Main Street Pizzeria

Today I ordered a cheese pizza and a Greek salad, the pizza was hot and delicious, the Greek salad…read morewas prepared with fresh ingredients with a generous amount of feta cheese. The staff were very friendly and accurate with the food order. The restaurant dining area was clean and decorated with an Italian mural of Venice.

I've been here multiple times, and today I saw something new on the menu - the same food but in…read moresmaller portions. I was so excited because, if you've never been to Toney's, you know the portions for Italian food are huge and always leave leftovers. For me, that gets wasted. So, I got the chicken Alfredo small portions for $9.50, and my boyfriend got spaghetti and meatballs with extra meatballs for, I believe, $15. We were both disappointed. He's gotten this exact order multiple times, but this time they reduced the spaghetti amount when he asked for extra meatballs, so he was able to eat everything when he normally has leftovers. Mine was a child's portion of food - no joke; it took me 7 bites to eat. I had to look at the menu again to make sure I didn't order off the children's menu.

Italian sandwich. Very good.

See all

Spaghetti and meatballs

Pizza Inn

3.8(22 reviews)

0.8 mi

Staff friendly. Salad bar was small but pretty good. Pizza on the buffet was mediocre. All the…read morepizzas lacked cheese (even the cheese pizza). Pasta was bland. We won't be going back.

Good pizza but didn't have the basic pizzas expect cheese. Came for pepperoni but i sat waiting for…read morethem to bring it out because i had to request it. Nice setting however.

See all

Domino's Pizza

2.4(16 reviews)

0.2 mi

I've ordered many times from this Dominos & the delivery/pick up is always prompt. My pizza & other…read morefoods ordered have been excellent.

Not sure why it's only got 2 stars when this it's the best chain pizza spot I've been too. I showed…read moreup late and got 3 pizzas and 2 pepperoni stick things all came out great along with wonderful service.

Pepperoni with mushroom. Thin crust

Half an order ! It's suppose to be Chicken Alfredo !

See all

This is what I received. Half the order.

Little Caesars Pizza

1.6(8 reviews)

1.2 mi

Rude cashier started playing with coworker in the middle of taking our order and then gave us pizza…read morethat seemed to be at least a few days old and looked like it had pimples on it.

The cashier was very rude and didn't give us everything, plus our pizza feels, looks, and tastes…read morelike it's been in the heater for 3 days.

ExtraMostBestest Pepperoni

Some of the best looking and tasting crazy bread I've had in a while.

See all

Little Caesars

The Scoop Ice Cream Shop

4.6(44 reviews)

8.1 mi

Best lil home town ice cream parlor with a lot of family fun and the service is always great.read more

We were rambling around on our way to visit family when I decided to look for ice cream…read more It seemed that we were headed Lord knows where, but we ended up at this sweet ice cream shop. The workers were friendly, and the restaurant was clean and comfy. We have already returned, and plan to visit when in the area

See all

Inky's Authentic Philadelphia Cheesesteaks and Hoagies

4.3(348 reviews)

6.9 mi

I found Inky's back when they were in the shopping center on Calhoun Mem Hwy. I'm from the Philly…read morearea and when I saw them prepping the sandwiches I knew I was home! Their Cheesesteaks are superb either way; "Wid or wideout". Now, if they could just get Frank's soda (black cherry .... Mmmmmm). I tried their hoagie one time and I wasn't super crazy about it. Could've been an off day. One problem with parking at their place in the Silos, it is very limited and neighboring shops are not too friendly to non customers using their parking.

Ok, you ready for this one, hide the woman and children. So was supposed to end up at Silo's…read morebrewery which is right Nextdoor but, Google Maps had it listed as being open and it was not. So decided why not I here, let's try out Inky's you can't go wrong with a good Philly Steal sub. OK here's the bad part no special microbrew beer on tab or in bottle, stuff they have on tap or in bottles is that domestic crap? You know it Bud, Miller etc.. suggestion get some local brew. Just saying. Now back to the food I had ordered the pasta salad. I was thinking it was gonna be more of an oil base or basil pesto type not sure, but it might've been more of a mayonnaise base. Philly was good. I thought the steak had some great seasoning and I enjoyed it. Definitely recommend ordering the small anything bigger than that you are busting a gut or taking a lot home. Onion ring were freash dipped which is a good thing. Size for the steak I really did enjoy the Philly steak and I think you will too great seasoning wonderfully put together beautiful presentation. So when you're thirsty for a grade local craft beer and you find out, the brewery is closed because it's a Monday. Come on over and enjoy some good food.

Inside

Half of Colossal Cheesesteak

See all

Entrance as seen from across street

Taco Bell

1.6(18 reviews)

1.4 mi

Went through drive though ask for 3 hard shell taco supremes, they gave me 2 chalupas and 1 beef…read moretaco so I went back around and asked for 3 hard shell taco supremes again, and had to pay for it and then they give me a beef potato taco and churros?? If I went back I would have to pay again because they can't get it right, ridiculous!.

Slow... you will be able to eat and leave at anyone of the Mexican restaurants in Pickens by the…read moretime they have your food ready. You walk up and have to enter your order in on a tablet. I wish this was a good place to eat but it is just slow.

See all

The Scoop at The Airport

4.9(8 reviews)

4.6 mi

The food is stunning you expect something and suddenly it's supper surprising…read more Service done fast and correct. You sit inside and see the people come and pick up orders.

Super cool ice cream shop and sandwich shop at the airport! But accessible to all…read more I had a really good club sandwich. Service was really good! Fun place for some good food and some ice cream!

See all

Freakshake

Subway

1.7(6 reviews)

6.5 mi

smelled like urine inside. over priced compared to other better subways…read more sign on the drink machine said only one free refill which is the only subway that has ever done this

This has to be the worse Subway I (Fleetwood, Easley, SC) have eaten from in a LONG time!! I placed…read morean order through the app and went in to pick up order. I opened one of the sandwiches and literally had to open the bread to see the meat and toppings. I combined the meat and toppings onto half of the sub bread to feel like I actually had a sandwich. My son did the same for the other sub. The instructions I sent through the app was obviously ignored because those sandwiches are NOT how I ordered them. Both sandwiches were Philly's. I will skip Subway and go to Publix next time. Subway Franchise should shut this store down for cheating their customers.

See all

Main Street Pizzeria - italian - Updated September 2026

Browse Nearby

BEST of Pickens, South Carolina Things to Do near Main Street Pizzeria

BEST of Pickens, South Carolina Restaurants near Main Street Pizzeria

BEST of Pickens, South Carolina Desserts near Main Street Pizzeria

BEST of Pickens, South Carolina Shopping near Main Street Pizzeria

BEST of Pickens, South Carolina Wineries near Main Street Pizzeria

BEST of Pickens, South Carolina Parking near Main Street Pizzeria

BEST of Pickens, South Carolina Coffee near Main Street Pizzeria

BEST of Pickens, South Carolina Cocktail Bars near Main Street Pizzeria

BEST of Pickens, South Carolina Pizza near Main Street Pizzeria

BEST of Pickens, South Carolina Dinner near Main Street Pizzeria

Best of Pickens

Things to do in Pickens

Browse Brands

Brands by name

Browse Articles

Articles by date

People who viewed Main Street Pizzeria also viewed

Real Pizza

4.1

(25 reviews)

Food: we only ordered the large pepperoni pizza and it was delicious. The cheese was stretchy and…read morenot chewy. The crust was crisp and flavorful. Staff: the staff was kind and professional. The young man offered and brought our pizza out to the car. Establishment: it is a small shop next to a gas station. You knock on the window and you place your order. The pizza was done fairly quickly (for pizza making standards.)

We really enjoy the pizza and grinders from Real Pizza. The grinders are on the smaller than…read moreexpected side, but the flavor makes up for it. The sauce on the pizza is pretty darn good. The service is always on-point with high expectations around smiles and fast checkout with the drive through. It's take out service only so the ambiance is non-impactful/irrelevant.

Columbo's Pizza

3.6

(63 reviews)

I love this place. Columbo's feels like home. When I was a kid growing up in Clemson we'd come here…read moreon special occasions. The dessert pizza was my favorite. Now that I'm back here for college, it's cool to be here again. Nothing's changed and it still feels frozen in time. Recently asked Mark if we could rent out the place for two hours on a Wednesday and he was down. They set up nice for us and provided us 5 Atlas pizzas. All the guests enjoyed themselves and the service as top notch. Stephanie was great all night and continued to refill our drinks and ask how she could help. Hope to do something like this again soon! Thanks Columbos!

I feel for the owner, you can see him working his tail off trying to meet the needs of the customer…read moreBUT the young lady taking orders and serving was horrible. Tonight we ate at a dirty table that the server told us was not cleaned. We had to ask for drinks multiple times and walk to get the one refill that we did get. I understand people having a bad day but we won't be back. Sad

Brooklyn Style Pizza

4.4

(66 reviews)

I've recently gotten into Brooklyn-style pizza, and I've really enjoyed exploring it. Being a…read moreSoutherner, I don't have the highest bar set when reviewing, but with that said, this place was very cool. I went in and ordered a pizza to go, and it took about 15 minutes--only because they made it fresh right then. The pizza is priced really well for the quality, and it tastes great. The ambience of the restaurant is also solid, and it seems like a fun spot to take the family on a weeknight or just hang out and watch a game. Overall, a really cool spot in downtown Pendleton and definitely a must-try.

This was the best pizza we have found in the area, the crust was perfect!!! They also now have…read moreexcellent sandwiches on the menu. Great service in a very cute neighborhood restaurant, wish we lived closer...

Joe's New York Pizza

4.0

(111 reviews)

Here again at Joe's eating a late lunch. Staff very friendly and helpful here at Joe's. Great…read morecasual spot to have lunch, love the music selection. We are switching it up today no pizzas for lunch. We are doing spaghetti lunch specials and chicken parmigiana sub with fries and meatball sub with fries. We also did the mozzarella sticks with marinara sauce to start as an appetizer. Everyone loved their dishes! I enjoyed my chicken parmigiana sub excellent!! Easy 5 Stars !!

Decent pizza... if you're in no rush. I wouldn't write this review, but this is FOUR separate…read moreinstances. Came here last week for dine-in. Service was good, our waitress was very nice and very attentive. However, our food (just regular old pizzas) took forever. Most recent update: we place an order at 7pm on a Saturday evening, says it will be ready at 7:45. Then we get a notification it won't be ready until 8:45. This is ridiculous. If you can't figure out how to make a pizza in 30 mins, I suggest another business. Plus- they still charged us!! $75 for pizza that was gonna take nearly two hours and we never got it. DONE with Joes.

Olivia's Pizza

4.6

(41 reviews)

Great product and super service. A favorite for us and our grandkids! Try them!…read more Dave and Bonnie

The pizza was good, however the price is hard to justify…read more The list of specialty pizza to me are amazing and the Washington Heights by description is some of my favorite on a topping, however I didn't a quality difference between this and your other local pizza spot. I am going to try again at some point, but $33 (tip included) for a large specialty pizza is hard to get yourself to come back to when nothing in particular stood out. Will definitely update when the time comes and I'd love to be wrong.

D'Allesandro's Pizza

4.0

(131 reviews)

I ordered a 10 inch pizza online and thought it was great! Reasonably priced, it came out quick,…read moreand was high quality. I like to order online and then sit outside or out of the way to eat it if I'm traveling alone. I sat in their enclosed outdoor area and they had all the good stuff at the table. Crushed red pepper, hot sauce, and even honey. The kid working the host area was friendly. I'll definitely order again when I'm traveling and need a post workout meal! Great experience.

The pizza was really tasty, I honestly enjoyed it. The dough was soft, and everything tasted fresh…read more It looked very appetizing too. I just wish there was a bit more toppings, but overall still a good experience.

Rapid Fired Pizza

3.6

(17 reviews)

The pizza is good. They have a nice little sauce bar. Service is fast casual. Ambiance includes…read moreindoor and outdoor seating.

I tried this for the first time tonight and it was great! The employees working the line were very…read morefriendly and professional! The gal was polite and called me "sir" while working my order on the line. The guy who cashed me out and gave me my order was also very friendly. The line looked great, all the pizza toppings/etc. were fully stocked and fresh looking. I got the pan build your own, the dough was fully cooked and tasted good. I was worried it would be under since the dough is thicker. Price point is great and sauce station is a bonus. I'd definitely be back!

Todaro Pizza GVL

4.4

(140 reviews)

So to start - I'm not a huge fan of their pepperoni and banana pepper pizza (what my bf always…read moreorders and what I do usually like from other places) but the white pizza is DELISH. I always mix up the toppings a little bit - this time I got prosciutto, ricotta, and basil. Delicious. Truly. And the ranch.... HEAVENLY. ALWAYS.

Great service. There is a special posted in the restaurant for Two slices Cheese Pizza. The…read moreAmbiance is very casual and has a few people showing up for late night dinners. This is a popular hangout spot for the locals in downtown Greenville. Is a great place to hang out with friends or colleagues.

Pizza Parcheggio

4.7

(98 reviews)

Pizza Parcheggio NEVER disappoints! We have enjoyed so many times and the pizza is 100! Love the…read morecrust - especially love the vodka sauce - Ordering is so easy and the staff is always very professional! We love this place!!!!! The restaurant itself is so quaint - and now they offer wine and beer ! Perfect

This pizza place has been on my must try list for a while. Not traveling to Greenville often, I…read morehadn't had the opportunity to indulge until today. It was worth the wait! You can taste the quality in the ingredients. This pizza is made with love!

Belladina's Pizzeria

4.5

(175 reviews)