The food is good and the wait staff are amazing. The salad bar is fresh and well stocked. Breakfast…read moreis especially yummy

We enjoy the salad bar here. It's a nice hometown feel place. We enjoy the occasional kids eat free…read morespecials.

Fantastic all around! A friend highly recommended while we were visiting the area. Amazing food and…read moreservice by Lynda. Lovely setting with a gorgeous bakery case. My husband enjoyed the chicken tender club and I had the best Reuben of my life. Owner, Mark Miller, stopped by to check in. We felt so welcome. Can't wait to return.

Frankly, I didn't hate or love it. I just don't see a reason to make a trip there other than a…read morelack of competition. Food = Jalapeño popper dip was good. Pork chop was cooked alright, but definitely needed a sauce to add some flavor as it was bland. Coconut mango rice was sad (my wife is filipino so she knows a bit about rice, mangoes, and coconut). I had the reuben and it was alright. I don't understand why all the steaks and fish are "market price" on the menu. This is not a fancier restaurant that serves wagyu, why can you not figure out how to price half of your meats? Service = Good with no problems. Restaurant = Stylish, Spacious, and Clean.

Dirty , food sub par, ripped off for five bucks at register for our change and they refused to give…read moreit back. Three adults watching the transaction

Service was good, soup barely warm.. no complaints just could be better. Always are go to, and will…read morecontinue to

7-2026 Buffet was very clean, and food was delicious I loved…read morethe cabbage casserole! My husband loved the chicken. Lots to choose from and hearty food. Good service, very crowded but it was organized and ran very well.

Used our "Amish Country Summer Package" which included dinner here…read more We got sat instantly right at 5:30, prime time. Karen greeted us right away and explained the deal to us. I got the full buffet & she got the salmon w/ sweet potato fries & salad bar. Drinks were included as well. Plus she brought wheat rolls. The hot buffet was limited but everything was always fresh & very tasty. I can't complain about any item. The salmon was pretty good as it had a nice crust on it. The sweet potato fries were perfect & the cinnamon butter was even better. Salad bar was really fresh & the local cheddar cheese was amazing. The cold prepared salads were a bit too wet but yummy. Only dessert item was jello. The full buffet w/ drink only cost $18! And Karen was the best server!

this is one of, if not the best resturants i have ever been too. our waitress katie was phenomenal…read more super friendly. personble. she served me and 6 of my buddies perfectly. the food was incredible. the drinks were even better. amazing hole in the wall. highly highly recommend.

Great service with a smile, a great rustic feel, and great cocktails…read more And did I mention the food is local and delicious. Burgers to steak, you can't go wrong with the menu. The deserts are awesome and the often feature live music. A quick detour off 70 or from Salt Fork.

I've been there several times over the years. It's very nice ambience. Service was excellent. I'm…read moresure we'll go back.

Situated in an early 19th century Philadelphia style house on the Zane Trace road. Decorated with…read morelots of period style stuff. Serving some seriously good German style potato salad along with a tasty Reuben sandwich. The cherry pie would probably be better heated up. Friendly service. Worth the drive!

OMG this place is soooooo great!! We loved it so much. 8 of us ordered 8 different things and we…read moreemptied all of them. This place is family owned and they first started as an ice cream shop. Everyone there was so nice and friendly. It's a little bit far away from where we live but it's definitely drive an hour for the food. Strongly recommend!

While out doing some RV shopping, we were getting a little hungry. After reviewing Yelp of all…read moreplaces in the area, we decided on the cottage restaurant. Nice little place with solid service and a nice little menu. I ordered their hotdog special and my wife Chicken tenders. Both were absolutely done well. And for dessert, we decided on a delicious piece of pie and ice cream. I doubt we'll ever be in the area again; however, if we are, we would probably stop here.

Green Leaf is a family favorite! Great food, fair prices, wonderful people, & a small town feel…read morewith fast & friendly service! Watching the fish when we arrive and get ready to leave is always fun too!

Nice diner with good food options and great service. We had…read morethe taco salad in a crispy taco shell and spaghetti with (only 2) meatballs. Topped it all with a warm pecan pie.

So I'm a person who loves spice; I am also from metro Detroit so I decided to try their chili dog…read moreand a bowl of chili. Let me start with the chili: it says spicy and they aren't kidding. Now it isn't uncomfortably spicy but you get some burn. Secondly, the chili is THICK! (My pic showed my spoon standing up in the chili). The chili dog was good, probably the same chili, as it was not a coney. I'm used to a coney sauce with a bit more onion but theirs was good. Service was excellent as our waitress took care of our table and others near us. The environment was not quiet, it bordered on loud but we could carry on conversations. The real key is would I return? Yes, tomorrow would be great. Their menu has so many options I could eat here five days in a row and not get the same thing.

April Fools . . …read more Our advertised "Spicy Lamb " "Gyro" is not worth 2 cent. Not a regular "Cone" cut like you'd think. Shared Photo show of the Dried out / what seems to be over cooked  different parts of the Lamb (?) / Shaped "Spicy Lamb Loaf" (?). NICE GROUP of Servers. Other visits, GREAT Menu Items . . . Just wrong direction with their "Spicy Gyro" SAVE YOUR MONEY and JOY, Don't Order The "Gyro" No Stars Gryo, 5 Star Service, Servers

AMISH KITCHEN COOKING…read more A big restaurant where you'll notice some Amish women working while wearing their traditional white head covering or bonnet. I visited Der Dutchman restaurant for the first time in Walnut Creek, Ohio in late July 2025 with 3 guy friends and 2 female friends. We drove down from Cleveland to visit sites in Amish Country (Millersburg and Berlin). We had just finished touring the Yoder Amish Homes property (over an hour tour in the heat) and after the fun tour we all were hungry for lunch. Der Dutchman came up on a Yelp search so we decided to visit. FOOD (see attached pics) -- Typical home cooking. Served buffet style. Reminds me of Hometown Buffet in Columbus but that restaurant doesn't exist anymore. The menu is large so you will definitely find something that you like. I got fried chicken, shredded beef, mashed potatoes, string green beans, and a side salad. I also got a second plate of food which I think was just another piece of chicken because guests can enjoy "all you can eat"; although, I didn't get too much food neither did I fill my plate up in my original serving. Plenty of options to choose from, including protein (chicken, fish, beef), salads, carbs (rice, mashed potatoes), and dessert. SERVICE -- friendly and efficient. The lunch time was busy but our waiter greeted us, brought water and bread rolls to our table and checked on our table during lunch. If you're visiting Amish country for the day like my friends and I did, then stop by Der Dutchman. It's a well talked about hometown favourite. All 6 of us enjoyed our time. Bon Appetite! **** GOAL of 250 reviews in 2026 - 158/250 total reviews in 2026 - 999 total Yelp reviews - Reviewed on 12 July 2026

It's been two years since I've been to Walnut Creek Der Dutchman…read more Wife and I had dinner there on June 1st. We asked for a window seat view and was easily granted that at 4pm. We chose to order off the menu instead of the buffet because we chose for better dinning. Salad and bread came to the table and was delish! As we enjoyed, we overheard the table behind us complain about lukewarm chicken. Kind of disappointing to overhear but we figured it came from the buffet. Our dinners took a while to come out so we assumed ours would be just fine. WRONG! I ordered three-piece dark meat, and it was lukewarm and very dry, like it sat under a heat lamp for some odd reason. My wife ordered three-piece white meat and found it extremely dried out and the skin was very dark almost burned like it stayed too long in the oven. I don't understand what is going on in the kitchen, but this is NOT the Der Dutchman that we've known in the past. It was always a pleasure to enjoy home cooked meals there. I'm very sorry to give such a bad review on a place we've loved to eat at but I believe knowledge is power and Der Dutchman should be looking at these two issues with summer travel upon them.