Lots of fresh produce, many organic choices. Awesome seafood, veggie pot pie are other favorites. There's even a liquor store inside!

All cash-paying customers are cheated, as McCaffrey's will "round up" your price [without asking!] to avoid using pennies. THIS IS THEFT. read more

First time here, I had previously been made aware of it from hearing about the Princeton location. Overall they carried a lot of mainstream products, with store specialties as a signature. A bit pricey in general, but there were some normal priced items also. read more

The vegetables are fresh and look inviting. The meat is superb with lots of choices in types of beef, grass fed, no antibiotics, etc. Service is always good, but they no longer have baggers. read more

Love mcCaffery Yet today bought Italian chicken cutlet. Breaded and sautéed. Grrr tough as nails. Never had a chicken cutlet sooo fibrous. Not happy. Glad I didn't have guests. read more

McCaffrey's is an upscale supermarket. You pay a premium for meats and produce, but I've felt that the prices were comparable to the quality. I've always been pleased with the service here. Deli and take-out items tend to be very good and tasty. There's a small state liquor store attached to the front of McCaffrey's. read more

McCaffrey's is a local grocery institution and many many people speak highly of it. While they do have some upside and utility, they also have ongoing issues with quality in their deli, cheese and meat departments and I feel like after more than a few incidents, I need to write an update. On Sunday, I purchased McCaffrey's in house oven roasted turkey at the deli. I checked out, it was it was in the car for 5 minutes on the ride home and then in my fridge until today Tuesday, totally unopened. I just opened the package to make sandwiches for the kids for school tomorrow and it's totally funky. Smells and tastes awful. It's two days old and totally spoiled? $8 straight into the garbage. Last week, I purchased a block of Boucheron semi aged goat cheese. Looked fine in the plastic. I drove home and 5 minutes later put it in the fridge. I then took it out over the weekend, opened the package and saw that the cheese was covered in a gel-like slimy film and what I think is mold. I purchased this exact cheese from Wegmans not too long ago and it had the texture and feel of Brie which is the way it should be. The one from McCaffrey's felt like it was covered in a kids mucousy tissue, possibly because it was not stored at the right temperature or was expired. Either way, yuck. $12 straight to the garbage. A few weeks before all this, I bought a package of organic ground beef. I get it home and want to use it immediately to make a Bolognese. I slice the package open and the smell? Rotten eggs. Why would fresh meat smell like rotten eggs? Answer: it shouldn't. Another $10 in the trash. All I can say is, why is this happening?? Either the food is not being handled properly, stored properly, refrigerated properly or food safety personnel aren't doing their job, or all of the above. Not really sure what the issue is, all I know is that I've been getting low quality products and I'm not exactly happy about it. I also want to add that our fridge is in perfect working order and set at the correct temperature. We also never, ever have the same problem with deli items, cheese or meat when we shop at Wegman's or Costco. It's just the McCaffrey's stuff that's problematic. read more

I love to stop here for the chicken and green beans at the Asian hot bar. I usually eat my lunch a bit earlier than noon. The last few times I have gone in, only a few items have been available. When I ask when the other food will be ready, I am told it is "usually" out by noon or so. I like to sit and eat my lunch by boon. Moving forward, Wegmans it is! read more

I shop at McCaffreys every week, I always find everything I need, and the service is good. I do however have a problem with the meat dept. the ground beef is stuffed with bad meat inside. I waited for the butcher to put out brand new ground round. when I opened it up the inside was all brown. I have returned ground beef at least three times, but many times I just pick out the brown pockets of meat. I have showed the service desk the actual brown meat, 3 hours after purchasing. the manager says we don't do that. yet the evidence was in my hand. it's a terrible practice. just thought I d throw it out there. as I said my review is only for the meat dept. read more

The market is poorly staffed, poorly stocked, lacking in customer service, and as everyone knows, extremely expensive.

Yah, I am a fan. It is pricey, but I do not use it for my everyday shopping. It is a specialty food market where you can find items that are not in your local grocery store. Like goose liver pate' or chipolte & adobo sauce or very special crackers and breads for special occasions. Fresh smoked white fish and eel can be purchased, as well as large deboned whole fish.. For the convenience, while I am there and in a hurry, it is nice to have a large selection of typical items found in your regular market, so you aren't running here, there and everywhere. Plus, when you sign up for your McCaffrey's card ( just a store discount card ) you will get a monthly to semi-monthly mailing for discounts on your entire shopping trips. 7% and up! I love McCaffrey's and I am happy they are there! read more

They make some of the most amazing cheese trays and cheese boards. Super friendly knowledgeable staff and will cater to your every need in cheese. The two gentlemen that work the cheese shop are so friendly and even if your not looking for anything in the cheese shop will go out of their way to help you the best they can. read more

See all

I went to Mccaffreys yesterday and needed help so I went to the costumer service counter. I met the sweetest girl Emily who reminded me of my grand daughter. She was so kind and gracious and helped me find the canned tomato's! Mccaffreys Is a great store with great employees!!. read more

Beautiful supermarket but beauty isn't free. Everything is more expensive here. They do have a great hot food bar. Their deli has a great system for slicing meats exactly how you want them when you order and how they pack them is perfect. Their Jewish food area is great. Good whitefish salad and RJs bagels. If you need a hard to find item it's probably here, but again, loosen your purse strings! read more

Was in town over the holiday. Visited here several times for some of our usual staples. Occasionally tough in Langhorne/Yardley area to find certain brands of food. I can only comment on a few choice items but I found them easily. Their fish was also good, though a small selection. Staff were friendly an knowledgeable. The store was clean and well organized. The prices are a bit higher than competitors, but they have a lot of items that can't be found in any of the other local stores. Overall good experience. read more

I go here for the salad bar and soup, it is usually very good. Over the last month the lettuce and veggies don't seem as fresh. They also WEIGH and charge you for dressing which is ridiculous. Over priced on groceries. Staff is unpleasant, they do not smile or greet you. read more

This is a nice grocery store! It is kind of like a mini local Wegmans. They have a pretty nice selection of prepared foods. I have a hard time not spending too much money here because of this but it is ok because it is so good! They have a little sushi bar-- it is alright, but, like most grocery stores, is very pricey. In the center of the prepared section I always find some gems that range from a prepared salmon dinner to amish potato salad. They also have really delicious flatbreads too! Oh and I can't forget their fresh pickle barrel!! The bakery here is good too. If you need to pickup a birthday cake or anything of the sort, you can rest assure it will taste good if you get it from here. (I have, admittedly, tried a few!) For regular groceries, they do not carry everything and it is a little more pricey than local competitors, but overall great store! read more

Excellent customer service and amazing catering! The cake decorator was accommodating, great to work with, and made this beautiful cake! I also ordered sandwiches which are always a hit and come beautifully prepared. I highly recommend and will always go to McCaffrey's for future parties! read more

McCaffrey's Food Market - Two tiered birthday cake - Grocery Near Me - Yardley, Pennsylvania

I had an extremely horrible experience at this location. The customer service was terrible in the bakery. The manager of the bakery seemed miserable as well. Very disappointed with this location. I'm going to stick to the blue bell one. I felt as though I should warn otherss. read more

Every so often I come to McCaffrey's for their hot bar when I need a quick bite to eat. The food is average, but convenient. Most items seem over priced. Luckily for the owner it seems he has some pull in the area, because a wegman's or Whole Foods would put this place out of business. read more

I don't get it. I would rather drive 15 minutes to NJ and spend my hard earned money at Whole Foods or Wegmans in Princeton. McCaffrey's has what I consider a small selection of gourmet items but nothing worth the price tag it costs to shop there. The store itself, needs a facelitft. It is strange because the front of store (where you enter) looks nice (like a Kings Market in NJ) but the rest of the store is unattractive and dated. The most bizarre part of the whole shopping experience is the crowd. There were a few affluent older woman there who apparently didn't feel as though they needed to be considerate of other shoppers. I don't get it. Because they are paying more for their groceries entitles them to be rude?? I literally had an older woman push her shopping cart right into my hip, look at me and then say "Well, are you going to move your cart?" You are in a grocery store for christ's sake not the red carpet honey. read more

This very good supermarket in Lower Makefield lies in the supermarket hiearchy immediately above the band containing Giant, Acme, Superfresh, Genuardis and Stop and Shop but below the premium top line of Whole Foods, Wegmans and Whole Earth (all in the Princeton and Philadelphia areas). So if you live in the Yardley/Makefields area and you dont want to drive 20 minutes for your groceries, this is as good as it gets. The poultry and meat sections contain organic and minimally process selections. The fish counter offerings are clearly labeled and almost always have wild-caught options. The bakery is good and usually has samples for the kids (and adults). If you are watching your budget, you can do what many people do (myself included): go to the Giant in the next-door lot for the packaged, non-perishable items and then go to Mccaffrey's for the meat, fish, produce and items you cant get at Giant (such as specialty condiments). Unlike most other grocery stores, this store's hot bar and salad bar are very good. The lunch room upstairs has plenty of tables and overlooks the store. My few gripes: 1. The produce guys act like undertakers and seem unaware that putting multiple stocking carts in the narrow produce aisles is a HUGE &^*@ing obstacle for us shoppers. I especially hate it when they have one barge in front of the parsely/lettuce section and another by the avocados/garlic area, which makes getting something from the area in between impossible. 2. The dimwit and preppy teens who work here are the worst baggers and tellers. The alterna-teens who work at Giant are much better (but still cannot bag well) There are errors on about 25% of my checkouts. 3. Why oh why did they change the bakery bread selections? And why cant they ever stock a good, crusty, large semolina flatloaf? read more

The products offered are ok...the big deal about this place is how rude, cold, and stone-faced the check out clerks are. I have literally been glared at upon saying "hello" or "how are you?". Just today I said hello to one of the older blonde clerks and she looked at me and said "just hold on" as if I was rushing her. Mindless self checkout is the way for me !!!! McCafferey's, you are not that special of a grocery store! read more

A wonderful selection of premium grocery products. The items are a little pricey but the quality is unmatched by any other food store

Just moved to the area, so I decided to visit McCaffrey's. Found it way overpriced, staff super unfriendly. One of the items I bought was a salad dressing, when I went to open it I saw the the Best by date was August 17, 2017! Sorry, not worth the convenience read more

I love shopping at McCaffrey's in Newtown (although it is expensive - I try to use the 15% coupons I get in the mail). I love shopping in a smaller store. It makes food shopping more manageable and enjoyable. I like the layout of the store as well as their selection of meat and produce. My only dislike is the front seating area by the take-out food. It is very uninviting. When I go into the front seating area, I feel like I am walking into a dirty back stockroom / employee break room. Also, the women's bathroom is really gross. read more

I usually love this store. However the last time I went I got apple cider and it was fermented. I also picked up cheese and it had mold on it. I hope it's better the next time read more

Fantastic as always. If you like crab cakes this is the place to get them. Went to Morton's King of Prussia a few weeks ago for our anniversary. Service was fantastic, food eh. Save yourself a few hundred dollars and visit a McCaffrey's. Quality is way better, they'd probably even come to your house and serve you for a nominal fee....... : ) read more

Called the store requesting closing time of the liquor store. So called employee notifies me it's 8 pm. After rushing to get to the store, the employee at the liquor store tells me they don't close until 9. Get your act together, I get it, small town whatever, you get New Yorkers coming through. Keep it moving and train your employees. read more

Well well well. I see orange roughy/slimehead is back for sale at your "sustainable" seafood counter. I've told management twice now that orange roughy is NOT sustainable, and is marked AVOID across the board by Seafood Watch; plenty of scientific research out there supports that conclusion. It is vulnerable to exploitation (and thus extinction) due to life history (slow reproduction and late maturity), and because bottom trawling is used to fish for it. Bottom trawling destroys benthic habitat, and renders it a wasteland. I'm not giving your stores any more of my money till this fish is removed from sale, permanently. I'm seriously disappointed. read more

All I can say is thank god Shop Rite is coming to Yardley. Over and over and over priced and not in a Whole Foods kind of way. Don't waste your time! Drive to Whole Foods or Trader Joe's! Way too pricey for weekly shopping! read more

I absolutely love shopping here. It's a little pricy and they haven't sent me any offers or anything besides the store flyer. But when I need a few quality items I definitely come here. Especially their nice rare store made roast beef. It's worth the $12.99 a pound. Of course I load up when it's on sale. It's always peaceful and quiet when I shop here during the day. No one is yelling crazy things like at Walmart. I usually grab all the cheaper stuff at the Giant next door afterwards. read more

The best run supermarket I have seen . Consistently high quality throughout the store. Deli counter carries the great Boars Head Brand which makes it stand out in a Dietz and Watson area. Fresh prepared food and great salad bar. Best selection of meats around.Prices are slightly higher but the high quality makes it worth it. Highly community oriented and many contributions to local charities and groups. read more

Small aisles. Expensive. Not a large selection. However, if you are looking for a rare ingredient, cheese, meat, etc... This is your place. Friendly managers who are caring and helpful. read more

Great Service 100% of the time. While they might not be the cheapest, their service is worth it. Plus they have a State Store inside. They really treat you like family. They are also very good to the local community. read more

I love this place! You can always count on the quality of the meat , seafood, bakery, produce. One stop shoppingFor anything that I need, a quick gift wine to go with the dinner, flowers etc. Our Yardley treasure! read more

I've only been to this McCaffrey's once but the inside was clean and neat. The shelves were well stocked. They also sell wine at this location which is a bonus. My only complaint is their prices were a bit high. I spent $80 for what normally would be $65 or $70 at another supermarket. I found the store easy to navigate and the aisles were not too narrow and well organized. If I ever find myself back at this store, I will write a more in depth review. read more

Nice store but the staff seems unhappy. Very unfriendly folks over at prepared foods. That pizza guy is miserable. I went there the other day at almost 12:30 to do some shopping and get a couple of slices. There was no pizza out! At lunchtime! I tried to communicate with the pizza guy and all I got was a frown and something unintelligible. I think I'll get my pizza at Villa Rosa and groceries at ShopRite. Too bad! read more

I am a fan, this place is a local institution...the prices are high but the quality and service are very good. Awesome sushi too. I wish the aisles were wider. read more

It's almost impossible to preorder from the grill. I love the cheese steak but decided to take my business elsewhere. Every time I call nobody will pick up the phone. If the pizza guy receives the call he will immediately put you on hold. I stopped ordering pizza because the manager (miserable older guy) has the worst attitude I've ever experienced. It's as if he is doing the customer a favor. Guess management will figure it out soon as De Lorenzo's opens! Obviously McCaffrey's isn't serious about pizza with the joker they have managing the pizza department. read more