Very friendly and kind staff, i was a bit skeptical because the owner was guaranteeing that I'd like it and be back for more. It was pretty good, no real complaints, it was made fresh and it was the perfect crisp. Classic pizza joint, but they don't have ready to go slices on display. read more

Mario's Pizza - Buffalo - Pizza Near Me - Mercerville, New Jersey

My wife and I went into this amazing place on our trip to New Jersey. They set us up with a table in the back and catered to us the whole time! Everyone was so friendly and the food was the BEST! We tried so many new things and it was all so good! The dessert i already miss because it was so good! I can't wait to go back and visit this place again. I don't understand how some people did not leave a good review because it was all BOMB! Thank you to all the amazing staff!! We miss yall already ! -From the two Cali women read more

See all

Catered pizza for a work event today and opened the box to a dead roach sitting on top of the white pizza, absolutely vile. 1 star automatically, clean your kitchen and check your product before sending it out... read more

My boyfriend and I do pizza Fridays every week and so far, this has been the BEST pizza. It's affordable and the quality is so good. The fries were really good too and it was very reasonably priced, as well. 5/5 read more

We bought 2 salads. 1 buffalo chicken Ceasar salad and 1 chicken Ceasar. For $31, I would have preferred to make our own salad at home after seeing it. There was nothing special about it nor was it visually appetizing. After my husband and I ate (threw half of it away), we both started to feel quite sick to our stomachs. We believe we were given spoiled salad dressing or maybe the chicken was not fresh. We will not be returning customers. This is not our first disappointmenting experience at the place unfortunately. read more

Good food Authentic Italian gravy on meatball parmigiana sandwich Salads were fresh and lots of flavor I met the owner Mario, nice guy Great Italian heritage Good people and great food. Go there you won't be disappointed I will be back and this restaurant will Be on my food blog as a place to visit frequently read more

See all

I don't know what kind of wicked magic is used here but my first trip here I grabbed a cheesesteak and a slice to go. This cheeseteak was so damn tasty, so far the best I have had in the area. Toasted roll went nicely with it. This will be my go to when I need to grab lunch or early dinner as I work down the street. read more

Pizza was outstanding! Great flavor Please come to Mario's Guaranteed Family friendly read more

I love Mario's there food is good and the workers are so nice. We order from them every Friday. They even have a credit card machine to use when they deliver. read more

I had a double take deal that was for dine in only but obviously this is not an option due to the Covid-19 restrictions imposed on restaurants. I decided I would call and ask if they would still honor the deal for takeout. I spoke with Mario himself who told me that if I spend more than the $30 on the certificate he would honor it and explained to me that his business was suffering terribly. So, I placed my order for Manicotti and Eggplant Parm dinners, as well as a plain large pizza and an eggplant parm sub and off I went to pick up my food. I pulled into the parking lot of Mario's pizza which was certainly an unassuming and old school building. Upon entering it was reminiscent of an 80's style pizzeria. I was surprised to see that the place appeared to be business as usual and no sign of gloves, masks, or sanitizers and several people working behind the counter. My food was ready when I arrived and still hot. I was a bit surprised that the dinners were on the smaller side and didn't come with any sides or bread as most places provide. The eggplant didn't even come with pasta. All in all the food was decent but I wasn't wowed. The only reason I really went here was because of the double take deal and based on the reviews I expected better. The pizza was nothing special either but on a positive note the prices are very low. Maybe there are some specialties here that I missed but I won't be going out of my way to go here again. read more

See all

Mario's Pizza is well known for it's excellent pizza with exceptional crust. My wife and I have frequented often over the years. We enjoy his tomato pie which I refer to as a "crossover" for he makes a perfect blend of a tomato pie on top of his pizza crust. Those who like tomato pie but want more crust than the super thin normally associated with it will be very pleased. In addition, we heard that the cheesesteaks and fries are second to none. So we tried them and were not disappointed. The cheesesteak was great, the roll was awesome. And the fries were the best! And generous servings too. read more

Mario's sits on East State Street Extension, west of the I-95 underpass; an area of Hamilton where I rarely go because it feels a bit isolated. Glad I put on my big boy pants and drove out there for lunch Friday afternoon, because it is a nice shop with everything made in house, and friendly folks. I sat at one of the few booths, in sight of the HDTV showing Trump's inauguration with commentary. Ordered the eggplant parmesan sandwich, and pulled a Coke Zero from the cooler. Even got to read the complementary Trentonian rag that was on my table. The hot sandwich was a foot long, cut in half, and loaded with thin slices of breadcrumb coated, olive oil pan sauteed, deep purple nightshade. It was topped with a layer of mozza and finally a thick chunky red gravy. It was so big, I decided to use knife and fork rather than attempt direct oral assault. It was delicious and filling. I should have asked for extra sauce on the side, because the eggplant overwhelmed the top dressing, and more dipping would have made the lunch even better. Not complaining. It was excellent. I chose to leave most of the roll aside so I could concentrate on the prize. Will return for their pizza and tomato pie and revisit Mario's star power, without the political commentary. read more

See all

I just called Mario's and they said they don't deliver to me ( they have many times before ) they are just mad because we don't tip them how much they want us to. They have said racial slurs to us because we're Mexicans. read more

This is one if those rare, old school Italian pizza joints that is frozen in time from 1975. The deep orange tile kitchen walls and contrasting floor, fake wood wall paneling with adjacent red booths, yellow lit menu boards with crooked black letters, and vintage chandeliers make this a place that gives you the feeling of stepping back to simpler time. The prices are old school too. I got a meatball parm and a soda for under $9. The meatballs were homemade, and there was just the right balance of marinara sauce and cheese. Toasted in the pizza oven perfectly and served on two paper plates stuck together, this was a fantastic sandwich for a Thursday afternoon. Coming back for sure when I'm in the area again. read more

I been going to Mario since they opened. The place is the same as it always been which makes it very warm and happy to be in there. The pizza is one of the best out there. Mario goes out of his way for all of his customers when requested. They took care of my catering for both of my parents funeral and always goes above and beyond for everyone. I couldn't ask for a better pizza place than Mario. Since moving out of state, I cannot wait to go back on my first day back to NJ to get Mario pizza !!! read more

Overall rating: 3.5/5. Our group ordered an order to go. I enjoyed the pizza buffalo (rating: 4/5), the one with cheese and mushroom (rating: 3.5/5), and the plain cheese one (rating: 3.5/5). The crust was crispy on the outside with the right amount of chew inside. The amount of topping was generous on all pizzas. The iceberg salad with ham was subpar (rating: 2.5/5). read more

We stopped in to have pizza, I eat gluten free. This was the best gluten free pizza I have had. The crust was fantastic. The pizza held up overnight for lunch the next day. The sauce was really good too. I had pepper, onion and garlic on it and they were perfectly cooked, not over or under cooked. I can't wait until I'm in the area again and eat their GF pizza. read more

Meatball parm - yummy - great toasted bread, sauce, delish cheese, good meatballs.. get one! My cousin says they are a must have!! Pizza - classic!!! read more

Awesome old school pizza joint. I order here often as I live in the area. Most of their business I believe is takeout. But there are a few booths to sit inside . Chicken cheesesteaks and regular cheesesteaks are very good. Fresh ingredients nice size. Solid roll . Cheese fries. Very good. Good pizza as well . Good prices nice people. One of the better pizza joints out of the 475 or so in the area. Check em out !! read more

We were looking for a place to eat and found it. When we walked in, it looked like it hadn't been renovated in 30 years. There was a Pacman-looking arcade game and empty gumball machines. The pizza was average. It was okay but there was nothing special about it. The meatball sub is really good, so I would suggest that. The mozzerella sticks were disgusting; they were freezer burned and the sauce was like soup. Overall, it was an average place and there's probably better. read more

Mario's is usually my first stop when I get in town. This was my uncle's favorite pizza place for years and it quickly became mine. Now, it is the only place my dad will order from :) Mario himself work on most days and love to make sure that everyone is enjoying their meal. The pizza is among the best in the area and the sandwiches will really take care of you!! Keep up the great work!!! read more

Great staple for regular pizza and sandwiches. Great Friendly owners. Not much ambiance but plenty of food, tastes great, and always some old Italian guys in there telling stories. I work down the street and hit the place up several times a month. I love the plain pizza and cheese steaks. read more

Mario's is usually up to the bar for the staple pizza stuff. That being said I was disappointed with the cheese steak I got tonight. Not the usual fair amount of meat by far. It was a roll with a bit of meat on it. I feel cheated. It changed my opinion on where to go for said fare. I'm going to post a pic of it if they don't pay enough attention to posts to care enough and contact me.. Again this is not the norm I know so far... read more

Good local pizza place. Use them regularly (once a month) as several people in the family prefer their pizza over others. I like the convenience and the nice coupon discounts. Never ate in the place, always have taken out. Never seem busy and always a cordial pick-up. And it's a Centipede video game in the corner. read more

They get the 3 P's from me - Perfect Pizza Place! If you love that good ol home town pizzeria then Mario's is the place 2b. They're "authentic" and to me that's the true essence of great pizza products. Friendly staff, fast cooking, and great tasting food. My new favorite cheese steak, beefy, tasty and filling. I also tasted 2 slices of plain and 2 slices of Sicilian (my fav) so far and both were great the ratio between sauce cheese and dough were perfect. (I used to be a pizza guy a looooong time ago, i was damn good too, made ev from scratch. Everything.) so take my word for it. ALSO, a nice HD flat screen on top of the soda machine with booths down the wall to sit in and enjoy the game. The decor, I couldn't rave enough about. They are fans of my sports team and have plaques on the one wall and world landscape photos on the other. fresh ingredients, veg's, etc ensure a quality tasting meal. They even got an ice cream case in there with all kinds of treats. There is ample parking in the front lot there right off the road. Got another cheesesteak the other day. Bangin taste. Nice friendly guys. read more

Best pizza in town. Grew up in Hamilton so I know all the places around town for pizza, and Mario's is by far my favorite. While the atmosphere isn't the greatest because they always have loud Italian soccer games on the TV, the owners are extremely friendly and make sure that you enjoy your meal. Even gotten free zepoles a few times for being a regular customer. Their crust is amazing and they never skimp in cheese. Their mushrooms are also my favorite. Best pizza in Hamilton. read more

Good family place run by a good family, we get our pies there often, they're just around the corner. Give'em your business you won't be sorry - the pizza is really good. read more

Seeing the sign for Mario's as I drive down 295 on a weekly basis made me look up the reviews on this place. While so many reviewers saying it's the best pizza they've ever had, I think it was just "ok" pizza. The flavor and texture was identical to Brother's by the Princeton Junction train station (which is closer to us). We won't be coming back, mainly because we can get the same stuff much closer to us and the same price. read more

Food was decent.crust was a bit too hard for my liking but over all a great family place. The staff are friendly and quick with orders. They are mostly italian food which is nice. read more

If you don't look like a "preferred customer" don't go to Mario's. I stopped by one night after work in plain clothes, ordered a large cheese pizza, and sat down across from the register. 10 minutes later a man in business casual walked in, ordered the same thing, and stood at the register. About 5 minutes one of the employees pulled a large cheese pizza out and the other customer prepared to pay. I stood up told him it was probably mine. He saw me waiting so he apologized and backed off. The employee "corrected" me, stating it was in fact the other guy's. How someone can order the same item 10 minutes later than someone else and be served first is beyond me. I guess the manager decided my time and business didn't matter. Now they don't seeing as I'll never go back. If my family wasn't waiting for me with the expectation of Mario's I would have left on the spot. read more

Pizza here is the Jersey standard. The restaurant is well kept and clean, though I was distracted from enjoying my pie by the soccer game on the television. I couldn't even have a conversation with my date. It definitely detracted from the atmosphere. Regardless when in Hamilton, Mario's isn't a bad choice. read more

UNOs had an hour wait so we searched and found this. Surprisingly ok. If you are looking for something inexpensive, good crust and reasonable pizza - this is ok. read more

Best pizza place around. Even when I go away on vacation, you cannot match the pizza this place makes. The owner and workers are the best all around. Highly recommended!!! read more