The waitress was nice but the kitchen made a small size instead of a medium. Absolutely no apology or compensation for the twice as long wait time (50 minutes) in a dining room with unruly loud kids at the next table. Ended up taking it to go. Got home and the pizza had no flavor except for GARLIC. Piles of GARLIC over the pizza. Under the toppings. GARLIC to the point of it burning and tasting like vinegar. See pictures. Called back. Asked to talk to one of the 2 managers. The girl who answered the phone wouldn't pass me to the manager like I requested. She spoke with one and got back on the phone and said- yah. There's garlic on that pizza in the sauce. I told her that this is a ridiculous amount and could send her photos. She said they're too busy and to bring the pizza back the next day to double check they made it right. Pretty bad all around! read more

Pizza Boys - At least 1/3 cup of minced garlic for the whole pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Soldotna, Alaska

See all

We are frequently in Soldotna visiting family and are often there multiple times a year. Although we most times will just make food at home, who doesn't want a great pizza to lessen the load of a day sitting in the warmth when its cold out or after a long day of fishing? Pizza Boys is always a great option and has delivered every time. The meat lovers and Hawaiian Punch are two of our favorites and always come out great. The online ordering has been consistent and reliable with the pizza being ready for us to pick up every time. I've always been satisfied with the process and pickup in store has always been friendly. It's nice to know that there has been a reliable and consistent pizza spot in town that delivers a quality product and make ordering easy for the customer. Thank you! read more

We ordered 3 pizza, outstanding pizza, had it delivered in under 1 hour, bet there estimated time. Will buy pizza from them again read more

The service is wonderful and the food is great! I recommend the Mac and cheese and the bread sticks!

Just had a great meal in June 2025. We've become comfortable with this place. On this visit we had a Margerite pizza and a Greek salad that was modified to our taste: no kalamata olives but artichoke hearts instead. The salad was large and came with garlic bread. The pizza was tasty and had a crisp thin crust that was nicely crunchy to the bite. The table service was friendly. This is a great casual dining joint after your summer adventures on the Kenai Peninsula. For the lunch crowd on the go, they have a noon drive up take out kiosk in the back parking lot for pizza slices. read more

Pizza Boys - Margarite 14" pizza on a crisp tasty thin crust. - Pizza Near Me - Soldotna, Alaska

See all

Did a quick drive by for a slice of pizza n met an amazing lady at the front of the counter, she was very polite knowledgeable about her pies n had a great personality! We got the types, Cheese for our kiddo, a Mombo Combo n the months special.. All was delicious cooked to perfection n on point! The restaurant was very clean n well put together. My family n I will be back for more! read more

Pizza Boys - BBQ Chicken - Pizza Near Me - Soldotna, Alaska

See all

I've been coming here for a long time and let me tell you what, best pizza in town! Has a nice atmosphere, it does get hot in there in the summer but it's worth it! Service is fast and easy to deal, pretty stress free! Would definitely recommend to anyone that likes a good pizza! read more

Meeehhhh. This is a cute place to hang out with friends. The owner was friendly. I was craving pizza But honestly. ..I wasn't thrilled with the pizza here, I wondered if Domino's would've been better. I personally felt it lacked spices and sauce. The crust was good. The photos I took has the pizza looking great but I would rate it a 4 out of 10. read more

Pizza Boys - The crust was good. The pizza lacked sauce and spices. - Pizza Near Me - Soldotna, Alaska

See all

My family and I have always enjoyed pizza boys. But yesterday we put an order in online to pick up. This is what happened. Pizza order placed, pizza came out of the oven ready to pick up. Arrived to pick up the couldn't find it. Here the delivery guy or gal grabbed it and took off with it. Therefore they had to make our order all over again. After an hour later finally received the order. Got the pizza home and the pizza was extra greasy. I was pretty let down from previous times we have ate there! read more

Outstanding pizza! Service with smile! Tight tables but worth getting to know your neighbor! Highly recommended. read more

Good go to for either dine in or take out. Great service, Good value for the price. Will go back for sure.

Great food! Fettuccine was very nicely done. Husband had a hot sandwich which was also good. Followed it up with the delicious cookie boat. I would definitely eat here again. Also try the root beer! Highly recommended. read more

We started out with the stuffed mushrooms. Decided that they were so good, we needed a second order. We could have just lived off of these mushrooms and beer all night long. As I returned from the bathroom, I saw the sausage rolls. Yep, gotta try it. Not disappointed. Awesome Pizza is incredible. Sauce is awesome, crust is perfect and the meats were awesome. Locals said it was the best pizza on the peninsula. They were not wrong. Man, love this place. Don't know what else to say. Great food and a great time. read more

See all

Great pizza and staff! Nice place to sit, have a drink and eat good food. Stop by if you're looking for dinner!

Been here a few times now. One of my favorite places to eat. My son picky son loves the pizza. The Mac & Cheese is my favorite. Very friendly the moment we walk in every time. Quick to get drink orders & food comes out hot & fast. It's an old school pizza parlor with a great atmosphere. It's great to have a place to get pizza without needing to take it to go. read more

Drove through their "slice box" (I think it was called) today for my first ever Pizza Boys and it was FANTASTIC! I've heard great things recently so while I was in town today I grabbed a slice for the road. It was hot, crispy and the perfect amount of cheesy saucy goodness. I didn't notice their special of the month till I was handed my food, it sounded awesome. Now I'll have to go back and dine in. I might have found my new favorite spot. The quick drive through for a slice is such an added bonus!! I will definitely be back, soon! read more

Great Pizza and fast service. Was worth the walk from the Kenai River Hotel. Pizza was good for breakfast the next day.

Came for a late lunch the other day and we were the only people there at the time. Ordered the Hawaiian Punch pizza on a gluten free crust. Service was fast and the pizza was delicious. Will be returning to try the other options as well. read more

Pizza Boys - Hawaiian Punch GF Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Soldotna, Alaska

Food was awesome - first visit here. One of the best calzones I've had. Service was great too!!

Pizza is always tasty. I understand that it is summer season, but I would suggest to add 10-20 minutes to your order pick up estimate. Last Thursday night they were off on the estimated pick up by 30-40 minutes. We ordered at 7:44p with an estimated pick up of 8:14p, we were finally able to pick up our pizza at 9pm Today we arrived at the estimated time and was told another 10-15 minutes for it to be ready. Along with their internet dropping for online orders around 11am for the initial opening of the day read more

This is always a 'must do' for us when we're fishing. Their servings are huge. They could easily feed two people. The pasta was better than expected and the pizza is legit. read more

The food is amazing! Very friendly service. Stop here every time we are in town. Good pizza and salads. Recommend if you are looking for a good meal with fast and friendly service. read more

Love pizza boys and always will. They're always coming out with new pizzas and have a new pizza by the slice DRIVE THRU! My favorites are the White Tiger, the Hawaiian Punch, and the Jalapeño Popper. Artichoke dip is awesome, and I don't even like artichokes. And the sausage bites! Secret pasta menu item: Meatballs and Penne w/ Alfredo. ‍ read more

Great atmosphere, staff welcomed us right in. The counter was busy with paying customer, and pick up orders. read more

Pizza Boys - Menu - Pizza Near Me - Soldotna, Alaska

See all

Excellent pizza. They have some great menu options with interesting flavors and sauces. We ordered the mombo and the jalapeño popper pizzas. They were both fantastic. The popper had a cream cheese sauce and tasted just like a jalapeño popper. So good. Nice ambiance inside and good service. Also had some great music playing! Highly recommend. read more

This place gets 5 out of 5 stars. Being a pizza snob coming from California, I know what good, fresh, farm to table pizza is. Especially boutique pizza - not a corporate chain. After trying a few other places on the Peninsula - this is the only place to get a good pie. The crust is on point with taste, texture, and color. It's crisp - not overly doughy. The sauce is great too. I always order a double pepperoni, double cut because I have kids and it makes it easier to handle for them... and for dad on the drive home. Be warned - they can be busy but the pizza always makes up for it. The staff are great, the manager knows how to treat their customers. The owner, a blond female, has a great sense of humor. All of which you find out by going inside and having some chit chat - if they have a moment because they get business. It's a smaller place if you're looking to dine in, but they keep it tidy. The bathroom is clean. They have the obligatory soda pop choices and some gelato if you're feeling brave. Don't rest too long of the negative reviews - some people can never be pleased. Don't waste your time at other places - this IS the only place to get a pizza. Tell the manager Mr. Perfect sent you. read more

The place smelt wonderful ! The cashier was polite & helpful the pizza was way too salty like unbelievably salty & that was last night today had upset stomach all morning hahah wouldn't go again maybe for a beer seems like a hangout read more

This is our go-to place for take-out or delivery pizza in Soldotna. We haven't eaten in the restaurant or tried any of their menu items, but it has a pleasant atmosphere and a nice menu. Pizza is always done when they say it will be. Our favorite is the Mombo Combo which is a traditional "everything " pizza. read more

Really good pizza. Easy to find and quick service with kind people. Needs more space cause it was packed!

So good and great service. It's like fast food meets gourmet. I would recommend this for your every day pizza!

I believe the owners wife was manning the station tonight, middle aged blonde haired white woman. First time we've ever seen anyone besides the male owner working the pizza joint. This woman was rude to us as soon as we entered the restaurant. Despite this, we stayed and ate our usual pizza. My family was hoping for a nice relaxing dinner but instead was greeted by a snarky, rude menopausal woman. Needless to say, this initial encounter ruined the entire experience. I can understand being busy, but that woman is no good at customer service and should not ever be working inside the store. read more

Was in town with a few friends for a fishing trip and decided to order pizza delivery. We had the mombo combo, white tiger, and hawaiian punch. All were great but the hawaiian punch was my favorite. We ordered from this place twice on separate nights. First delivery was on time and second was about 30-40 mins late. Alaska gets dark late so it wasnt much of an issue except i had to deal with hungry guys waiting after a d ay of fishing. Would recommend this place and eat again!! read more

After a long day of fishing in Homer, we were able to order a custom made pizza conveniently online and it was ready when we got to Soldotna (we chose what time we wanted to pick it up). Amazing thin crust just how the hubby likes it! And not too often I can find a place that has green olives for your pizza. Amazing meal to end a perfect day. read more

Overcooked pizza, very little sauce, almost no taste. Did not finish our pizzas or take them to go - very disappointing. Service was good.

We stopped here as we drove back to Cooper Landing from Homer. The pizza was very good, but we thoroughly enjoyed the cheesy bread that we had. We could've honestly gotten away with just ordering the cheesy bread. Sadly, I did not take any photos. read more

Restaurant was very warm when we first sat down inside. We ended up moving outside to get a breeze. Server brought out our salad which was very good. We also ordered a pizza and waited a very long time (25-30min). Other tables outside were receiving food so my husband went to check on pizza. They had it ready but was just sitting there for who knows how long. We ended up getting the pizza to go. It was ok but nothing to write home about. Probably won't return as there are many other food choices around. read more

3 stars for kindness. Service was great and very polite. I sat outside because it was a beautiful day but the ambiance was your typical small town pizza shop. The pizza was mediocre at best. The "by-the-slice" were a little stale and tasted flat. Reminded me of heating up pizza the next day with the cardboard taste. I wasn't given the correct slices I ordered but I said, screw it and ate it. They charge for everything...$2.50 for a side of ranch and $2.00 for a soda. Little pricey if you ask me. I get that it's tourist season but $2.50 for a side of ranch? Seems overboard. read more

Had late lunch there on Sunday, July 14. The place was hopping with customers, and like everywhere, short staffed, but the man who was waiting tables was awesome. He acknowledged each customer as they came in, explained the situation and promised to get to each person as soon as possible. When that's the way you are treated, reasonable people don't mind waiting their turn. And the wait was worth it. The pizza was excellent! read more

Always consistent and delicious pizza, subs and sandwiches. I recommend the Greek salad, the hot hoagie and the White Tiger. Don't forget to try the draft root beer!! read more

Pizza Boys - White Tiger pizza and draft root beer. - Pizza Near Me - Soldotna, Alaska

Yummy and affordable. We called ahead and picked it up. Staff was very friendly. Pizza was delicious!!