Barely a step above gas station pizza, which is on pad with the fact they are located at a gas station.

We are visiting from Tennessee. When traveling, we seek out locally owned restaurants. The kids wanted pizza so we ordered a cheese, a chicken bacon and ranch, and a "build your own" with Canadian bacon, mushrooms, and jalapeños. They were all great! The staff even stayed 10-15 minutes after close for my carry out order. Please note as of today 6/29/2022, their window posted hours are 11am-7:30pm and the online menu is not accurate. The cashier said, "It needs an overhaul" We were very pleased and satisfied. read more

Main Street Pizzeria - Street view - Pizza Near Me - Youngstown, New York

See all

Had an event next door at Fort Niagara State Park. Popped over here to get something to eat and it was pretty empty. Menu is really great and we got some slices which were reasonably priced and really tasty. Wound up coming back two times over the day and then one more time to take a whole pie home with us which didn't make it home. We were eating the old fashion which was a pretty unique take on pizza. It had Romano instead of mozzarella and tasted great. My daughter and wife got the chicken strips and were raving about how good those were although they were a bit expensive. Staff was really friendly and a beautiful view out the window of the river. read more

I was told, at gunpoint, to try this amazing Youngstown-area pizza from a gas station. Who was I to say no to a beautiful naked woman holding a gun? She totally didn't need the gun but whatever, no biggie smalls. Knowing that a similarly heralded pizza (Godfathers in NF) is absolutely amazing, I thought I might really like this based on the reviews. It was mediocre at best, it didn't impress me at all. Yes it was extremely cheap, and that is the big selling point... but it was also similar to a lot of frozen pizzas and really not particularly enjoyable. read more

Gas was priced 40 cents per gallon higher than five minutes up the road at smokin Joes. The inside is grimey and the lots looks like no one cares. I pulled in, checked the pumps, and left. read more

I grew up in Niagara Falls...left here many years ago...I have eaten pizza all over the country...NYC, Chicago, Fla, Texas, AZ...live in Southern Calif now...came home to visit my Mom...when I tell people who live in Calif. that "Even the Gas stations in western New York have better pizza than you Jamokes" they always laugh! I come back here and I am ALWAYS right! These guys know how to do it..I wish they would move to San Diego. Good stuff. read more

Ok. Always creeps me out a little that it's a gas station. Open and close when they feel like it. They just told me they were closed at 845pm on a Friday night while they don't have any hours earlier than 10pm. As a gas station they kinda suck as their delivery drivers park and block the pumps. As a pizza place they're ok, but they're super slow - 45 minutes for pickup for anything ordered. read more

The building looks ghetto but that pizza was a solid 10/10. I got the pepperoni and it's the old world style pepperoni would highly recommend! read more

Pizza was undercooked n thin dough had not risen. Wings were not crispy white n fatty almost no garlic honey sauce on them. For a local place, it was really bad. read more

Not horrible, but not that good either. Not good for dine in cause they only got three stools to sit on.

The pizza here is sub par. That's it. They cut it into square slices, but they are not that big. The crust was burnt too. Friendly service, but food needs to improve drastically! I also prefer to eat in places other than a gas station. Also, little parking!:( read more

Friends and myself were out on a motorcycle ride and we needed gas so the next gas station was this one and we were also hungry and saw that they server food as well so we went in to check us out...not a fancy place at all but the food was excellent..we had salads, wings, pizza and a wrap..everyone loved what they had and we had a lot of wings left over to bring home...we live in canada so it's hard to find good wings, but now we know where to get them..a few weeks after this my husband and I went to the Anchor bar in buffalo because we heard they had great wings...well they were not even close to this place..the place was being run by all guys so I was leary about the salads but they were great..we will be eating here again and taking more of our motorcycle friends.. read more

Extremely little parking. First I do have to admit the Chicken Fingers are fantastic, Subs are good especially the meatball! BUT when ordering and you ask for no seasoning, CHECK IT! Twice I have gotten seasoning after specifically saying NO SEASONING!! Then when I called them 12 minutes before closing, no answer...I don't get the pizza anymore, especially the slices. The dough is SO thin it is almost non-existant, very little cheese and way over priced for the cardboard shingle. Much better pizza at the gas station in Ransomville. read more

I was a big fan of this pizzeria, spending over $1,000 a year for pizza. They were the best in the area and it was nice being just a couple of blocks away. Something happened to their pizza a couple of years ago and I stopped buying it there. Not sure if it was a change in ingredients or cooks or what but I could no longer waste my hard earned money in pizza I don't enjoy. There's nothing good in Lewiston since Smith Brothers closed so now I make a trip to the Falls to get my pizza. I actually stopped into Main Street the other day for some slices from the case and it was very good. My question is, why when I order a tray of pizza is it made differently than the slices in the case? If I could order a tray of those slices I'd be happy! read more

It's pretty amazing that pizza this good comes from a place called Main Street Gas & Grille. The pepperoni style is a very good version of the distinctive Niagara area taste. Excellent flavor, delicious crust. My recommendation would be to let it settle for a good 15 minutes before digging in. read more

We lived in Youngstown for a few years and LOVE their pizza and subs so every time we go back we make a point to stop in. Order is always the same: 2 slices of pizza and two large steak and cheese subs. I have yet to find anyone who can come close to their pizza and subs. LOVE THIS PLACE! Wish they could deliver to us, hey it's only 200 miles away lol read more

Awesome food and customer service. Great prices and scenery. Nearby parks of you want to eat outside. These guys are awesome!

My first review on yelp because this place is drastically underrated. Yes it's not fancy, limited parking and seating but dear lord it's in a GAS Station. Food is consistently fantastic, whether it be take out or delivery. It won't be great for your high cholesterol but it's a PIZZA place. In the summer you can eat down by the dock on the river too. This is a great, unpretentious pizza joint. If you want delicious, timely, quality pizza and wings at an affordable price look no further. read more

I also grew up NF which boasts the best pizza around in my book. Gas and Grille also has Great pizza, OK subs and and nice people. Yes, the ambiance is not great for an eatery but better than average for a gas station. read more

Great Pizza & subs. They completely remodeled their dining area, which offers a GREAT view of the lower Niagara River in the Youngstown Harbor area. Also the "Pizza" shop is isolated from the store section. Love their Pizza!! read more

I went here 10 years ago but wasn't impressed and never went back but another pizza place in the area closed so I was forced to call them for a party I was having. I ordered 5 sheets of pizza five hours ahead asking for a specific delivery time and paid ahead. I was assured it would be on time. The pizza arrived a half hour late because we were told they had another delivery. It was cold and the worst pizza I've had in a long time. I was totally embarrassed and will NEVER go back. I made sure to tell all my guests where it came from too. If you want good pizza run from this rotten place!!!! read more