servers were very rude, never smiled or greeted us friendly. The restaurant was loud and the pizza was very expensive. We will never go back. Plenty of other restaurants to go to that will grant you with a smile and friendly attitude. read more

Who would have thought there was good pizza in the middle of Alaska? The pies at Magpye's are better than most pizzarias in Hawaii...I'm hedging it's probably even better than that brick oven pizzeria on Kauai. They use all fresh ingredients, not overly sauced, and cooked just right where the juices of the pepperoni, sausages, onions, bell peppers, mushrooms, and olives weren't dry and the dough wasn't thick or chewy. GAHHHHHH too bad they don't deliver to HAWAII!!!!! read more

We stopped at Magpye's while enroute from Seward to Homer, AK. after Yelping the area. The single review was convincing and we were in the mood for good pizza, so we took a chance and were very pleased. Magpye's is a funky little cabin-style building along the Sterling Highway with a tall sign on a bright red pole. The landscaping is decorated with colorful floral-shaped pinwheels and a beautiful pine tree. Inside, there is a bar and a big, open, cafeteria-style dining room that lacks warmth and has terrible acoustics, but the pizza makes up for it. The dough is made from scratch and the ingredients are almost all fresh--except the mushrooms on our pizza appeared to be canned. However, they tasted good and did not at all detract from the fresh, balanced flavors of the pizza. Excellent food!! Definitely worth the stop. read more

Growing up in the area might make my opinion a little one sided. Keep in mind this is a small town and the restaurant is generally full of locals. They are short staffed from time to time so the wait time might be more than you are used to. But the beer is always cold and served in a frosty mug if you like it that way. They keep a few local brews on tap as well. Pizza is fair, and the crust is great. The burgers are priced fair and always seem to be fresh. This is my go to for a cold beer and a burger after work. read more

Horrible customer service. For me, service is often more important than food. The quality of the food + the service = horrible. I also noticed the restaurant has their clocks set 15 minutes fast, and turned away customers who were wanting to eat (provide business) Very disappointing read more