We took advantage of the BOGO 50% off 'Sandwich Day' special. While not exactly authentic (this from a native new yawker) this deli delivers darned good deli sammies. The New Yorker corned beef & pastrami sandwich is very satisfying at an excellent price. I did comment to Tami that no self respecting New York deli would serve it on marble rye. Steamed broccoli side had just the right amount of crunch and, as always, the unsweetened tea is terrific. Tami opted for the roast chicken club sandwich with a side of very good Mac & cheese. read more

Good salads but cheese for spuds and nachos taste so canned.The cheesecake carmel sauce tastes so artificially flavored. I'm sure it's not the fault of this location, it's the chains' decision to use cheap artifical foods. Shame because the salads are good size and pretty good. read more

McAlister's Deli - Chose 2 veggie spud and strawberry pecan salad - Sandwiches Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Delicious meal! Had a BLTA and asked for crispy bacon, and they delivered! The broccoli cheddar soup was hot and delicious. Overall, we placed our order quickly and they delivered to our table quickly and politely. The staff here is really friendly and helpful. Plenty of space to eat, and they have a room that if you have a large group, would be able to accommodate. read more

McAlister's Deli - BLT Avocado - Sandwiches Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Ordered chicken tortilla soup and got broccoli cheddar. So disappointed. I of course did take away so there was no exchanging it. Waste of money and time. read more

McAlister's Deli - Broccoli and Cheddar - Sandwiches Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Good, fresh food. APP orders always timely and accurate. On one occasion, my pick-up order was stolen, but the staff accommodated the replacement quickly. Soups always hot and tasty. The carrot cake is awesome. McAlister's is a bit pricey, but the quality is consistent. If you join their APP Loyalty Club, you may build up points towards entrees, drinks, and desserts. read more

I always forget about McAlisters as a quick and somewhat healthy option, but recently we have been on a kick on getting take out from there. My choice has been the grilled chicken croissant sandwich and the Pecanberry salad choose 2. It is surprisingly filling and I feel better about myself after eating it, rather than something heavy or greasy. Last time, they also threw in a lemon blueberry cookie, and it was surprisingly great, coming from someone who doesn't love lemon things. Going to do our best to not forget about it going forward and keep going here as a good option. read more

3 stars. Great lunch option... if you have time to wait! The line is often out the door. Why have only one register open during the rush? And be careful because people enter from the pickup door and cut the line when they see people they know. So irritating! Arrrgh! But the food is good. It's fresh. It's reasonably priced. Kids meals are a fabulous value. My littles enjoy them immensely. Buy a tumbler and get refills for only $.99! Totally worth it. read more

McAlister's Deli - Tomato & Cucumber Salad - Side - Sandwiches Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

Ordered food for take out 3/29/25. There were two strands of hair in the baked potato. Selected extra option for butter and sour cream. Only received one of each. Base on this experience that was our first and last time as patrons at this establishment. read more

Hurry to McAlister's! It's the last day of free tea day! And they do not skimp, you get a huge serving of tea AND you can get up to 4 free teas per order! Yummy tea and it's free!!! Run!! read more

McAlister's Deli - You can get up to 4 free teas per order on free tea day - Sandwiches Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

My to-go sandwich came in what appears to be a bloody fingerprint wrapper. When I called, the manager told me that the wrappers were arriving at the store this way, but he said he just now noticed that when I called. No, that is unbelievable. Absolutely disgusting and will be reported accordingly. This thing went straight in the trash, and I will not return. read more

McAlister's Deli - Highly questionable splotchy red stained wrapper - Sandwiches Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

See all

I eat at McAlister's quite often. I've picked up dinner from this location two nights in a row. The food is good. Usually the same and I like many different menu items. My 3 stars are not the food. It's the service. Both times, parking was scarce. They removed their to-go spots in front. Then both times I walked into the restaurant to grab my food - not one worker acknowledged or spoke to me. Also, if you don't get them yourself - you will not get crackers for soups/chili. I hope it improves soon as I like visiting for the food. Update: This week I ordered a pick 2 of a club wrap and cup of chili. The order took a little longer than quoted. When I got home it had toppings I had asked to be removed and the toothpick to hold the wrap closed was in the middle of the wrap and was not visible so I bit it. Not safe! read more

We really enjoy the salads, sandwiches, and side dishes at Mc Alister' Deli, but lately have had issues with long waits due to staff shortages and running out of items such as baked potatoes, in the middle of placing an order. The best scenario is to place an order on line and pick up. We will definitely return for some of the items, but probably won't consider trying to dine in. It takes too long. read more

McAlister's is always one of my go to comfort foods. Stopped by this location and was impressed with their Covid precautions. A lot of other locations have staff wearing their masks incorrectly. Highly recommend the Sweet Chipotle Chicken. I always substitute the Chipotle Ranch, in place of the Chipotle Peach! read more

McAlister's Deli - Sandwiches Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Went here for lunch on a busy afternoon. Staff was the friendliest group of people I've encountered in a long time. Multiple different people came by bringing me refills and picking up anything extra on the table. Customer service goes a long way even with the small things. Kudos to this location's entire staff. read more

Received the sandwich and large Diet Coke on time, but there was no potato salad in my order.

Since COVID, my family has been ordering box lunches from McAlisters for all of our small, socially distant gatherings. We have been together to celebrate a baptism, a gender reveal party, and two baby showers and continue to order box lunches. Each box is VERY reasonably priced and includes an enormous amount of food, including a sandwich, side, large cookie, and usually pickle. The napkins, utensils, and condiments are individually wrapped and placed in the individual orders. The box lunches have been the perfect way for us to stay safe and skip the buffet-style meals of the past during COVID. I have recommended this option to all of my other friends and family and recommend it to you if you will be hosting an event during these crazy times! read more

Order at the counter and they bring it to your table. Will also come around to check on drink refill needs. Baked potato meals are huge. I had the half reuban (always gotta try a reuban), and a cup of corn crab chowder, and both were a #yum. #ReviewsByRL read more

See all

We got McAllister's curbside pick up today for lunch. They are not allowing anybody to go in and pick up their own food, which made me a bit nervous about the time it was going to take to get our food. However, they have been running orders out super fast one after another and updating us on the order status. Awesome service!! Way to step it up during this crazy time!!!! read more

McAlister's Deli - Sandwiches Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

McAlisters has a deal: buy $25 card get $5 for a future purchase. The $5 is only if you have an app. If you don't have the app the $5 bonus card is worthless. It says if you have an app on there table talker if you look at the fine print that blends in with the background. Horribly dishonest. Not good will toward the customer. I just gave my card away to the people in line. It took me a while to find someone that had the app. Too many apps! I thought I would let people know before you also get stuck with a gift card. read more

I swear every time I go to this location I have a bad experience! From missing food in a Togo order, to a rude manager yelling at her employees about a cookie being over cooked and now half of a half of a sandwich. Yes that's what I said half of a half of a sandwich. This location is absolutely ridiculous! I order a half club and broccoli cheddar soup open my bag to check b4 I leave since I had missing food b4. The guy walks over while I'm opening it and I say to him it's not even a full sandwich he says to me well we put lettuce and tomato on the top layer okay cool but can it fill up the top layer at least? He said no that's how it is and I responded I'll be sure to complain about that. No effort to redo the sandwich or anything. It's just sad that if the lettuce and tomato are on that layer they can't even fill the layer with the tomato and lettuce. Every time I say I'm going to give them another chance it's just not worth it! read more

See all

I really enjoy McAlister's because they have such a wide variety of items. For a fast(er) food establishment, they have a surprisingly large offering of vegetarian options. My favorite menu item, though, is the chicken spud. If you've never had a potato here, be warned--they're huge!! Definitely a filling meal, assuming you can even finish the potato. (I can. No judgement, please!) I also love their potato salad. I'm starting to see a theme. Many people love the sweet tea here. I'm not a fan of sweet tea but their unsweetened tea is good! Drinks are huge too! And free refills if you're dining in! I find that the takeout is often slow so we always call ahead and give it a little longer than the time quoted. Although we've not actually tried the takeout at this particular location, the Carmel locations seem to be consistently slow. Give it a try--and order the spud! read more

McAlister's Deli - Sandwiches Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Best go to lunch spot in Fishers! Service and food are always consistently GREAT! Sweet tea can't be beat? read more

Mmm do I LOVE McAlister's! No matter what I am in the mood for McAlister's always has something on their menu to satisfy my taste buds. Recently I've been into their Savannah Chopped Salad. It's flavorful and fresh and I can customize the salad to my liking. But we all know the real reason we love McAlister's....THE TEA! it's delicious. My favorite combination is 1/2 sweet, 1/2 unsweetened with a shot of peach! it's a must try and perfect for those spring and summer days. The customer service at this location is always amazing. You're greeted with a smile and the staff is fast and friendly. You can also order ahead on the app and pick your items up at the to go counter! read more

Reasonable price. Good options for lunch. Love the lemonade big gulp with a splash of peach syrup

I always enjoy McAlister's so when I found out that today was National Sandwich Day and they had $4 McAlister clubs I made sure I was there before the big rush. Typically I order from the app but I saw the special was not available via the app so I went in and ordered at the registers. I ordered my sandwich to go along with a side of chips and a coke. I paid cash and really did not think about what I was paying so I then went to the sitting area to wait. While I was waiting, I looked at my receipt and realized that I did not pay the special price for today which was $4 for the McAlister club. Because of the difference, and they were still slow, I asked the girl that checked me out why the difference and she said the offer was for dine in only. I said OK very confused and sat down to wait for my order. I then looked at McAlister's Facebook page to see what was posted because I remembered reading that take-out orders were acceptable for the discount. After I found it, I then stood at the counter to ask why the difference and while I was there, I realized my order was already complete and waiting for me. The employees were really focused on a large take out order that, from the look of it, included many salads. My order kept being pushed back every time they had another tray of salads. The awesome girl that always works carryout was busy filling the teas so she told a different employee to help me. After I told him I was waiting for my order that was complete, he gave me my order but I still wondered about the special of the day and noticed the manager was working on orders. Once I finally got his attention I told him my question and wondered why it was so different. He told me that he was told that it was dine in only and that the cashier was correct, the special was for dine in only. I showed him the Facebook posts that said if you could not eat in you, anyone could get it to take out. He was shocked and read the posts several times. Instead of telling me that it was a mistake, because obviously it was as he read the McAlister posts on Facebook numerous times, he said he need to make a phone call. Seriously?!?!? He made me wait even longer when all I wanted was to tell him that he was telling his cashiers incorrectly and I wanted my $3+ difference. I waited and then he returned asking me to see my phone again so he could read it to the person he was talking to on the phone. Of course I showed him but then he gave me the wait sign with is hand and walked off to the area I could not see. He eventually returned and asked me to send him the Facebook post to his phone and told me I was correct that take out was acceptable not just eat in. He was not sure how else to do it besides taking screenshots and the sending them to him. I took multiple screenshots and texted them to him. I had told him that I knew I would not be the only one to ask so I was glad he figured it out. He thanked me and then acted as if our conversation was complete. I waited and then asked him if I could have a refund. He looked confused and then said "of the difference". Yes, I should have been clearer to explain that I thought I deserved the difference of what I paid vs the discount....but shouldn't that have immediately been offered and not asked? The manager acted as if I had done him a favor but yet I deserved to pay the full price even though those after me may pay the special price?!!??!?!? He did give me the difference after several minutes. I left very confused ad over 30 minutes beyond what I should have and expected to spend in the Fishers McAlister's restaurant, I am always willing to help and I could not be the only one questioning the deal today. Just look at social media and you will see how many people planned to make the McAlister's Club their lunch to go. read more

See all

So good! A couple years back, I went twice a week sometimes! My daughter loves the ham and cheese melt so much. She never gets it with mustard but she loves it. Fun to go with the whole family and or friends. From my experience, the staff is super friendly! The free pickles are also delicious! read more

what a horrible location! The staff is clueless, and does not even know how to redeem a coupon through the app. The "manager" didn't even come out from the back to assist. The 2 useless cashiers only said sorry there is nothing we can do. Then started taking other customers without resolving my issue. This is how they do business. I will never go back to this place. I asked for a # to call their corporate, and she gave me some generic # that doesn't do anything. That "manager" needs a bit of people skills and to at least step up to the plate, but not here. I have had goldfish with better people skills. Next time it could be someone that isn't as nice as me, and you could be in some real trouble, with the issues at restaurants lately. This place needs to have some training and give the manager a little control to resolve a few dollar issue. I'm not even sure this place had a manager, since the elusive manager never came out. It looked like a bunch of 16 year old clueless kids running the place. The ONLY location worth anything is the one by the fashion mall. I've had an issue at the fashion mall location before, and they resolved it. I know issues happen, but learn how to actually step in to fix it.......it's not rocket science. If they had just fixed a minor issue, all would have been good. But to just ignore the situation is messed up. Hey Fishers, just hire a baboon to do the job. It would have at least been a better experience. Useless employees and "manager" read more

Wednesday/ 6:42 Staff- friendly and knowledgeable of the menu and prices. Management- up front, noticeable, helpful Store overall look clean and well maintained. Only reason for not getting 5 stars is not because of the store, but for McAlister's as a whole. As a customer I wanted just a half savanna chop salad as my side but was unable to. Only through the choose 2 was I able to get a half salad but then I would have to order another half to complete the choose 2. I feel that McAlister's should have the option to order just a half of any salad or sandwich for that matter. Overall I was impressed given that most other locations are not as well managed. read more

Absolutely love this location! Went for lunch with 4 co-workers and were able to grab a table outside. All employees were super helpful, attentive, and kind - especially Christian who brought us our meals and refills for our drink. All at a deli? Amazing!! We'll be back :) read more

McAlister's Deli - When you want to make sure employees can see what meals we need - Haha. - Sandwiches Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

Good food, but the bathrooms today were very dirty. Not only did i stick to the bathroom floor in the men's room, the toilet and sink was a mess. Your male employee's shoes were sticking as they delivered food to the table. No towels in the bath either. As Tom Peters noted in his "In Search of Excellence" books in the 90s...If the tray tops in the plane are dirty, you wonder if they did engine maintenance. And if the restaurant bathroom is dirty...you wonder about the kitchen???? Just saying. You have a very good--work to keep that reputation! read more

I hate leaving bad reviews but my FIL has food poisoning from this location. He had the club sandwich.

This place is good everywhere, but this specific location has always gotten it right. This is my go to spot for lunch, I just can't resist and everything i try is good! read more

McAlister's Deli - Turkey Club, potato with cheese, side of broccoli - Sandwiches Near Me - Fishers, Indiana

service has gone down. Waited over 30 minutes for 1 kids meal. They said they misplaced the ticket and then didn't even offer an apolog.

Waited almost 30 minutes for a cup of soup and salad I don't care how deep in the weeds you are that is pathetic read more

This was the first time that I have had poor service. The employee was constantly wiping his nose while filling my tea. I asked for a sweet tea with light ice and instead he gave me a unsweet tea with a lot of ice. I ordered one Caesar salad and it took forever to get. Three other people behind me received their meals before me. I am very disappointed in the service and the quality of food. I am a regular customer at this place, but I don't intend on going here for a while until things change. read more

this location has come a long way on the quality and service upward trajectory path. At the core of it the staff is welcoming and cares. Thank you. read more

Food here is always good. I came in for lunch, and it wasn't as crowded as I thought it would be. Pickles galore! The price was right, but make sure you get the app. Service was kind of slow this time. They only had one person at the counter. I also wish they had more booths power outlets. Sorry I forgot to take a picture. read more

Great, friendly service! I ordered online and on my way there I received a phone call from the manager just to tell they were out of the dressing that went with my salad and to ask me what I would like for a replacement! I appreciated them not waiting till I got there due to the hurry I was in. I was very impressed! The people behind the counter were very friendly as well! Usually they are just going through the motions but I actually felt like they were happy to be there and help me! I usually go to a different location but this was on my way home that day and I will definitely try to go to this one from now on.. read more

Called in several times to place a to go order. (Typically it's a pretty long wait).. My luck no answer. Maybe they switched to online orders only? 30 minutes later I drive up there to place my order in person. Was told it would be 15 minutes. Probably a dozen others dining in. 8-10 employees. I waited 45 minutes for my to go order... "soup and a grilled cheese"..... Minutes later I find my order has been ready for the past 20 minutes but left on the counter to get cold. Never announced the order was out.. come on! Very frustrating because I love the food! know it's a hard time with people not wanting to clock in to work. For the ones that did show up for a paycheck, they are living in LALA land! Wake up, answer the phone! Do your job! read more

This used to be such a great place to go! The past several months the service has slid downhill and our take out orders are always missing something! Tonight our food sat for 30 minutes while our daughter also sat there waiting- on the food- . What a pain! And the order still was missing an item when she got it home! There are too many other places to spend our money if they can't get it back together! read more