Got a 10" ciminos everything pizza with Bosco sticks. The amount of toppings on there was insanity. It was decent, the service was fine. Cash only, they have an atm. We were lucky enough to witness a 16 year old attempt to complete their hurricane challenge. read more

Mama Cimino's - Pizza Near Me - Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

See all

Farmer was awesome . Phenomenal service . He was informative did not rush us. Very through in explaining. Started off with really great meat balls. So tender and delicious. Everything from scratch. My boyfriend who wasn't hungry had one meatball and two and a half pieces of pizza. Open late night. The owner was very nice, talked about the history of M.C. Will be back read more

Mama Cimino's - Pizza Near Me - Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

Quaint little Italian place in Lake Geneva. Happened in and took the big pie challenge. Crushed it and beat the speed record. Other food was great and served with a smile. If you are ever in town it's worth consideration. read more

Mama Cimino's - New record set this week! We had an hour and this was the countdown for the finish. - Pizza Near Me - Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

See all

Very disapointed. Went for fish fry sign outside says 13.95 however when i got the bill i was charges 38.00 for 2 fish dinner 3 pieces of fish handful fries. When i asked about it i was told oh the piece of paper with the new fish dinner price blew away its 18.95. Then we were never told that there was a 4.00 up charge to use credit card. The service took forever to get our waters. You can get all you can eat fish fry up the road for 19.99 I have been told the pizza is good however of going for anything else maybe re think it. read more

When you face the building at 131 N. Wells Street in Lake Geneva, be aware that more than half of it is a coin laundry. Mama Cimino's door is nearly hidden around the first corner to your right. The place is small, offering seating at six tables and places at the small bar. The ambiance is definitely Italian and Italian-American. The tables are set with red and white checked plastic tablecloths and individual paper maps of Italy. The restaurant is open Tuesday-Sunday 4 pm to 12 am, and does lots of take-out business. We arrived for an early dinner, and were met by a friendly older lady who suggested we sit anywhere we liked in the empty dining area. Mama Cimino's does have a liquor license, so my husband and I ordered Blue Moon beer and Pinot Noir wine, followed by Bruscetta and the Specialty Stuffed Chicago-style pizza that takes 45 minutes to make. The Bruscetta came on a dozen two-bite pieces of Italian bread (not like the slices from a big loaf) and was served cold, drizzled with balsamic vinegar. It was good and quite filling. My husband enjoyed his Blue Moon, but my wine had an ascerbic flavor that didn't bloom and wasn't friendly like the Australian and California wines I favor. The Specialty Stuffed Pizza appeared just at the 45 minutes promised. It was a delicate crust filled with mozzarella, parmesan, green bell pepper, olives, several kinds of meats, and a sauce that didn't fight with the other flavors. It also wasn't too sweet. I managed to eat one piece, my husband had two. Our server happily packed the leftovers into a box for us to take home, and asked with a laugh if we'd like dessert. That will have to wait until next time, when we order a smaller pizza! read more

Mama Cimino's - One slice of Mama Cimino's specialty Stuffed Pizza. - Pizza Near Me - Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

See all

I am not sure there is a rating low enough for this place. It took over 3 hours and 5 phone calls (one where I was on hold for 21 minutes) to get our very cold and tasteless pizza. I get they may be understaffed, but perhaps then don't take so many orders when there is one delivery driver. Worst experience with a restaurant I have had in a long time. Avoid this place, if you can. read more

Oddly enough, this was one of the only places open late at night. We were pleasantly surprised, the food was amazing! Now we will go out of our way anytime when in the area to have an authentic Italian meal! Whether you're having pizza or pasta, the gravy/sauce makes all the difference. This hidden gem is well worth finding! We'll be back! read more

My girlfriends and I recently visited Lake Geneva for my bachelorette party, and after going to a few bars on Main Street, we decided to walk over to Mama Cimino's for some late night food. Our server Stacey was incredibly kind and provided great service. The food came in a timely manner and exceeded all expectations. My girlfriends said the jalapeño poppers were the best they ever had! I got a pepperoni pizza and thoroughly enjoyed it. Would definitely go back in the future. read more

My family and I spent a Sunday night in Lake Geneva in November and were looking for a last minute place to eat that was open late. We found Mama Cimino's and they were outstanding! The service was excellent even though we walked in near closing time and the food was excellent as well! I apologize that I cant remember the waitress's name but she was great! She talked to us like we were family and was so kind to our granddaughter whose bday it was. We will definitely be back!! read more

I have only been 1x. I really enjoyed the taco pizza. I would go back and get that again.

The waiter Stacey was amazing. The food matched the service. Everything we order was absolutely delicious. The spinach artichoke dip was phenomenal. Highly recommend this place. 10/10. read more

I completely understand it's the holiday weekend and restaurants are slammed with take out orders. However, I have never experienced such rude customer service as I did at this joint. I ordered via their website $130 worth of food, received a confirmation via their website, an email noting my order is confirmed, and a text messages noting my order will be ready in 30-40 minutes. When I went to pick up order, the woman at the take out desk was sweet and welcoming as she asked the kitchen if they had my order. I could hear in the kitchen chirping there was no order under my name. That was my first sign something was wrong. I showed her my confirmations of my order then another woman came out, who honestly was one of the rudest, most insensitive, unapologetic people I've ever met. She said started out our interaction by claiming my order must not be under my own name and that I was wrong. I again showed my order confirmations, my name appearing on the email, and the order number. She disappeared into the kitchen asking the staff for my order. Nothing was found. Instead of telling me it was a mistake and that they do not have my order, I proceeded to wait with no answers. As I asked for details on what was going on, this woman proceeded to tell me online orders sometimes don't go through, which translates into "you are out of luck." Instead of apologizing immediately for the issue, the woman gave me a lecture on if I order online I should always call the restaurant to check. I was shocked by this response. I have never had to do that for any order from a restaurant before. My rebuttal was the restaurant should take the online portal down if it doesn't work. To matters more bizarre, she printed out my order proving it was received and recited it to me. I stopped her in her tracks and asked for an explanation of what is going on. She never fully acknowledged what happened, but she said she can work on my order now and try to get it to me in 30 minutes. No offer to deliver to me. What was I supposed to do? Sit there for another 30 minutes?! I asked for a refund and went home empty handed to my family. Again mistakes happen. I get it! But to make the customer feel like they did something wrong by using a restaurants platform is mind boggling to me. My complaint is I was sitting there at the restaurant with no explanation of what was going on, where my order was, if I had an order, or if I will get a refund. The woman who was working with me spoke to me like I was dirt on the ground. It was such a disappointing end to the holiday weekend. I've been coming up to Lake Geneva my entire life and never have experienced anything like this. My advice: order from Gino's or Rosatis. They can handle online orders. Don't go here unless you want to be taken for a ride. read more

We used them for catering for a party of 50. Oh my god it was reasonably priced and so delicious. We had abundant amount of food and everything went perfectly it arrived right at agreed time. The pizza was great as usual, and sausage rolls were an amazing hit. The surprise delight was the chicken parmesan wow not the beaten down patties you find most places but plumb breaded chicken breaded and seasoned perfect. Friends and family all loved it, and there was enough to make plates to take home. I would highly suggest for any event. read more

This is by far the best Italian Restaurant in the Lake Geneva area. Nick, the owner will tell you the story of his family and the local restaurant if you asks him (and you should) it's very interesting. The food is outstanding and with a vast menu it's hard to make a good choice. The server we had "Stacy" was soooo nice and informative about everything on the menu. She helped guide us through the best options and made the entire experience well worth it! Please do yourself a favor and try this place....it's delicious and you will not be disappointed...!!!! read more

Always feel welcome and the food is outstanding in my opinion! My wife and I come from the Chicago area and this is our can't miss stop. We always bring their sausage bread home to or son and daughter in law. Thanks Nick and staff look forward to our next visit!! read more

You would be pleasantly surprised to dine at this quaint restaurant. The staff is friendly and attentive, the food is worth the trip alone. My husband loves the sausage or pepperoni ball appetizers, he makes a meal out of it and there is still take homes. We have had a variety of dishes and every single one is delicious. Like I said, this place is worth a try. You can tell they appreciate their patrons. This is the restaurant you look for on vacation that is local and good. Enjoy! read more

Amazing food! First visit and had a phenomenal experience. Nick (the owner) was so personable, attentive and checked several times to make sure we were fully satisfied with everything. Cheese curds, fries, pizza, fettuccine alfredo, Caesar salad, and a house salad were all made to perfection. Loved the pizza sauce, not too thick, not too heavy, it was the perfect amount to let all the toppings the star of the show. Waiter was awesome. Very genuine and kind. He also made sure we were fully enjoying our visit. Great first experience - we will definitely be back! read more

One of the the few places open on a Monday night in town after 9:00 p.m. Good buffalo & bbq wings, good calamari (some fancy places are worse), and good service. Shrimp average. Decent ambiance depending who comes in. read more

Mama Cimino's - Good buffalo & bbq wings, good calamari (some fancy places are worse), and good service. Shrimp average. - Pizza Near Me - Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

Truly some of the greatest Italian food I've ever had. Run - DONT WALK - to get the lasagna. Couldn't give it higher praise if I could!

Nice little pizza joint. Staff is friendly and helpful. Place isn't fancy. Prices were good. Got the Pepperoni Rolls and they were great. Got 14 inch Ciminos Crust(thin) with Sausage/Black Olives. Very Tasty and thought sausage was excellent. Will go back. read more

See all

This place was great and I definitely recommend the 24 inch pizza and the bone in wings 10 out of 10 must try again

Stumbled upon this place on a random Monday night. Had an amazing server and an awesome spinach dip pizza! 10/10 would recommend!

Cimino's pizza is better than my favorite local family pizza place in Chicago! The sauce was amazing and they use quality cheese. A thin crust but not crunchy or soggy. The pizza was ready promptly and the staff was friendly. read more

We stopped here after a concert at Alpine, because our Uber driver recommended it. Not only is this place open until 3am for dinner seating (stops serving food & alcohol at 2am), but their staff and service was outstanding. Melissa was our servicer and she was super kind, funny, and gave great recommendations. It is cash only but there's an ATM inside the restaurant. There is outside seating, even though we ate inside I can totally see myself coming back for a nice lunch break. We odered: - Jalapeño Poppers (only $9 for a bunch of them) - Muscles (the sauce was so good we asked for extra bread to dip into) - Pizza - you're allowed to half and half of whatever ypu want (even the specialty ones). Wr had thr Artichoke Dip and BBQ Chicken which was fantastic. read more

Mama Cimino's - 1/2 Artichoke Dip Pizza & 1/2 BBQ Chicken Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

The food had a sticky paste on it and the driver told me it was spunk. The other pizza had a swastika on it with the pepperoni. read more

Mama Cimino's - this man jizzed in my pizza - Pizza Near Me - Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

See all

I just had a private event at this reaturant and it was just absolutely amazing. The food was delicious, especially the meatballs and the sauce! The gluten free pizza was awesome too! Jim was so great helping me plan this. He opened the place early to accommodate 40 people for me, and took care of us like we were family. The resturant was clean, well lit and spacious. Great experience. 10/10 would recommend! read more

Absolutley amazing pizza pie!!! We are from Chicago and were really impressed!!! You gotta try it!! read more

Mama Cimino's - 24" inches of perfection - Pizza Near Me - Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

A nice intimate restaurant and friendly waiter. The pizza was filling and not greasy. They're open til midnight which is good for all night owls read more

Great place great food great people just like family your best bet in town for pizza. A good time great service and overall great food that's gonna leave you with a smile.! read more

See all

Listen, the pizza is good, but they don't have an alcohol license, and they are advertising alcohol with neon signs outside. They never brought us plates, napkins, silverware, nothing. I pointed this out, I said, This is odd, she said this is how people know we are open. Take it for what you will, don't expect restaurant service nor alcohol. Again, good pizza , open late, and will deliver to a 20 mile radius. read more

Mama Cimino's - Pizza Near Me - Lake Geneva, Wisconsin

Amazing and open late! I left to Cali and I am so sad that I don't get this amazing food anymore. However, I always come back so that says something. I can't wait to visit again and enjoy the wonderful flavors of Ciminos pizza! read more

This place is lovely! We went on Thanksgiving, and were served quickly and kindly. The pizza was great and our server, Jim, was awesome. They're open on major holidays and we're very friendly. The bathrooms were cleaner than any I'd ever seen, enough to encourage me to write this review! Great place ! read more

went To go with my family and after a hour wait we were met with mid food and a rude staff wouldn't recommend for even people with a degradation kink read more

We have wanted to try this place for a long time since I found and follow them on social media. Tonight on March 29th we stopped. we ordered a pizza and it was delicious. The staff was friendly and respectful. Nick was in the Kitchen making pizzas. When we stood up to leave he asked us how everything was? very impressed. I will be back. read more

The food was outstanding! BIG portions. We ordered the pepperoni wheel appetizer was SO big and delicious. Service was Exceptional! Would go back and recommend this restaurant to anyone! read more

MEEEEEEEOWWWWW, not only did this go down easy, it came out easy. Fantastic staff, Jim was marvelous. Don't even get me started on Stacy. So dang fun. Food was the bomb digitty. Atmosphere was cute and relaxed. read more

I'll be honest, it did take a long time but right after I called, the delivery showed up. I think they might be using their own delivery drivers so you can't even track it. After it being so long, I thought it show up cold, but it didn't -- it was still hot and it was absolutely delicious! We ordered the pineapple, Hawaiian and it was perfect. I'm sorry people call it "trash" and are so rude too -- they should absolutely work on their delivery and drivers but the pizza was amazing. read more

Great Pizza and Italian food the owner is a great chief .His hot wings are fantastic.

The garbage pizza was indeed garbage. Why? Because EVERYTHING was so salty it was inedible. The meat, cheese, veggies, sauce and crust were ALL crawling with so much friggin' salt my lips literally started to chap and burn! read more

I stopped here because it was the only place open after 9:30 and am so happy I did. It was some of the best pizza and garlic bread I have had. fast and very friendly service. Was greeted on arrival and the server chatted with us while we were there. We had a cash pay special and ended up paying less than we would at a fast food place. this is going on my "we will always stop here when in Lake Geneva list" read more