Cancel

    Open app

    Search

    Mary Coyle

    3.1 (106 reviews)
    Closed Closed

    Mary Coyle Photos

    Business Info

    MARY COYLE ATMOSPHERE

    What's the vibe?
    Quiet
    Casual
    Outdoor seating
    Good for kids

    You might also consider

    Recommended Reviews - Mary Coyle

    Your trust is our priority, so businesses can't pay to alter or remove their reviews. Learn more about reviews.
    Yelp app icon
    Browse more easily on the app
    Review Feed Illustration

    Reviews With Photos

    Comparison of a peanut butter sundae vs. a dish of strawberry ice cream
    Sue T.

    This is one of the best local ice cream spots in town. Not only that, it holds a lot of historical value to Akron, OH. Come here for generously sized sundaes and THE BEST peanut butter pie ever. I ordered a dish of strawberry ice cream and got a serving that would be a large anywhere else! The serving sizes are so generous; I don't understand how this place makes $$! There's a wider variety of flavors and toppings to satisfy even the pickiest of eaters! I'm not sure why but the pizza here reminds me of my childhood. It just takes me back to when I didn't eat pizza that much and didn't know about all the different types available. It was hot, fresh and the tomato sauce was tart but balanced the softness of the crust well. This is an ideal place to take a date. There's some outdoor seating available, perfect for people watching!! Whatever you do, please order the peanut butter pie. It's decadent, fluffy, and so delicious. I imagined, if I was going through a breakup.. this would absolutely be a perfect thing to eat my feelings. Even better, it's made from scratch from a secret recipe.

    Keith H.

    Our quest to try new places continues! Mary Coyle's Homemade Ice Cream has been an Highland Square icon since 1937. I ordered the Original and Meshelle ordered the Peanut Butter & Jelly! The ice cream was fantastic, we will definitely be going back to try some of their other offerings. Boom!!!!

    Ilona P.

    Home made ice cream! I'm in! This review is just for the ice cream. Just finished my two scoop ice cream! I ordered coconut and vanilla almond- both were amazing but coconut was slightly better! The place was located in heart of highland square- close to Akron's downtown. The menu was slightly confusing but clerk lady explained me all. They also serve Italian food, but I haven't tried yet. I loved my ice cream and already thinking who I'm going to bring here at the next time. Small minus is that place is slightly outworn- I believe they need some interior update :) Nevertheless, come here and get some good and cold ice cream! I will be back lol

    a neon sign in the window

    See all

    Photo of John J.
    3
    92
    22

    13 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    17 years ago

    Great ice cream and their peanut butter pie is awesome!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of eric l.
    9
    65
    129

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    13 years ago

    Love Mary Coyle's homemade ice cream. Can not wait to try their Italian food!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Tim B.
    1
    17
    13

    13 years ago

    Mary Coyle's ice cream is great! The almond ginger crunch beer ice cream is my favorite!

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    7 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    12 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of T M.
    0
    2
    0

    8 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    17 years ago

    Helpful 8
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    17 years ago

    Helpful 8
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0
    Photo of M S.
    0
    7
    0

    15 years ago

    Helpful 6
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 3
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Bob B.
    2
    308
    1067

    14 years ago

    Helpful 2
    Thanks 0
    Love this 1
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 1
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    10 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0
    Photo of Lisa D.
    711
    113
    130

    10 years ago

    Homemade ice cream. Delicious ice cream sodas. exceptional sundaes. great place for a date or special occasion

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    20 years ago

    Good homemade ice cream but fabulous italian pasta. They make the best spaghetti with clam sauce ever.

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    11 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    14 years ago

    Helpful 0
    Thanks 0
    Love this 0
    Oh no 0

    Page 3 of 3

    Ask the Community - Mary Coyle

    You might also consider

    Verify this business for free

    People searched for Ice Cream & Frozen Yogurt 1,103 times last month within 10 miles of this business.

    Verify this business

    Luigi's Restaurant - The standard side salad - yes, there is lettuce (and olives) hiding under the abundance of cheese.

    Luigi's Restaurant

    3.8(900 reviews)
    1.5 mi
    $$

    First time visiting and I was pleasantly surprised! I usually don't go for antipasto, but this one…read morewas really enjoyable--the lettuce was fresh and crisp, and the Italian dressing was flavorful without being too overpowering. The pizza was also very good. If you like a slightly doughy bite, you'll love it--the crust had the perfect balance of crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. Our server was attentive, friendly, and honest about portion sizes, which I really appreciated. I wish I had taken a picture of our food, but that just gives me an excuse to come back--and I definitely will! Looking forward to trying more dishes next time. The place was very quaint, casual and laid back atmosphere....you may want to bring a sweater.

    First time in a long while since visiting this restaurant…read more Place was crowded but our companions secured a table before we arrived. We ordered the antipasta salad for two. It was pretty basic. Two peperoncini peppers and a radish adorned the top. There were four sticks of salami, no pepperoni or ham and the salad was covered with cheese. The salad dressing was on the light side and you could barely taste it, recommend you ask for it on the side. I ordered the sausage and meatball splash and my spouse had the rigatoni. Both entrées were just ok. The bread was great and served warm. Our waitress was attentive w/o being a bother. They finally accept credit cards albeit with a surcharge. I've had better meals in the past at Luigis.

    Photos
    Luigi's Restaurant
    Luigi's Restaurant - Meatball sub

    Meatball sub

    Luigi's Restaurant - Inside wall bar area booths

    See all

    Inside wall bar area booths

    D'Agnese's at White Pond Akron - Beet salad

    D'Agnese's at White Pond Akron

    4.0(219 reviews)
    2.3 mi
    $$

    What a great Italian spot. Cozy throwback vibe…read moreNot expensive Great service The food really was that good. Six of us. Everyone loved their dishes. We all brought leftovers home. Can easily fill up on half salads and bread. Great drinks. Special monthly menu in addition to the standard. Great variety of entrees. Pieces of cake can be eaten by 2 people. Carrot cake is standout. Tip is automatically added to parties of 6 or more. On the " go back to" list.

    Our family came here on Good Friday - the restaurant was calm and not overly busy. We had a…read morereservation for 6pm and were seated right away after arriving. We had 3 four top tables pushed together for our group. We dine out every Good Friday and the acoustics in this restaurant were great. We could hear conversation from one end of the table to the other. Several people had the Fish Fry special of fish and chips - some liked it, some didn't care as much for it. I didn't try it personally, but the plate had three decent size pieces of fish with a side of fries and coleslaw. Nice offering for Good Friday meal. Two of us had Chicken piccata and really appreciated that we could substitute out the side of pasta! One of us ordered a side of grilled veggies (highly recommend) and the other steamed broccoli. Highly recommend the grilled veggies! Good combination of different vegetables. The broccoli was good, but would have ordered without butter. There was a pool of butter they were swimming in. The piccata was good - 3 decent sized pieces of chicken breast. Note if you are not a red pepper fan, order the sauce without. I forgot to ask, but they were easy to pick out. The calamari was a good portion for an appetizer. We hoped they had cocktail sauce for it, but they only had marinara. The mesclun salad was very good and really good size for a half portion. We did not order dessert, but the cakes when you first walk in are quite impressive and imagine are delicious!

    Photos
    D'Agnese's at White Pond Akron - Outside

    Outside

    D'Agnese's at White Pond Akron - Fried artichoke app

    Fried artichoke app

    D'Agnese's at White Pond Akron - The patio view from my table.

    See all

    The patio view from my table.

    Trattoria Vaccaro

    Trattoria Vaccaro

    4.2(185 reviews)
    6.1 mi
    $$$

    Went to celebrate an event in our married lives. We were regulars for years at this eatery. Always…read moregreat food and service. This last time we were both disappointed by service and food. I ordered a pasta dish with pomadoro sauce and a ceaser salad. My wife ordered pasta with seafood. It was easily 20 minutes from salad to entre. When It did come, my pasta was swimming in sauce and not what I had hoped for. My wife's dish had overcooked shrimp, scallops and other seafood was also overcooked. The dessert was good as the wine was too. Sorry to see thus happen to a once great Italian eatery. We won't return.

    Stopped by yesterday with 2 friends for a 4:30 reservation - there were few other diners there yet…read more When the server seated us, she said that our table was booked with another reservation at 6:30 - insinuating we had a time limit, it seemed. Now, a server may think along those lines all the time in their job, but to say it out loud to diners was tactless and less than welcoming. By 5:30 we did not have food yet, and joked with each other that we weren't going to make it in time. Ultimately, at the end of the meal the owner came around and I told him what the server had said. He went into a discourse about how the online booking service (which we did not use) uses 2-hour reservation slots etc etc, either missing or avoiding the point entirely. I mentioned it took an inordinately long time for our orders to come to the table. He said good food takes time. A cop-out, but okay. Consider my plate of salmon piccata. The salmon was not prepared as requested. Capers appeared to be absent (the whole point of piccata) but found a mere 4 under the fish. The asparagus was missing altogether, but the server did bring some quickly. The pasta wasn't overcooked, so that was right. But there was the bread, "focaccia", $2 ala carte. It was so dense and tasteless, except for the garlic on top. There were no air bubbles in sight. Granted I'm not Italian but this was not focaccia. So we'll go back to our usual place on White Pond.

    Photos
    Trattoria Vaccaro - Main seating area

    Main seating area

    Trattoria Vaccaro - Fried calamari

    Fried calamari

    Trattoria Vaccaro - Sorry plate looks messy but pasta and sauce were great, meatballs too finely ground and exact same size. They screamed Cisco..

    See all

    Sorry plate looks messy but pasta and sauce were great, meatballs too finely ground and exact same size. They screamed Cisco..

    Luciano's Cucina Italiana - Alfredo with grilled chicken delicious

    Luciano's Cucina Italiana

    4.2(42 reviews)
    1.5 mi

    We had a lovely time at Luciano's. I was disappointed to see DBA go, however, the replacement is…read morejust as good. (Though I do miss the little pasta flights.) I got the Panzanella with chicken and it was divine. Very filling. The bottle prices were excellent. My husband loved his dish, which was the risotto special... I believe it had seafood in it. Everyone really enjoyed their dishes and the portions were enough. They had an excellent bar menu, though we just stuck with wine. Our server was very attentive and had lots of recommendations. I loved seeing a traditional carbonara on the menu as well... Often, a restaurant will just make this with a cream sauce and call it "carbonara", which is so wrong that it makes my Italian ancestors turn over in their graves. Though I did not get the carbonara this time, I will certainly try it next time. We also saw waiters preparing the table side, Cacio E Pepe, which looked really fun, but ultimately, I felt it was priced more for the experience than the actual food so I did not get that. We had reservations at 8:15 but arrived at 7:45 (planning on waiting at the bar for our friends to arrive ) and they were able to seat us right away. We also got a welcome bubbly drink upon arrival which was such an unexpected, fun, and friendly touch! The servers are very professional, but down to earth. I would absolutely love to come back and try the chef's table.

    First time being in Akron, we stumbled across this really good Italian authentic restaurant. The…read moreambience is incredible. The service is great. The food impeccable. I recommend it for a great date night or out with friends.

    Photos
    Luciano's Cucina Italiana
    Luciano's Cucina Italiana - Risotto (Sweet Potato & Goat Cheese)

    Risotto (Sweet Potato & Goat Cheese)

    Luciano's Cucina Italiana - Cucumber-fennel martini

    See all

    Cucumber-fennel martini

    Parasson's Italian Restaurant - Baked Lasagna and Baked Rigatoni

    Parasson's Italian Restaurant

    3.8(88 reviews)
    5.2 mi
    $

    Parisson's Italian Restaurant is truly a gem! From the moment we walked in, everything from the…read morewarm, welcoming hostess to our attentive waitress made us feel right at home. The food brought back that nostalgic taste of home-cooked Southern Italian cooking the kind of authentic flavors that are comforting, familiar, and incredibly satisfying. And the meatballs were absolutely amazing! I am a very hard critic to please when it comes to Italian food, and these definitely impressed me! The restaurant was clean, the service was wonderful, and the prices were extremely reasonable for the quality and portions. There's also a special connection for me: my sister worked for Parisson's at another location over 40 years ago, and it was so wonderful to see that the food and tradition have continued and, if anything, only gotten better! From start to finish, it was a fantastic experience. Don't change a thing, Parisson's! Keep doing exactly what you're doing and preserving those wonderful Italian flavors and traditions. We will absolutely be back!

    Parasson's is our families Italian food go-to. If you love Italian food, this place is a must try…read more I grew up with a Parasson's location in Canton that I miss a lot. This location has picturesque decor throughout: from the entryway to the dining area. (Check out the pictures of the decor)! There is statue in full armor before entering the dining area... so cool! Make sure to check out the plastic table display holders for limited time only specials and new items. The menu features: salads (house and antipasto), subs: meatball, sausage, and Italian, pasta: lasagna, penne, and spaghetti, pizzas, and you can't forget their cannoli! During this visit, I tried the half & half combo which has a half order of Parassons special meatball and half order of their sausage patties topped with pasta sausage and cheeses! I also added a side salad (iceberg lettuce, tomato's, cucumbers, and cheese with buttermilk ranch dressing ) I had the red onions removed from the side salad. You won't go home hungry! The service is always friendly and hospitable, willing to sing happy birthday (if you want them to). This place brings back lots of childhood memories!

    Photos
    Parasson's Italian Restaurant - Dining area

    Dining area

    Parasson's Italian Restaurant - Order of Garlic Bread

    Order of Garlic Bread

    Parasson's Italian Restaurant - Booth

    See all

    Booth

    Lucci's Place - honestly gas

    Lucci's Place

    4.5(110 reviews)
    10.7 mi
    $

    Absolutely some of the best New York style pizza you can get in the area. Their hours have changed…read moreso it's mostly a dinner time slot now and I hope they will change that back to lunch and dinner in the future but it really good pizza high-quality great taste if you're not in New York City this is the second best place.

    In desperation for a "good"pizza place near us I navigated to YELP for assistance. Lucci's has an…read morealmost 5 star rating so I went in with high hopes here, as would anyone. What I Ordered; a large pizza with one half pepperoni and the other half sausage. Also ordered a SMALL white sauce pizza with chicken, bacon, black olives, fresh tomatoes, and an order of cheesy bread VS What I got; a large pizza with virtually ZERO sauce (it was sooo dry) with half cheese and the other half was BOTH pepperoni and sausage...a large (not small) white pizza with no white sauce to speak of (it looked like it might have been brushed with olive oil or garlic butter, but definitely not Alfredo sauce) these toppings were correct but the chicken was flavorless and the pizza was undercooked. Cold.. Cheese, what there was of it, wasn't even melted. The cheesy bread was correct. HOWEVER despite our picking our order up the instant it came out of the oven (we were in the parking lot) the pizzas were underdone/undercooked and we're cold in the middle. We live LITERALLY 6 minutes away. No way a pie can cool that quickly. Not sure if they were having a bad night or I'm a PICKY bitch ‍ but no way this was 5 stars consistently. HOW?? Maybe since it's across from the University the drunk college kids have no taste buds. It's a no from me sorry. I'm still in search of a really GOOD pizza place.

    Photos
    Lucci's Place - Large supreme - excellent

    Large supreme - excellent

    Lucci's Place - SUPER MEGA ZA PACK, 8.4 FIRE

    SUPER MEGA ZA PACK, 8.4 FIRE

    Lucci's Place - Large pepperoni - excellent

    See all

    Large pepperoni - excellent

    San Marino Italian Restaurant - Large meat lovers pizza

    San Marino Italian Restaurant

    4.2(43 reviews)
    7.4 mi

    I drive past San Marino almost daily but had never stopped in. Italian usually isn't something I go…read moreout of my way for, but after seeing their homemade fettuccine Alfredo featured in a video, it basically summoned me. Our Sunday dinner started a little rocky. It took 5+ minutes to see our server, the kitchen was apparently backed up, and the Watermelon Mojito advertised on the new cocktail menu wasn't available. The Long Island, however, was excellent. From there, things began to improve. The bread was light and airy with an herb dipping oil, and the house salad was fresh mixed greens with a really good house-made Italian dressing. The Chicken Fettuccine Alfredo was the star. Fresh, al dente pasta with a rich, creamy, garlicky sauce and a well-seasoned, crispy chicken cutlet. Absolutely delicious. Melissa loved her Chicken Parmesan with gnocchi. When we asked for extra red sauce, they made it fresh and brought out a warm bowl a few minutes later -- BIG points for that. Our server also became much more attentive and personable once things settled down. A shaky start, but San Marino definitely finished strong. After driving past it countless times for years, I'm already looking forward to stopping again.

    We've been skeptical about San Marino for a while, but after seeing a food review from an…read moreinfluencer who travels the country, we finally decided to give it a try. So glad we did! It was pretty busy for a Sunday at 6:30pm, but we were seated immediately. Our server took a little while to get to us, but quickly apologized and gave us a heads-up that food would take a bit longer because they were so busy. We appreciated the honesty. The table bread and dipping oil were tasty and definitely helped hold us over. I did try to order a watermelon mojito they were advertising on a TV inside the dining room but I was told they no longer had them. So I stuck with water. For dinner, I ordered the chicken Parmesan gnocchi with a side salad and their house Italian dressing. The salad was fresh and delicious (and not a shred of iceberg lettuce!) and the house made Italian dressing was very tasty. It was a golden Italian that had a nice flavor. My gnocchi was AWESOME -- tender, airy and full of flavor, and the chicken cutlet was delicious. I asked for extra sauce because I like my pasta saucy, and they brought me a gravy boat full of freshly made, piping-hot sauce! Turns out their sauces are made to order, which was such a nice surprise.and wellllll worth the wait. Prices were a little higher than I expected, but you can tell the food is made fresh and with care. There's definitely some love going into these dishes. I was a little discouraged in the beginning from the rough start but it all worked itself out and we left really happy that we finally gave San Marino a shot. There are several other things on the menu we both want to try, so we'll definitely be back!

    Photos
    San Marino Italian Restaurant
    San Marino Italian Restaurant - Table set for success

    Table set for success

    San Marino Italian Restaurant - Side dinner salad

    See all

    Side dinner salad

    Mary Coyle - icecream - Updated September 2026

    Loading...
    Loading...
    Loading...