Marcella's is one of those classic happy hour spots that my friends and I keep coming back to. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Not only do they always accommodate our large parties, but the low lit ambiance and impeccable service cannot be beat.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The arancini is a MUST try. I had never tried it before and was pleasantly surprised. I recommend getting a pizza or their mussels on happy hour. Definitely a great spot for a date night or girls night outing! read more

Marcella's - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Marcella's is a classic Columbus staple. What makes it stand out above the rest is their happy hour! M-F half off drinks and apps. My wife and I brought some out of town friends here on a Friday and left stuffed and feeling like we didn't break the bank! Amazing food. The meatball is to die for. Service was great. Our waitress was very friendly. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Great ambiance.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] It stays busy so you'll need a reservation. I can't recommend this place enough. read more

See all

Parking was aweful. Ok, I knew we were going to the short north and parking would be a challenge but plan ahead- it was a solid 5 minute walk. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Marcella's was jam packed on a Wednesday evening, the noise level made table conversation very difficult[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]. We were seated along the left adjacent to the isle leading from the front door to the kitchen and restroom. We were bumped MULTIPLE times. A party of 7 was squeezed into a round 5 top next to us adding to the cramped space. [[HIGHLIGHT]]It was in the 50's yesterday and they kicked on the AC 30 minutes after we were seated. Now I'm Im cold, cant hear and Im getting bumped by guests and staff[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]]. We ordered the Italian Wedding Soup expecting a chicken broth based soup. The soup base was ONION. It was aweful. DO NOT recommend. Hubs ordered the chicken parmmesian. The chicken was tender, breaded and well seasoned. The red sauce on the chicken tastes like vinegar. The side of fettini alredo noodles was nothing special. He didnt care for the noodles and sauce admitting Carabbas and Olive Garden has better chicken parmesian and alfredo I orderedthe meatball alredo. And also didnt care for my meal. The meatball was "mealy" an crumbled on the plate. I had 2 different red sauces on my plate. The rich deep red the meatball was simmered in that slightly tasted like the sauce had burned. The fettuccini noodles were delicious, light and fluffy BUT dry. More sauce was needed. The red sauce on the noodles was brright and delicious! The alfredo was lost in the burnt taste of the meat ball sauce. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Overall, this was a disappointing experience. The ambiance was poor and the food was terrible[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] We had invited a friend visiting from out of state who ordered the italian salad and only ate part saying it was just ok. He also ordered the ravioli, ate part of it and let the rest go back. I expected better from a Cameron Mitchell restaurant. read more

Went to the Short North location of Marcella's for happy hour. I've been to this location a few times but this was by far my favorite experience. Buckeye Espresso Martini was a special and it was amazing. The Crispy Potato Pizza was also a new one for me, and I loved it. The arancini is always amazing. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Server was great, service was quick, and the ambiance is always great at Marcella's.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Can't wait to visit again! read more

Marcella's - Arancini - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

My favorite restaurant in Columbus, always a perfect time here! [[HIGHLIGHT]]Came here for Valentine's Day, so it was definitely busy but still a good experience.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]I've honestly never seen this restaurant not super crowded.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Our server Jacob was very attentive. Food was delicious as always! Had the roasted garlic cheese bread as an appetizer, and the creste arrabbiata for dinner. This was plenty of food for the both of us as we split the entrée. Both dishes were perfectly cooked and very yummy; to be honest I could probably order one of everything off this menu as everything looks and smells so good. Great time here as always, and will definitely be back! read more

See all

One of the best happy hour spots around. Half price appetizers, salads, drinks and pizza!! A couple of friends joined me for the first time and they loved it. You can beat the wide range of delicious options. There wasn't a bad bite. Hard to beat this beautiful restaurant right in the heart of the Short North. Our service was good, depending on what you like. Our waiter could have been a little more attentive, but overall it was friendly and spot on! We got a meatball, arancini, and some shrimp. We got a couple of pizzas. And, I had to have some of their mussels. We all had at least two rounds of drinks. All for $100. We thought it was a deal. Check it out! read more

See all

I am a sucker for a good happy hour and Marcella's does not disappoint here. I came here with a large group of friends and dispute our bigger party and the restaurant being packed our waitress did an excellent job of taking care of us and keeping the drinks following. We had a round of espresso martinis which were delicious and I had some wine. My husband and I started with the incredible meatball, which could not have been more tender or flavorful. Then I had an awesome ceasar salad and my husband and I also split the mushroom pizza which was amazing. Our table tried the bruschetta, gnocchi, Marsala, and chicken parm and everyone raved about their food. I will definitely be back! read more

Marcella's - Mushroom pizza - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

5 Italian dining. Everything we had was delicious and great service. There personal care was so welcoming. The burrata salad was a highlights as were the desserts. The Chocolate Almond tasted like an olive oil cake so tender and moist. The Tiramisu was so unique and creamy with a light coffee flavor it may have been the best I have ever eaten. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Very romantic and cozy vibes.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

See all

Great experience! Came in on a Wednesday at 5:30 for dinner. The place was bumping! We had a reservation and were promptly seated. Our server was fast and friendly, bring drinks shortly after we sat down. Started off with a couple of salads that were outstanding. Had the chicken Parmesan which was really, really good. Usually I ask for more red sauce, and this one was a bit skimpy on it as well, but the side of fettuccine Alfredo just made the dish perfect! I was going to stop half way through and save it for lunch tomorrow, but I just couldn't do it and powered down the whole plate. Daughter got the fettuccine Alfredo with a meatball that she said was also very good. With all the people in the joint and the metal ceilings, it can be rather loud, but I never really had a problem listening to my daughter with my hearing impaired old man ears. Didn't know this was a Cameron Mitchell restaurant until I saw it on the check, which surprised me. I know his restaurants are supposed to be top notch, but I've always been disappointed in one thing or another. Not today. With the exception of the traffic coming down town, I have no complaints whatsoever. Looking forward to coming back again before a show at the Garden Theater. read more

See all

This place is something I have heard about for sometime now. The atmosphere and the bar area is perfect for a date or a night with friends. The staff were incredible and very friendly and overly knowledgeable . The tables are tight so not a fan of that . The food was incredible, had the lasagna and usually I'm afraid it won't be filled with meat and pasta perfectly. I was overwhelmed with joy at how they nailed the portion. Just a perfect place for a great night out. read more

Marcella's - Lasagna - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

We attended a private luncheon with a set menu. The interior is cozy and warm with the dark woods and mood lighting. The service was great and the food was served hot. The desserts were some of the best I've had in a lonnng time. read more

See all

When in downtown Columbus (or Polaris) Marcella's is the place to go for authentic Italian food. It's always fresh and is the closest to my nona's that I have tasted. A must try is the meatball appetizer. It's the size of softball, covered in sauce and cheese, served in a small cast iron dutch oven. Absolutely delicious. The Creste Arabiata is my go-to dish. Rich, spicy and delicious. I wish we had one of these in Cincinnati. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The place is a noisy, but conversation is still possible (grant it, I was here with a convention with 9000 of my closest friends).[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The wait staff had always been friendly are quick. I gave up my table (to help get others seated), so I ate at the bar. The bar staff were fun and engaging. I cannot say enough about this place. read more

[[HIGHLIGHT]]This place was packed last Saturday![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] We called on our way there and they were able to find us a reservation. Our server was the nicest and she truly did her best! She was running around making sure all of her tables had everything they needed. [[HIGHLIGHT]]This is not your typical Italian restaurant. They were playing loud music, playing the football games on their tvs by the bar, and it seemed like people went there to drink and eat their flatbread.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The food was delicious but it was missing their "it" factor. I think it's because they are so busy there is really no time to make the food extraordinary. This place is not the cheapest so I'm not sure if I'll be back. read more

See all

I came for a happy hour and dinner on my recent trip to Columbus. [[HIGHLIGHT]]We were sat in a window seat along High Street which was lovely.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]The ambiance in the restaurant was great.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] We had foccacia, calamari, Italian wedding soup, salad, wine and beer. We shared the gnocchi. Everything was delicious. Our waiter was funny and attentive. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The atmosphere was lively.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] read more

Marcella's - Gnocchi - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

We had a reservation for 7:45 and were seated immediately when we arrived. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Despite how open the seating area is, we were able to hear each other and have a quiet dinner.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] [[HIGHLIGHT]]I did have to use my flashlight to see the menu and get a good look at my food...[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The food was delicious. Most of the menu can be made gluten free which is awesome! The only thing we ordered that we didn't love was the lemon tart. It reminded us of flan, which I'm not a fan of. Our server was sweet and attentive. The only reason I did not give a 5-star review was that it took over an hour for our appetizer to come out and an hour and a half for our entrees. I get they were busy, being that it was Saturday night and we did order gluten free, but that wait seemed excessive, so I moved it down to 4 stars. read more

This is a quick walk from the convention and sports district and is 100% worth the walk and any wait time. We randomly ran upon Marcella's are couldn't be happier that we found it - you will definitely not regret it. Since we arrived early, we were able to be seated immediately (although that changed really quickly) and were immediately greeted by our server who had plenty of recommendations for us to discuss before choosing. We tried a few different drinks and each were great. I'm not sure I can give one as a favorite since they were all so good. Of course, the bread to start was also fresh, warm, and perfection. Any place that starts with fresh bread is a win, for sure. As for food, we had a quick appetizer, burrata, which was great, easy and exactly as expected. Since I couldn't decide on an entree, I went with classic lasagna and was not disappointed. The portion was large, the sauce was perfect, and the filling was delectable. I can't wait to get back to Columbus to go again. read more

See all

This place is a 5/5 for sure. Asher was a friendly guy that Cameron may have groomed himself. We got a little bit of everything. Muscles, carpaccio, wedding soup, mushroom pizza, fettuccine and meatball. Cocktails wines. Favorites were the carpaccio and the meatball. [[HIGHLIGHT]]Pretty tight space, I guess they are trying to get as many people a they can in there.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] I was ok with it. At one point Marcella came out and bashed some skulls, no biggie. I'll be back for sure!!!!!!!!!! read more

See all

Service: Anders was attentive and friendly. He answered any and all questions we had during our first visit. Waiting for water was not an issue. Ambiance/Atmosphere: [[HIGHLIGHT]]The inside is beautiful. Dimly lit and well decorated. This is a great spot for an Italian date night.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Food: Lasagna was delicious. The bolognese is a mixture of veal and ground beef. The meat sauce was flavorful and perfectly seasoned with quality flavorful cheese and béchamel. This lasagna is some of the best I've had and I highly recommend. Meatball Alfredo was great. Incredibly tender and flavorful veal meatball with a delicious marinara sauce and lying in a bed of Alfredo linguine. This dish was well seasoned and flavorful. Refreshing change from basic meatball dishes. I'd recommend. Veal picatta was ok. The veal was tender and the lemon sauce was good, but it lacked flavor. The potatoes it came with were fluffy inside and a somewhat crisp exterior, but again lacked flavor. The dish as a whole needed a lot of work with seasoning and it seemed to rely on the lemon sauce rather than a flavorful dish in itself. I wouldn't recommend. Chicken Parmesan was good. Large Crispy cutlet topped with quality mozzarella and well seasoned. This was a solid chicken parm and the Alfredo angel hair pasta it came with was an excellent pairing. I'd recommend. Gnocchi Bolognese was amazing. Soft but squishy, gnocchi as it should be. Flavorful sauce and lamb bolognese was tender and in abundance. This was a highlight of the night and I'd highly recommend. Ricotta Cheesecake was good. The lemon cookie curst was an excellent change from the basic graham cracker crust. The strawberry sauce and fresh strawberries added a perfect freshness to the sweet and citrus notes of the cheesecake. If you enjoy cheesecake I'd recommend. Cherry Crostata was excellent. Crispy pastry shell filled with an excellent cherry filling. Chunks of cherry mixed so well with the vanilla gelato. If you're a fan of cherries I'd recommend. Cannoli was good. The pistachios added a great flavor and excess crunch. The shell was crunchy and the chocolate ganache was decadent without being overly sweet. The filling was good, but room temperature which isn't ideal for a should be fresh filled cannoli. This was good, but not the best I've had due to the warmth of the filling. This is a maybe recommend. Flavor is good, but the filling temperature really lets this dish down. Almond chocolate cake was fantastic. Layers of almond and chocolate sponge with a chocolate ganache and nuts on top to add a nice crunch. This was a great way to end the meal and I was pleasantly surprised by the strength of the almond flavor. I'd highly recommend. read more

Location: 615 N High Street, Columbus Ohio I would never try to dine here without a reservation for 2 reasons: 1) you will be disappointed to find they have no openings 2) the food warrants security of a guaranteed seating. Sure. There are countless options but when you want the comfort of pasta, there is no close choice. We started our meal with the garlic cheese bread. Served with a small dish of their fabulous tomato sauce, this fluffy, thick bread with crusty cheese and garlic topping is a lovely starter. We shared a Caesar salad (with anchovy) and the kitchen thoughtfully split it into 2 small plates for us. For our main course, we chose the famous veal/beef meatball and one order of lasagna. This was the perfect portion for 2 to share. The meatball arrives in a small covered Dutch oven and is somehow both hearty and delicate. Delicious and lighter than I expected. The lasagna was the star of the show. Perfectly seasoned, the right amount of meat sauce to pasta to cheese. I really prioritized these bites and enjoyed each and every one. We were far too full for dessert but the tiramisu is haunting me - a few tables indulged and the substantial slices had thick layers of their fabulous tomato sweet maracapone cheese filling surrounding the softened lady finger cookies. Next time, for sure. My only FOMO moment was not having enough appetite for the 'melted pecorino', served with crostini and apple - that is what we wanted for dessert but were far too full. This is a traditional Italian restaurant and the service is delightfully friendly and attentive. The magic here is the high level of food quality from an expert kitchen paired with extraordinary servo e. read more

We had a great time at Marcella's. I can't imagine a better happy hour deal. The food and drink were great- chicken parm-yay!! Chase was our server and his service was outstanding in every way and really contributed to our experience. Highly recommend!! Thanks Marcella's! read more

We had a 5:15 pm reservation on Wednesday before a Columbus Fury game at Nationwide Arena. A few of our party arrived at 5 and were seated right away. They even ordered some happy hour appetizers which arrived within minutes of when I arrived at 5:10. I'd been to the Polaris location previously, but the vibe of the Short North location during happy hour is different. Service was very quick, there were a lot of small groups enjoying happy hour, and it was a great experience. We ordered the large meatball, arancini, and bruschetta to start. All were delicious and fairly easy to split 4 ways. I had the Strawberry Fields "Mocktail" which had a lovely strawberry flavor with a fun citrus foam on top. The pepperoni pizza was a great thin crust, and the shrimp appetizer had a great lemon garlic flavor. From other members of my party the red sangria had great fruit flavor and the tortellini was split 2 ways. read more

Marcella's - Bruschetta, Arancini, and Strawberry Fields zero proof mocktail - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Service was fast. I ordered my food and it came out quick and hot. 10-15 mins tops. The bread was delicious, especially with the olive oil. The chicken Parmesan was very good! I would definitely get that again! The meal was very filling! read more

Marcella's - Focaccia bread - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

I've been to Marcella's numerous times now and am never disappointed. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The ambiance of the short north location is cozy (slightly loud) and up scale without feeling like you have to get overly dressed up.[[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] The service is great. They have one of the best happy hours in town. And the food is always delicious. Favorites on the happy hour menu include the melted pecorino cheese, meatball, their pizzas (crispy potato is delish but so is mushroom and prosciutto), and a salad. I also love their chicken Parmesan on the non happy hour menu! Definitely a staple and would recommend read more

We ordered a simple spaghetti and meatball to go on a Saturday night. Our order was ready in 30 minutes and we popped in for a swift pickup. [[HIGHLIGHT]]The restaurant smells amazing![[ENDHIGHLIGHT]] Out of 10, we would rate the spaghetti 5/10. It was edible, but the sauce was lacking flavor and the flavor it did have was definitely on the sweet end. The meatball was graciously large and very tender. The sauce affected the meatball flavor as well, sadly, and the sauce certainly brought the dish down. We would certainly come back, but likely for another offering. read more

Marcella's - Spaghetti & Meatball - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

A Cameron Mitchell restaurant doesn't need any more reviews, but here we are. You know what to expect here: really great service, really unique flavors, and a pretty pricey bill to top off the experience. I will say that Marcella's definitely feels like it's been here for a long time. That comes with the big downside of being in a classic, older location: everything feels really cramped here. Accessibility-wise, this can make it hard to manuever around the location. If you use walking aids or need wide walkways, I would recommend a different restaurant instead. I'd avoid peak hours (or even near peak hours) if you have difficulty hearing. All of the seating here has you closer than one arm's reach to a different table. It's tight. If the table next to you is celebrating something or just louder, it can be really impossible to hear the person across the table you actually came to eat with. If you need extra space for dining, you may need to request a larger table. The tables are barely large enough for the patrons they're designed to seat, and we're always playing tetris with plates throughout dinner. I'm always blown away by service when I come here. Servers are really personable, check in constantly, and very friendly. They're honest and happy to point you away from menu items with an easy familiarity of what they're serving. ("I'm not really into the cream of this dish, but if you love savory beef, you'll love this instead.") Delicious food, amazing service with a restaurant that feels like it has outgrown its space. Just make sure you're prepared for that when you pop in. read more

This is the spot if you're looking for a lively bar area on a work trip. Marcella's was packed when I arrived, but I managed to find a singular seat at the bar. I ordered a glass of Sauvignon Blanc to start my experience, but would've ordered a cocktail had I know they make their own limoncello and pineapple liqueur in house!! Dinner was on the simple side during this dining session. I enjoyed their margarita flatbread, which was so fresh. However, I recommend adding some red pepper flakes to spice it up. I was also feeling a little hungrier so I indulged in their tiramisu! Holy crap- this stuff is amazing!! It balances salty and savory to perfection. read more

See all

While in Columbus Ohio on business hubby & i chose Marcella's for dinner. It was a Saturday night & the place was busy & packed, Good thing we had reservations. We arrived a little early & sat at the bar. The ambiance was lively & people were in good spirits. My cocktail with Aperol & citrus was delicious. My hubby had his fave an old fashion. Both drinks were great. The food was delicious, fresh & tasty. Authentic Italian. I had salmon & it was a tad overcooked. My husband's pasta was super delicious. The restaurant was highly rated & had great reviews. Great service. It did not disappoint. Next I'm in Columbus I will surely try them again. read more

See all

I'll start by saying I love Marcella's. I always get the Braised Veal Meatball and the Marcella's Italian Salad - typically (before the remodel) I would enjoy the free bread, oil, and vinaigrette however they no longer offer that service and instead point you in the direction of one of the other items on the menu that have bread. The Burrata for the price it was underwhelming - I don't think I need to order anymore bread type of dishes... I wish we could petition to get the bread, oil, and vinaigrette back because I sure do miss it. read more

Marcella's - Braised Beef Tortellini Burrata Marcella's Italian Salad - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

I've been to Marcella's many times over the past year - whether it's for date nights, catching up with girlfriends, or group dinners, it's truly become one of my go-to spots in Columbus for a consistently wonderful dining experience! The atmosphere is always vibrant and welcoming - and the service is consistently fantastic--friendly, attentive, and always on top of things. I also really appreciate that one of the first questions they ask is whether anyone at the table has any food allergies. They offer gluten-free pasta and bread which is a thoughtful touch for anyone with dietary restrictions. My absolute favorite dish is the Penne alla Vodka - cooked to perfection every time. I do request it without prosciutto (even though I love it usually) because they crisp it more than I prefer. The creamy tomato sauce with mushrooms is rich and flavorful! The charcuterie board is a lot of fun - you can choose your own meats and cheeses for a fully customized experience! Their bread service is simple but amazing 1 warm, fluffy bread served with oil and balsamic. It's honestly one of my favorite parts of the meal! The bruschetta is a must - whipped ricotta, prosciutto spread, peperonata, and aged balsamic all layered together for a perfectly balanced bite! My go-to drink is a glass of Pinot Noir - pairs beautifully with everything on the menu. Pro tip: Always make a reservation--it gets busy, especially on weekends and you won't want to miss out! Marcella's never disappoints! Whether it's your first visit or your tenth, you'll feel well taken care of and leave full and happy every time! read more

I have been coming here for years and haven't ever had a bad experience. They have two locations; Short North and Polaris. I prefer the Short North ambiance. Feels very Italian, always alive, and packed. Can be harder to find parking in the downtown and they are always packed so make a reservation. There is a parking garage a block away. Polaris has parking, you'll be fine. They have space so no problem here. I've had so many items on the menu. My favorite is the chicken Marsala but sub the potatoes with linguini, you'll be even happier. I have had the carbanara - too creamy for me. Ask for it without the egg at least. The salmon is delicious, and so is their chicken parmigiana. Any of their appetizers are good too. They don't have salad nor any just strict steak or chicken dishes other than the salmon and Marsala. I wish they did. Anything you get is really good. I heard they are changing the menu on Monday, November 11th! '24. Looking forward to seeing what they change and add. Will always be back! read more

Marcella's - Ratatouille with veggies, added shrimp, and linguini! - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

Our table of 12 had a really nice meal at Marcella's. We were able to sample a bit of everything from appetizers to entrees and desserts and really enjoyed the atmosphere as well. I feel the price point was very reasonable. read more

I visited Marcella's while in Columbus for a conference. The vibe when you walk in is pretty cool and not overly fancy. It was a bit crowded, but it wasn't too difficult to hear the people at my table. I had the gnocchi bolognese which included lamb as the meat. I'd never had bolognese this way but it was tasty. Nothing I'd necessarily run back for, but that's based on my own preferences rather than the restaurant. If I were ever back in town I'd come back! read more

Absolutely loved the service and the food. And their 1/2 off happy hour covers so much that you can enjoy a lot of quality food in an affordable way. Seriously - beer, sangria, wine, cocktails, meats, cheeses, antipasti, appetizers, salads, soups and pizzas were all half off from 4 to 6pm (Mon-Fri). My spouse and I tried three cocktails and a red sangria. The best of them was Tuscan Limonata. Stuffed Peppadews had more of a kick than I expected, but they were still good. The Zucchini Parmesan was even better; they may look like house made chips but they are perfectly seasoned and deliver so much more. The veal meatball came highly recommended from our server and it was as good as advertised - sauce and meat. We ended with the Crispy Potato Pizza. Don't sleep on it because it was really, really good. Their Pastas and Specialties are not included in happy hour, but the selections we're appealing, and Marcella's definitely made a strong case for a return dinner date. read more

See all

I have eaten here about 5 times. The Chicken Parmesan and the Strawberry Fields mocktail are both very good. I highly recommend them. The rest has not met expectations. The Chili Rosa pizza tasted like a sweet jam, chili, and cheese. The Cesar salad was overpowered with lemon with burnt croutons. Overall, I'd return for the chicken parmesan and mocktails, but some of the other dishes could use improvement. read more

We went for our anniversary and it was amazing. The food was delicious and not super pricey. The pizza and pasta both very good. The best part was the service! One of the best servers I've ever had! Will be back for sure. read more

Excellent Caesar salad and mocktails ! Two things that are hard to find . Our server was busy but gave us great service . We had a long 15 hour drive and this was a hip fun place to vibe. Fun music too. read more

Marcella's - Mocktail! - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

We went here for the Tirimisu , as another waiter at our dinner restaurant recommended it. We got a seat quickly as we were just eating dessert and coffee. They were very busy. The waiter was very pleasant and engaging in conversation. The Tirimisu was on the sweeter side, not the traditional bitter coffee taste. It also had caramel, which isn't my favorite. It was fresh, I drizzled my coffee over it which made it more reminiscent of traditional Tiramisu. I don't think I would try that dessert again there, but if you like a sweeter dessert you may like it. I would love to try the dinner there because it smelled delicious. The place was clean and had a nice feel of an Italian restaurant. read more

Marcella's - Tirimisu - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all

Service was so so. Soup was delicious but the braised beef tortellini wasn't very good read more

This place is outstanding! It came highly recommended and I can see why. It's a beautiful restaurant located in Short North near tons of bars and hotels, yet it's more of a local's spot. The restaurant is very cozy and beautiful. I made a reservation day, actually night!, of and we had a table when we arrived early (it was a week night but still!) My colleague and I both ordered the Chicken Parmesan. It's a huge piece of tender and juicy, lightly breaded chicken. Well seasoned and topped with marinara sauce. Alongside the chicken is a large pile of pillowy, creamy linguine Alfredo. WOW! It was amazing! You also get bread and oil/vinegar for the table. Prices seem reasonable. Our waitress, Ren, was the absolute best! She was hilarious and kind. We hugged at the end of our dinner and I'd request her everytime I come back! Service was really quick for a busy night. Make a point to have dinner here one night and apparently the meatballs are a must?! The chicken is pretty darn close, too! read more

See all

Ordered carry out and was incredibly underwhelmed. Have enjoyed dining in on multiple occasions so figured carry out would be the same quality of food- we were wrong. The serving sizes were minimal- nearly half of what you'd get in house. For three entrees and appetizer they gave 3 pieces of bread and no oil/ vinegar. They also don't have a place to store the food to keep warm while waiting for pick up so it was just sitting at the host stand. Dining in is a great experience, carry out, not so much. read more

Marcella's - Chicken Parm - Italian Near Me - Columbus, Ohio

See all