I just had to share my absolutely phenomenal dining experience at Mannino's Italian Restaurant in Hightstown, NJ -- because WOW. This place isn't just good... it's on a completely different level. With a massive menu that truly has something for everyone, Mannino's delivers incredible food, next-level service, and unbeatable value. Honestly? It's a solid 11 on a 1- 10 scale! Let's talk service. It was nothing short of spectacular. Co-owners Vito and Jose run the dining room with such precision, warmth, and genuine care that you feel like a VIP the entire time. Their attention to detail is unreal, and watching them keep everything running flawlessly in a bustling, fast-paced environment is seriously impressive. And the food... my goodness, the food! These are classic Italian recipes passed down through generations, but what truly makes Mannino's shine is the quality of their ingredients. You can taste it in every bite -- rich flavors, perfect textures, and this unmistakable touch of culinary magic. It's the kind of food that makes you stop mid-bite and say, "This is something special." If you haven't been to Mannino's yet, go. Don't walk -- run. It's a dining experience you absolutely do not want to miss. Harry Robinson CEO Technology Solutions Partners read more

Great pizza Amazing cheese steak and fries Quick delivery Review forced 85 words, so.... Will pad and fill review.... Try their calzones... Must...eat...now... read more

Great pizza for the price. Friendly too! Beef options for pepperoni which is hard to find! read more

Best pizza in town. Always yummy, although I prefer to just order takeout. Try the pasta, also; it's delicious! It was surprisingly good.

Solid no-frills family owned pizzeria! Been coming here for years and never had a bad meal. Thank you mannino's for always delivering on quality! read more

Mannino's 4 Pizza & Restaurant - Pepperoni and onions - Pizza Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

See all

Went for a late night food crave on a Saturday night. Let me check out the shrimp Parmigiana it was tasty. Shrimp weren't very large, but you got six. The pizza was nicely crusted with a thin crust without us asking for it. So greedy, I forgot to take a picture. I have the linguine leftover as my take home. The place is cute. Stone walls, with chairs with the carved into the back of the chairs. The staff was very friendly. Great for a neighborhood local spot. read more

See all

Fast friendly and personal takeout service. It amazes me how they know who you are and take care of you so fast despite being mobbed with n a Friday evening. Pizza was hot and very good! The right crust and cheese/sauce amounts. read more

Amazing margherita pizza and wings. Prompt delivery too. They even throw in some free rolls.

What a great surprise. We stopped on our way to Florida during an overnight in Princeton, and we tried find the best cheesesteak we could. We happen upon Mannino's, and by far it was amazing. Growing up in south Jersey it brought me back and reminded me of the most delicious childhood memories . We ordered the large , and they double checked just to make sure that was what we wanted it. We understand why now it came. It came in two separate boxes. Cut in half enough to feed a family of four. My husband and I enjoyed all of it and months later still compare every other one to theirs. It was absolutely perfect and exactly what we're looking for. Thank you read more

Came in for slice and just wanted Sausage and onions, asked if they could just add on regular slice. Was told no... The price of this place is also off the roof...they are feeling themselves a little too much. Sad because they are so close but with papas or DeLorenzo a few miles away, then I guess will have to take the ride. Poor customer service. Over it they will not see my business for a while. read more

We stopped here on a complete random chance trying to get through NY. Amazing. The owner was gracious to welcome us in and the kids had a few great slices. We tried the God Father sammy. That was really great! I highly recommend this place to those passing by as well as others from Texas! read more

Mannino's 4 Pizza & Restaurant - Pizza Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

Just a short drive from the highway, this was a terrific, authentic pizza shop with great service and excellent food! I will definitely be back! read more

First time here since I was passing through. Read good reviews. Didn't disappoint! The crisp on that cheese slice was music to my ears and porn for my palate ;) read more

Mannino's 4 Pizza & Restaurant - Cheese slice. Broccoli and tomato - Pizza Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

Service at counter is uncertain and not reliable. I was not given a discount that was advertised read more

Mannino's is a no-frills pizza joint in Hightstown. I used to order from here on occasion when I used to work in the area and remember the pizza was pretty good. However, it was very underwhelming on a recent take out visit. The pizza was light on cheese, and neither the cheese, nor the sauce registered well with regards to flavor/quality. The best part of the pizza was the crust, but the overall pie was otherwise an unmemorable disappointment. I hate to rate them as 3 stars, but you have to do better in a competitive central NJ pizza market. They do have an extensive menu which includes pasta & sandwiches, so will have to try those when in the area again, but I won't be rushing back to try their pizza. read more

Mannino's 4 Pizza & Restaurant - Large Cheese Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

This place is definitely not as good as it once was. The chicken on my orders ( eg. buff chicken pizza, chicken cheese steak sandwich, etc) tastes rubbery and an odd taste to it. What happened? This place was a fave for over 20 years. read more

The restaurant has a great on-line ordering process for delivery. Delivery is always prompt and courteous. They have an extensive menu with very tasty and good quality food. read more

Great pizza. Not only do they have your average pizza toppings, but they have gourmet pizza like buffalo chicken, penne vodka, etc. The penne vodka is carb HEAVEN. Oodles of noodles piled high on the pizza and the perfect amount of tasty, authentic vodka sauce. The penne vodka pizza is my favorite by far. Fair prices and a nice seating area--whether you're here for just a slice or a pie, wings and the works, this makes it a great place to stop for a cheap bite to eat. read more

Mannino's 4 Pizza & Restaurant - Penne vodka pizza! Carb heaven! - Pizza Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

I swung in for a late night dinner with my wife. We ordered a small god father that was super affordable, with enough left over for a mid night snack. The pizza was fresh made and right out of the oven. Super fresh and tasty. I would definitely come back again when in the mood for pizza. read more

Mannino's 4 is located in the lovely town of Hightstown along a busy main street. There is plenty of seating and lovely photographs and wall furnishings that create a warm and inviting environment. There are plenty of options at the front counter and I decided to get a plain slice, Margherita slice, and a pasta slice. The slices at Mannino's 4 have a perfectly thin and crispy base that is a medium-brown color and has a good structure to hold up the toppings. The outer crust is crispy, with a fluffy, bready interior. The plain slice had a good cheese to sauce ratio with a pleasant, sweet-tasting sauce. The penne-vodka slice was decent and featured a good, creamy vodka sauce. The aesthetic was enhanced by some fresh herbs placed on top of the slice, though they didn't add much noticeable flavor. The big winner at Mannino's 4 is the Margherita slice. The base is perfectly crispy and thin. The sauce is rich and chunky with great flavor. The cheese is fresh, milky mozzarella that melts in your mouth. This is the slice I highly recommend if you are stopping in for a bite to eat. read more

Mannino's 4 Pizza & Restaurant - Awesome slice of Margherita - Pizza Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

See all

The best pizza place in town. Buffalo chicken pizza is to die for. Buffalo sauce and blue cheese mixed into one creamy sauce, not super spicy. Godfather is also delicious--ham, fried chicken, vodka sauce, mozz. They have the best vodka sauce, so also recommend that entree. Sausage roll could use some work--doughy, soft crust that would be better crispy. read more

Mannino's 4 Pizza & Restaurant - Godfather large pie - Pizza Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

Pleasantly surprise the food is great I love it service is great and the ambience is also great I recommended

Solid pizza place with a ton of other option's , chicken parm and cheesesteaks are delicious

As a visitor to the area I asked some colleagues what was the best place to get an authentic eggplant parmigiana sub and a slice as they say in Jersey ! Well Manning's delivered the best eggplant parmigiana I have ever tasted in the United States ! Great service, convenience dine-in and outstanding food! If your in this area you have to try this incredible place! read more

absolute BEST buffalo chicken pizza i've ever had. been coming back for years just to buy it! was there to pick up a few slices on new years eve, which i had to spend alone due to possible covid exposure. not only was it 20 minutes past close (i wasnt aware until i left), but they insisted on giving me some free slices to go- which made my night much better! read more

Great NJ pizza. Stopped here while driving on NJ TPK. Good Sicilian slice- thick, good flavor dough, and right amount of crunch to crust. Also had slice of plain. Good sauce and right amount of cheese. Not greasy. Always happy to see shakers of oregano, crushed red pepper, and garlic powder readily available. As a native Jersey girl, and now living elsewhere, it's always frustrating to have to ask for those at a pizzeria. And usually the wait staff says they have to see if they have any ( no comment on why the waitstaff would not think that a pizzeria would have those basic ingredients in an Italian kitchen). And if they return with it, it's usually in a tiny cup with - small amount. Although once they brought out a Costco size oregano container. sorry for the digression. Try Mannino's. You'll enjoy it. The staff are very friendly too. read more

Mannino's 4 Pizza & Restaurant - Grandma and plain slice - Pizza Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

Really really good. This place will certainly be added to the regular rotation for pizza places. Classic NJ pies, very reliable. Don't need to say much more than that. read more

The pizza was great! A crispy bottom, an even layer of cheese and sauce the pizza had, but it could have use a touch of extra spices. This is my first time having Jersey pizza in a while. This place was definitely step up from Virginia pizza (which I've been used to for the the last 5 weeks) but not as good as the pizza from my home state of New York. Either way, the friendly service, clean establishment, and good food is the reason why I give this restaurant a 5 star rating! I hope to return soon! read more

Mannino's 4 Pizza & Restaurant - Two slices of plain pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

I travel to NJ for work a few times a year and these are hands down some of the best wings I've ever had. For the last 10 years they never disappoint. Pizza is really good to but I go for the wings!!! read more

It was going to be raining and I needed sub sandwiches. Yelp was there to find close by place. Service for fast for takeout and so.. looks great in a box. Italian bread makes the difference. read more

Mannino's 4 Pizza & Restaurant - Wall mural on right at entrance - Pizza Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

See all

Have been going to Mannino's for 20+ years and it's by far the best pizza in town! I'd also challenge you to find more plump and juicy buffalo wings anywhere else as well. The family friendly atmosphere put forth by Joe and his wife are consistent with each visit to this pizzeria. You won't go wrong with any dish, but my favorites by far are the Grandmas Pizza and the Buffalo Pizza read more

This was my first time trying Mannino's 4 and I can sum up this visit by saying "I'll be back." I ordered The Godfather Pizza for my daughter and I. Not only did it sound good, it looked good and tasted even better. I will definitely have to try their other pizzas and menu items as well. read more

Mannino's 4 Pizza & Restaurant - Godfather Pizza - Pizza Near Me - Hightstown, New Jersey

Favorite pizza in town! The sauce is rich. The pies are huge. The entrees are delicious. Everyone we've interacted with has been friendly. Great spot! read more

First time trying the pizza at this place ordered Asked for pizza well done Was a really good pie. Great crust Will try again read more

Mannino's 4 is horrible. I feel like this is a place of yesteryears that is riding the coat tales of a once good reputation. It feels like they do not care about their restaurant or the quality of food that they are now dishing out. We ordered the chicken parm it was disgusting, the sauce was from a can, the chicken was old, and the bread it came with was frozen. We also ordered salad to share for our dine in dinner. The server came out with a salad on a styrofoam plate that had one cherry tomato on it. Who puts one cherry tomato on a salad. The service was horrible. The sit down tables were dirty. we went on a Thursday night, it appeared they had plenty of staff who could care less about working and more about hanging out being on their phones. The atmosphere sucked. Who wants to hear loud annoying music that has nothing to do with Italian dining. Calamari, was disgusting. It feels like they do not put love or care into what they are serving. Everything came out at once as if we ordered takeout or they just wanted to be done having to work as soon as possible....I want to like this place, I really do, but this is not the first disappointment from them in the last year. This however will be the last time we go or order takeout. Get your shit together Mannino's 4. read more

Always quality pizza. Simple sauce, well done crust and perfect amount of cheese. My go to in the area

Food is always amazing and delivered fresh and hot, my go to spot! Their Vodka sauce is amazingggg !!! Wings are always perfectly crispy and flavorful. Cant go wrong eight their pizzas either, I've never not liked something I've ordered here. Keep up the great work! read more

Overall excellent food reasonable prices. The pizza is very good and always constantly good. The calzone is great.

Since the pandemic, I have been trying to support local businesses in my area. I frequently order pizza from Planet Pizza however Mannino's is a new favorite. Their wings are the BEST around. The pizza is thin and crispy, not soggy, and flavor is great. My favorite is the TouchDown Pizza. The pizzeria has a great neighborhood feel. I will be ordering more from here from now on! read more

Right down the street from where I work so when I forget my lunch, it's always a reliable spot to stop in. Pizza is always great, amazing low prices and lunch deals. One of the best pizza places I've been to that's not a mega-chain. Top notch pizza. Make sure to stop in and try their honey mustard & chicken pizza. Delicious, and I honestly don't really like honey mustard that much! Amazing place and will always stop in for a bite. read more